Thank you to Penguin Teen for sending me an ARC of From Here in exchange for an honest review!
Luma Mufleh's memoir From Here depicts her journey coming to terms with herself as she grows up. Luma grew up in Jordan in the 1980s, without resources like the internet or Western media (for the most part). And because of this, Luma struggles with understanding what sets her apart from other people — what she eventually realizes is being gay. Luma takes us through parts of her childhood, through college in the U.S., and into her attempt at applying for political asylum.
This was a moving memoir, and at times horribly dark. I would highly recommend checking out the trigger warnings I have compiled at the end of this review. I really loved Luma's commentary throughout. This unique perspective (which I suspect is not an uncommon experience, just a suppressed one) of being gay and Arab gave Luma's story authenticity.
Luma tackles some really difficult questions about religion (specifically Islam) in relation to her sexuality, all the while recognizing her privilege. Luma is from a wealthy family with a well-known name, and because of that she has more economic resources than others and more opportunities to get out of Jordan. And recognizing that privilege was key in a memoir like this. Luma went through so much to get to the relative peace she has today, and I think it would have been negligent to have not recognized that most people don't get even slightly close to her relative safety.
I found Luma's memoir especially impactful at the beginning and ending. Luma frames her book as a sort-of letter to her children. These moments of family and companionship were my favorite parts of the novel because they felt intimate and real. My largest critique would be that I wished there was more framing of the story throughout. As it is right now, only the prologue and epilogue were addressed to Luma's children, but I think it would have been much more moving had the entire book used that framing.
In terms of pacing, I was able to get through this book quickly, but there were definitely some moments that were brushed over (especially once she's in America), and some parts that took way too long to get to the point (a lot of her crushes and romantic exploits seemed to serve the same reasoning). I would also have liked to see a little more about settling into her life as a gay refugee, as personally I felt the ending was a bit abrupt.
Overall, I highly recommend Luma Mufleh's memoir. It is an important read and one I am hopeful will make an impact in the lives of other people who are trying to reconcile two contrasting identities.
Trigger Warnings: descriptions of multiple suicide attempts, suicidal ideation, anxiety and depression, adult/child relationship, homophobia (internalized and direct), antisemitism (not challenged), racism against Arabs, misogyny, religious rhetoric to justify violence (including gun threats and descriptions of "honor killings”), killing of animals, family estrangement