What do you think?
Rate this book
Star Wars: The High Republic (2022) (Single Issues)
Star Wars: The High Republic (2022-2023) #1
A new chapter begins for Star The High Republic! One hundred and fifty years before the fall of Starlight, another beacon burns bright in the galaxy, a beacon of faith and spirituality. Jedha. The Pilgrim Moon. The Kyber Heart. But tensions are rising in the holy city and dark days are to come.
Jedi Vildar Mac, a Jedi safe and secure in who he is and what he could be, arrives as Jedha's fragile peace begins to crumble... But a nightmare awaits...a nameless terror that will become the stuff of legend…
Jedi Vildar Mac, a Jedi safe and secure in who he is and what he could be, arrives as Jedha's fragile peace begins to crumble... But a nightmare awaits...a nameless terror that will become the stuff of legend…
30 pages, Kindle Edition
Published October 12, 2022
About the author
Cavan Scott
866 books444 followersis a freelance comic writer and author. He is best known for his work on a variety of spin-offs from both Doctor Who and Star Wars, as well as comics and novels for Vikings, Pacific Rim, Sherlock Holmes, and Penguins of Madagascar.
Cavan Scott, along with Justina Ireland, Claudia Gray, Daniel Jose Older, and Charles Soule are crafting a new era in the Star Wars publishing world called Star Wars: The High Republic. Cavan's contribution to the era is a comic book series released through Marvel Comics titled Star Wars: The High Republic.
Cavan Scott, along with Justina Ireland, Claudia Gray, Daniel Jose Older, and Charles Soule are crafting a new era in the Star Wars publishing world called Star Wars: The High Republic. Cavan's contribution to the era is a comic book series released through Marvel Comics titled Star Wars: The High Republic.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 24 of 24 reviews
October 12, 2022
The High Republic is back! Well, theoretically it has been since Path of Deceit released last week, but as with Phase I, the comic book series that accompanies the story kicks off just after the first novel does. Though we’re taken a whopping 150 years back in time, you won't feel lost within the comic, as the creative duo of writer Cavan Scott and artist Ario Anindito remains the same. This time, however, the colors were added by Frank William and the ink by Mark Morales, while Ariana Maher is responsible for the lettering. On we go, as we embark on a new turbulent adventure titled "Balance of the Force"!
Content analysis * contains spoilers for plot discussion *
Chapter 1 of the ten-part series takes us to the titular location, "The Pilgrim Moon." The journey gets off to a pretty creepy start right away, as Cavan Scott introduces us to the first protagonist through a flashback that quickly turns out to be a nightmare. Without wasting much time, we thus directly learn about the Jedi Vildar Mac, who, unlike many other Jedi, can still remember a pivotal moment from his past. Through this creepy dream, Scott manages to immediately make us empathize with Vildar and want to know what this memory is all about. But before we get to learn any more about it, he wakes up from the dream. Of course he does. It would simply be too convenient if we knew everything right away!
During the approach to Jedha we also learn that Vildar is not the most talkative person. While elsewhere, people would kill to be in the Jedi's shoes, he’s relatively unimpressed by the melting pot of Force religions. As a wonderful contrast to Vildar, Matthea Cathley, Matty for short, enters the scene, all too well aware that she is a passionate chatterbox. Within just one page, she’s instantly likable and her lively manner lightens the mood immensely. Her and Vildar form an interesting duo, which will certainly make for tension and funny moments ... at least that's what you’d think at this point in the comic.
Something I was especially excited about within this first issue is how alive and real Jedha seems. Right at the beginning, Vildar bumps into someone, much like Jyn Erso did in Rogue One. Due to time and history, the planet is obviously not an exact representation of the place we know from the movie, but the depiction we see still feels in line with it. Without an Imperial presence and Rebel cells, this version of Jedha is explosive in a very different way – representatives of different Force religions lurk around every corner, wanting to show off their talents, convert you or deny you your faith. The theme of different Force philosophies, some of which go to extremes, is something I’ve already grown to love about Phase II.
You should also be alert to the many mentions of other places and cults. Matty mentions that Vildar was supposed to have traveled to the front lines of the Togruta – looks like this conflict, having been mentioned in Phase I, will probably also find room within Phase II! But there are a lot of other things to possibly keep in mind as well: The Shrine of Sarrav, the Truthsayers of Bfassh, the Followers of the Black Eye, even the Sorcerers of Tund are included. As the author himself likes to say, time will tell … if Cavan Scott simply made up some cool terms to include or if we should keep our eyes peeled for more. At the very least, the Sorcerers of Tund should be a familiar name to many.
The clash of cultures definitely provides a lot of potential, as of course there are scammers among the many religions on Jedha or, as in the case of Tey Sirrek (the name is not revealed in the issue itself, but Scott shared it on Twitter), sneaky thieves. Right from his first interaction, it’s obvious to see that this one is quite sly, and I’d like to commend Ario Anindito for aptly bringing the character's traits to the page in visual form as well. As a discussion unfolds in the city, Vildar rushes after Tey, but is called right back by Matty. I really appreciate that both Matty and Vildar are very dynamic characters and that their fundamentally different natures complement each other as opposed to simply converging.
Back in the middle of the commotion, Vildar has a flashback of his horrific memory. When it comes to nightmares, flashbacks, and intrusions, the psychologist in me can’t help but think: are we dealing with another Jedi with PTSD? Anyway, the Sorcerer of Tund turns out to be harmless and the two Jedi head off to where they wanted to go all along. In the process, Matty does a bit of lore dumping, which I appreciate as we have to get to know a lot of new groups. I am intrigued to see how the story of the comic will possibly tie into Path of Deceit, as certain clues can definitely be found already.
However, apparently it was Tey Sirrek who’s responsible for the theft of the mural, and an exciting showdown ensues. And again, I find myself willingly walk into the Cavan Scott trap. The final pages of the issue’s happenings could easily pass as the end of an entire story arc! Turns out there's more to Tey than just a simple thief - he possesses Force abilities that even the Jedi don't believe exist. And so, he just happens to possess the ability to effortlessly kill our protagonist. After one issue. Anyone who didn’t gape at this can probably not be surprised by any plot twist at all. I, at least, almost got annoyed at myself and then had to laugh at having thought myself and the characters safe. But that’s not all: following the scene, we’re confronted with the superbly orchestrated twist that we now learn who has been narrating the comic. And it is not an omniscient narrator after all. My immediate thought was that it had to be Matty, but you quickly realize that it's not our second protagonist narrating the comic either. Nope, right from the start, we have been listening to Tey. And his final words promise that Vildar's story is far from over.
In the end, as is quite typical for issues written by Cavan Scott, we're left with a bunch of questions. When does Tey tell this story? Why is he telling it to us? How does he know so much about Vildar and why seemingly nothing about Matty? How did he get his abilities? For first answers to all these questions, we'll have to eagerly await the next issue. I, for one, can hardly wait!
Bonus Story Peace and Unity
In the bonus story Peace and Unity, we get to know the Jedi Oliviah Zeveron as well as the Convocation, the congregation of Force religions that was mentioned quite a few times in the main story. On the first page, we see the large statue of a Jedi-like figure whose toppled version we know from Rogue One. It’s exciting to see Jedha still intact, at least for now. I'll still have to warm up to Oliviah a bit, she's not quite as tangible within those few moments as Matty or Vildar were to me. Is she an apprentice of Master Leebon like Matty? Or a former one? To me, she still seems pretty young, but if I'm reading this correctly, she's not wearing a Padawan braid. In any case, it's interesting and quite funny to see that there are characters like her in Star Wars who like the desert despite all the sand 😉.
The Convocation, meanwhile, is a bit of a mess. The individual representatives obviously don't really get to shine with their personalities here, but with the background they stand for. Thus, this story is mostly intended for introducing the different philosophies and portraying the tense mood among them. Yet, there is one thing that the members of the Convocation agree on: the dark side is not welcome. The representative of the Yacombe prefers to withdraw their application for a spot on the debate group rather than to get caught in their disarray. The smarter and wiser move! Oliviah’s entrance also once again reinforces the idea of the Jedi not being welcome on Jedha and having no special status there, as they do in the rest of the galaxy. This is an exciting starting point for the further plot, especially considering that the Jedi will generally not have a good time within this phase (in Path of Deceit, their philosophy was looked down on and looking to the future, the title The Battle of Jedha does not bode well, and let’s not even get into the way the events of this phase are talked about in Phase I!).
The most intriguing moment to me, however, is the last page of the story, in which Radicaz Dobbs, also known as Sunshine, makes an entrance and announces the arrival of the Path of the Open Hand we know from Path of Deceit. I wonder if this can go well. Has anything ever gone well in the High Republic?
About the illustrations
You've seen me write this dozens of times, but I'm happy to say it again: Ario Anindito is the perfect artistic choice for these comics. Both Matthea and Vildar and also Tey, who I've already pointed out above, feel real – not only because of the dialogue, but also because of Ario's illustrative talent. Whether it's shock on Vildar's face that has seen quite a few years of life, awkwardness on Matty's features as she tries to excuse Vildar, or Tey's sleazy grin ... each character is vividly brought to life.
What's also amazing about the art is how busy the city is. You don't just see a lot of random characters walk around, but the streets are filled with people of different species, cultures, clothing styles, ages. Of course, many of them can only be seen from behind or they are wearing capes, but a lot of effort has been put into the people who are clearly visible and in focus.
Also worth highlighting is the city and the architectural design itself. With his architectural background, Anindito was able to fully express himself here. Additionally, every now and then a slightly blurry effect is used, which lends the issue an interesting, quite slippery mood. The layout of the panels is pleasant to follow, with panels full of background details occasionally alternating with quieter character-focused sections.
In contrast to the 2021 run, this issue could almost be described as monotonous, as we're used to the bright colors of Starlight, the Drengir and Jedi. Personally, I enjoy this pastel look quite a lot, and I like that the series can be distinguished from the previous run in terms of coloring. Within the beige color scheme, Vildar automatically stands out due to his big physique, and Matty and Tey draw our attention through their colorful skin tones. This keeps our focus on the most important characters. I also noticed that onomatopoeia is kept to a minimum and is incorporated very subtly, an artistic choice I personally prefer in comics.
The same goes for the bonus story, which excels with its character designs. Andrea Broccardo is responsible for the illustrations of this story, and he has done a fantastic job. The representatives of the various groups all have a completely unique appearance and are clearly distinguishable. There's no lack of details either (did you see the two Jawas moving towards the speeder?). At times, the action seems a bit chaotic, but it's probably intended to be like that due to the plot. I'd love to see more of Broccardo's work within The High Republic, especially as these illustrations are on a similar level as Anindito's and complement those of the main story of this issue – creating no rift between the two styles.
Conclusion
The High Republic #1 manages to pull us right back into the spell of the era. No matter how skeptical we may have been about new characters and a new time period, Cavan Scott – in collaboration with Ario Anindito's artistic skills and the laid back but aesthetically pleasing coloring by Frank William – succeeds to convince you of new Jedi in just a few pages. The author also takes direct advantage of this affection, awaiting us with a surprising twist that will put you into shock that is going to last … right at the end of the first issue. With Jedha, Scott has chosen the ideal location to fully elaborate on the theme of Force philosophies, techniques and objects and put our beloved characters through the wringer once again, and I'm more than curious to see how the threads of the individual stories of this Phase will come together.
This is a self-translated version of my review published on Jedi-Bibliothek that you can find here: https://jedi-bibliothek.de/2022/10/ma...
Content analysis * contains spoilers for plot discussion *
Chapter 1 of the ten-part series takes us to the titular location, "The Pilgrim Moon." The journey gets off to a pretty creepy start right away, as Cavan Scott introduces us to the first protagonist through a flashback that quickly turns out to be a nightmare. Without wasting much time, we thus directly learn about the Jedi Vildar Mac, who, unlike many other Jedi, can still remember a pivotal moment from his past. Through this creepy dream, Scott manages to immediately make us empathize with Vildar and want to know what this memory is all about. But before we get to learn any more about it, he wakes up from the dream. Of course he does. It would simply be too convenient if we knew everything right away!
During the approach to Jedha we also learn that Vildar is not the most talkative person. While elsewhere, people would kill to be in the Jedi's shoes, he’s relatively unimpressed by the melting pot of Force religions. As a wonderful contrast to Vildar, Matthea Cathley, Matty for short, enters the scene, all too well aware that she is a passionate chatterbox. Within just one page, she’s instantly likable and her lively manner lightens the mood immensely. Her and Vildar form an interesting duo, which will certainly make for tension and funny moments ... at least that's what you’d think at this point in the comic.
Something I was especially excited about within this first issue is how alive and real Jedha seems. Right at the beginning, Vildar bumps into someone, much like Jyn Erso did in Rogue One. Due to time and history, the planet is obviously not an exact representation of the place we know from the movie, but the depiction we see still feels in line with it. Without an Imperial presence and Rebel cells, this version of Jedha is explosive in a very different way – representatives of different Force religions lurk around every corner, wanting to show off their talents, convert you or deny you your faith. The theme of different Force philosophies, some of which go to extremes, is something I’ve already grown to love about Phase II.
You should also be alert to the many mentions of other places and cults. Matty mentions that Vildar was supposed to have traveled to the front lines of the Togruta – looks like this conflict, having been mentioned in Phase I, will probably also find room within Phase II! But there are a lot of other things to possibly keep in mind as well: The Shrine of Sarrav, the Truthsayers of Bfassh, the Followers of the Black Eye, even the Sorcerers of Tund are included. As the author himself likes to say, time will tell … if Cavan Scott simply made up some cool terms to include or if we should keep our eyes peeled for more. At the very least, the Sorcerers of Tund should be a familiar name to many.
The clash of cultures definitely provides a lot of potential, as of course there are scammers among the many religions on Jedha or, as in the case of Tey Sirrek (the name is not revealed in the issue itself, but Scott shared it on Twitter), sneaky thieves. Right from his first interaction, it’s obvious to see that this one is quite sly, and I’d like to commend Ario Anindito for aptly bringing the character's traits to the page in visual form as well. As a discussion unfolds in the city, Vildar rushes after Tey, but is called right back by Matty. I really appreciate that both Matty and Vildar are very dynamic characters and that their fundamentally different natures complement each other as opposed to simply converging.
Back in the middle of the commotion, Vildar has a flashback of his horrific memory. When it comes to nightmares, flashbacks, and intrusions, the psychologist in me can’t help but think: are we dealing with another Jedi with PTSD? Anyway, the Sorcerer of Tund turns out to be harmless and the two Jedi head off to where they wanted to go all along. In the process, Matty does a bit of lore dumping, which I appreciate as we have to get to know a lot of new groups. I am intrigued to see how the story of the comic will possibly tie into Path of Deceit, as certain clues can definitely be found already.
However, apparently it was Tey Sirrek who’s responsible for the theft of the mural, and an exciting showdown ensues. And again, I find myself willingly walk into the Cavan Scott trap. The final pages of the issue’s happenings could easily pass as the end of an entire story arc! Turns out there's more to Tey than just a simple thief - he possesses Force abilities that even the Jedi don't believe exist. And so, he just happens to possess the ability to effortlessly kill our protagonist. After one issue. Anyone who didn’t gape at this can probably not be surprised by any plot twist at all. I, at least, almost got annoyed at myself and then had to laugh at having thought myself and the characters safe. But that’s not all: following the scene, we’re confronted with the superbly orchestrated twist that we now learn who has been narrating the comic. And it is not an omniscient narrator after all. My immediate thought was that it had to be Matty, but you quickly realize that it's not our second protagonist narrating the comic either. Nope, right from the start, we have been listening to Tey. And his final words promise that Vildar's story is far from over.
In the end, as is quite typical for issues written by Cavan Scott, we're left with a bunch of questions. When does Tey tell this story? Why is he telling it to us? How does he know so much about Vildar and why seemingly nothing about Matty? How did he get his abilities? For first answers to all these questions, we'll have to eagerly await the next issue. I, for one, can hardly wait!
Bonus Story Peace and Unity
In the bonus story Peace and Unity, we get to know the Jedi Oliviah Zeveron as well as the Convocation, the congregation of Force religions that was mentioned quite a few times in the main story. On the first page, we see the large statue of a Jedi-like figure whose toppled version we know from Rogue One. It’s exciting to see Jedha still intact, at least for now. I'll still have to warm up to Oliviah a bit, she's not quite as tangible within those few moments as Matty or Vildar were to me. Is she an apprentice of Master Leebon like Matty? Or a former one? To me, she still seems pretty young, but if I'm reading this correctly, she's not wearing a Padawan braid. In any case, it's interesting and quite funny to see that there are characters like her in Star Wars who like the desert despite all the sand 😉.
The Convocation, meanwhile, is a bit of a mess. The individual representatives obviously don't really get to shine with their personalities here, but with the background they stand for. Thus, this story is mostly intended for introducing the different philosophies and portraying the tense mood among them. Yet, there is one thing that the members of the Convocation agree on: the dark side is not welcome. The representative of the Yacombe prefers to withdraw their application for a spot on the debate group rather than to get caught in their disarray. The smarter and wiser move! Oliviah’s entrance also once again reinforces the idea of the Jedi not being welcome on Jedha and having no special status there, as they do in the rest of the galaxy. This is an exciting starting point for the further plot, especially considering that the Jedi will generally not have a good time within this phase (in Path of Deceit, their philosophy was looked down on and looking to the future, the title The Battle of Jedha does not bode well, and let’s not even get into the way the events of this phase are talked about in Phase I!).
The most intriguing moment to me, however, is the last page of the story, in which Radicaz Dobbs, also known as Sunshine, makes an entrance and announces the arrival of the Path of the Open Hand we know from Path of Deceit. I wonder if this can go well. Has anything ever gone well in the High Republic?
About the illustrations
You've seen me write this dozens of times, but I'm happy to say it again: Ario Anindito is the perfect artistic choice for these comics. Both Matthea and Vildar and also Tey, who I've already pointed out above, feel real – not only because of the dialogue, but also because of Ario's illustrative talent. Whether it's shock on Vildar's face that has seen quite a few years of life, awkwardness on Matty's features as she tries to excuse Vildar, or Tey's sleazy grin ... each character is vividly brought to life.
What's also amazing about the art is how busy the city is. You don't just see a lot of random characters walk around, but the streets are filled with people of different species, cultures, clothing styles, ages. Of course, many of them can only be seen from behind or they are wearing capes, but a lot of effort has been put into the people who are clearly visible and in focus.
Also worth highlighting is the city and the architectural design itself. With his architectural background, Anindito was able to fully express himself here. Additionally, every now and then a slightly blurry effect is used, which lends the issue an interesting, quite slippery mood. The layout of the panels is pleasant to follow, with panels full of background details occasionally alternating with quieter character-focused sections.
In contrast to the 2021 run, this issue could almost be described as monotonous, as we're used to the bright colors of Starlight, the Drengir and Jedi. Personally, I enjoy this pastel look quite a lot, and I like that the series can be distinguished from the previous run in terms of coloring. Within the beige color scheme, Vildar automatically stands out due to his big physique, and Matty and Tey draw our attention through their colorful skin tones. This keeps our focus on the most important characters. I also noticed that onomatopoeia is kept to a minimum and is incorporated very subtly, an artistic choice I personally prefer in comics.
The same goes for the bonus story, which excels with its character designs. Andrea Broccardo is responsible for the illustrations of this story, and he has done a fantastic job. The representatives of the various groups all have a completely unique appearance and are clearly distinguishable. There's no lack of details either (did you see the two Jawas moving towards the speeder?). At times, the action seems a bit chaotic, but it's probably intended to be like that due to the plot. I'd love to see more of Broccardo's work within The High Republic, especially as these illustrations are on a similar level as Anindito's and complement those of the main story of this issue – creating no rift between the two styles.
Conclusion
The High Republic #1 manages to pull us right back into the spell of the era. No matter how skeptical we may have been about new characters and a new time period, Cavan Scott – in collaboration with Ario Anindito's artistic skills and the laid back but aesthetically pleasing coloring by Frank William – succeeds to convince you of new Jedi in just a few pages. The author also takes direct advantage of this affection, awaiting us with a surprising twist that will put you into shock that is going to last … right at the end of the first issue. With Jedha, Scott has chosen the ideal location to fully elaborate on the theme of Force philosophies, techniques and objects and put our beloved characters through the wringer once again, and I'm more than curious to see how the threads of the individual stories of this Phase will come together.
This is a self-translated version of my review published on Jedi-Bibliothek that you can find here: https://jedi-bibliothek.de/2022/10/ma...
March 2, 2023
It has been 6 months since I received my last High Republic review comic. I must admit, it feels nice to get back into the groove of things. Anxiety Monday afternoon waiting for it to hit my inbox, screaming internally over an issue, somehow staying quiet about it for days till it comes out, and then the process begins anew with every issue. The tradition of writing a review that will inevitably be too long and that I took too much time to write. Alas, I will try to keep this review under one thousand words if I can help it. Now onto the issue!
Hello Jedha! Home to all things related to the force. Not just Jedi Knights, but adherents to other religions (or cults) that the force plays a holy role in.
A trend in Phase II has to do with religions and cults. Jedha is full of them. The Holy City of the Force. Much like actual religion, some hate each other, some love others, and few get along with. The conflict is explored through the PoV of Jedi Vildar Mac, the main character of this first issue.
He was supposed to be on Togruta, but requested a posting to Jedha for reasons unknown. Once he lands, he is introduced to Padawan Matthea Cathley. A talkative lovable Padawan who serves as Mac’s introduction guide to Jedha.
They trek right into the first conflict, between multiple force-adherent cultures. That is the main action of this first issue. Exploring the Holy City, experiencing it in all of its glory, and issues. It makes for a very interesting experience. Vildar represents the audience in a way. Like him, we have no idea who these people are, what they stand for, and whether their purposes are generally beneficial or nefarious.
Naturally, it wouldn’t be a Cavan Scott story without some surprises, some amazing background work in terms of throwaway lines giving us way too many questions as opposed to answers, and character beats which can sometimes make a character feel fully fleshed out even though we know not who they are.
The backup story is also lovely. There, we get to see how some of the biggest religions….convene with each other to put it best. Full of arguing and fighting, yet they do not realize how they are all hyprocties. Well, sort of realize it when Padawan Oliviah Zeveron ends the conflict, but I chalk that up to them really shrugging it off. It was nice to get to see Oliviah. Her appearance was something of a shock to me. I know she was in the concept art with Matthea, but having her pop up so early with no teases or anything of the like was certainly a pleasant surprise.
The art is superb. Ario Aninditio could have done the same style as he did within the 2021-2022 series. That art was impeccable and superb, and whenever he was absent in an issue, his absence was most definitely felt. With this new series, he has changed his style and brought his A game. The art has a more retro style.
It still feels like the High Republic. His detail as always is impeccable. That two-page panel of Jedha at the beginning is truly shocking with the amount of detail. You can pinpoint different quadrants of the panel, and yet all look like it could be real.
Crowds are also prevalent in Jedha, as could be expected. It is a bit of a tourist destination, as most wish to go to one holy destination or another, or visit one the multiple holy bodies that consecrate there. Each panel feels like it belongs. There is nothing really out of place, or anything that stands out as “wrong”.
Andrea Broccardo also does a swell job on the backup story. Her style is not so different from Ario’s and it still fits. It is a much better transition than what we got last year between Ario and Georges Jeanty. The panel with Oliviah meditating in front of that sole Jedi statue has to be their standout panel on this issue.
To wrap this up, it is damn good to have The High Republic comics. A monthly joy that I have missed dearly over the last 6 months. Within this issue, few faults exist and none that I can find. Giving this a very well deserved 5/5 stars.
Hello Jedha! Home to all things related to the force. Not just Jedi Knights, but adherents to other religions (or cults) that the force plays a holy role in.
A trend in Phase II has to do with religions and cults. Jedha is full of them. The Holy City of the Force. Much like actual religion, some hate each other, some love others, and few get along with. The conflict is explored through the PoV of Jedi Vildar Mac, the main character of this first issue.
He was supposed to be on Togruta, but requested a posting to Jedha for reasons unknown. Once he lands, he is introduced to Padawan Matthea Cathley. A talkative lovable Padawan who serves as Mac’s introduction guide to Jedha.
They trek right into the first conflict, between multiple force-adherent cultures. That is the main action of this first issue. Exploring the Holy City, experiencing it in all of its glory, and issues. It makes for a very interesting experience. Vildar represents the audience in a way. Like him, we have no idea who these people are, what they stand for, and whether their purposes are generally beneficial or nefarious.
Naturally, it wouldn’t be a Cavan Scott story without some surprises, some amazing background work in terms of throwaway lines giving us way too many questions as opposed to answers, and character beats which can sometimes make a character feel fully fleshed out even though we know not who they are.
The backup story is also lovely. There, we get to see how some of the biggest religions….convene with each other to put it best. Full of arguing and fighting, yet they do not realize how they are all hyprocties. Well, sort of realize it when Padawan Oliviah Zeveron ends the conflict, but I chalk that up to them really shrugging it off. It was nice to get to see Oliviah. Her appearance was something of a shock to me. I know she was in the concept art with Matthea, but having her pop up so early with no teases or anything of the like was certainly a pleasant surprise.
The art is superb. Ario Aninditio could have done the same style as he did within the 2021-2022 series. That art was impeccable and superb, and whenever he was absent in an issue, his absence was most definitely felt. With this new series, he has changed his style and brought his A game. The art has a more retro style.
It still feels like the High Republic. His detail as always is impeccable. That two-page panel of Jedha at the beginning is truly shocking with the amount of detail. You can pinpoint different quadrants of the panel, and yet all look like it could be real.
Crowds are also prevalent in Jedha, as could be expected. It is a bit of a tourist destination, as most wish to go to one holy destination or another, or visit one the multiple holy bodies that consecrate there. Each panel feels like it belongs. There is nothing really out of place, or anything that stands out as “wrong”.
Andrea Broccardo also does a swell job on the backup story. Her style is not so different from Ario’s and it still fits. It is a much better transition than what we got last year between Ario and Georges Jeanty. The panel with Oliviah meditating in front of that sole Jedi statue has to be their standout panel on this issue.
To wrap this up, it is damn good to have The High Republic comics. A monthly joy that I have missed dearly over the last 6 months. Within this issue, few faults exist and none that I can find. Giving this a very well deserved 5/5 stars.
November 23, 2022
3.5 stars.
What a fascinating and engaging read.
I loved this issue so much.
Getting to see this Convocation thing in action and what it's supposed to do. Visiting Jehda, a place we've seen and heard about but never seen in its glory days, was quite fun but, definitely, the best part was getting to explore and being exposed to all these different Force-worshipper religions and seeing the world get expanded.
After all, it only makes sense that there would be so many different interpretations of something as mythical as the Force.
Now, I want more and I think this comic series will give it to me so I am hyped.
“Not many remember their lives before the order. Vildar Mac always said he was one of the lucky ones. A joke? Maybe, the truth? That remained to be seen. He didn’t remember everything. How could he? He had only been 4 years old. He didn’t remember his parents, and he did not remember his home. But he remembered when evil came to his village. He remembered the darkness… and he remembered the fear. Certainly not all the time, and not when he was awake. The memories came in fits and starts, and he thought he could control them. Of course, he did. He was Jedi. But even Jedi dream.”
What a fascinating and engaging read.
I loved this issue so much.
Getting to see this Convocation thing in action and what it's supposed to do. Visiting Jehda, a place we've seen and heard about but never seen in its glory days, was quite fun but, definitely, the best part was getting to explore and being exposed to all these different Force-worshipper religions and seeing the world get expanded.
After all, it only makes sense that there would be so many different interpretations of something as mythical as the Force.
Now, I want more and I think this comic series will give it to me so I am hyped.
“I’m sure the Convocation seemed like a good idea when it was first created… much like the statues. An advisory body designed to promote understanding between the various religious groups of Jedha. A place for deliberation and debate. Where all are welcome. What’s not to love? […] Yes, well… that’s the general idea.”
October 13, 2022
First issues are always tricky, because you need to lure people in (new comers as well as longtime fans) and guarantee in the shortest possible time that this is going to be a good story. And Cavan Scott can easily do that in this brief issue while setting up the growing conflict on Jedha, which I'm guessing will eventually come to a head in George Mann's audiodrama The Battle of Jedha.
Issue 1 deals with the arrival of Jedi Vildar Mac on Jedha. A taciturn Jedi with a complicated past, he is already given a lot to process because everyone he meets seems to want to do the one thing he has no interest in doing: talking. And no one does that better than the Jedi Padawan sent to greet him: Matthea Cathley. This young Twi'lek is a hoot and a half because she just seems to say whatever comes through her head at that particular moment, before remembering that there was something she was supposed to say. Very quickly establishes both characters very quickly, and makes them both likeable.
And Matty's introduction of Jedha to Vildar finishes the set-up in a pretty seemless way. Particularly the thing that is going to make following this series so easy and so different from following Keeve Trennis's adventures in the previous main High Republic series:
The Jedi are not the only Force-using group on Jedha!
Both Issue 1 and its bonus story, 'Peace and Unity', establish that very well and provide the set up for the main conflict of this prequel. Where Phase I establishes the Jedi as a dominant force (no pun intent, just happy coincidence), Phase II is making clear that, in these early days of expansion, the frontier is occupied by other Force-worshiping groups, some familiar to the reader for those who have read the old Expanded Universe (such as the Fallanassi), others known only by reputation even for film watchers (the Guardian of the Whills), others probably established for the series (the Truthsayers of Bpfassh), and yet more with significance for the characters (ths Sorcerers of Tund clearly had a pronounced effect on Vildar).
And, perhaps unsurprisingly in a a galaxy that is only five centuries on from the devastating wars of the Jedi and the Sith, these groups don't get on. Scott does a good job showing how even people who believe in the same thing (the Force) can have vastly different views on how it should be used. And the Convocation of the Force, while a great idea in pratice, echoes a lot of real world religious gatherings, such as the First Council of Nicaea in Christianity, and how these groups are more interested in focusing on their differences and finding causes for conflict than they are on the thing they worship and all agree on. Just as Path of Deceit is establishing the fundamental difference between using the Force and leaving it 'free', this issue pushes that even more and seems to be setting the tone for the rest of Phase II, and the conflict that will continue so much later (chronologically) but have already been covered (in a very Star Warsy original, prequel set up) in Phase I.
So, in a very limited number of pages, Scott has established his characters and his setting with very mininal effort. But has he given us more than just set-up in this first issue?
HELL YES!
I still can't quite wrap my head around the way this issue ends, and I can't say anything about it without spoiling it, but it certainly sets the stage for what will come next in an even clearer way than Sskeer's trauma in his first series did. So, once more, Scott, who produced some true gems in Phase I such as The Rising Storm and the audiodrama Tempest Runner, is promising us something great. And I'm on board for it.
Issue 1 deals with the arrival of Jedi Vildar Mac on Jedha. A taciturn Jedi with a complicated past, he is already given a lot to process because everyone he meets seems to want to do the one thing he has no interest in doing: talking. And no one does that better than the Jedi Padawan sent to greet him: Matthea Cathley. This young Twi'lek is a hoot and a half because she just seems to say whatever comes through her head at that particular moment, before remembering that there was something she was supposed to say. Very quickly establishes both characters very quickly, and makes them both likeable.
And Matty's introduction of Jedha to Vildar finishes the set-up in a pretty seemless way. Particularly the thing that is going to make following this series so easy and so different from following Keeve Trennis's adventures in the previous main High Republic series:
The Jedi are not the only Force-using group on Jedha!
Both Issue 1 and its bonus story, 'Peace and Unity', establish that very well and provide the set up for the main conflict of this prequel. Where Phase I establishes the Jedi as a dominant force (no pun intent, just happy coincidence), Phase II is making clear that, in these early days of expansion, the frontier is occupied by other Force-worshiping groups, some familiar to the reader for those who have read the old Expanded Universe (such as the Fallanassi), others known only by reputation even for film watchers (the Guardian of the Whills), others probably established for the series (the Truthsayers of Bpfassh), and yet more with significance for the characters (ths Sorcerers of Tund clearly had a pronounced effect on Vildar).
And, perhaps unsurprisingly in a a galaxy that is only five centuries on from the devastating wars of the Jedi and the Sith, these groups don't get on. Scott does a good job showing how even people who believe in the same thing (the Force) can have vastly different views on how it should be used. And the Convocation of the Force, while a great idea in pratice, echoes a lot of real world religious gatherings, such as the First Council of Nicaea in Christianity, and how these groups are more interested in focusing on their differences and finding causes for conflict than they are on the thing they worship and all agree on. Just as Path of Deceit is establishing the fundamental difference between using the Force and leaving it 'free', this issue pushes that even more and seems to be setting the tone for the rest of Phase II, and the conflict that will continue so much later (chronologically) but have already been covered (in a very Star Warsy original, prequel set up) in Phase I.
So, in a very limited number of pages, Scott has established his characters and his setting with very mininal effort. But has he given us more than just set-up in this first issue?
HELL YES!
I still can't quite wrap my head around the way this issue ends, and I can't say anything about it without spoiling it, but it certainly sets the stage for what will come next in an even clearer way than Sskeer's trauma in his first series did. So, once more, Scott, who produced some true gems in Phase I such as The Rising Storm and the audiodrama Tempest Runner, is promising us something great. And I'm on board for it.
January 1, 2025
this came in clutch at 11:30pm on dec 31. made my reading goal with this lol.
October 13, 2022
“Above all, Jedha was a haven, a sanctuary. It was a place to retreat and reflect and renew. A place where you could discover who you truly were…. and who you could become. But not for this proud man. For this protector of the Light. He knew exactly who he was.”
This issue kicks off the new High Republic comic by Cavan Scott. I was so excited to start Phase 2 of this saga and this issue did not disappoint! In this issue we are introduced to our two leads, a grumpy, troubled Jedi Vildar Mac, and a bubbly padawan called Matty. Vildar arrives on Jedha, ready to get down to work, but he and Matty are immediately sent on a mission to locate a stolen relic, and quickly, all goes to hell.
This issue was wild, a perfect beginning. The ending left me so, so pumped for the next issue. The characters were introduced well and I feel like I already have a solid idea on what they are like. Vildar's story arc is already very intriguing, and I like how these demons and traumas of his past are affecting him in present day, even though he was so young when those bad things happened that he hardly remembers them. Matty seems like a sweetie and must be protected at all costs.
Jedha is a fascinating location and I am so happy that we're getting to see it at this point in time when it's not under imperial occupation or something like that. Jedha is a melting pool of different cultured, beliefs, communities and all kinds of people, and I love how it was depicted. It was full, vibrant and colourful, but there are also quarrels, misunderstandings and fights constantly breaking out due to different cults and faiths having to co-exist. I love the idea of Jedha as a shared holy space, a planet and city that is sacred to all kinds of ideologies, and I'm super eager to see more of the Convocation of the Force, a panel of representatives from different ideologies and cultures, who are trying to act as mediators and peacekeepers to stop these quarrels from happening.
Cavan Scott has knocked it out of the park once again. The art is also phenomenal and expressive. I cannot wait for next month's issue!
This issue kicks off the new High Republic comic by Cavan Scott. I was so excited to start Phase 2 of this saga and this issue did not disappoint! In this issue we are introduced to our two leads, a grumpy, troubled Jedi Vildar Mac, and a bubbly padawan called Matty. Vildar arrives on Jedha, ready to get down to work, but he and Matty are immediately sent on a mission to locate a stolen relic, and quickly, all goes to hell.
This issue was wild, a perfect beginning. The ending left me so, so pumped for the next issue. The characters were introduced well and I feel like I already have a solid idea on what they are like. Vildar's story arc is already very intriguing, and I like how these demons and traumas of his past are affecting him in present day, even though he was so young when those bad things happened that he hardly remembers them. Matty seems like a sweetie and must be protected at all costs.
Jedha is a fascinating location and I am so happy that we're getting to see it at this point in time when it's not under imperial occupation or something like that. Jedha is a melting pool of different cultured, beliefs, communities and all kinds of people, and I love how it was depicted. It was full, vibrant and colourful, but there are also quarrels, misunderstandings and fights constantly breaking out due to different cults and faiths having to co-exist. I love the idea of Jedha as a shared holy space, a planet and city that is sacred to all kinds of ideologies, and I'm super eager to see more of the Convocation of the Force, a panel of representatives from different ideologies and cultures, who are trying to act as mediators and peacekeepers to stop these quarrels from happening.
Cavan Scott has knocked it out of the park once again. The art is also phenomenal and expressive. I cannot wait for next month's issue!
October 18, 2022
A lot of stuff happens in this issue compared to most modern single issue comic book. My first foray into the comics of the High Republic era was quite enjoyable and interesting. This issue was a great jumping on point introducing readers to the setting of phase II and some of its factions and characters in a fun way.
We, as readers, arrive with the Jedi Vildar Mac to the pilgrim moon Jedha and immediately get embroiled in the conflicting public opinions and religions while we try to investigate a theft of a religious artifact as well. The perspective of someone new with a traumatic past entering into this place which is as new to him as to the readers was a good way to introduce us to the setting.
Cavan Scott also kept throwing various factions and species at us at considerable speed, reminding readers of the richness of the Star Wars universe. The plot progression was free flowing and swept us along nicely for the ride, abruptly jolting us with the ending twist and the reveal of the surprise narrator.
The art by Anindito and Morales did a fine job depicting the beautiful locations and backgrounds while nicely introducing us to this dizzying array of different species in such a short scope. I would have loved a bit more dynamic approach to the fight scenes, though, hopefully this will be implemented in the future.
The side story 'Peace and Unity' does a brilliant job of introducing us to another new Jedi and showing us a glimpse of the Convocation and yet more new species to sink our teeth into. And the short story also has a nice bit of ironic humor to make it more enjoyable.
All in all, this was a thoroughly enjoyable entry into the new phase of the High Republic for both old and new readers. 4.5 out of 5 stars from me.
For more reviews and stuff check out my blog -
http://ihate00critics.blogspot.com/
We, as readers, arrive with the Jedi Vildar Mac to the pilgrim moon Jedha and immediately get embroiled in the conflicting public opinions and religions while we try to investigate a theft of a religious artifact as well. The perspective of someone new with a traumatic past entering into this place which is as new to him as to the readers was a good way to introduce us to the setting.
Cavan Scott also kept throwing various factions and species at us at considerable speed, reminding readers of the richness of the Star Wars universe. The plot progression was free flowing and swept us along nicely for the ride, abruptly jolting us with the ending twist and the reveal of the surprise narrator.
The art by Anindito and Morales did a fine job depicting the beautiful locations and backgrounds while nicely introducing us to this dizzying array of different species in such a short scope. I would have loved a bit more dynamic approach to the fight scenes, though, hopefully this will be implemented in the future.
The side story 'Peace and Unity' does a brilliant job of introducing us to another new Jedi and showing us a glimpse of the Convocation and yet more new species to sink our teeth into. And the short story also has a nice bit of ironic humor to make it more enjoyable.
All in all, this was a thoroughly enjoyable entry into the new phase of the High Republic for both old and new readers. 4.5 out of 5 stars from me.
For more reviews and stuff check out my blog -
http://ihate00critics.blogspot.com/
November 1, 2022
The Start Into A New Era
conclusion:
A first issue full of mystery and potential - off to a great start. 5/5
story:
"The High Republic #1" by Cavan Scott brings the reader to the so-called "pilgrim moon" aka Jedha. Jedi Vildar Mac arrives on the surface and realizes soon enough that the city of harmony is not as peaceful as it once was. Meanwhile a central institution which was installed to bring the many religious groups of Jedha together experiences one of its freuquent conflicts.
rating:
"High Republic" is off to a great start with the mysterious city of Jedha as a new core location. The events of Phase II take place approximately 150 years before the fall of Starlight Station. Hyperspace is still dangerous to travel and vastly unexplored while many pilgrims search for peace and knowledge on Jedha. The first issue supports the reader in introducing himself to the holy city. I felt excited to read on and find out more about the people and their beliefs. Of course the huge amount of different opinions will ultimately lead to disputs and conflicts which sets an action-packed surrounding for the coming stories. Vildar Mac seems like an interesting protagonist and the reader starts off with a snippet of the Jedi's past packed into a nightmare. A small piece of memory which sets the rough tone for the otherwise more or less grumpy character. The padawan who awaits him in Jedha is a more or less comical relief but good become so much more. I'm intrigued to find out more about Jedha, the mysteries it holds and the two Jedi. Meanwhile the art looks amazing and shines with its vibrant colors and Star-Wars-feeling.
conclusion:
A first issue full of mystery and potential - off to a great start. 5/5
October 12, 2022
A wild and intriguing launch for The High Republic Phase 2 comics! The new characters are already precious to me, with at least one mysterious back-story hinted, another dear Padawan with restraint issues, and unexpected appearances from a few other new characters. We also get a glimpse of the unique social climate on Jedha as conflicting Force-related religious entities apparently attempt to establish common ground. This comic has a great mix of world-building and exposition, action, references to other media of the era and beyond, and of course, a touch of horror. It's all rendered through Ario Anindito's beautiful art. We also get a bonus backup story in this issue, and Andrea Broccardo leaves his touch on the series with careful depictions of a fascinating cast of new characters in a moment of conflict. This issue is great fun that leaves me desperate for the next installment!
November 28, 2022
Cavan Scott delivers yet again.
Here's the first issue for Phase 2 of the main comic and it is fantastic. It is divided into two stories, the prime one starts in a good way and with a single twist left me in a state of "Wait, what the heck?" The bonus story was also great but so far i'm more interested in the first one.
Both stories had compelling and colorful characters and good enough action.
Overall: I didn't know what to expect (and to be honest i wasn't really keen on the idea of the whole 150 years in the past thing when i heard it) but from this first Issue and what i heard from Path of Deceit,i have to say, things don't look bad.
Here's the first issue for Phase 2 of the main comic and it is fantastic. It is divided into two stories, the prime one starts in a good way and with a single twist left me in a state of "Wait, what the heck?" The bonus story was also great but so far i'm more interested in the first one.
Both stories had compelling and colorful characters and good enough action.
Overall: I didn't know what to expect (and to be honest i wasn't really keen on the idea of the whole 150 years in the past thing when i heard it) but from this first Issue and what i heard from Path of Deceit,i have to say, things don't look bad.
October 17, 2022
Adventures in Galactic Jerusalem!
If you like exploring philosophies of the Force, then it seems Phase II of the High Republic is made for you! Set on the Pilgrim Moon of Jedha, the relationship between the Jedi and other Force-believing religions is in the spotlight as a veteran Jedi arrives for his new posting on Jedha and stumbles straight into the diversity of belief and practice, as well as a young Padawan who knows the streets and is investigating the mystery of stolen relics. The introduction to the Convocation and final twist both left me eager for more!
If you like exploring philosophies of the Force, then it seems Phase II of the High Republic is made for you! Set on the Pilgrim Moon of Jedha, the relationship between the Jedi and other Force-believing religions is in the spotlight as a veteran Jedi arrives for his new posting on Jedha and stumbles straight into the diversity of belief and practice, as well as a young Padawan who knows the streets and is investigating the mystery of stolen relics. The introduction to the Convocation and final twist both left me eager for more!
October 13, 2022
Jako nevěděla jsem, že do Star Wars zahrnou téma náboženského schizmatu a nesnášenlivosti, ale je to super udělaný. Vzali si z Phase 1 poučení, že komiksy by se neměly tolik vázat ke knihám, což je super. Postavy a worldbuilding skvělý. Storytelling a kresba taky. Vše na jedničku. Uvidíme dál. Fakt lépe provedený začátek, než u hlavního HR komiksu před rokem.
October 22, 2022
This was a good continuation after Path of Deceit…Love the Jedi…this build up is getting to be some real shit about to go down! A war! Love the illustrations on some of the pages as well! The dialogue fits with the illustrations…overall this was a great comic start to the high republic era
October 26, 2022
Pretty great starting point for the new comic series. Please read Path of Deceit first, there are some connections here that definitely are enhance by reading it. However, this issue can be read on its own
January 17, 2023
What a great first issue. The art was good and the story kicked into gear right away. Both of the stories were interesting and have characters that are fun and worth reading more about. Very excited for this to continue.
September 25, 2023
THIS is how you start a comic book series. Action was high, the characters were introduced efficiently and effectively, the story left me wanting to find out what’s next. Between this and Path of Deceit, Phase 2 of the High Republic is off to a very strong start!
October 26, 2022
A pretty good start. It's interesting how between this Jedha stuff and Andor, we've been getting more Rogue One backstory lately.
November 12, 2022
I just love the High Republic era and am so excited to see where this next wave of stories go!
January 1, 2023
interesting to see jedha and the chaos it is
May 17, 2023
I love how they’re embracing the weirdness of having various brands of Force users.
July 24, 2023
4.5 Stars
October 9, 2023
I'm no critic
Not bad for book one. I liked seeing Sunshine in the flesh. I'm excited to see where this goes. Solid
Not bad for book one. I liked seeing Sunshine in the flesh. I'm excited to see where this goes. Solid
January 25, 2024
#1 – The Pilgrim Moon – “Not many Jedi remember their lives before the Order.”
Displaying 1 - 24 of 24 reviews