5 stars. A sensational and fantastic book! And if you read all of this review, I’ll send you a gold star sticker in the mail 🌟
To start, as the echoes of covid and all that the pandemic entails continues to reverberate globally, this book arrives as a crucial and timely piece of work. It doesn’t stop at just dissecting the systemic racism deeply ingrained in our healthcare and medicine and science here in the west, but also lays down the urgency of decolonisation, making it essential reading not only fr healthcare professionals but fr anyone concerned about the glaring disparities vulnerable and marginalised populations face.
Sowemimo’s eloquence in unravelling the complex historical roots of modern medicine is well-researched and accessible, and she confronts these uncomfortable truths head-on, forcing us to reevaluate our understanding of modern western healthcare’s colonial and racist past that’s still bleeding into the present. Overall, she presents us w a searingly truthful account that speaks to the heart of the matter.
Sowemimo’s lived experience in this book also really shines through, as a doctor, patient, activist, etc etc, that all infuse authenticity into her overarching narrative. Through her, I was able to further my knowledge and understanding of the stark realities of systemic racism, hidden histories, and healthcare myths that persist today, and her courage in sharing these experiences really underscore the urgency of this conversation.
One thing I really appreciated in the book was her discussion on how we perceive the advancements in modern science and medicine. As she explains, it challenges the prevailing narrative that attributes these advancements solely to individual “geniuses”, who were more often then not privileged white European men, while overlooking, ignoring, and concealing the collective and more diverse contributions that have shaped modern medicine. Like modern medicine is a result of collective learning and collaboration across cultures, borrowed and sometimes appropriated frm different traditions, and this perspective forces us to acknowledge the rich tapestry of medical knowledge that existed long before the advent of “modern” medicine, often held by Indigenous cultures and other marginalised groups.
And by perpetuating this notion that modern medicine is primarily a product of white European male genius, we unintentionally (but also intentionally) erase the contributions of Indigenous and other historically marginalised communities. As Sowemimo explains, this erasure not only distorts the history of medicine but also reinforces harmful stereotypes and power imbalances. Likewise, the deliberate obscuring of the full history of medicine serves a colonial and white supremacist agenda, suggesting that Indigenous and enslaved people lacked the intellectual capacity to care fr themselves before European colonisation, and this viewpoint is not only entirely inaccurate but also incredibly harmful, as it dismisses the resilience, knowledge, and contributions of these communities. As she says, “We believe that Western medicine heralded progress, but the reality is that it could never have progressed were it not for colonial exposure to ‘traditional’ medicine practised in the Global South.”
Sowemimo also highlights a critical issue in the criminal legal system, in that her proposal to seek alternatives to incarceration challenges the conventional notion of retribution, drawn frm her experience as a doctor treating victims of sexual violence. She recognises that our current system in place in the west often fails to provide victims w the necessary tools, such as therapy and monetary reparations, to address the psychological traumas they endure after sexual violence, and this forces us to question the efficacy of punitive approaches, raising important questions about rehabilitation, healing, and addressing the root causes of criminal behaviour. As she says, we must envision a more compassionate and effective way of addressing crime and supporting those who have suffered its consequences, as the current system we have in place is very clearly not working.
I also found a lot of value in Sowemimo’s exploration of another critical issue in modern healthcare: the digital divide. In an age where technology is becoming increasingly integrated into healthcare services, there’s this steadily growing disparity between those who can easily access digital healthcare solutions and those who cannot. This divide disproportionately affects vulnerable populations, including the elderly, the homeless, the working class, and those w limited computer education. She explains that it’s evident that as healthcare services move online, those who are already at risk of poor health are further marginalised. As we continue to build internet-based healthcare solutions, we must ensure that we leave no one behind and work to create a healthcare system that serves all members of society, regardless of their digital capabilities or socioeconomic status.
All up, this book not only exposes the racial biases within medicine but also provides an illuminating perspective on how our world operates and, also importantly, who it serves. It’s a wake-up call that demands our attention, and it’s impossible to read it w/out being profoundly moved. ‘Divided’ has helped further reshape my perception of health and medicine, in a similar vein to ‘Inflamed’ by Rupa Marya and Raj Patel, and if you enjoyed that book you’ll undoubtedly appreciate this work as well. ‘Divided’ deserves nothing less than five stars fr its eloquence, urgency, and the profound impact it can make on our world. My gratitude to the author fr this monumental contribution to our understanding of healthcare, racism, and the pressing need fr decolonisation.