DO. NOT. READ. THIS. BOOK.
According to Joel C. Rosenberg, it's okay that 6 million Jews died at the hands of the Nazis because not *ALL* of the Jews died. God got the Jews through it, just like he saw them through Egyptian slavery! Sure, he only managed to save like 10% max of those who went into concentration camps, but it's all good. Because he came through at the end! You know, after the Nazis had nearly finished what they set out to do, effectively wiping out Europe's entire Jewish population because those who did survive immediately booked it for Palestine and the U.S.
Even though I've never heard someone blame Christians for the Holocaust, Joel C. Rosenberg makes a hell of a lot of excuses for them and how even church-going Nazis weren't *real* Christians. No shit. But Christians across Europe are culpable in the fact that a very very tiny percentage of non-Jews in Europe actually did something to save the Jews. Denmark and the French city of Le Chambon were anomalies in terms of actual communities of people who worked together to save Jews, as were the individuals who made up various resistance groups, but the MAJORITY of Christians in Europe were not only apathetic, but were in fact COMPLICIT in the Holocaust, especially in Poland where most people threw morality and values out the window to turn in their Jewish neighbors to the police so they could be rewarded with loaves of bread. I don't blame these people - they did what they had to in order to survive, even if it meant culpability in systematic murder. But this book basically asserts that all Christians in Europe were saints because they loved Jesus so much and Jesus was Jewish. He spends less of the book on his weak plot and more on trying to get us to believe that Christians have literally zero responsibility for what happened. (He also seems to believe that Polish Christians were evangelical Protestants when in fact like 90% of Poles were Roman Catholic but I digress.)
It's so alarmingly offensive, I really don't even know where to begin. Aside from Rosenberg making excuses on every other page and aside from him making every character try to force their belief in God in the main character Jacob Weisz (who, SHOCKER, becomes a Christian and believes in God by the end of the book!), there are just so many problematic issues...I rolled my eyes at the less offensive nonsense but mostly gritted my teeth in rage.
Basically, the author is trying to say that Jews shouldn't have lost faith in God during the Holocaust because sometimes, he looked out for his 'chosen people' and even though it happened, God eventually ended it. I mean, come on, God. Too little too late, amirite? Of course, many Jews did hold onto their faith...but those who did lose faith had a pretty valid reason. They don't need some asshat who could barely do his research to come around 70 years later and explain why they should have all kept on praying.
There's a lot to hate about this book, but on top of everything the research done was abysmal. Two sentences in, a character quotes some made-up book. It's 1940 and the quote is "evil, unchecked, is the prelude to genocide." COOL, except the word genocide didn't actually exist in a wide scale vernacular until 1944, when it was coined and introduced by Raphael Lemkin. That one little factual error irked me to my core pretty much immediately, but I clearly didn't know what was coming. There are smaller errors as well, some intentional (i.e. changing the dates Mengele worked at the camp so it fit his narrative) but most not.
It's just a mess of a book. True god awful trash. I picked it up because of the high ratings, and then I remembered that most people are dumb and give this book a 5 because of Jesus and not because it's actually good. To be fair, without Rosenberg's obnoxious proselytizing, it moves quickly and tells a compelling story, but it truly is evangelical propaganda thinly disguised as historical fiction. If anything, it's religious fiction, and Rosenberg should be ashamed of himself for taking a Jewish tragedy and turning it into a Christian missionary tale. No, Christians were not responsible for the Holocaust; it was about racial makeup, not religion. I don't think anyone has ever blamed Christians for the atrocities committed. But at the same time, Christianity is not a solution to the suffering caused by the Nazis. Doing this is SO problematic because you're essentially saying that it's okay that Nazis killed millions of people because God eventually swooped in and saved a few. WRONG. GROSS AND WRONG.