What do you think?
Rate this book
Beyond Innocence: The Life Sentence of Darryl Hunt
A deeply reported, gripping narrative of injustice, exoneration, and the lifelong impact of incarceration, Beyond Innocence is the poignant saga of one remarkable life that sheds vitally important light on the failures of the American justice system at every level In June 1985, a young Black man in Winston-Salem, N.C. named Darryl Hunt was falsely convicted and sentenced to life in prison for the rape and murder of a white copyeditor at the local paper. Many in the community believed him innocent and crusaded for his release even as subsequent trials and appeals reinforced his sentence. Finally, in 2003, the tireless efforts of his attorney combined with an award-winning series of articles by Phoebe Zerwick in the Winston-Salem Journal led to the DNA evidence that exonerated Hunt. Three years later, the acclaimed documentary, The Trials of Darryl Hunt , made him known across the country and brought his story to audiences around the world. But Hunt’s story was far from over. As Zerwick poignantly reveals, it is singularly significant in the annals of the miscarriage of justice and for the legacy Hunt ultimately bequeathed. Part true crime drama, part chronicle of a life cut short by systemic racism, Beyond Innocence powerfully illuminates the sustained catastrophe faced by an innocent person in prison and the civil death nearly everyone who has been incarcerated experiences attempting to restart their lives. Freed after nineteen years behind bars, Darryl Hunt became a national advocate for social justice, and his case inspired lasting reforms, among them a law that allows those on death row to appeal their sentence with evidence of racial bias. He was a beacon of hope for so many—until he could no longer bear the burden of what he had endured and took his own life. Fluidly crafted by a master journalist, Beyond Innocence makes an urgent moral call for an American reckoning with the legacies of racism in the criminal justice system and the human toll of the carceral state.
338 pages, Kindle Edition
Published March 8, 2022
24 people are currently reading
272 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 34 reviews
February 28, 2024
This book is one that ripped at my heartstrings because there was no happily ever after ending to the wrongful conviction of Darryl Hunt. His case is one of many criminal injustice cases that we have heard of much too often. Along with the pain, and raw emotions that you felt knowing about this case, you also come away enraged by the venom people of power spewed on people, no matter how innocent they were, due to extreme racism. I couldn't put this book down and was not shocked due to the evidence of the highs and the lowest of lows the criminal justice system embodies.
While we are fully aware of, and in many situations experienced the darkness of injustice, the magnitude is astonishing and history proves that it always has been a game-changer of life. Darryl Hunt always pleaded his innocence of not committing the crime he was charged, and imprisoned for. He refused to compromise his innocence. He was not prepared to sell his birthright.
Phoebe Zerwick did an amazing job of investigative journalism to meticulously chronicle personal and legal facts that finally led to Hunt's exoneration.
Always, there was the pain few could understand, the pain of enduring all this for someone else's crime...Prison life requires a code of silence, for the perpetrators of violence, for its victims, and for its witnesses.
Hunt was leery of putting too much in writing. There was no telling what the guards would do to him if they knew what was in his heart.
Darryl carried the weight of a lifetime of loss. It was mind-boggling how deeply flawed the case against Darryl Hunt and others like him really was. He had panic attacks, which is a classic symptom of PTSD, for the body remembers what the mind tries to forget. Years of wrongful imprisonment would leave those who suffer such injustice scarred. Their symptoms ranged from hypervigilance, nightmares, heart palpitations, and panic attacks to digestive disorders.
A study published in the Journal of Urban Health: Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine found that most individuals who had spent time in solitary were more likely than those who had not, were diagnosed wit post-traumatic disorder. If those experiencing solitary confinement are negatively affected by the exposure, it is society at large that bears the burden of 'resocializing them.' Those who spent time in solitary were more likely to die after leaving prison than those who did not, especially of suicide, homicide, and overdose. Idle time and isolation can make people lose their minds. The trauma manifests itself in such mental illnesses as reclusiveness, psychosis, and PTSD.
I was so impressed by the tireless commitment of Hunt's legal team led by Mark Rabil. From the time he met Darryl when he was arrested on these false charges, Mark never gave up on Hunt's defense case against all odds. Even when Rabil was grieving the death of his wife who battled breast cancer, Rabil didn't walk away. He stuck by Darryl until the very end.
Hunt could not escape the legacy of slavery and Jim Crow, the false narrative of Black men as sexual predators, the violence and tenderness of his youth, the terror of a jail cell, the heartbreak of a false conviction, the long years lost to captivity, and the public pressures that came next, the full weight of which he bore until he could bear no more. In March 2016, Darryl Hunt was found dead from a gunshot wound to the abdomen, and his death was ruled a suicide.
As Hunt would tell an interviewer: "Prison is just a warehouse, making money off of them, that's just sending the back on the street to go back again."
Scholars today make the case that our system of mass incarceration is rooted in slavery, a history that helps explain how and why Black men are so disproportionately represented in the nation's prisons. With the abolition of slavery, Jim Crow laws created a new form of bondage by criminalizing unemployment, loitering, and other conditions of impoverished Black life. Racial profiling by police and other forms of systemic racism made prisons the new plantation.
While we are fully aware of, and in many situations experienced the darkness of injustice, the magnitude is astonishing and history proves that it always has been a game-changer of life. Darryl Hunt always pleaded his innocence of not committing the crime he was charged, and imprisoned for. He refused to compromise his innocence. He was not prepared to sell his birthright.
Phoebe Zerwick did an amazing job of investigative journalism to meticulously chronicle personal and legal facts that finally led to Hunt's exoneration.
Always, there was the pain few could understand, the pain of enduring all this for someone else's crime...Prison life requires a code of silence, for the perpetrators of violence, for its victims, and for its witnesses.
Hunt was leery of putting too much in writing. There was no telling what the guards would do to him if they knew what was in his heart.
Darryl carried the weight of a lifetime of loss. It was mind-boggling how deeply flawed the case against Darryl Hunt and others like him really was. He had panic attacks, which is a classic symptom of PTSD, for the body remembers what the mind tries to forget. Years of wrongful imprisonment would leave those who suffer such injustice scarred. Their symptoms ranged from hypervigilance, nightmares, heart palpitations, and panic attacks to digestive disorders.
A study published in the Journal of Urban Health: Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine found that most individuals who had spent time in solitary were more likely than those who had not, were diagnosed wit post-traumatic disorder. If those experiencing solitary confinement are negatively affected by the exposure, it is society at large that bears the burden of 'resocializing them.' Those who spent time in solitary were more likely to die after leaving prison than those who did not, especially of suicide, homicide, and overdose. Idle time and isolation can make people lose their minds. The trauma manifests itself in such mental illnesses as reclusiveness, psychosis, and PTSD.
I was so impressed by the tireless commitment of Hunt's legal team led by Mark Rabil. From the time he met Darryl when he was arrested on these false charges, Mark never gave up on Hunt's defense case against all odds. Even when Rabil was grieving the death of his wife who battled breast cancer, Rabil didn't walk away. He stuck by Darryl until the very end.
Hunt could not escape the legacy of slavery and Jim Crow, the false narrative of Black men as sexual predators, the violence and tenderness of his youth, the terror of a jail cell, the heartbreak of a false conviction, the long years lost to captivity, and the public pressures that came next, the full weight of which he bore until he could bear no more. In March 2016, Darryl Hunt was found dead from a gunshot wound to the abdomen, and his death was ruled a suicide.
As Hunt would tell an interviewer: "Prison is just a warehouse, making money off of them, that's just sending the back on the street to go back again."
Scholars today make the case that our system of mass incarceration is rooted in slavery, a history that helps explain how and why Black men are so disproportionately represented in the nation's prisons. With the abolition of slavery, Jim Crow laws created a new form of bondage by criminalizing unemployment, loitering, and other conditions of impoverished Black life. Racial profiling by police and other forms of systemic racism made prisons the new plantation.
March 7, 2022
This is such a well-written mixture of the very personal, heart-wrenching life and death of Darryl Hunt with a balance of facts around the never-ending horrors of our "justice" system. Her way of moving between the story of Mr. Hunt and the data around the criminal justice system reminded me of J.Anthony Lukas' Common Ground.
Much of the injustice in this book doesn't come as a surprise. But the level of it does. It is hard to realize how completely these wrongly convicted people are destroyed by the experience. And how widely that destruction extends to those who care about them.
And the recidivism rates - good lord, how can anyone ignore this and not realize how horribly our system is failing everyone?
Ms. Zerwick has managed to pull together so many different people and facts to produce a book that should be read by everyone, especially those interested in police or legal work. She leaves the reader with the understanding that there must be a better way.
Much of the injustice in this book doesn't come as a surprise. But the level of it does. It is hard to realize how completely these wrongly convicted people are destroyed by the experience. And how widely that destruction extends to those who care about them.
And the recidivism rates - good lord, how can anyone ignore this and not realize how horribly our system is failing everyone?
Ms. Zerwick has managed to pull together so many different people and facts to produce a book that should be read by everyone, especially those interested in police or legal work. She leaves the reader with the understanding that there must be a better way.
May 19, 2024
This is a really important book, because it tells the story of how one man was wrongfully convicted, but also of a police coverup, the courts willfully ignoring evidence--even DNA, once testing became available--out of racism and an obtuse belief that the legal system is much less fallible than it is, and the immense trauma that a miscarriage of justice like this heaps onto the innocent person.
Phoebe Zerwick points out that many people see an exoneration as a victory, but the truth is much more complicated. How can we celebrate an innocent man being released when he was robbed of 19 years of his life and subjected to such dehumanizing conditions and treatment? How can we expect that person to ever be okay again? Being pressured to be the face of justice and reform is a lot to take on while also battling PTSD and readjusting to life on the outside--too much for any person to reasonably bear, as Darryl Hunt's story teaches us.
As a human, American, and North Carolinian, I found this book both powerful and appalling. The picture it paints is of the laziness and even intentional wrongdoing of our legal system, but also of the incredible power of community to persist and push for justice A tough read, but one that doesn't turn away from the nuance or complexity of the person at its center.
Phoebe Zerwick points out that many people see an exoneration as a victory, but the truth is much more complicated. How can we celebrate an innocent man being released when he was robbed of 19 years of his life and subjected to such dehumanizing conditions and treatment? How can we expect that person to ever be okay again? Being pressured to be the face of justice and reform is a lot to take on while also battling PTSD and readjusting to life on the outside--too much for any person to reasonably bear, as Darryl Hunt's story teaches us.
As a human, American, and North Carolinian, I found this book both powerful and appalling. The picture it paints is of the laziness and even intentional wrongdoing of our legal system, but also of the incredible power of community to persist and push for justice A tough read, but one that doesn't turn away from the nuance or complexity of the person at its center.
March 22, 2022
Compelling, readable, and well-researched, this book tells the story of the wrongful arrest and conviction of Darryl Hunt for the murder of Deborah Sykes in Winston-Salem, North Carolina, in 1984. The incompetence, and later, deception and malevolence of the police department is illustrative of the racsim of our criminal injustice system. After nearly 20 years of imprisionment, Hunt is exonerated, and goes on to advocate for others in the carcerel system. Hunt is deeply traumatized by the experience, however, and it is this lasting trauma that author Zerwick details in the latter portions of the book. The legacy of wrongful imprisonment and its effects have been underexamined; this book begins to correct that.
October 9, 2023
The life story of Darryl Hunt is one everyone should know because it drives home all that is wrong with our criminal justice system. Darryl Hunt worked unceasingly after being exonerated even though sharing his story continued to cause him additional trauma. His story is one I will carry with me.
February 26, 2024
the first third of this book literally made me nauseous. this book is not easy. but it's necessary. i am in awe of the people who supported Hunt throughout his incarceration, who fought for his release and devoted so much of their lives to his freedom. the least i can do is be informed about it, right...? not sure there is a right.
it's a tragic story. sometimes i was struck by how injustice can take the form of the mundane, the details. shoddy paperwork. bureaucracy. semantics. these small things, together, hide the more glaring forms of racism and prejudice.
and then, the most glaring form of injustice -- and the final impetus for Zerwick's writing of this book -- is the lack of post-incarceration support services, especially for those who have been wrongly imprisoned. isn't it insane that we can legally lock people up and take their freedom away and then just set them out on the streets sometimes with nothing more than a "good luck"? after years and years imprisoned? with something like the opposite of a college-education career path? we offer educational VA benefits to those who serve in our military but nothing to what are essentially POWs of our own country?
finally, this story was also a little bit of a cautionary tale about monetary compensation. no money could save Darryl Hunt. In fact, it might have had the opposite effect. the ability to throw money at problems can be such a cop out. sad, sad, saddy sad sad.
it's a tragic story. sometimes i was struck by how injustice can take the form of the mundane, the details. shoddy paperwork. bureaucracy. semantics. these small things, together, hide the more glaring forms of racism and prejudice.
and then, the most glaring form of injustice -- and the final impetus for Zerwick's writing of this book -- is the lack of post-incarceration support services, especially for those who have been wrongly imprisoned. isn't it insane that we can legally lock people up and take their freedom away and then just set them out on the streets sometimes with nothing more than a "good luck"? after years and years imprisoned? with something like the opposite of a college-education career path? we offer educational VA benefits to those who serve in our military but nothing to what are essentially POWs of our own country?
finally, this story was also a little bit of a cautionary tale about monetary compensation. no money could save Darryl Hunt. In fact, it might have had the opposite effect. the ability to throw money at problems can be such a cop out. sad, sad, saddy sad sad.
December 23, 2022
This whole book was a gut punch the whole way through. It was a raw look into our system and how it has failed many over the years!
There were lots of sections that were difficult to read only because they are tough to imagine someone going through.
I really thought the author did a great job at capturing all of Darryl Hunt’s story, and capturing the world around his story to give you the full picture.
There were lots of sections that were difficult to read only because they are tough to imagine someone going through.
I really thought the author did a great job at capturing all of Darryl Hunt’s story, and capturing the world around his story to give you the full picture.
February 21, 2024
Wow!! Knowing the topic of this book even before I began, as a NC native who had heard some about it at the time, this book was still shocking. I was saddened by the reality of our criminal justice system and the way it ruined Darryl Hunt’s life, and I kept noticing parallels between his story and the story of Money Rock, also from NC. I listened to his one as an audiobook, and it felt like listening to a true crime podcast—entertaining and captivating, although the subject matter is sad and I hate to see how Darryl was never the same after everything that happened to him.
January 25, 2024
Tragic and disturbing. Racism, stereotypes, drugs, betrayal, gangs. Only finished it for NCReads book club at the library. Totally depressing and out of my comfort zone.
January 2, 2024
A master journalist’s devastating account of the legacy of American slavery carried on in the carceral state and its brutal punishment on a remarkable human being
May 14, 2022
Reviewed in my Substack newsletter
https://umarlee.substack.com/p/darryl...
https://umarlee.substack.com/p/darryl...
June 12, 2022
This book has the power to change what is wrong with the system. Phoebe Zerwick's brilliant research and reporting of Mr. Hunt's plight is the best I have ever read on race and justice. If only those in government and the courts were half as smart and honest. It's a book you will not be able to put down. It's easy to read because it is so well written, but equally hard to read because of the unthinkable miscarriage of justice it describes. The facts outlined in the book prove to me that Darryl Hunt's life was destroyed by government/justice system incompetence and corruption. This book, more than anything else, showed me that it's everybody's responsibility to work towards social justice.
February 25, 2024
I read this book as part of the North Carolina Humanities “NC Reads” program.
This is an all too often true story of the incarceration of Darryl Hunt for a crime he did not commit. Beginning in the 1980’s of Winston Salem, NC, Mr. Hunt, a black man, was targeted as the perpetrator of a rape of a white woman, although clearly, the investigation was completely mishandled and ultimately, someone else was proved to be guilty of the crime. While this book details the now all too familiar incompetence and racism of the police, newspapers, court and penal systems, the story is also about the PTSD suffered by those imprisoned unjustly. It is also a commentary on the poor state of the penal system in the US, especially in the South.
The author is a newspaper reporter who covered this story for the Winston Salem Sentinel at various periods. Gratifyingly, she recognized how her “impartial” coverage of the story was also a contributing factor to the system that railroaded the charges against Mr. Hunt. I get the feeling that this book was part of her contribution to try to right the gross miscarriage of justice. Nevertheless, Mr. Hunt’s story is such a travesty of justice, that this one book is not going to fix. I hope the NC Reads program gives the book a broader exposure and that it becomes required reading for anyone entering policing, law, and politics. So to that end, I recommend this book for everyone who cares about improving our social ills.
This is an all too often true story of the incarceration of Darryl Hunt for a crime he did not commit. Beginning in the 1980’s of Winston Salem, NC, Mr. Hunt, a black man, was targeted as the perpetrator of a rape of a white woman, although clearly, the investigation was completely mishandled and ultimately, someone else was proved to be guilty of the crime. While this book details the now all too familiar incompetence and racism of the police, newspapers, court and penal systems, the story is also about the PTSD suffered by those imprisoned unjustly. It is also a commentary on the poor state of the penal system in the US, especially in the South.
The author is a newspaper reporter who covered this story for the Winston Salem Sentinel at various periods. Gratifyingly, she recognized how her “impartial” coverage of the story was also a contributing factor to the system that railroaded the charges against Mr. Hunt. I get the feeling that this book was part of her contribution to try to right the gross miscarriage of justice. Nevertheless, Mr. Hunt’s story is such a travesty of justice, that this one book is not going to fix. I hope the NC Reads program gives the book a broader exposure and that it becomes required reading for anyone entering policing, law, and politics. So to that end, I recommend this book for everyone who cares about improving our social ills.
February 22, 2024
I read this one as part of the 2024 NC Reads program. I was worried that I would not be able to get into it based on some of the other non-fiction books that have been part of the NC Reads program and I am happy to say this was not the case. This book blew me away. I did the audio of this one and it flowed much like a true crime podcast would which made it very easy to follow. It has made me rethink so many different views and opinions and want to get involved in some way to help others who are in similar situations.
February 27, 2024
I am so glad that my local library is participating in the statewide North Carolina Reads program so that I was made aware of this book. Just like so many of our systems, the criminal justice one is still broken. I knew things like this took place, but not as blatant as this. I can't believe with overwhelming evidence that he did not commit the crime that it still took so much time to release him. It made me realize how awful we set up people for failure who have already served their time or who were not guilty in the first place. I am looking into how I can help with this problem.
January 2, 2026
This is a well-written book that follows the wrongful incarceration of Darryl Hunt, falsely accused and convicted of the brutal rape and murder of Deborah Sykes. His legal team's fight for exoneration ultimately freed Hunt, but only after he spent 19 years behind bars. Zerwick does a great job of using Hunt's story to paint the larger picture of what is wrong with our criminal justice system, the impact of the legacy of institutional racism, and the difficulties the formerly incarcerated face with reentry into society.
March 16, 2022
I knew the murder victim Deborah Brotherton Sykes. She went to high school with me and we played together as children and her husband Doug graduated with me. Zerwick takes on the case and how wrongful convictions take place in this country. The only fly in the ointment is her sense of location . I graduated from North Iredell High and it is nowhere near Mooresville. The high school is near a little town called Harmony NC.
July 30, 2022
This is right up there with Just Mercy and others about wrongful imprisonment and systemic racism and the underserved in American society. It’s unconscionable that so many in authority were able to sleep at night knowing an innocent man went to prison. He continued to say he was innocent and wouldn’t throw his friend under the bus to get himself out because his friend was also innocent. The wrongful conviction truly ruined his entire life - to the point of apparent suicide.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
April 9, 2023
I liked the journalistic style, it felt candid and honest. The story is heartbreaking and though i wasn’t familiar with Darryl Hunt’s, it’s one I’ve sadly heard before. I think it would be easy as an author to focus of the drama of the events as they unfold because they will clearly generate emotion from the reader, but this author didn’t. The forthright style helps the reader build a more genuine connection to this tragic story. Beautifully done.
March 18, 2024
I have read other books about people who have been wrongly accused of a crime and find them very revealing about how our justice system works and potential shortfalls. I had a hard time getting into the book, the author's style did not read very well. As a journalist, I expected the narrative would be written so that the information flowed more smoothly. Listening to a zoom with the journalist/author and one of the attorneys was very interesting and informative. I would recommend this book.
August 21, 2025
4.5 stars. Systemic racism and the racism of individuals ruined Darryl Hunt's life. The truth of police making up evidence makes me sick, and a judge that ignores DNA evidence makes me sick. Will the United States of America ever stop being a racist nation????? Reading this book is so depressing. I had to keep focus on the few helpers just to get through it. It is an important history of our crappy court system. I hope we can do better.
February 27, 2024
I read this as part of the NC Humanities Book Club. As someone who moved to NC, I'm always curious to learn more about the culture, authors and history of the state. This was a gut wretching story which made me think about the inadequaties of our legal system.
July 13, 2024
My professor is the attorney in this book, and the author and I practice yoga together. The book takes place in my law school town. It is an amazing read, well-researched, and tells a very important story about our (flawed) justice system.
September 20, 2025
The wrongful conviction of Darryl Hunt, his exoneration, and the challengedhe faced after his release, including the burden of advocacy and the difficulties of re-entry.
This gripping narrative of injustice that sheds light on his own case, as well as the American justice system and how it has failed, at times. I could not put this down, each chapter reveling facts that are well researched by a master of journalism.
An excellent read. Well written.
This gripping narrative of injustice that sheds light on his own case, as well as the American justice system and how it has failed, at times. I could not put this down, each chapter reveling facts that are well researched by a master of journalism.
An excellent read. Well written.
May 23, 2022
Important for highlighting how Darryl Hunt was severely traumatized by his wrongful conviction.
July 27, 2022
a very important read
The rare combination of a story of wrongful conviction and reentry that needs to be told and understood. Well written and delivered
The rare combination of a story of wrongful conviction and reentry that needs to be told and understood. Well written and delivered
February 1, 2023
Powerful story of Darryl Hunt’s journey to, through and after prison. So sad.
May 11, 2023
Couldn’t put it down!!
October 1, 2023
The true story of a man wrongly convicted and imprisoned of rape and murder and the lifelong implications that followed.
February 27, 2024
4.25/5
Displaying 1 - 30 of 34 reviews