What do you think?
Rate this book
Mrs. Jeffries #41
Mrs. Jeffries Aims to Win
Mrs. Jeffries must help Inspector Witherspoon crack a new case and catch a killer in this next installment of the beloved Victorian Mystery series.
Successful businessman Jeremy Marks wasn't highly regarded by any of the members of the West London Archery Club. Most of them considered him a buffoon and a bore. But everyone was stunned when the fellow was murdered during a lull in the club's annual archery competition. He'd been shot with arrows from a longbow during a raging thunderstorm.
But those who knew Marks well understood that the unkempt court jester persona adopted by the late, unlamented man was as fake as the smile he wore. As Inspector Witherspoon investigates the murder, he discovers the victim had real enemies amongst the assembled archery contestants. Marks was notorious for not paying his bills, cheating vendors, bad-mouthing business rivals, and worst of all, betraying his business partners. The dead man had built a whole career and amassed quite a substantial fortune by harming those who trusted him. It will take Mrs. Jeffries and the inspector's household as well as their friends to sort out fact from fiction and target a killer.
Successful businessman Jeremy Marks wasn't highly regarded by any of the members of the West London Archery Club. Most of them considered him a buffoon and a bore. But everyone was stunned when the fellow was murdered during a lull in the club's annual archery competition. He'd been shot with arrows from a longbow during a raging thunderstorm.
But those who knew Marks well understood that the unkempt court jester persona adopted by the late, unlamented man was as fake as the smile he wore. As Inspector Witherspoon investigates the murder, he discovers the victim had real enemies amongst the assembled archery contestants. Marks was notorious for not paying his bills, cheating vendors, bad-mouthing business rivals, and worst of all, betraying his business partners. The dead man had built a whole career and amassed quite a substantial fortune by harming those who trusted him. It will take Mrs. Jeffries and the inspector's household as well as their friends to sort out fact from fiction and target a killer.
304 pages, Paperback
First published August 29, 2023
69 people are currently reading
262 people want to read
About the author
Emily Brightwell
72 books526 followersCheryl Lanham was born on 11 October 1948 in the Appalachian mountains of West Virginia, USA. Her family moved to Southern California in 1959 and she grew up in Pasadena. After graduating from California State University, she decided to work her way around the world and took off for England. She didn’t get much further because she met Richard James Arguile, the Englishman who became her husband, got married on May 1976, and had two children, Matthew and Amanda. While working in international shipping, she decided to pursue her dream and become a writer – which, of course, is the best job ever. She has written romance novels as Sarah Temple, and Young Adult novels as Cheryl Lanham. As Emily Brightwell, she is the author of the “Mrs. Jeffries” mysteries.
Cheryl Lanham Arguile returned to California, where she lives with her husband and a cranky old cat named Kiwi.
Cheryl Lanham Arguile returned to California, where she lives with her husband and a cranky old cat named Kiwi.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 63 reviews
September 19, 2023
This is my go-to light cozy who-done-it so after a couple of really heavy reads and a bit of upheaval in real life “Mrs. Jeffries Aims to Win” it is.
Set in Victorian London this is #41 in the series if you can believe it. Having followed Mrs. Jeffries from the beginning I have come to know the characters like old friends. Everyone is a likable individual and somehow the author has managed to keep them fresh and engaging in every story.
In this edition Inspector Witherspoon is investigating the murder of a man that was disliked by everyone who knew him. He was killed with a bow and arrow during a competition at the London Archery Club, so not your everyday kind of murder. And pretty much everyone who was at the club is a suspect.
To make matters worse Inspector Witherspoon’s nemesis has wrangled his way back on to the police force and is determined to make life difficult for Witherspoon.
Mrs. Jeffries and the gang know this is going to be a hard one to crack. The ending was quite the surprise – not the culprit, just the manner in which it ended.
As usual an easy enjoyable read with really, really likable characters.
Set in Victorian London this is #41 in the series if you can believe it. Having followed Mrs. Jeffries from the beginning I have come to know the characters like old friends. Everyone is a likable individual and somehow the author has managed to keep them fresh and engaging in every story.
In this edition Inspector Witherspoon is investigating the murder of a man that was disliked by everyone who knew him. He was killed with a bow and arrow during a competition at the London Archery Club, so not your everyday kind of murder. And pretty much everyone who was at the club is a suspect.
To make matters worse Inspector Witherspoon’s nemesis has wrangled his way back on to the police force and is determined to make life difficult for Witherspoon.
Mrs. Jeffries and the gang know this is going to be a hard one to crack. The ending was quite the surprise – not the culprit, just the manner in which it ended.
As usual an easy enjoyable read with really, really likable characters.
October 9, 2023
Luty Belle and Hatchet are on hand at the West London Archery Club where Hatchet is supposed to be competing in the novice men's division when Hatchet's event is postponed due to the rain. As they are waiting for the rain to let up they hear whispers there's been a murder! Nell's Bells and yippe?! The servants at Upper Edmonton Gardens waste no time getting in on this one, however, it's tricky because all of the constables will recognize the staff by sight! Their information is mainly just gossip and getting them nowhere. Can they actually solve this one? Meanwhile, Inspector Nivens is back on the force and still eager to get revenge on Inspector Witherspoon. He decides to beat Witherspoon at his own game - by solving the murder first. Mrs. Jeffries doesn't trust him and she's determined to solve the murder and get her beloved Inspector the credit he deserves. It won't be easy because it seems everyone had a motive to murder Mr. Jeremy Marks! Finding out which one was the actual killer is the hard part.
This wasn't the best of the bunch. I figured out who very early on. The clues were there even after I guessed who (but not why). Inspector Witherspoon would have gotten there with his timeline. Mrs. Jeffries must be getting slower because she should have figured it out with the same information I did. Still, it was fun to catch up with everyone and see what they were up to. This one had a little more specific history. It's set at a time when social values were changing. The British upper crust is now made up of a new class of people- those who have recently come into their fortunes. Without the birth and breeding of the nobility and gentry, these new money people don't have entry into the upper echelons of society but they don't seem to care. They've formed their own social clubs like the West London Archery Club. I did wonder when and how bankers and businessmen became the elite so that was informative. However, I was shocked this book made it to publication in 2023. There are some stereotypes about Native Americans and I'm not sure that information is accurate or plausible. At least the adjective "red" is not used to describe anyone.
Jeremy Marks was a disgusting human being. He was morally bankrupt in business and in romance. He may have had charm but I don't see it and he lacked the brains and finesse to be a successful cad. The business practices he used were not right but not illegal. Neither was his wooing of the ladies but he skirted the line of illegal. I'm surprised no one sued him for breach of promise. Mrs. Jeffries thinks the murderer has to be someone from his present because why would someone kill him 20 years later? Surprise? Deep-seated hatred? Coming across the man again for the first time? Or maybe it is a case of hell hath no fury like a woman scorned?
I'm wondering if Rufus Farley, the club manager, is the murderer. He's an officious man who values his position over justice. He caters to the whims of the wealthy and doesn't seem to like scandal and Jeremy Marks ALWAYS brought scandal with him. Mr. Marks wasn't even a member and if his fiancé really did break it off with him as the gossips claim, Mr. Farley would have no reason to keep Mr. Marks around. Plus Mr. Farley flat out lies to the Inspector, more than once I think.
Chester Atwood and Horace Miller were watching Marks look for arrows in the rain. They were the first to discover the body so I don't think either of them was the actual murderer. They did have a motive and where were their ladies? Didn't they see who shot Marks? It happened so quickly, within a short amount of time, they had to have seen something!
Hannah Lonsdale was - WAS - the fiancé of Mr. Marks up until moments before he died. Gossips claim Hannah Lonsdale, a middle-aged wealthy woman, had a great row with Mr. Marks and then she left. She doesn't seem very upset by the news of his death and not terribly surprised either. The club manager and other members indicate that Hannah Lonsdale's family has a lot of clout and no one wants to upset them. Is Inspector Witherspoon certain Miss Lonsdale went home and didn't return to the club? Did she have family there with her? Mrs. McElhaney, a wealthy matron, was previously engaged to Mr. Marks. She's spitting nails furious that he proposed to another woman while still dating HER! EEE! That's bad. That's a good reason to want revenge! She doesn't blame the woman, fortunately, but her eyes were opened to Mr. Marks's character. How good a shot is she? Where was she when the murder happened? Miss Lonsdale is very smart and a very good archer. I think she could easily be the murderer. Mrs. McElhaney doesn't seem too shabby in the brains department either. What if they teamed up to kill their ex-lover?
Luty is crazier than ever! Hatchet is the one who wants to learn to shoot a bow and arrow. Luty never learned and doesn't care. She's happy with her Colt! She's eager to be a part of the investigation but the pair have to figure out how to lie low and not arouse Witherspoon's suspicions that they are helping with the case. Hatchet's contacts are invaluable in their help. Luty's not so much this time.
Mr. Merriman and Mr. Stanley previously accused Mr. Marks of altering his score and that resulted in Marks being kicked out of the club. Did one of them want Marks removed - permanently? Mr. Merriman also has beef with Mr. Marks from a past business deal when Marks cheated him out of money owed for work on his house. Mr. Merriman joined the archery club because his wife's uncle is a director. Mr. Merriman did NOT appreciate Marks joining the club too. Could Mr. Merriman have removed Marks from the club - permanently? Mr. Merriman is very smooth and he's honest with the detectives - or he cooperates anyway. Whether he's honest remains to be seen. He's protective of his wife's health, she's in delicate condition. I don't fully trust Mr. Merriman. He's quick to agree to go down to the station and answer questions.
Mrs. Storch, a wealthy matron, and her companion, Miss Linwood, were sitting with Mr. Merriman at the time of the murder. At least Mrs. Storch was. An august lady who enjoys being snobby and giving orders, MADE her companion go out in the rain to put a picnic basket of expensive food items back in the carriage. Poor Miss Linwood! Miss Linwood comes across as silly and foolish. She idolizes Inspector Witherspoon and it makes him uncomfortable. I think she's flirting and maybe trying to assist with the investigation. Yikes! He's taken by the estimable and sensible Lady Cannonberry!
Even Miles Wiley, Mr. Marks's solicitor loathed his client. That bad?! Mr. Wiley has motive but not means or opportunity. What's up with Stephen Marston? He seems so suspicious running away from the police! There's also the matter of someone believing they recognized him under another name. I thought I knew who the murderer was but Mr. Marston just made himself look super guilty! Is his story to be believed? He's an actor! Inspector Witherspoon is too trusting. There's a whole list of people Marks wronged in the past both in business and in romance. Could one of them have come back for revenge?
Mr. Marks' housekeeper is a drunk, lazy and a gossip. She seems to have adored Mrs. Marks who had money and status. Why a lovely woman married a loser like Mr. Marks I don't know. The point of the gossip is that Miss Fairfax as was had money. Lots of it. Could one of her family members have it out for Marks? She also names a Stephen Mueller, who Mr. Marks cheated in business. The other witnesses are unmemorable but one of them provides a vital clue!
Wiggins and Phyllis are still in competition. I think she's jealous when one of his contacts tries to flirt with him. The rivalry between the two youngest members of the staff is super annoying. I hope now they realize they're stronger together because they pick up more clues. Phyllis seems to want to be Miss Scarlet LOL! She's smarter and has a team to help talk things over with and figure out the clues. That's why Inspector Witherspoon is so successful. I think he's come a long way, however, and he's better at solving crimes on his own now. The rest just want to be useful and have something to do. They want to give back to the Inspector for his kindness but I think they've done enough to repay him.
This wasn't the best of the bunch. I figured out who very early on. The clues were there even after I guessed who (but not why). Inspector Witherspoon would have gotten there with his timeline. Mrs. Jeffries must be getting slower because she should have figured it out with the same information I did. Still, it was fun to catch up with everyone and see what they were up to. This one had a little more specific history. It's set at a time when social values were changing. The British upper crust is now made up of a new class of people- those who have recently come into their fortunes. Without the birth and breeding of the nobility and gentry, these new money people don't have entry into the upper echelons of society but they don't seem to care. They've formed their own social clubs like the West London Archery Club. I did wonder when and how bankers and businessmen became the elite so that was informative. However, I was shocked this book made it to publication in 2023. There are some stereotypes about Native Americans and I'm not sure that information is accurate or plausible. At least the adjective "red" is not used to describe anyone.
Jeremy Marks was a disgusting human being. He was morally bankrupt in business and in romance. He may have had charm but I don't see it and he lacked the brains and finesse to be a successful cad. The business practices he used were not right but not illegal. Neither was his wooing of the ladies but he skirted the line of illegal. I'm surprised no one sued him for breach of promise. Mrs. Jeffries thinks the murderer has to be someone from his present because why would someone kill him 20 years later? Surprise? Deep-seated hatred? Coming across the man again for the first time? Or maybe it is a case of hell hath no fury like a woman scorned?
I'm wondering if Rufus Farley, the club manager, is the murderer. He's an officious man who values his position over justice. He caters to the whims of the wealthy and doesn't seem to like scandal and Jeremy Marks ALWAYS brought scandal with him. Mr. Marks wasn't even a member and if his fiancé really did break it off with him as the gossips claim, Mr. Farley would have no reason to keep Mr. Marks around. Plus Mr. Farley flat out lies to the Inspector, more than once I think.
Chester Atwood and Horace Miller were watching Marks look for arrows in the rain. They were the first to discover the body so I don't think either of them was the actual murderer. They did have a motive and where were their ladies? Didn't they see who shot Marks? It happened so quickly, within a short amount of time, they had to have seen something!
Hannah Lonsdale was - WAS - the fiancé of Mr. Marks up until moments before he died. Gossips claim Hannah Lonsdale, a middle-aged wealthy woman, had a great row with Mr. Marks and then she left. She doesn't seem very upset by the news of his death and not terribly surprised either. The club manager and other members indicate that Hannah Lonsdale's family has a lot of clout and no one wants to upset them. Is Inspector Witherspoon certain Miss Lonsdale went home and didn't return to the club? Did she have family there with her? Mrs. McElhaney, a wealthy matron, was previously engaged to Mr. Marks. She's spitting nails furious that he proposed to another woman while still dating HER! EEE! That's bad. That's a good reason to want revenge! She doesn't blame the woman, fortunately, but her eyes were opened to Mr. Marks's character. How good a shot is she? Where was she when the murder happened? Miss Lonsdale is very smart and a very good archer. I think she could easily be the murderer. Mrs. McElhaney doesn't seem too shabby in the brains department either. What if they teamed up to kill their ex-lover?
Luty is crazier than ever! Hatchet is the one who wants to learn to shoot a bow and arrow. Luty never learned and doesn't care. She's happy with her Colt! She's eager to be a part of the investigation but the pair have to figure out how to lie low and not arouse Witherspoon's suspicions that they are helping with the case. Hatchet's contacts are invaluable in their help. Luty's not so much this time.
Mr. Merriman and Mr. Stanley previously accused Mr. Marks of altering his score and that resulted in Marks being kicked out of the club. Did one of them want Marks removed - permanently? Mr. Merriman also has beef with Mr. Marks from a past business deal when Marks cheated him out of money owed for work on his house. Mr. Merriman joined the archery club because his wife's uncle is a director. Mr. Merriman did NOT appreciate Marks joining the club too. Could Mr. Merriman have removed Marks from the club - permanently? Mr. Merriman is very smooth and he's honest with the detectives - or he cooperates anyway. Whether he's honest remains to be seen. He's protective of his wife's health, she's in delicate condition. I don't fully trust Mr. Merriman. He's quick to agree to go down to the station and answer questions.
Mrs. Storch, a wealthy matron, and her companion, Miss Linwood, were sitting with Mr. Merriman at the time of the murder. At least Mrs. Storch was. An august lady who enjoys being snobby and giving orders, MADE her companion go out in the rain to put a picnic basket of expensive food items back in the carriage. Poor Miss Linwood! Miss Linwood comes across as silly and foolish. She idolizes Inspector Witherspoon and it makes him uncomfortable. I think she's flirting and maybe trying to assist with the investigation. Yikes! He's taken by the estimable and sensible Lady Cannonberry!
Even Miles Wiley, Mr. Marks's solicitor loathed his client. That bad?! Mr. Wiley has motive but not means or opportunity. What's up with Stephen Marston? He seems so suspicious running away from the police! There's also the matter of someone believing they recognized him under another name. I thought I knew who the murderer was but Mr. Marston just made himself look super guilty! Is his story to be believed? He's an actor! Inspector Witherspoon is too trusting. There's a whole list of people Marks wronged in the past both in business and in romance. Could one of them have come back for revenge?
Mr. Marks' housekeeper is a drunk, lazy and a gossip. She seems to have adored Mrs. Marks who had money and status. Why a lovely woman married a loser like Mr. Marks I don't know. The point of the gossip is that Miss Fairfax as was had money. Lots of it. Could one of her family members have it out for Marks? She also names a Stephen Mueller, who Mr. Marks cheated in business. The other witnesses are unmemorable but one of them provides a vital clue!
Wiggins and Phyllis are still in competition. I think she's jealous when one of his contacts tries to flirt with him. The rivalry between the two youngest members of the staff is super annoying. I hope now they realize they're stronger together because they pick up more clues. Phyllis seems to want to be Miss Scarlet LOL! She's smarter and has a team to help talk things over with and figure out the clues. That's why Inspector Witherspoon is so successful. I think he's come a long way, however, and he's better at solving crimes on his own now. The rest just want to be useful and have something to do. They want to give back to the Inspector for his kindness but I think they've done enough to repay him.
September 11, 2023
This was fine but not my favorite in the series.
I enjoyed the archery club based plot, but the rest of the setting and historical detail felt a bit thin compared to the best books in this series.
Series regulars excepted, it’s an obnoxious cast of characters, and the solve just furthers that based on how it’s rooted in their relationships and actions toward one another.
The mystery itself is fine, well-structured with a logical solve, though nothing especially unusual.
The pacing remains good, as it always is with this series, and I appreciated the subtle humor of the dialogue.
*I received an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.*
I enjoyed the archery club based plot, but the rest of the setting and historical detail felt a bit thin compared to the best books in this series.
Series regulars excepted, it’s an obnoxious cast of characters, and the solve just furthers that based on how it’s rooted in their relationships and actions toward one another.
The mystery itself is fine, well-structured with a logical solve, though nothing especially unusual.
The pacing remains good, as it always is with this series, and I appreciated the subtle humor of the dialogue.
*I received an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.*
August 30, 2023
Great Read!
So many changes in some of the characters’ lives! Such an unusual setting. Ending was very surprising. Hope this isn’t the last book of this series.
So many changes in some of the characters’ lives! Such an unusual setting. Ending was very surprising. Hope this isn’t the last book of this series.
September 21, 2023
I think this may be the best one yet!
January 12, 2024
Listened to the audio book which is not listed on good reads. Another good story but I am afraid that it might be the last on the series
August 25, 2024
I have read all the books in this series and enjoyed them for the most part. I always enjoy the family bond the household & friends share and am happy to catch up with the latest news. Sadly, this story didn't ring as true for me. The plot and characters are good and I enjoyed the read, but I believe some editorial polish would have improved it, like deleting some duplicate thoughts & comments.
The opening scene with Hatchet and Luty bickering struck me as harsh, also seemed like backstory, since their presence at this event is covered again later for the Witherspoon household.
Mrs Jeffries who has always warned her gang about jumping to conclusions without facts, does some big hops in this story--and lands correctly. Her conclusion about Niven's reason for getting involved repeats what Niven himself has already revealed by his thoughts. Ever the antagonist, Nivens was portrayed as an incredible fool in this story. More than he deserved, I think.
UK English: I believe what's called a Crescent in North America is called a CLOSE in England, though it may not have been back then?
Some dramatic scenes, but would someone actually be stupid enough to make snide comments to someone threatening to shoot them? The human instinct for self-preservation is normally quite strong.
The opening scene with Hatchet and Luty bickering struck me as harsh, also seemed like backstory, since their presence at this event is covered again later for the Witherspoon household.
Mrs Jeffries who has always warned her gang about jumping to conclusions without facts, does some big hops in this story--and lands correctly. Her conclusion about Niven's reason for getting involved repeats what Niven himself has already revealed by his thoughts. Ever the antagonist, Nivens was portrayed as an incredible fool in this story. More than he deserved, I think.
UK English: I believe what's called a Crescent in North America is called a CLOSE in England, though it may not have been back then?
Some dramatic scenes, but would someone actually be stupid enough to make snide comments to someone threatening to shoot them? The human instinct for self-preservation is normally quite strong.
October 3, 2023
I'm rounding this up from 2.5 stars. It's a perfectly competent mystery novel...and one that I've discovered is part of an incredibly long series. But it's missing two things that makes even the lesser efforts of Agatha Christie so enjoyable: eccentric characters and bucketloads of melodrama. Unfortunately, the protagonists of the novel aren't in the same league as Poirot and Miss Marple.
June 26, 2024
This one had a weird ending, which I didn't care for. It was choppy and quick. I had figured out the murderer much more quickly than Mrs. Jeffries, who seemed to be losing her concentration and cool towards the end. I also think it's past time for Witherspoon and Ruth to move forward in their relationship. It is beginning to stagnate for me.
August 30, 2023
When the shady businessman is shot dead at the local club during an archery competition the inspector isn’t short on suspects it seems the victim was previously kicked out of the club for cheating and that the only one there who really liked him with his fiancé. To make matters worse it was during a break due to thunderstorms and the two men who reported him for cheating were the two that found him Inspector Weatherspoon gets a clue however when he is told that only an expert could’ve shot Mr. Marks from such a range with a long bow but at a women’s archery competition who could that be? This is the series 41st book and although I haven’t read all 41 the ones I have read have been so funny that includes the latest. I love all the servants and inspector Weatherspoon‘s house I love how excited they get when there is a murder a foot in the links they will go to to help make their master look like a brilliant detective. If you love cozy mysteries and have yet to read these books you really are missing out these are books I highly recommend and have yet to write one less than five stars. I want to thank Berkeley Annette galley form I free arc copy please forgive any mistakes as I am blind and dictate my review.
August 26, 2023
4.5 stars
Fun installment in a great cozy series. Surprising, satisfying ending.
Fun installment in a great cozy series. Surprising, satisfying ending.
September 23, 2024
I so enjoy listening to these cozy mysteries.
August 30, 2023
Top Pick - 4.5 Stars
Inspector Gerald Witherspoon has solved more homicides than any other Scotland Yard detective, but he didn’t accomplish that alone. The inspector and Constable Barnes have had assistance from Witherspoon’s household and a few close friends without his knowledge. In his newest case, two of those friends, Luty Belle Crookshank and her butler/friend Hatchet, are first on the scene. A man with many enemies is murdered at the archery club where Hatchet was participating in a competition. Hatchet and Luty are able to give Mrs. Jeffries, Witherspoon’s housekeeper and super sleuth, first-hand knowledge of the crime to help her deduce who the killer is.
I’ve been reading this series for a long time and have come to care about these characters. The mystery itself works as a standalone, but some of the things that occur in the book will be more meaningful to those who have read at least a couple of the prior books. Jeremy Marks, the victim, was an unwelcome guest to the archery club, and his numerous enemies mean there are plenty of suspects with a motive to kill him. The method of the murder is an arrow, so that gives most everyone on the scene the means. Therefore, the investigation is all about figuring out who had the opportunity to commit the murder. I really enjoyed how Witherspoon and Barnes, and Witherspoon’s friends all work together to get the clues needed to solve the case. In addition to working on the case, Mrs. Jeffries is also trying to find out what Nigel Nivens is up to. Nivens is jealous of Witherspoon’s success and has been newly reinstated to the force and is always out to discredit Witherspoon.
This case is interesting, and I like it when the household members work together, with each person contributing to the investigation. Hatchet participated more than usual this time, but I enjoyed that. Even though I’ve been reading this series for a long time, it was nice getting to know him better as an individual and not just as Luty’s sidekick. I enjoyed the interactions of the characters, who have become like family to each other and like old friends to me. In addition, the author does a great job of including bits of history from the Victorian period in the story. There are some developments at the end of the book that fans of the series won’t want to miss. I was very surprised but happy over the way things turned out.
~ Christine
Inspector Gerald Witherspoon has solved more homicides than any other Scotland Yard detective, but he didn’t accomplish that alone. The inspector and Constable Barnes have had assistance from Witherspoon’s household and a few close friends without his knowledge. In his newest case, two of those friends, Luty Belle Crookshank and her butler/friend Hatchet, are first on the scene. A man with many enemies is murdered at the archery club where Hatchet was participating in a competition. Hatchet and Luty are able to give Mrs. Jeffries, Witherspoon’s housekeeper and super sleuth, first-hand knowledge of the crime to help her deduce who the killer is.
I’ve been reading this series for a long time and have come to care about these characters. The mystery itself works as a standalone, but some of the things that occur in the book will be more meaningful to those who have read at least a couple of the prior books. Jeremy Marks, the victim, was an unwelcome guest to the archery club, and his numerous enemies mean there are plenty of suspects with a motive to kill him. The method of the murder is an arrow, so that gives most everyone on the scene the means. Therefore, the investigation is all about figuring out who had the opportunity to commit the murder. I really enjoyed how Witherspoon and Barnes, and Witherspoon’s friends all work together to get the clues needed to solve the case. In addition to working on the case, Mrs. Jeffries is also trying to find out what Nigel Nivens is up to. Nivens is jealous of Witherspoon’s success and has been newly reinstated to the force and is always out to discredit Witherspoon.
This case is interesting, and I like it when the household members work together, with each person contributing to the investigation. Hatchet participated more than usual this time, but I enjoyed that. Even though I’ve been reading this series for a long time, it was nice getting to know him better as an individual and not just as Luty’s sidekick. I enjoyed the interactions of the characters, who have become like family to each other and like old friends to me. In addition, the author does a great job of including bits of history from the Victorian period in the story. There are some developments at the end of the book that fans of the series won’t want to miss. I was very surprised but happy over the way things turned out.
~ Christine
November 8, 2023
Inspector Witherspoon was put in charge of another murder. His Housekeeper Mrs Jeffries, his household servants and friends, help him find evidence to help him solve his cases. Inspector Witherspoon doesn't know they are helping him. A greedy swindler was killed at the West London Archery Club, he died from two arrows. The victim had many enemies, but Mrs Jefferies and her sleuthing companions are "on the hunt". That's what they call their detecting. It's always fun to see how it all comes together to find the killer. These mysteries are really fun to read and I highly recommend them.
July 5, 2025
I love the wonderful characters in Emily Brightwells books. They become old friends and each time I read one of her books it is like coming home again. Mrs. Jefferies is a woman with wonderful skills helping the inspector solve his cases. This takes place in the Victorian era and the main setting is an archery club. A man that so many despise is murdered and the household crew and friends go about gathering clues to help the inspector solve his case. They are all clever and wanting to help. Very enjoyable. Always a great mystery with her books
October 19, 2023
Mrs Jeffries & Friends Win Again
Loved this 41st book in Emily Brightwells’ series. It was like a family reunion. As I came across all the characters from past books I had to smile. Storyline is detailed and I didn’t figure out the culprit until revealed. The savory and unsavory characters along with the good, the bad, the ugly, the graceful, those from above stairs and below work together to help solve another mystery. Highly recommend!
Loved this 41st book in Emily Brightwells’ series. It was like a family reunion. As I came across all the characters from past books I had to smile. Storyline is detailed and I didn’t figure out the culprit until revealed. The savory and unsavory characters along with the good, the bad, the ugly, the graceful, those from above stairs and below work together to help solve another mystery. Highly recommend!
May 28, 2024
I have enjoyed every book in this series. Got to know all the characters well and watched them grow. I do hope there will be more with maybe even new characters in the future. I was really sad that Inspector Niven died in this last one, even though he was a thorn in Inspector Witherspoons side. I was hoping he would make it and maybe finally really change. I have listen to all of them on CD's and enjoyed the reader. Hopefully there will be more.
October 22, 2023
https://openbooksociety.com/article/m...
Brought to you by OBS Reviewer Jeanie
Mrs. Jeffries is one of my favorite Victorian era British sleuths, one who could easily have been a detective. The widow of a policeman, Hepzibah Jeffries was Inspector Gerald Witherspoon’s delightful housekeeper. He had inherited an estate several years ago, and the home was large enough to require servants. He was excellent to work for, and those in his employ would do almost anything to help him.
Witherspoon worked in the records room of Ladbroke Station until Mrs. Jeffries joined his household. Unbeknownst to the Inspector, Mrs. Jeffries, his staff, and a couple of their friends began to help him solve homicides. They and their sources were from various backgrounds and social tiers, including his dear lady friend. Their help was invaluable, and when the inspector had a case, Mrs. Jeffries met with the group daily to discuss updates and plans.
It didn’t take many solves until Gerald had the attention of the higher ups, and he left the records room to become the inspector who solved more homicides than anyone in the Metropolitan Police Department. He is humble, unassuming, and respectful. His servants and even some of their informants fondly call him “our inspector”.
Archery was a popular sport with both men and women, and many top archers competed. The archery club in West London was conducting local competitions. The winning archers move to the next level, with the potential of going to the nationals. An all-out thunderstorm explodes during a competition, with skies as dark as night. When there was a brief lull in the storm, two archers on the back porch noticed Jeremy Marks near the targets, carrying a lantern and looking closely at the ground. They are convinced he is finding arrows to steal, some of them costly, that had not been collected when the skies opened. One minute they saw him looking at the ground, then he was lying on the ground. He had been shot with two arrows, either of which would have killed him. It would require an excellent archer to accomplish those shots with the wind speed and darkness.
Police learned quickly that Marks was not liked by anyone at the club. Due to his dishonesty, he lost his membership months earlier. He was only allowed to come in with his fiancée, a member, and would become a member again after he and Hannah got married. Even if he had not been shot, however, the wedding was off. Hannah learned several things that day from his last fiancée, including confirmation he was marrying her for her money. She became one of the top suspects; his prior fiancée was also high on the list. Marks had totally ruined families and finances of several business partners, increasing the suspect list. Even Marks’s attorney wasn’t surprised he was murdered!
I enjoyed learning about or catching up with the three-dimensional characters. With colorful backstory included about the primary people, one doesn’t need to read the entire series in order. The new or returning reader can be comfortable whether they start with the first or forty-first mystery. This time I noticed how encouraging Mrs. Jeffries is to Gerald. She can tell when his self-confidence is failing and is quick to show him how well he is doing with the mystery.
The friendship “our inspector” had with his housekeeper fascinates me. Perhaps it was because her late husband was in law enforcement, or that he recognized her as a good sounding board. When he is on a case and gets home from work, he invites her to have glass or two of sherry with him. He tells her what he learned about the case or people involved with it. When Constable Barnes, with whom he was partnered, arrived to walk to the station with Witherspoon each morning, she told him anything that the staff uncovered and he inserts it into plans with the inspector.
There were so many pieces to this puzzle, it seemed as if it wouldn’t be solved as quickly as the chief superintendent pushed for. Mrs. Jeffries had something in the back of her mind that she couldn’t quite remember on time to tell Barnes that day. When it did come together, it was quite a surprise, and happened in a such a way to injure a couple people. I was very pleased with how it ended, and highly recommend this novel and series!
Brought to you by OBS Reviewer Jeanie
Mrs. Jeffries is one of my favorite Victorian era British sleuths, one who could easily have been a detective. The widow of a policeman, Hepzibah Jeffries was Inspector Gerald Witherspoon’s delightful housekeeper. He had inherited an estate several years ago, and the home was large enough to require servants. He was excellent to work for, and those in his employ would do almost anything to help him.
Witherspoon worked in the records room of Ladbroke Station until Mrs. Jeffries joined his household. Unbeknownst to the Inspector, Mrs. Jeffries, his staff, and a couple of their friends began to help him solve homicides. They and their sources were from various backgrounds and social tiers, including his dear lady friend. Their help was invaluable, and when the inspector had a case, Mrs. Jeffries met with the group daily to discuss updates and plans.
It didn’t take many solves until Gerald had the attention of the higher ups, and he left the records room to become the inspector who solved more homicides than anyone in the Metropolitan Police Department. He is humble, unassuming, and respectful. His servants and even some of their informants fondly call him “our inspector”.
Archery was a popular sport with both men and women, and many top archers competed. The archery club in West London was conducting local competitions. The winning archers move to the next level, with the potential of going to the nationals. An all-out thunderstorm explodes during a competition, with skies as dark as night. When there was a brief lull in the storm, two archers on the back porch noticed Jeremy Marks near the targets, carrying a lantern and looking closely at the ground. They are convinced he is finding arrows to steal, some of them costly, that had not been collected when the skies opened. One minute they saw him looking at the ground, then he was lying on the ground. He had been shot with two arrows, either of which would have killed him. It would require an excellent archer to accomplish those shots with the wind speed and darkness.
Police learned quickly that Marks was not liked by anyone at the club. Due to his dishonesty, he lost his membership months earlier. He was only allowed to come in with his fiancée, a member, and would become a member again after he and Hannah got married. Even if he had not been shot, however, the wedding was off. Hannah learned several things that day from his last fiancée, including confirmation he was marrying her for her money. She became one of the top suspects; his prior fiancée was also high on the list. Marks had totally ruined families and finances of several business partners, increasing the suspect list. Even Marks’s attorney wasn’t surprised he was murdered!
I enjoyed learning about or catching up with the three-dimensional characters. With colorful backstory included about the primary people, one doesn’t need to read the entire series in order. The new or returning reader can be comfortable whether they start with the first or forty-first mystery. This time I noticed how encouraging Mrs. Jeffries is to Gerald. She can tell when his self-confidence is failing and is quick to show him how well he is doing with the mystery.
The friendship “our inspector” had with his housekeeper fascinates me. Perhaps it was because her late husband was in law enforcement, or that he recognized her as a good sounding board. When he is on a case and gets home from work, he invites her to have glass or two of sherry with him. He tells her what he learned about the case or people involved with it. When Constable Barnes, with whom he was partnered, arrived to walk to the station with Witherspoon each morning, she told him anything that the staff uncovered and he inserts it into plans with the inspector.
There were so many pieces to this puzzle, it seemed as if it wouldn’t be solved as quickly as the chief superintendent pushed for. Mrs. Jeffries had something in the back of her mind that she couldn’t quite remember on time to tell Barnes that day. When it did come together, it was quite a surprise, and happened in a such a way to injure a couple people. I was very pleased with how it ended, and highly recommend this novel and series!
December 26, 2023
If one enjoys reading mysteries set in Victorian England, this is a wonderful series to try. They do not have to be read in order, as there is enough information about the regular characters included in each episode to help the reader know them. There are several things I especially enjoy about this mystery and series. The mysteries are not easily solved despite the clever detective, constables, and informers. The regular characters are mostly engaging and wise people. There are corresponding pieces of history that are relevant to the era.
Mrs. Jeffries is the housekeeper in the home of Inspector Gerald Witherspoon. She is a wise and hardworking woman who works well with the rest of the staff. They are like their own little family, since many have no blood relatives.
Inspector Witherspoon has the best homicide solve rate in the area, with the help of his associate, Constable Barnes. His nemesis, Inspector Nivens, is reduced to working in the records room due to his previous behaviors, and he wants to get Witherspoon in trouble So Bad that I picture him as a caricature or a cartoon villain.
Witherspoon and Barnes get sent to an archery club where, until a terrible storm interrupted it, competitions were being held for the season. During a very brief break in the rain, a former member, Jeremy Marks, was seen at the targets, looking closely at the ground with the aid of a lantern. Marks is notorious as a cheater (which got him kicked out the club), a man who one wouldn’t want to go into business with or be engaged or married to. Most haven’t heard yet, but his fiancée had just broken up with him before the women’s competition. A couple men waiting for the competition to resume are out on the back porch, watching and discussing what Marks might be looking for. One second he was bent over, and seconds later, he was lying on the ground, dead, felled by a couple well-aimed arrows. They had been unable to see what happened as it was still dark with heavy clouds.
Thus begins a confounding investigation to catch the killer of a man who will not be missed by anybody. Mrs. Jeffries, the servants of the estate, and even Witherspoon’s special lady friend are ready to help the inspector find whodunit, of which he is totally unaware. There is a network of people who will help collect intel to discuss with Mrs. Jeffries. She puts it together with what Witherspoon tells her of the case, and gives the information to Constable Barnes the next morning when he picks up the Inspector. If the process works, as it has many times before, the man they respectfully refer to as “our inspector” will soon have another case solved.
I truly enjoyed this novel, and was certainly surprised at the ending. I had looked at the vast number of suspects (ex-lady friends, former business partners, and vendors), and didn’t have a pet suspect, so I watched the inspector’s loyal staff and what they learned from their informers. This is one of my favorite historical mystery series of the time and setting, and I highly recommend it to those who appreciate well written cozy/ historical mysteries set in London with interesting and intelligent characters, startling plot twists, and a bit of humor throughout.
Mrs. Jeffries is the housekeeper in the home of Inspector Gerald Witherspoon. She is a wise and hardworking woman who works well with the rest of the staff. They are like their own little family, since many have no blood relatives.
Inspector Witherspoon has the best homicide solve rate in the area, with the help of his associate, Constable Barnes. His nemesis, Inspector Nivens, is reduced to working in the records room due to his previous behaviors, and he wants to get Witherspoon in trouble So Bad that I picture him as a caricature or a cartoon villain.
Witherspoon and Barnes get sent to an archery club where, until a terrible storm interrupted it, competitions were being held for the season. During a very brief break in the rain, a former member, Jeremy Marks, was seen at the targets, looking closely at the ground with the aid of a lantern. Marks is notorious as a cheater (which got him kicked out the club), a man who one wouldn’t want to go into business with or be engaged or married to. Most haven’t heard yet, but his fiancée had just broken up with him before the women’s competition. A couple men waiting for the competition to resume are out on the back porch, watching and discussing what Marks might be looking for. One second he was bent over, and seconds later, he was lying on the ground, dead, felled by a couple well-aimed arrows. They had been unable to see what happened as it was still dark with heavy clouds.
Thus begins a confounding investigation to catch the killer of a man who will not be missed by anybody. Mrs. Jeffries, the servants of the estate, and even Witherspoon’s special lady friend are ready to help the inspector find whodunit, of which he is totally unaware. There is a network of people who will help collect intel to discuss with Mrs. Jeffries. She puts it together with what Witherspoon tells her of the case, and gives the information to Constable Barnes the next morning when he picks up the Inspector. If the process works, as it has many times before, the man they respectfully refer to as “our inspector” will soon have another case solved.
I truly enjoyed this novel, and was certainly surprised at the ending. I had looked at the vast number of suspects (ex-lady friends, former business partners, and vendors), and didn’t have a pet suspect, so I watched the inspector’s loyal staff and what they learned from their informers. This is one of my favorite historical mystery series of the time and setting, and I highly recommend it to those who appreciate well written cozy/ historical mysteries set in London with interesting and intelligent characters, startling plot twists, and a bit of humor throughout.
January 8, 2025
Luty and Hatchet are present at the West London Archery Club when former member and current guest Jeremy Marks is murdered with two arrows piercing his body. Inspector Witherspoon and Constable Barnes, ably assisted by other members of the police force, quickly realize that this will be a difficult case to solve simply because so many people loathed Marks - and with good reason. No businessman would have dealings with him after he had ruined many a partner by bailing out when finances turned risky; his former fianceé was present - he had jilted her for a richer fianceé, who was also at the scene. As if that was not enough to create havoc, Inspector Nigel Nivens has somehow weasled his way back on police force and his sole intention is to bring Inspector Witherspoon down…. This is the 41st and, as of this writing, the last of this long-running cozy Victorian series, and it packs quite a wallop. Of course our intrepid household staff, led by Mrs. Jeffries, do all they can to surreptitiously aid the Inspector, and of course the case is solved by the end, but it’s quite a harrowing journey along the way. I caught a couple of missteps here, in particular the name of one of Hatchet’s sources, and I figured out the culprit fairly early on, but overall this was still a splendid read, and I can only hope that Ms. Brightwell will soon again return to these characters and this world; recommended!
October 9, 2023
This was a decent read, I did like the archery angle with the mystery. Liked that they showed that archery was a popular sport for both men and women in this time period. How it wasn't just the extremely wealthy who had clubs and activities they did in groups. Nice to see a focus on other classes in Victorian England.
I liked that it focused more on the mystery than wasting time on things that weighed it down in previous books. I enjoyed myself with the writing of the mystery, how the team worked to solve the case, and the overall feel of the book.
Sadly once again the killer was extremely obvious early in the book, and how the return of Nivens was handled was disappointing and felt a bit like a cop out. But I'm glad that part of the story is done, Nevens was starting to become an annoying "villain" and it needed to be wrapped up as the series continued.
But overall, it was a quick nice read and a good installment of the series.
I liked that it focused more on the mystery than wasting time on things that weighed it down in previous books. I enjoyed myself with the writing of the mystery, how the team worked to solve the case, and the overall feel of the book.
Sadly once again the killer was extremely obvious early in the book, and how the return of Nivens was handled was disappointing and felt a bit like a cop out. But I'm glad that part of the story is done, Nevens was starting to become an annoying "villain" and it needed to be wrapped up as the series continued.
But overall, it was a quick nice read and a good installment of the series.
September 20, 2023
A disreputable man ends up being the target at an archery competition in "Mrs. Jeffries Aims to Win." Luty and Hatchett just happen to be on hand when the murder occurs, so our team gets an early start on gathering information. There's lots of information and lots of suspects since everyone hates the dead guy.
Emily Brightwell follows a consistent formula in her books, which is fine. Readers know what to expect, and the stories feel like catching up with old friends.
Unfortunately, Betsy is all but missing in this novel. One could argue that her absence from the crime solving is appropriate, given the Victorian timeline and the fact that she is a wife and mother. I still miss her involvement.
There's a major development at the end of the story. I won't spoil it for you, but it's huge.
Emily Brightwell follows a consistent formula in her books, which is fine. Readers know what to expect, and the stories feel like catching up with old friends.
Unfortunately, Betsy is all but missing in this novel. One could argue that her absence from the crime solving is appropriate, given the Victorian timeline and the fact that she is a wife and mother. I still miss her involvement.
There's a major development at the end of the story. I won't spoil it for you, but it's huge.
March 17, 2024
Another engaging Mrs Jeffries mystery. Different and interesting to see more Inspector/constable invovlement vs the servants—or was that just me?—in terms of asking questions and tracking down suspects. The author loves to throw a lot of suspects and characters at the reader, and this one is no exception. Out of 40-something mysteries, this is one of two or three where I anticipated the killer’s identity about halfway through, but as I say I’m rarely able to do that in these. Pesky Inspector Nivens is back, and though there’s a shocking revelation in the end, I felt the subplot of him trying to get back at Witherspoon wasn’t substantial enough.
I always look forward to a Mrs Jeffries book—I’ve read all of them now, about half of them twice. I was never a cozy reader before Mrs Jeffries, and those I’ve tried since just don’t do it for me. But Mrs Jeffries is a consistent delight.
I always look forward to a Mrs Jeffries book—I’ve read all of them now, about half of them twice. I was never a cozy reader before Mrs Jeffries, and those I’ve tried since just don’t do it for me. But Mrs Jeffries is a consistent delight.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 21, 2023
What can I say. Another wonderful entry. Would make a wonderful series for PBS. Or the BBC.
The plot revolving around Nivens and his continuous effort to ruin Witherspoon has come to a welcome end. And I think this was a good call.
This book felt a bit different than the rest of the series because much of the focus was on the police investigation rather than the household staff. And I also noticed that the author didn’t offer her usual background information on how Witherspoon came to live in this home, Betsy’s background, Wiggins, Smythe etc., allowing new readers to jump in.
I hope that this is not the last book in the series.
The plot revolving around Nivens and his continuous effort to ruin Witherspoon has come to a welcome end. And I think this was a good call.
This book felt a bit different than the rest of the series because much of the focus was on the police investigation rather than the household staff. And I also noticed that the author didn’t offer her usual background information on how Witherspoon came to live in this home, Betsy’s background, Wiggins, Smythe etc., allowing new readers to jump in.
I hope that this is not the last book in the series.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 31, 2023
I enjoyed this book, very much! As always the characters in this book are the staff of workers employed by Inspector Witherspoon, his fiancee, Ruth and several close friends of the staff all work to help the inspector to solve his crimes. The housekeeper, Mrs Jeffries is the also quite a good sleuth and is the leader of all of the the people working for the inspector and with her talks after he gets home helped to mold him into the very good inspector he has become. I most definitely highly recommend this book and the rest of the books in the series.
December 11, 2023
A nasty womanizer and ruthless businessman, Jeremy Marks, gets killed my arrows at an archery club.
A bit confusing, but Mrs. Jeffries solves the murder.
A woman engaged to probably the only man that would love her is jilted when her father loses all his money in a scheme perpetuated by Marks. Her vengeance is served cold.
A bit confusing, but Mrs. Jeffries solves the murder.
A woman engaged to probably the only man that would love her is jilted when her father loses all his money in a scheme perpetuated by Marks. Her vengeance is served cold.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 30, 2023
This series is one that I have enjoyed from the beginning. The characters are so human, the plots believable and such a challenge to get to before the end of the book. I hope Emily Brightwell continues this one. Will the Inspector marry Lady Ruth???
September 16, 2023
My wife and I have read the entire series. That said we found #41 remarkably good! It is remarkable how the author has outdone herself this late into the series! I am afraid of letting any spoilers out that I will leave it at even if you are new to the series, you will not be disappointed.
September 24, 2023
I love this series! It is perfectly cozy and always a sweet read. I liked the mystery in this entry and the new investigatory method the inspector came up with when he couldn't use his typical timeline method. I hope this series never ends and it just goes on until the end of time. 4/5 stars
October 14, 2023
Mrs.jeffries
Loved this book and welcoming back these characters.love their caring for each other esp inspector witherspoon. It is so much fun being with each of their journeys to gather info. To help the inspector and Barnes solve their cases.
Loved this book and welcoming back these characters.love their caring for each other esp inspector witherspoon. It is so much fun being with each of their journeys to gather info. To help the inspector and Barnes solve their cases.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 63 reviews