Topline review: READ THIS BOOK ASAP!
I have been on the edge of my seat waiting for Alok Vaid-Menon to publish more poetry since their 2017 debut, Femme in Public. That chapbook fundamentally changed the way that I see — and move through — the world. This collection reveals new dimensions to the same courage, perception, defiance, and deep care that first drew me to Alok. It is a beautiful, beautiful collection. You cannot read it and be unmoved.
The collection as a whole straddles the “before and after” divide of the COVID-19 pandemic, some written before it began, and others noted to have been written after. But in the arrangement of the poems, Alok — a master of challenging binaries — seems perhaps to challenge whether the experiences of the pandemic can be so cleanly delineated into a “before and after” framework. Are we really to believe that people weren’t already lonely before being trapped indoors? Were we not beset by countless other epidemics (violence against trans and non-binary people, for instance) back when things were deemed “comfortable” and “normal”? Are we not still laden with griefs that precede the stasis induced by the pandemic? The poems question and probe this line and range in tone from mourning to euphoria, from ridicule to self-regard. The collection picked up steam as it went, with the home stretch packing in a crescendo of particularly magnificent poems.
Some poems were especially powerful standouts. The final quartet — “impossible lives,” “your wound is my garden,” “our tremendous beauty,” and “care is our natural state” — simultaneously brought me to tears AND had me exclaiming aloud in affirmation. I read these final four poems so many times; read together, they feel almost imbued with the properties of a map. They are revealing, instructive, orienting. Absolutely flawless work that is a gift to read, and to which I will frequently return. Another highlight: the twin poems “a new unit of measure” and “bilingual.” Should there someday be an anthology of poems about the COVID-19 pandemic (and there someday will be such an anthology), these two are absolutely essential contributions. They are some of the first poetry produced during the pandemic that I have read thinking “yes, exactly this, remember this.” Finally, I have to lift up Alok’s poem about the death of their beloved grandfather, “dying is the longest verb i know.” It is an exquisite, wrenching memorial — one of the best descriptions of loss that I have ever read. Reading it for the first time was such a tender gift; in the way that it pins down a momentous experience with small details, it instantly reminded me of my own losses. To me, reading it stands beside my first time reading Tracy K. Smith’s masterpiece poem about her father’s passing, “The Speed of Belief,” from her collection Life on Mars. And I assure you, I have no higher poetic praise to give than that. I never even expected to be able to make that kind of a comparison with another poem.
I’m winding down my review, but of course, no review of this book is complete without engaging with the STYLE! When I tell you about the absolute LOOKS served alongside these poems! The book is laced with stunning glamour shots of Alok. And this, of course, is central to Alok’s creative work: celebrating, loving, esteeming, making sacred the ever-evolving beauty that others would (and have tried and failed to) trample. It’s hard to choose a favorite, but mine are the cover photo, the diptych in the garden on page 48, and the departing portrait on page 51. Just stunning, and so in communion with the power of the poetry.
Vaid-Menon is a visionary and a waymaker. A genius. I sincerely believe they are one of the most important artists working in any medium today. Am I gushing? Yes! And it is warranted. Alok is one of the artists and thinkers of my life, and it is such a treasure to sit with this new material at a time when I needed it. It’s January 2 as I am writing this, and I already know that it will be one of the most important books I read all year. Y’all ought to pick up a copy and read it for yourself as soon as you can.