What do you think?
Rate this book
Two Truths and a Lie #3
A Matter of Fact
Name – Rhys St. George
Age – 37
Relationship status – Single
Looking for – A way to make all of this right
Biggest regret – Callahan McMillian
Hobbies – Having money, making money, spending money, and wine.
Name – Beckett Thatcher
Age – 27
Relationship status – Super Single!
Looking for – The kind of man who knows what I'm worth
Biggest regret – Being hesitant to form meaningful relationships after moving
Hobbies – Cooking, baking, and being a good plant dad
Rhys doesn't know what he wants anymore, but he knows he wants to be in Myers Bluff and he wants to make things right with his brother, and maybe his ex-boyfriend too. The only problem is... he doesn't know how to do any of that.
Beckett has a bad job and big dreams, and he's not going to let either of those things hold him back. He definitely doesn't have time to deal with a man like Rhys St. George, but there's something magnetic about the way too-rich-for-his-own-good man that Beckett can't deny.
Rhys is used to buying whatever he wants, but finds Beckett cannot be bought. For the first time in his life, Rhys isn't two steps ahead; he's half a pace behind. But maybe that's exactly where he needs to be to find what he's always been looking for--a purpose, personal redemption, and love.
Age – 37
Relationship status – Single
Looking for – A way to make all of this right
Biggest regret – Callahan McMillian
Hobbies – Having money, making money, spending money, and wine.
Name – Beckett Thatcher
Age – 27
Relationship status – Super Single!
Looking for – The kind of man who knows what I'm worth
Biggest regret – Being hesitant to form meaningful relationships after moving
Hobbies – Cooking, baking, and being a good plant dad
Rhys doesn't know what he wants anymore, but he knows he wants to be in Myers Bluff and he wants to make things right with his brother, and maybe his ex-boyfriend too. The only problem is... he doesn't know how to do any of that.
Beckett has a bad job and big dreams, and he's not going to let either of those things hold him back. He definitely doesn't have time to deal with a man like Rhys St. George, but there's something magnetic about the way too-rich-for-his-own-good man that Beckett can't deny.
Rhys is used to buying whatever he wants, but finds Beckett cannot be bought. For the first time in his life, Rhys isn't two steps ahead; he's half a pace behind. But maybe that's exactly where he needs to be to find what he's always been looking for--a purpose, personal redemption, and love.
319 pages, Kindle Edition
First published March 1, 2022
74 people are currently reading
242 people want to read
About the author
Kate Hawthorne
93 books939 followersWith over two dozen published romances to her name, Kate Hawthorne has built a recognizable brand around telling emotional stories that pack a figurative (and sometimes literal) punch.
Existing on a steady diet of wine and coffee, Kate spends her days dreaming up angsty stories full of heat, kink, and heart. Kate now lives in Louisville, where she writes romance, reads romance, and hides from the humidity.
Visit her website at http://www.katehawthornebooks.com
Existing on a steady diet of wine and coffee, Kate spends her days dreaming up angsty stories full of heat, kink, and heart. Kate now lives in Louisville, where she writes romance, reads romance, and hides from the humidity.
Visit her website at http://www.katehawthornebooks.com
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 73 reviews
January 14, 2024
Second read: I have no clue how this happened, but I woke up this morning with the insane urge to re-read this book. So well I re-read this entire book in a day. I just adore this book so much. This is still one of my favourite book that I have ever read!
——
Original review:
5 “I would spend every cent in my bank account if it meant I’d get to kiss you like that just one more time” stars
First things first, I don’t really recommend reading this book as a standalone, this is the third book in a series, and it is a redemption book for one of the evil side characters of the previous two books in the series and I think it’s really beneficial to see the character’s previous actions before reading his book. But I think you could read it as a standalone if you wanted to, the book does a fine job of explaining everything that happened in the previous books of the series, but it does seems like it starts in the middle of a story and only explains many things later on in the book, so please be warned of that.
This book was probably my most anticipated new release of the entire year. Even since we met Rhys in book 1 of the series, I have been aching to get his book. It’s no secrets that books about the redemption of an evil main character are my favourite book trope of all time, so I was not so patiently waiting to read this book and I was so excited to get it in my hands. I binge read this book in one day the second I received an ARC copy of it and I have no regrets about it, it was one of the best reading experience I have ever had. We might only be at the start of the year, but I can already predict that this book will end in my top 5 favourite book of the year, it just left such an impact on me and I’m sure I will be talking and thinking about this book for the rest of the year.
Brief summary
Rhys is 37 and he is crumbling under his family’s expectations (he’s from a really wealthy family and he had to do a lot of things he regrets to uphold the family name) and he is very unhappy with his life. Rhys goes to brunch at a restaurant, and he meets his waiter, Beckett. They see each other again and again, go on multiple dates and they fall in love.
“Beckett, I think I’m in love with you.”
“You don’t have to say it back.”
“What if I want to?”
“What?”
“What if I love you too?”
“Then you’re a fool,”
“Then I’m a fool.”
First, I don’t think I will ever be able to stop talking about how much I love Rhys. In fact, expect me to mention him in every other sentence about books that I will speak this entire year. Rhys was an evil side character in the previous books of this series but as far as I’m concerned, Rhys has been fully redeemed and is now one of my top 3 favourite book characters of all time. Rhys is a cold, calculating heartless characters in the previous books in the series, but in his book, he was so awkward and fumbling, he was so unsure of himself and just so eager to fall in love. And I just loved everything about him.
Second, at the start of the book, we see Rhys who is absolutely crumbling under family expectations. He is the oldest son of a very wealthy family, and he took all the expectations of what comes with that on his shoulders, including sacrificing his life and dreams and never marrying a man like he wanted to because his father was against that. He doesn’t have friends or much of a life, or people he cares about. Rhys was just so alone and all he wanted was to be happy because he really wasn’t and he hadn’t been in a long time, and it broke my heart to read about that and how unhappy with his life he was. And Rhys feared falling in love because it meant to he would have to be vulnerable, and he doesn’t know how to be anything but in control. But then we got to see Rhys meet Beckett and we got to see Rhys finally be happy and get all the things he wants in life, and it just made me utterly happy to see Rhys do and get everything he has denied himself his entire life. I loved seeing him being so carefree and in love, it felt so rewarding to see him opening up and just living, instead of being the cold and heartless person he had been for years. I loved how eager he was to just be in love and have someone that loved him, he radiated such joy about his relationship and just being with Beckett and it was lovely to see. It was very rewarding as a reader to see the cold and calculating facade shred apart to reveal a man that just wants to be loved for who he is.
Here is an interaction between Rhys and Sebastian, his brother, that I think really shows how Rhys felt: “How did you do it?” […] “How did I do what?” “Give yourself permission to be happy.”
Side note, there is something so beautiful about reading about a character that used to be really closed off and never opened starting to open up and let someone in. And that’s exactly what Rhys did. And I loved reading about how he let himself be vulnerable for one of the first time in his life and how he let Beckett in, it was an absolute thing of beauty to read about.
Another side note, I just want to mention how much I loved that this book put a really big focus on Rhys finding his found family, the fact that Rhys didn’t belong and didn’t have friends was a big part of his character, so I loved how the book made sure to give him a found family that loves him exactly like he is.
Third, I’m a cry baby and I have a soft spot for people who are lonely and who had life situations that didn’t allow them to be happy so safe to say that I cried for a lot of this book. I just got so emotional over Rhys and what he was feeling, and I just wanted to give him a big hug. This book made me cry so much, just because I felt for Rhys so much and I just wanted him to have a moment of peace for once. I was just a mess at the end of this book, it made my cry my entire body weight in tears and I loved every seconds of it.
Fourth, I talked in detail about how much I love Rhys already, but now I want to talk about how much I adored Beckett, he was just the perfect love interest for Rhys to me. Beckett was just so lovely, and he was so good to Rhys and I loved how understanding he was to Rhys and I just adored how Beckett did everything to make Rhys feel good and to shatter every fear and doubts that Rhys has ever had.
Beckett also understood that knowing Rhys, or rather, being allowed to know him, to see him…it was a gift. It was such a gift. And no amount of money would ever balance that.
Fifth, I now want to talk about how much I loved the redemption part of this book. This was everything I have ever wanted to read about in a book about a character’s redemption. When we got to see Rhys in the previous books of the series, he was mean and seemed super cold and arrogant, so I loved seeing in his brains and learning the reasons for his behaviour and why he was that way. I really enjoyed learning to know him in a new light. I really enjoyed having a peak into his head and seeing his motivations for his previous actions, that really worked for me. What I love about redemption books is that they take you on a journey. Especially since we met Rhys in book 1 of the series, we got to see all his evil ways and the ways in which he hurt every other character in the series, so it was even more impactful as a reader to see him maturing and realizing how he went wrong before and apologizing for the hurt he previously caused. I really loved how much of this book put a focus on Rhys and on redeeming his previous actions and showing his motives for them and how he learnt from them and how he changed his life to now be a better man, everything about that part of the book really worked for me. Also, I just loved how hard Rhys tried to be different than the way he used to be, Rhys just wanted to show that he was changing and growing, and I loved that for him.
Side note, I just adored that while this book was a redemption book and a lot of the book was focused on the redemption, it was also about Rhys finding who he is and growing as a person, that just really worked for me.
Beckett loved him always. And he loved Beckett. He loved him so much. And he refused to give up on that. […] He’d just gotten a taste of what it could be like, a life with the support of a partner, completely separate of the familial ties that had held him in bondage his whole life.
Sixth, I just adored the romance in this book. It was just so sweet; it melted my entire heart. I loved how Rhys just wanted to spend all the time he could with Beckett, he didn’t care how, he just wanted to spend time with him. I just loved how happy Rhys was to spend time with Beckett I loved how happy they seemed to make each other every time they interacted with each other. And I just adored how much of this book’s focus was put on them going on dates and getting to know each other, that just really worked for me.
Seventh, I loved their communication and how mature their relationship is, when they had an issue, they talked about it together and compromised and I loved it so much.
Eight, all the books in this series talk about money and the consequences of having a lot or not having much and I really enjoy talks like that in books and I really appreciated in this book too. Rhys is rich and at the start of the book he thinks that all he’s worth is his money and that people only like him because of his money and not because of who he is, and I loved how Beckett spent so much time proving to Rhys that he is more than his money.
Ninth, I have read the other books in this series and the way this book brought an end to the series and answered many questions brought by the previous books in the series was just so well done. This book served as a perfect ending for the characters in the series and their lives and it wrapped everything in a way that was just super satisfying.
I just adored every second of this book, I don’t think I will be able to stop talking about this book any time soon, this book just had my heart from the second I started it and I think it will have my heart for a very long time. This book was just perfect for me.
I received an ARC of this book and this is my honest opinon.
——
Original review:
5 “I would spend every cent in my bank account if it meant I’d get to kiss you like that just one more time” stars
First things first, I don’t really recommend reading this book as a standalone, this is the third book in a series, and it is a redemption book for one of the evil side characters of the previous two books in the series and I think it’s really beneficial to see the character’s previous actions before reading his book. But I think you could read it as a standalone if you wanted to, the book does a fine job of explaining everything that happened in the previous books of the series, but it does seems like it starts in the middle of a story and only explains many things later on in the book, so please be warned of that.
This book was probably my most anticipated new release of the entire year. Even since we met Rhys in book 1 of the series, I have been aching to get his book. It’s no secrets that books about the redemption of an evil main character are my favourite book trope of all time, so I was not so patiently waiting to read this book and I was so excited to get it in my hands. I binge read this book in one day the second I received an ARC copy of it and I have no regrets about it, it was one of the best reading experience I have ever had. We might only be at the start of the year, but I can already predict that this book will end in my top 5 favourite book of the year, it just left such an impact on me and I’m sure I will be talking and thinking about this book for the rest of the year.
Brief summary
Rhys is 37 and he is crumbling under his family’s expectations (he’s from a really wealthy family and he had to do a lot of things he regrets to uphold the family name) and he is very unhappy with his life. Rhys goes to brunch at a restaurant, and he meets his waiter, Beckett. They see each other again and again, go on multiple dates and they fall in love.
“Beckett, I think I’m in love with you.”
“You don’t have to say it back.”
“What if I want to?”
“What?”
“What if I love you too?”
“Then you’re a fool,”
“Then I’m a fool.”
First, I don’t think I will ever be able to stop talking about how much I love Rhys. In fact, expect me to mention him in every other sentence about books that I will speak this entire year. Rhys was an evil side character in the previous books of this series but as far as I’m concerned, Rhys has been fully redeemed and is now one of my top 3 favourite book characters of all time. Rhys is a cold, calculating heartless characters in the previous books in the series, but in his book, he was so awkward and fumbling, he was so unsure of himself and just so eager to fall in love. And I just loved everything about him.
Second, at the start of the book, we see Rhys who is absolutely crumbling under family expectations. He is the oldest son of a very wealthy family, and he took all the expectations of what comes with that on his shoulders, including sacrificing his life and dreams and never marrying a man like he wanted to because his father was against that. He doesn’t have friends or much of a life, or people he cares about. Rhys was just so alone and all he wanted was to be happy because he really wasn’t and he hadn’t been in a long time, and it broke my heart to read about that and how unhappy with his life he was. And Rhys feared falling in love because it meant to he would have to be vulnerable, and he doesn’t know how to be anything but in control. But then we got to see Rhys meet Beckett and we got to see Rhys finally be happy and get all the things he wants in life, and it just made me utterly happy to see Rhys do and get everything he has denied himself his entire life. I loved seeing him being so carefree and in love, it felt so rewarding to see him opening up and just living, instead of being the cold and heartless person he had been for years. I loved how eager he was to just be in love and have someone that loved him, he radiated such joy about his relationship and just being with Beckett and it was lovely to see. It was very rewarding as a reader to see the cold and calculating facade shred apart to reveal a man that just wants to be loved for who he is.
Here is an interaction between Rhys and Sebastian, his brother, that I think really shows how Rhys felt: “How did you do it?” […] “How did I do what?” “Give yourself permission to be happy.”
Side note, there is something so beautiful about reading about a character that used to be really closed off and never opened starting to open up and let someone in. And that’s exactly what Rhys did. And I loved reading about how he let himself be vulnerable for one of the first time in his life and how he let Beckett in, it was an absolute thing of beauty to read about.
Another side note, I just want to mention how much I loved that this book put a really big focus on Rhys finding his found family, the fact that Rhys didn’t belong and didn’t have friends was a big part of his character, so I loved how the book made sure to give him a found family that loves him exactly like he is.
Third, I’m a cry baby and I have a soft spot for people who are lonely and who had life situations that didn’t allow them to be happy so safe to say that I cried for a lot of this book. I just got so emotional over Rhys and what he was feeling, and I just wanted to give him a big hug. This book made me cry so much, just because I felt for Rhys so much and I just wanted him to have a moment of peace for once. I was just a mess at the end of this book, it made my cry my entire body weight in tears and I loved every seconds of it.
Fourth, I talked in detail about how much I love Rhys already, but now I want to talk about how much I adored Beckett, he was just the perfect love interest for Rhys to me. Beckett was just so lovely, and he was so good to Rhys and I loved how understanding he was to Rhys and I just adored how Beckett did everything to make Rhys feel good and to shatter every fear and doubts that Rhys has ever had.
Beckett also understood that knowing Rhys, or rather, being allowed to know him, to see him…it was a gift. It was such a gift. And no amount of money would ever balance that.
Fifth, I now want to talk about how much I loved the redemption part of this book. This was everything I have ever wanted to read about in a book about a character’s redemption. When we got to see Rhys in the previous books of the series, he was mean and seemed super cold and arrogant, so I loved seeing in his brains and learning the reasons for his behaviour and why he was that way. I really enjoyed learning to know him in a new light. I really enjoyed having a peak into his head and seeing his motivations for his previous actions, that really worked for me. What I love about redemption books is that they take you on a journey. Especially since we met Rhys in book 1 of the series, we got to see all his evil ways and the ways in which he hurt every other character in the series, so it was even more impactful as a reader to see him maturing and realizing how he went wrong before and apologizing for the hurt he previously caused. I really loved how much of this book put a focus on Rhys and on redeeming his previous actions and showing his motives for them and how he learnt from them and how he changed his life to now be a better man, everything about that part of the book really worked for me. Also, I just loved how hard Rhys tried to be different than the way he used to be, Rhys just wanted to show that he was changing and growing, and I loved that for him.
Side note, I just adored that while this book was a redemption book and a lot of the book was focused on the redemption, it was also about Rhys finding who he is and growing as a person, that just really worked for me.
Beckett loved him always. And he loved Beckett. He loved him so much. And he refused to give up on that. […] He’d just gotten a taste of what it could be like, a life with the support of a partner, completely separate of the familial ties that had held him in bondage his whole life.
Sixth, I just adored the romance in this book. It was just so sweet; it melted my entire heart. I loved how Rhys just wanted to spend all the time he could with Beckett, he didn’t care how, he just wanted to spend time with him. I just loved how happy Rhys was to spend time with Beckett I loved how happy they seemed to make each other every time they interacted with each other. And I just adored how much of this book’s focus was put on them going on dates and getting to know each other, that just really worked for me.
Seventh, I loved their communication and how mature their relationship is, when they had an issue, they talked about it together and compromised and I loved it so much.
Eight, all the books in this series talk about money and the consequences of having a lot or not having much and I really enjoy talks like that in books and I really appreciated in this book too. Rhys is rich and at the start of the book he thinks that all he’s worth is his money and that people only like him because of his money and not because of who he is, and I loved how Beckett spent so much time proving to Rhys that he is more than his money.
Ninth, I have read the other books in this series and the way this book brought an end to the series and answered many questions brought by the previous books in the series was just so well done. This book served as a perfect ending for the characters in the series and their lives and it wrapped everything in a way that was just super satisfying.
I just adored every second of this book, I don’t think I will be able to stop talking about this book any time soon, this book just had my heart from the second I started it and I think it will have my heart for a very long time. This book was just perfect for me.
I received an ARC of this book and this is my honest opinon.
March 29, 2022
This would be a fairly average not-particularly-original-but-hey three stars CR, EXCEPT FOR the egregious plot manipulation. It concerns money & finance and such-like complicated things that writers of CRs seem to assume SIMPLY DON'T MATTER. I apologise for the shouty caps, but REALLY. WHY do CR authors not pay their readers the compliment of writing credible money-related plots?
This one is especially dismissive of our intelligence:
Two stars, and that's generous under the circumstances.
Maybe I should offer my services as a plot consultant.
"Does money make your lovers' world go round? Draw on Drew to Devise Dependable Details of Dimes, Dollars and Dividends!"
This one is especially dismissive of our intelligence:
Two stars, and that's generous under the circumstances.
Maybe I should offer my services as a plot consultant.
"Does money make your lovers' world go round? Draw on Drew to Devise Dependable Details of Dimes, Dollars and Dividends!"
March 3, 2022
Looking back on my reviews for A Real Good Lie and A Cold Hard Truth, I realized that I mentioned Rhys and my need for his story in both of them. I could sense he was worthy of redemption in book one and knew he was after reading book two. To me, this whole series could be considered the Rhys St. George show because I felt like everything that happened in the previous books was leading up to his HEA. Because of this, I have to reiterate what other reviewers have written and say that reading the series in its entirety is crucial if seeing the big picture is important to you. Each book is about a different couple, but Rhys is the catalyst and the common thread throughout the entire series.
I spent the first few chapters wanting to cry on Rhys' behalf. Yes he had been insufferable and a total jerk, but he had absolutely no one in his corner at all. He was in a new city, living in a condo that didn't belong to him with nothing but time for some pretty harsh introspection. His own brother acted like talking to him was a hardship and when he needed dating advice, the one person with any perspective to offer was someone who hated his guts. It felt like he was constantly rolling with the punches, reserved to the fact that he deserved each and every one of them. So much of this book was a long walk of shame for Rhys and my heart hurt for him.
I loved Beckett, but I did feel as though his story was drowned out by Rhys. I mean, I'm not even sure what Beckett looked like other than having curly brown hair. If we were told his eye color I must have missed it because I was curious throughout the entire book. You can skimp on a lot of physical details and I'll be okay with it, but eye color is so important to me. Beckett was a lot like Jace from book one. He worked a minimum wage job as a waiter and struggled to make ends meet but wanted to bring his dreams to fruition without hand outs. The topic of money was so huge in this book that it could have been a named character with its own redemption arc. Villain turned savior.
Beckett and Rhys together physically was pure magic. The sex scenes were perfection. There is so much more to steam than cocks, holes and balls (sorry if that's crass, but we're all reading the same books soooo...). I love the smaller intimate moments - the kisses, the goose bumps, the fingernails digging into skin. It was always so sensual and passionate between them and I loved it.
On the flip side, the problem I had with this book mirrored the problem I had with the first book, which was a lack of relationship building before the ILY's. We were told about conversations they had, but they took place off the page which made the big moments in their relationship feel a bit rushed. I initially wondered what Beckett and Rhys liked about each other outside of their physical attraction. As the story progressed their feelings began to feel authentic and well earned, I just wish there was more "getting to know you" before the declarations.
Despite some niggles, I really did like this book. It was by far my favorite in the series and I thoroughly enjoyed the bonus extra the author sent through her newsletter.
I spent the first few chapters wanting to cry on Rhys' behalf. Yes he had been insufferable and a total jerk, but he had absolutely no one in his corner at all. He was in a new city, living in a condo that didn't belong to him with nothing but time for some pretty harsh introspection. His own brother acted like talking to him was a hardship and when he needed dating advice, the one person with any perspective to offer was someone who hated his guts. It felt like he was constantly rolling with the punches, reserved to the fact that he deserved each and every one of them. So much of this book was a long walk of shame for Rhys and my heart hurt for him.
I loved Beckett, but I did feel as though his story was drowned out by Rhys. I mean, I'm not even sure what Beckett looked like other than having curly brown hair. If we were told his eye color I must have missed it because I was curious throughout the entire book. You can skimp on a lot of physical details and I'll be okay with it, but eye color is so important to me. Beckett was a lot like Jace from book one. He worked a minimum wage job as a waiter and struggled to make ends meet but wanted to bring his dreams to fruition without hand outs. The topic of money was so huge in this book that it could have been a named character with its own redemption arc. Villain turned savior.
Beckett and Rhys together physically was pure magic. The sex scenes were perfection. There is so much more to steam than cocks, holes and balls (sorry if that's crass, but we're all reading the same books soooo...). I love the smaller intimate moments - the kisses, the goose bumps, the fingernails digging into skin. It was always so sensual and passionate between them and I loved it.
On the flip side, the problem I had with this book mirrored the problem I had with the first book, which was a lack of relationship building before the ILY's. We were told about conversations they had, but they took place off the page which made the big moments in their relationship feel a bit rushed. I initially wondered what Beckett and Rhys liked about each other outside of their physical attraction. As the story progressed their feelings began to feel authentic and well earned, I just wish there was more "getting to know you" before the declarations.
Despite some niggles, I really did like this book. It was by far my favorite in the series and I thoroughly enjoyed the bonus extra the author sent through her newsletter.
February 14, 2024
Unlikeable MC
dates flake, pays his debts, finds love.
Read better books next.
dates flake, pays his debts, finds love.
Read better books next.
March 5, 2022
OMG I LOVED THIS!
OK so first off - you will want to read this series in order, as this book revolves around Rhys (who has been a major factor in the previous stories). This is a MAJOR redemption story, one that has been building, and you need to understand his past mistakes to understand why all the characters around him view him the way they do. I feel like you'd possibly feel a bit lost if you just jumped into this one.
I adored Rhys and Beckett together like OMG SO MUCH. I had been waiting to see how Rhys would redeem himself and set things right - and also the type of man that would fall for Rhys, and would be enough to make Rhys break away from his father and become his own man. Beckett was perfect for him - sweet, honest, and most importantly, saw past the money and saw Rhys for the man he really could be. (and of course Beckett loves the ostentatious sink! LOL)
Also - the amount of schmoopy and sweetness from Rhys when he allowed himself to truly be himself with Beckett was adorable. Mmmmm I just loved the two of them together, so much. The little moments of support, of them together, the "darling" and knuckles kiss. I just just loved them.
Absolutely adored this, and so so happy for Rhys to get a HEA and complete redemption!
OK so first off - you will want to read this series in order, as this book revolves around Rhys (who has been a major factor in the previous stories). This is a MAJOR redemption story, one that has been building, and you need to understand his past mistakes to understand why all the characters around him view him the way they do. I feel like you'd possibly feel a bit lost if you just jumped into this one.
I adored Rhys and Beckett together like OMG SO MUCH. I had been waiting to see how Rhys would redeem himself and set things right - and also the type of man that would fall for Rhys, and would be enough to make Rhys break away from his father and become his own man. Beckett was perfect for him - sweet, honest, and most importantly, saw past the money and saw Rhys for the man he really could be. (and of course Beckett loves the ostentatious sink! LOL)
Also - the amount of schmoopy and sweetness from Rhys when he allowed himself to truly be himself with Beckett was adorable. Mmmmm I just loved the two of them together, so much. The little moments of support, of them together, the "darling" and knuckles kiss. I just just loved them.
Absolutely adored this, and so so happy for Rhys to get a HEA and complete redemption!
March 1, 2022
Finally!
The most anticipated book of the series.
I knew Rhys St. George wasn't the one he let everyone saw him in the past.
Saying he's redeemable wasn't right after all. The reasons he did what he did back then, made him close to a hero, or a martyr.
I loved Rhys.
Best of the series.
Full review coming up.
The most anticipated book of the series.
I knew Rhys St. George wasn't the one he let everyone saw him in the past.
Saying he's redeemable wasn't right after all. The reasons he did what he did back then, made him close to a hero, or a martyr.
I loved Rhys.
Best of the series.
Full review coming up.
March 4, 2022
5 stars
Yes. God. The author heard us asking and she DELIVERED.
Misunderstood villain? Check. Angst? Check. Rich boy breaking free? Check. HEA? Check check.
In book1 Rhys St. George was our villain. He broke Callahan's heart so ruthlessly and he was painted as malicious, cruel, and selfish. However in this book we learn there is always more behind the story.
It will hurt your little heart to see how lonely and isolated Rhys is in his suffering as he protected his brother. He isn't totally blameless, but definitely redeemable.
Beckett is not the most interesting love interests to be honest. He was the polar opposite of Rhys which says he's poor as fuck. I didn't dislike Beckett but:
"Everyone else had wanted him for his money and his name, and Beckett wanted him in spite of it. But he wouldn't be who he was without those things, so maybe Beckett's refusal to accept those parts of him was somehow just as bad as being used for those things in the first place"
That sums it up. Beckett hated Rhys's money and it just felt like he didn't really accept a very big part of Rhys. Beside that, honestly I didn't understand why they were together since they didn't really have anything in common beside attraction. Also was super insta-kinda-love. Rhys's interest in Beckett left me perplexed because all Beckett did was literally serve him a drink.
Nevertheless, Rhys had the HEA he deserved. They were super cute together and I loved how they both opened up. They made it work and had HEA. That's all that matters. Amen.
Yes. God. The author heard us asking and she DELIVERED.
Misunderstood villain? Check. Angst? Check. Rich boy breaking free? Check. HEA? Check check.
In book1 Rhys St. George was our villain. He broke Callahan's heart so ruthlessly and he was painted as malicious, cruel, and selfish. However in this book we learn there is always more behind the story.
It will hurt your little heart to see how lonely and isolated Rhys is in his suffering as he protected his brother. He isn't totally blameless, but definitely redeemable.
Beckett is not the most interesting love interests to be honest. He was the polar opposite of Rhys which says he's poor as fuck. I didn't dislike Beckett but:
"Everyone else had wanted him for his money and his name, and Beckett wanted him in spite of it. But he wouldn't be who he was without those things, so maybe Beckett's refusal to accept those parts of him was somehow just as bad as being used for those things in the first place"
That sums it up. Beckett hated Rhys's money and it just felt like he didn't really accept a very big part of Rhys. Beside that, honestly I didn't understand why they were together since they didn't really have anything in common beside attraction. Also was super insta-kinda-love. Rhys's interest in Beckett left me perplexed because all Beckett did was literally serve him a drink.
Nevertheless, Rhys had the HEA he deserved. They were super cute together and I loved how they both opened up. They made it work and had HEA. That's all that matters. Amen.
February 26, 2022
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Kate Hawthrone writes beautifully complex characters. Ones that you can love and hate in the same breath. Ones that you want to smack up the side of the head one minute and then bring you to tears the next. It’s masterful and has quickly made her one of my favourite authors.
Rhys St. George is one of those brilliant characters. He is wealthy, arrogant, and rude. He treats everyone like they’re beneath him. Basically - you hate him. Yet…yet, you also want to wrap him up in bubble wrap to protect him, because he isn’t really all those things. Or at least he’s only partly those things. He’s - human. He deserves a second chance. And more importantly, he’s ready to be the man who earns it. He’s ready to be seen for who he is, not just for his name.
Beckett Thatcher isn’t interested in power and fortunes. He doesn’t own a suit, let alone dine in Michelin star restaurants. He has no time for pomp and circumstance, he’s too busy trying to pay the bills and figuring out how much ramen he can afford. He’s been surviving, alone. But he too is ready to be seen. Live a life beyond simply surviving, one full of love and friends.
This is a story of second chances and trusting you deserve love, even if you don’t always believe it.
Kate Hawthrone writes beautifully complex characters. Ones that you can love and hate in the same breath. Ones that you want to smack up the side of the head one minute and then bring you to tears the next. It’s masterful and has quickly made her one of my favourite authors.
Rhys St. George is one of those brilliant characters. He is wealthy, arrogant, and rude. He treats everyone like they’re beneath him. Basically - you hate him. Yet…yet, you also want to wrap him up in bubble wrap to protect him, because he isn’t really all those things. Or at least he’s only partly those things. He’s - human. He deserves a second chance. And more importantly, he’s ready to be the man who earns it. He’s ready to be seen for who he is, not just for his name.
Beckett Thatcher isn’t interested in power and fortunes. He doesn’t own a suit, let alone dine in Michelin star restaurants. He has no time for pomp and circumstance, he’s too busy trying to pay the bills and figuring out how much ramen he can afford. He’s been surviving, alone. But he too is ready to be seen. Live a life beyond simply surviving, one full of love and friends.
This is a story of second chances and trusting you deserve love, even if you don’t always believe it.
March 10, 2022
I wasn't really sure what to expect with this book, since main character Rhys has been cast a villainous character, but I wanted to know the conclusion to everything.
Rhys has moved to the city where his brother and ex-boyfriend reside. He's pretty much done with his controlling father and all the expectations and restraints his upbringing has put on him since he was a child. He's not entirely sure how to be a better person, but he knows he wants to make amends with his brother and the man he hurt, Callahan (one of the main characters from the first book). Beckett, on the other hand, just wants to pay all of his bills and get back into the good graces of his manager at the restaurant where he works.
Beckett is Rhys's server during a rather awkward brunch, and Rhys is determined to make Beckett part of his life. Beckett has no interest in Rhys's money or being part of his moneyed world. But Beckett is inexorably drawn to the deeply caring man under all the arrogance.
I had no problem with the romance at all. Beckett is charming, relatable and able to hold his own against Rhys. Rhys opens up to him pretty well, and you definitely understand that Rhys needs a caring person to be vulnerable with.
My biggest problem with Rhys's arc for this book and the one before it is: why hasn't he just told his brother and Callahan the truth about how his father has treated him and all the sacrifices he's made? Especially now that he's far away from his father and WANTS to make amends. But he's not just sitting both of them down, and being like, "Listen, this is why I treated you this way. This is what happened." It takes FOREVER in a way that doesn't make sense except to drag out the narrative, and it's frustrating as hell. Yes, Rhys is like a steel trap of emotions, but it actively works against his goals of creating a new life and making amends by not doing this right off the bat, or at least way sooner than he does.
The writing is good; the way its constructed does a really good job of communicating the type of people each main character is. Beckett's voice is more carefree; Rhys's is more constrained. The reading experience is a bit muted, but I think that's the theme of the whole series. I felt that way about the previous two books, too.
I will say that while Rhys and Sebastian father clearly sucks, the true villain of the story is Beckett's manager, Heather. She's evil and I only wish her the worst. She holds Beckett's emergency oral surgery against him, not giving him any good moneymaking shifts to the point that he is late on his rent. Then she manipulates him; ooooo, I hated her.
It's pretty spicy -- way more than the previous book for sure and possibly more than the first. Once Beckett gives himself permission to be with a guy as rich as Rhys, neither of them hold back sexually. I also really like that all three powerful, wealthy men in the series have submissive sides their partners fulfill.
Remington remains my favorite character -- he's the only one who sees through Rhys's smokescreen and actually advocates for him in conversations with Sebastian, Jace and Callahan. It's nice to see someone in Rhys's corner, because by the end of this book, I almost didn't like Jace for what a petulant child he is a lot of the time. I get that Rhys was a dick to him, but it was just excessive at points, especially when he keeps up the act even when he's agreed to help Rhys at various times. It's like, either hate him and stay away or agree to help him and help him.
Anyway, I was satisfied with the ending even if the series overall was a bit of a disappointment for me. Or maybe not a disappointment, but rather flat.
| I received an ARC from Gay Romance Reviews, and this is my honest, freely given review. |
Rhys has moved to the city where his brother and ex-boyfriend reside. He's pretty much done with his controlling father and all the expectations and restraints his upbringing has put on him since he was a child. He's not entirely sure how to be a better person, but he knows he wants to make amends with his brother and the man he hurt, Callahan (one of the main characters from the first book). Beckett, on the other hand, just wants to pay all of his bills and get back into the good graces of his manager at the restaurant where he works.
Beckett is Rhys's server during a rather awkward brunch, and Rhys is determined to make Beckett part of his life. Beckett has no interest in Rhys's money or being part of his moneyed world. But Beckett is inexorably drawn to the deeply caring man under all the arrogance.
I had no problem with the romance at all. Beckett is charming, relatable and able to hold his own against Rhys. Rhys opens up to him pretty well, and you definitely understand that Rhys needs a caring person to be vulnerable with.
My biggest problem with Rhys's arc for this book and the one before it is: why hasn't he just told his brother and Callahan the truth about how his father has treated him and all the sacrifices he's made? Especially now that he's far away from his father and WANTS to make amends. But he's not just sitting both of them down, and being like, "Listen, this is why I treated you this way. This is what happened." It takes FOREVER in a way that doesn't make sense except to drag out the narrative, and it's frustrating as hell. Yes, Rhys is like a steel trap of emotions, but it actively works against his goals of creating a new life and making amends by not doing this right off the bat, or at least way sooner than he does.
The writing is good; the way its constructed does a really good job of communicating the type of people each main character is. Beckett's voice is more carefree; Rhys's is more constrained. The reading experience is a bit muted, but I think that's the theme of the whole series. I felt that way about the previous two books, too.
I will say that while Rhys and Sebastian father clearly sucks, the true villain of the story is Beckett's manager, Heather. She's evil and I only wish her the worst. She holds Beckett's emergency oral surgery against him, not giving him any good moneymaking shifts to the point that he is late on his rent. Then she manipulates him; ooooo, I hated her.
It's pretty spicy -- way more than the previous book for sure and possibly more than the first. Once Beckett gives himself permission to be with a guy as rich as Rhys, neither of them hold back sexually. I also really like that all three powerful, wealthy men in the series have submissive sides their partners fulfill.
Remington remains my favorite character -- he's the only one who sees through Rhys's smokescreen and actually advocates for him in conversations with Sebastian, Jace and Callahan. It's nice to see someone in Rhys's corner, because by the end of this book, I almost didn't like Jace for what a petulant child he is a lot of the time. I get that Rhys was a dick to him, but it was just excessive at points, especially when he keeps up the act even when he's agreed to help Rhys at various times. It's like, either hate him and stay away or agree to help him and help him.
Anyway, I was satisfied with the ending even if the series overall was a bit of a disappointment for me. Or maybe not a disappointment, but rather flat.
| I received an ARC from Gay Romance Reviews, and this is my honest, freely given review. |
March 4, 2022
4.5 Stars!
So, I haven't read the previous 2 books in the series, but I didn't feel lost while reading AMoF. Actually, it might have been better for me in the long run as it seems Rhys was a bit of a jerk in the previous ones, LOL.
I loved Rhys, I loved the antihero that turned out to be a hero in his own right. He was perfectly imperfect and definitely my favorite of the two, although I really liked Beckett, too. Rhys is a rich man, used to getting his way, until he meets Beckett who doesn't let him buy him or his time. Beckett makes Rhys work for his attention and I adored how well they fit, despite their vastly different upbringings. They had great chemistry and damn if they didn't make the temp in my room rise a few degrees. *fans self* If anything, I felt a bit cheated that we didn't get Rhys's POV when they met, because it felt a bit sudden as it was, but the rest was gold.
I liked their interactions with Sebastian and Remington, Jace and Callaghan, and Audra. I hated Rhys and Sebastian's poor excuse for a father and I was ecstatic by how things played out in that front.
A Matter of Fact was a fascinating read, sexy, emotional—the scene when Rhys's father comes to collect him and Sebastian realizes how wrong he was about his brother just about broke me—and angsty, as Ms. Hawthorne expertly redeemed Rhys St. George and made him a man worthy of loving Beckett and being loved by him. Definitely a recommendation from me!
*** Copy provided by GRR for my reading pleasure, a review wasn't a requirement. ***
So, I haven't read the previous 2 books in the series, but I didn't feel lost while reading AMoF. Actually, it might have been better for me in the long run as it seems Rhys was a bit of a jerk in the previous ones, LOL.
I loved Rhys, I loved the antihero that turned out to be a hero in his own right. He was perfectly imperfect and definitely my favorite of the two, although I really liked Beckett, too. Rhys is a rich man, used to getting his way, until he meets Beckett who doesn't let him buy him or his time. Beckett makes Rhys work for his attention and I adored how well they fit, despite their vastly different upbringings. They had great chemistry and damn if they didn't make the temp in my room rise a few degrees. *fans self* If anything, I felt a bit cheated that we didn't get Rhys's POV when they met, because it felt a bit sudden as it was, but the rest was gold.
I liked their interactions with Sebastian and Remington, Jace and Callaghan, and Audra. I hated Rhys and Sebastian's poor excuse for a father and I was ecstatic by how things played out in that front.
A Matter of Fact was a fascinating read, sexy, emotional—the scene when Rhys's father comes to collect him and Sebastian realizes how wrong he was about his brother just about broke me—and angsty, as Ms. Hawthorne expertly redeemed Rhys St. George and made him a man worthy of loving Beckett and being loved by him. Definitely a recommendation from me!
*** Copy provided by GRR for my reading pleasure, a review wasn't a requirement. ***
March 1, 2022
A Joyfully Jay review.
5 stars
A Matter of Fact is the third book in Kate Hawthorne’s fabulous Two Truths and a Lie series (or as I personally think of it — The Redemption of Rhys St. George). Redeeming a villain in a romance novel is not an easy task; when readers start off hating a character, it is hard to move that dial and create someone we can love and care about. There is such a delicate balance here between making the character enough of a villain to make the redemption meaningful, but not so awful that you can’t forgive him. We need to discover things that show the character in a new light, while at the same time not having him undergo a complete personality transplant. And the redemption needs to be believable, rooted in the story and the character. And I have to say, Hawthorne really nails it completely here with Rhys. This book, and this series, has one of the best redemption journeys I have ever read and I absolutely loved this story.
Read Jay’s review in its entirety here.
5 stars
A Matter of Fact is the third book in Kate Hawthorne’s fabulous Two Truths and a Lie series (or as I personally think of it — The Redemption of Rhys St. George). Redeeming a villain in a romance novel is not an easy task; when readers start off hating a character, it is hard to move that dial and create someone we can love and care about. There is such a delicate balance here between making the character enough of a villain to make the redemption meaningful, but not so awful that you can’t forgive him. We need to discover things that show the character in a new light, while at the same time not having him undergo a complete personality transplant. And the redemption needs to be believable, rooted in the story and the character. And I have to say, Hawthorne really nails it completely here with Rhys. This book, and this series, has one of the best redemption journeys I have ever read and I absolutely loved this story.
Read Jay’s review in its entirety here.
February 28, 2022
3,5 stars
I will start by saying that I haven't read the previous books in the series.
However, I can definitely see Rhys St. Germain being the villain in the previous novels.
His redemption story is so satisfying and totally deserving. His character arc is so well executed and I totally enjoyed the book.
With that said, there is just one thing that held me back from rating it more than 3,5 stars. The relationship with Beckett felt a bit forced. I totally get the insta-lust part, because duh!, but Beckett immediately understanding Rhys' real self and thoughts felt a bit unrealistic.
Don't get me wrong, I'm totally on board with this immediate connection between 2 characters, I just felt that something was missing.
Beckett is undeniably the best and what Rhys needs. I just need a bit more context before the couple says their I love yous.
Thank you @gayromancereviews for the copy!
I will start by saying that I haven't read the previous books in the series.
However, I can definitely see Rhys St. Germain being the villain in the previous novels.
His redemption story is so satisfying and totally deserving. His character arc is so well executed and I totally enjoyed the book.
With that said, there is just one thing that held me back from rating it more than 3,5 stars. The relationship with Beckett felt a bit forced. I totally get the insta-lust part, because duh!, but Beckett immediately understanding Rhys' real self and thoughts felt a bit unrealistic.
Don't get me wrong, I'm totally on board with this immediate connection between 2 characters, I just felt that something was missing.
Beckett is undeniably the best and what Rhys needs. I just need a bit more context before the couple says their I love yous.
Thank you @gayromancereviews for the copy!
March 5, 2022
I found this author 2 days ago. I binged all 3 books in this series in 2 days!
I could NOT put them down. I wasn’t sure how she was going to make me like Rhys, he was such a PRICK! The fact that I fell in love with him, could understand exactly why he was the way he was, could empathize and sympathize with him shows you what an amazing author Kate is.
I look forward to reading everything she has to offer!
I could NOT put them down. I wasn’t sure how she was going to make me like Rhys, he was such a PRICK! The fact that I fell in love with him, could understand exactly why he was the way he was, could empathize and sympathize with him shows you what an amazing author Kate is.
I look forward to reading everything she has to offer!
March 2, 2022
Absolutely amazing redemption story! A story that tugs on your heartstrings something fierce. Rhys is just the most fascinating character. I loved him so much! He was already plenty of intriguing in the previous book, and learning more about him and seeing his softer side was just incredible. I love the juxtaposition of his outwardly cold and arrogant demeanor and his hidden insecurities and desire for love. I was so charmed by Rhys and Beckett’s dynamic and their unique courtship, so to speak. Beckett’s a really special guy and easy to love. There’s a big dark cloud, seemingly inescapable, that looms over their future, and things get really tense and heartbreaking when Rhys seems to have run out of options to secure their happiness. What a rollercoaster of emotions, this story! One of the things that also really touched me and this an even more engrossing read were the storylines revolving around the secondary characters—everything comes together in the best way.
May 25, 2025
Rhys doesn't know what he wants anymore, but he knows he wants to be in Myers Bluff and he wants to make things right with his brother, and maybe his ex-boyfriend too. The only problem is... he doesn't know how to do any of that. Beckett has a bad job and big dreams, and he's not going to let either of those things hold him back. He definitely doesn't have time to deal with a man like Rhys St. George, but there's something magnetic about the way too-rich-for-his-own-good man that Beckett can't deny. Rhys is used to buying whatever he wants but finds Beckett cannot be bought. For the first time in his life, Rhys isn't two steps ahead: he's half a pace behind. But maybe that's exactly where he needs to be to find what he's always been looking for--a purpose, personal redemption, and love.
Rhys St. George knows he has made lots of mistakes in his life. His overbearing and cruel father demands nothing but obedience and, as the oldest son, Rhys has always borne the brunt of his attention. Rhys learned at his father’s side to always be in control, to stay steps ahead of everyone else, and to make sure to manage every situation to his advantage. Which also means Rhys isn’t always the easiest man to deal with and he is used to getting what he wants. What most people don’t realize, however, is that one of the things Rhys wants most of all is for his younger brother to live a happy life free from their father’s overbearing presence. That means Rhys has made plenty of hidden sacrifices to appease his father, so he stays focused on Rhys and out of Sebastian’s life. Now, however, Rhys is tired of having his life controlled by his father and has moved to Myers Bluff where Sebastian lives. Rhys wants things to change, but he has no idea how to even begin.
Beckett Thatcher is a waiter that is struggling just to make ends meet. His lack of money has caused him to put aside the dream of opening a restaurant of his own. When Rhys dines at one of Beckett’s tables one day, Beckett can’t help but notice the handsome, and powerful man...and even more so when Rhys leaves Beckett a thousand-dollar tip. When Rhys returns and asks Beckett out for lunch, Beckett knows he is out of his element. Rhys lives in a rarified world where money is so plentiful as to be almost meaningless, and Beckett feels like he is so out of place in Rhys’ life. It is clear Rhys is used to getting what he wants, when he wants it, and Beckett is certain that he isn’t going to be another person to do Rhys’ bidding...but he also finds that Rhys is surprisingly willing to adapt and compromise where he is concerned.
The two men should never work together, yet somehow, they do. When Beckett begins to know Rhys better, he learns more about the family drama, Rhy's traumatic past with an ex-boyfriend, and the control his father still exerts over him. But what he does know is that Rhys is sweet and loving to him and he is opening his heart up to Beckett in way he never expected. Rhys finds himself off balance when it comes to Beckett. Beckett wants nothing from Rhys except his love...something so different than he got from past partners who only see the dollar signs. The men are falling hard for one another, and they are beginning to dream of a future together. Of course, Rhys’ father is not willing to let his son go. He is rich, powerful, and determined to see Rhys back by his side whatever the cost.
This is the third book in what I think is a trilogy and we have been led to hate Rhy from book 1...so it is hard to think of him as someone we should forgive and love now. Discovering new things about him soon showed him in a new light, while he also had what seemed like a complete "personality transplant". I have to say, Hawthorne really accomplishes her goal here with Rhys. This book, and this series, has one of the best redemptions journeys I have ever read, and I absolutely loved this story. There are some really sweet and completely believable moments in their relationship, a relationship that should have never worked
This is without a doubt, my favorite book of the three, and perhaps my favorite Kate Hawthorne series. The three books need to be read in order to understand it all. You will enjoy following the journey of this family and friends that find love and connection in so many unexpected ways.
Rhys St. George knows he has made lots of mistakes in his life. His overbearing and cruel father demands nothing but obedience and, as the oldest son, Rhys has always borne the brunt of his attention. Rhys learned at his father’s side to always be in control, to stay steps ahead of everyone else, and to make sure to manage every situation to his advantage. Which also means Rhys isn’t always the easiest man to deal with and he is used to getting what he wants. What most people don’t realize, however, is that one of the things Rhys wants most of all is for his younger brother to live a happy life free from their father’s overbearing presence. That means Rhys has made plenty of hidden sacrifices to appease his father, so he stays focused on Rhys and out of Sebastian’s life. Now, however, Rhys is tired of having his life controlled by his father and has moved to Myers Bluff where Sebastian lives. Rhys wants things to change, but he has no idea how to even begin.
Beckett Thatcher is a waiter that is struggling just to make ends meet. His lack of money has caused him to put aside the dream of opening a restaurant of his own. When Rhys dines at one of Beckett’s tables one day, Beckett can’t help but notice the handsome, and powerful man...and even more so when Rhys leaves Beckett a thousand-dollar tip. When Rhys returns and asks Beckett out for lunch, Beckett knows he is out of his element. Rhys lives in a rarified world where money is so plentiful as to be almost meaningless, and Beckett feels like he is so out of place in Rhys’ life. It is clear Rhys is used to getting what he wants, when he wants it, and Beckett is certain that he isn’t going to be another person to do Rhys’ bidding...but he also finds that Rhys is surprisingly willing to adapt and compromise where he is concerned.
The two men should never work together, yet somehow, they do. When Beckett begins to know Rhys better, he learns more about the family drama, Rhy's traumatic past with an ex-boyfriend, and the control his father still exerts over him. But what he does know is that Rhys is sweet and loving to him and he is opening his heart up to Beckett in way he never expected. Rhys finds himself off balance when it comes to Beckett. Beckett wants nothing from Rhys except his love...something so different than he got from past partners who only see the dollar signs. The men are falling hard for one another, and they are beginning to dream of a future together. Of course, Rhys’ father is not willing to let his son go. He is rich, powerful, and determined to see Rhys back by his side whatever the cost.
This is the third book in what I think is a trilogy and we have been led to hate Rhy from book 1...so it is hard to think of him as someone we should forgive and love now. Discovering new things about him soon showed him in a new light, while he also had what seemed like a complete "personality transplant". I have to say, Hawthorne really accomplishes her goal here with Rhys. This book, and this series, has one of the best redemptions journeys I have ever read, and I absolutely loved this story. There are some really sweet and completely believable moments in their relationship, a relationship that should have never worked
This is without a doubt, my favorite book of the three, and perhaps my favorite Kate Hawthorne series. The three books need to be read in order to understand it all. You will enjoy following the journey of this family and friends that find love and connection in so many unexpected ways.
February 1, 2022
4.5 stars
Disclaimer: I received an electronic ARC of this novel from the author.
Though I enjoy both plot- and character-driven fiction, one of my favorite elements of storytelling, no matter the genre, is that every character is the hero of their own story. I also love a good redemption arc, which is a lot easier to pull off realistically in contemporary romance than speculative fiction for a villain in a previous series installment—especially a character as close to the previous heroes as a heartbreak and an older brother.
So, Rhys’ story is not going to work for everyone. Hawthorne doesn’t waste a lot of time on the background of why Rhys finally decides to break away from his father; instead, readers should take it as a given that the events of previous books have ultimately been the tipping point in his life. That certainly doesn’t erase all sins, and it’s obvious from this book’s opening that Rhys still has a lot of work to do (and it’s not all the fault of a certain copper sink). Luckily, Remington has been a good influence on Sebastian, and Sebastian is not willing to give up on his older brother. This continued connection leads Rhys on a collision course with Beckett, who is pretty much his polar opposite. This book is not an “opposites attract” story, however. I thoroughly enjoyed the push and pull of both men forcing each other to meet in the middle of their dating and relationship comfort zones.
My major quibble about this book is that we never actually see Rhys’ point of view when it comes to when he notices Beckett and decides to pursue him. That pursual is obvious from Beckett’s perspective, as the initial events that bring them together all happen during his point of view chapters. The chemistry is there once they get closer, but I wish I’d had more of that context to ease the romantic arc away from the “insta-love” it otherwise smacks of.
I loved that the external plot coincides with the final extradition of Rhys from the St. George legacy. I also appreciated that elements of it included giving Rhys and Callahan the same goals. This story doesn’t end with the two of them forgiving all and becoming besties—instead, their “reconciliation” is much more realistic. Along those same lines, Beckett’s own redemption arc doesn’t get tied in a pretty bow either. Hawthorne excels in crafting real characters in real scenarios and packing their stories with real emotion. Her books are not always easy reads, but they are always worth it.
Disclaimer: I received an electronic ARC of this novel from the author.
Though I enjoy both plot- and character-driven fiction, one of my favorite elements of storytelling, no matter the genre, is that every character is the hero of their own story. I also love a good redemption arc, which is a lot easier to pull off realistically in contemporary romance than speculative fiction for a villain in a previous series installment—especially a character as close to the previous heroes as a heartbreak and an older brother.
So, Rhys’ story is not going to work for everyone. Hawthorne doesn’t waste a lot of time on the background of why Rhys finally decides to break away from his father; instead, readers should take it as a given that the events of previous books have ultimately been the tipping point in his life. That certainly doesn’t erase all sins, and it’s obvious from this book’s opening that Rhys still has a lot of work to do (and it’s not all the fault of a certain copper sink). Luckily, Remington has been a good influence on Sebastian, and Sebastian is not willing to give up on his older brother. This continued connection leads Rhys on a collision course with Beckett, who is pretty much his polar opposite. This book is not an “opposites attract” story, however. I thoroughly enjoyed the push and pull of both men forcing each other to meet in the middle of their dating and relationship comfort zones.
My major quibble about this book is that we never actually see Rhys’ point of view when it comes to when he notices Beckett and decides to pursue him. That pursual is obvious from Beckett’s perspective, as the initial events that bring them together all happen during his point of view chapters. The chemistry is there once they get closer, but I wish I’d had more of that context to ease the romantic arc away from the “insta-love” it otherwise smacks of.
I loved that the external plot coincides with the final extradition of Rhys from the St. George legacy. I also appreciated that elements of it included giving Rhys and Callahan the same goals. This story doesn’t end with the two of them forgiving all and becoming besties—instead, their “reconciliation” is much more realistic. Along those same lines, Beckett’s own redemption arc doesn’t get tied in a pretty bow either. Hawthorne excels in crafting real characters in real scenarios and packing their stories with real emotion. Her books are not always easy reads, but they are always worth it.
January 24, 2022
As a matter of fact, Rhys St. George isn't the villain after all
Before reading this book, I was the last person who would have tried to argue that Rhys St. George had a heart, but this story changed everything for me. Instead of the cold, selfish man I'd witnessed from other characters' point of views, I got to see a much more raw, unfiltered version of Rhys. This Rhys still had to live with the crappy things he'd said and done in the past, but was seeking something different from life instead of forcing himself into the box his father had built for him. I got to watch him step out of his comfort zone, try to date someone without using his money and influence as a shield to be more attractive, and fall unconditionally head over heels in love. Rhys still had all the rough edges and ingrained habits of someone forced to shield his emotions for all his life, but also the quiet desire to be more than the loneliest, most unhappy version of himself. Beckett didn't need or want Rhys's money, and that's part of what made him exactly who Rhys needed in his life. Their initial few dates were super awkward as they tried to figure out how to mesh their wildly different lifestyles, but not once did I question whether their feelings were real. Their chemistry was undeniably scorching, their quiet moments and conversations heartfelt, and despite all the reasons they had to walk away from each other, they didn't. To say that Rhys was all-in on Beckett feels like a laughable understatement, and though Beckett was understandably more cautious, I could sense the depth of his feelings as well. Not even Rhys's father's machinations could make me seriously concerned for their happily-ever-after, because if there's one thing I knew I could trust, it's that Rhys would fight tooth and nail for the ones he loved.
**I voluntarily read an ARC of this book. This review expresses my honest thoughts and opinions.
Before reading this book, I was the last person who would have tried to argue that Rhys St. George had a heart, but this story changed everything for me. Instead of the cold, selfish man I'd witnessed from other characters' point of views, I got to see a much more raw, unfiltered version of Rhys. This Rhys still had to live with the crappy things he'd said and done in the past, but was seeking something different from life instead of forcing himself into the box his father had built for him. I got to watch him step out of his comfort zone, try to date someone without using his money and influence as a shield to be more attractive, and fall unconditionally head over heels in love. Rhys still had all the rough edges and ingrained habits of someone forced to shield his emotions for all his life, but also the quiet desire to be more than the loneliest, most unhappy version of himself. Beckett didn't need or want Rhys's money, and that's part of what made him exactly who Rhys needed in his life. Their initial few dates were super awkward as they tried to figure out how to mesh their wildly different lifestyles, but not once did I question whether their feelings were real. Their chemistry was undeniably scorching, their quiet moments and conversations heartfelt, and despite all the reasons they had to walk away from each other, they didn't. To say that Rhys was all-in on Beckett feels like a laughable understatement, and though Beckett was understandably more cautious, I could sense the depth of his feelings as well. Not even Rhys's father's machinations could make me seriously concerned for their happily-ever-after, because if there's one thing I knew I could trust, it's that Rhys would fight tooth and nail for the ones he loved.
**I voluntarily read an ARC of this book. This review expresses my honest thoughts and opinions.
March 1, 2023
Out of all three books, I liked this one the best. Rhys and Beckett were a little more fleshed-out than some of the other MCs. Plot: Rhys, the first born son and heir to his family's empire, has always seemed like a villain, but is he really? Beckett is a struggle waiter who dreams of opening his own restaurant. When the two meet over a super-awkward brunch one day, sparks fly. The struggles are what you expect--tension with exes, they come from different worlds, family obligations, etc.
All of my prior criticism about the other books in this series still apply here, but to a lesser extent. Again, I struggled with the whole "family expectations" sub-plot because those expectations are never really explained or shown through interactions/dialogue. It's more "I'm being crushed by the weight of these.....unspecified expectations." Still bugs me. Same goes for the Rhys as villain plot. We know what he did to his ex, Callahan, but other than that we don't get much. Rhys is supposedly some super-cold, super-manipulative guy, but just like with the family stuff, we are asked to mostly take that on faith, i.e., every character saying so without us ever really seeing it.
I don't know, for whatever reason I just couldn't connect with these books, even this one. Do people really have such super-awkward brunches? Do they really talk to one another in this really cryptic, snark-speak? None of it felt true to me, so while I liked this book, I didn't love and I didn't love the series.
All of my prior criticism about the other books in this series still apply here, but to a lesser extent. Again, I struggled with the whole "family expectations" sub-plot because those expectations are never really explained or shown through interactions/dialogue. It's more "I'm being crushed by the weight of these.....unspecified expectations." Still bugs me. Same goes for the Rhys as villain plot. We know what he did to his ex, Callahan, but other than that we don't get much. Rhys is supposedly some super-cold, super-manipulative guy, but just like with the family stuff, we are asked to mostly take that on faith, i.e., every character saying so without us ever really seeing it.
I don't know, for whatever reason I just couldn't connect with these books, even this one. Do people really have such super-awkward brunches? Do they really talk to one another in this really cryptic, snark-speak? None of it felt true to me, so while I liked this book, I didn't love and I didn't love the series.
June 16, 2022
just no
This is the third book in a series and this guy is the villain of the other two books. I just don’t buy it. Why rehabilitate him now?
It was super sappy many times, to the point of being annoying. Also it seems like just a vehicle to write sex scenes. Sex scenes are fine but this is a romance? There’s supposed to be more to it.
The big drama is the dad is a primo jerk and he caused Rhys to be the way he is in order to protect the brother Sebastian. Sebastian’s book I couldn’t even get through. Anyway, the big takedown of the evil dad read like an afterthought. Like the author got tired of that bit and just sorta blew it off. Then everything after was the two guys have the greatest relationship ever and lots of sex. The poor guy wasn’t believable because I think the author doesn’t really believe that someone could not want his money or all the things it could provide. So the poor guy, Beckett, just ended up taking everything the other dude wanted to give. But there was a tiny resistance, like he could buy him his own restaurant to run but had to say it was a loan. Or buy a beach house to live in but had to say please do it for me. 🙄
And what’s up with Beckett finally getting a tan after four days in Italy? And highlights in his hair? They live in a frickin beach house in California! Does Beckett not go outside at home??
This is the third book in a series and this guy is the villain of the other two books. I just don’t buy it. Why rehabilitate him now?
It was super sappy many times, to the point of being annoying. Also it seems like just a vehicle to write sex scenes. Sex scenes are fine but this is a romance? There’s supposed to be more to it.
The big drama is the dad is a primo jerk and he caused Rhys to be the way he is in order to protect the brother Sebastian. Sebastian’s book I couldn’t even get through. Anyway, the big takedown of the evil dad read like an afterthought. Like the author got tired of that bit and just sorta blew it off. Then everything after was the two guys have the greatest relationship ever and lots of sex. The poor guy wasn’t believable because I think the author doesn’t really believe that someone could not want his money or all the things it could provide. So the poor guy, Beckett, just ended up taking everything the other dude wanted to give. But there was a tiny resistance, like he could buy him his own restaurant to run but had to say it was a loan. Or buy a beach house to live in but had to say please do it for me. 🙄
And what’s up with Beckett finally getting a tan after four days in Italy? And highlights in his hair? They live in a frickin beach house in California! Does Beckett not go outside at home??
February 25, 2022
A Matter of Fact by Kate Hawthorne is book 3 in her Two Truths and a Lie series. I will admit that I have not read the previous 2 and will definitely go back and read these as soon as I can. I really enjoyed this book, but may have understood some of the references better if I had read the previous two stories. Fact is the story of Rhys, a wealthy young man who’s parental expectations weigh heavily on his shoulders. He’s had to give up so much of himself to try to keep those he loves safe, without them knowing about it. This leads to fractured relationships with those who mean the most to him. He meets Beckett, a man making his own way through life and is instantly pulling into this orbit. Beckett is the person that makes him want to break all of his chains and become the person he wants to be, and most likely is down deep. He wants to right the past wrongs, but sometimes you have to take 2 steps back before you can move forward. Kate Hawthorne’s writing style is so emotional and touching. She brings a connection between her characters that you don’t often see. I always enjoy the characters and tales of love that she brings us and can’t wait to read more.
January 28, 2022
She did it! She really did. KH went and made me fall in love with Rhys St. George when all I really wanted to do was hate him for how cruel and awful he was to Callahan and Jace.
This is definitely not a standalone read. To understand Rhys, you need to read the first two books because then you’ll understand why I disliked him so much. However, as we all know, most villains have a back story that made them this way and throughout this book, my heart hurt over and over again for Rhys.
I loved Beckett so much too! He and Rhys are total opposites in every way and yet their chemistry is off the charts! He saw Rhys like no one ever had before and Rhys let himself be seen by him. Their quiet conversations and determination to compromise for the other was what made this story. I loved how seeing his brother happy opened up Rhys’s heart and control and allowed him to love Beckett so strongly and with so much passion.
There really isn’t enough words to say how much I love Rhys and when he calls Beckett “Darling”, I swoon right along with Beckett!!
This is definitely not a standalone read. To understand Rhys, you need to read the first two books because then you’ll understand why I disliked him so much. However, as we all know, most villains have a back story that made them this way and throughout this book, my heart hurt over and over again for Rhys.
I loved Beckett so much too! He and Rhys are total opposites in every way and yet their chemistry is off the charts! He saw Rhys like no one ever had before and Rhys let himself be seen by him. Their quiet conversations and determination to compromise for the other was what made this story. I loved how seeing his brother happy opened up Rhys’s heart and control and allowed him to love Beckett so strongly and with so much passion.
There really isn’t enough words to say how much I love Rhys and when he calls Beckett “Darling”, I swoon right along with Beckett!!
January 29, 2022
I love a good redemption story. Rhys St George was enemy number one in A Real Good Lie. I knew there had to be more there than meets the eye but he was going to have to prove himself. He has always been the first son, the good son, the one that did what father wanted and sacrificed his own happiness to keep the wolves away from everyone else. Now he has to figure out who the real Rhys is and what he actually wants. It definitely isn’t easy. I love how Beckett tries to get Rhys to do things without throwing his money around. Beckett figures the other man out pretty quickly, in spite of Rhys himself. He sees something there worth fighting for. Now Sebastian and Beckett just have to convince him of that. I also really appreciated the whole scene with Callahan and Rhys. They may never be close again but their confrontation in the first book is a part of the catalyst to them both becoming better people by the end of this one. Like I said, I enjoy a good redemption story and this book definitely qualifies.
February 28, 2022
I love a good redemption story so it's safe to say I've been waiting for Rhys's story since his despicable behaviour in A Real Good Lie.
I absolutely adored this. Rhys is so isolated, so used to making hard decisions and pushing people away, not really sure who he is without his money and power; Beckett is so sure of himself and his place in the world. Rhys is obscenely rich; Beckett is struggling to make rent. Rhys is an astute business man with a high IQ; Beckett is a student of human nature with an eye for narrowing in on a person's true character.
They work beautifully together, and although at one point I was starting to get anxious, the tension is so well balanced that I never tipped over the edge into panic mode.
A Matter of Fact is high heat, dual third person POV. You could read it as a standalone but you'll get much more out of the story if you read the first two books, as Rhys is a major side character in both A Real Good Lie and A Cold Hard Truth.
I received a copy of this book from the author and I have chosen to leave an honest review.
I absolutely adored this. Rhys is so isolated, so used to making hard decisions and pushing people away, not really sure who he is without his money and power; Beckett is so sure of himself and his place in the world. Rhys is obscenely rich; Beckett is struggling to make rent. Rhys is an astute business man with a high IQ; Beckett is a student of human nature with an eye for narrowing in on a person's true character.
They work beautifully together, and although at one point I was starting to get anxious, the tension is so well balanced that I never tipped over the edge into panic mode.
A Matter of Fact is high heat, dual third person POV. You could read it as a standalone but you'll get much more out of the story if you read the first two books, as Rhys is a major side character in both A Real Good Lie and A Cold Hard Truth.
I received a copy of this book from the author and I have chosen to leave an honest review.
March 1, 2022
A Matter of Fact is my favorite book in the Two Truths and a Lie series. Rhys is the villain in the first two books, so I was invested in his story from the beginning of the novel. He’s done some pretty terrible things over the course of his life, but most of it was his misguided attempt to protect his brother from their controlling and homophobic father. He doesn’t feel worthy of love and isn’t looking for a relationship with a man when he meets Beckett, a waiter who’s struggling to make enough money to buy groceries and pay rent. Beckett isn’t interested in Rhys’s money or power, which is unsettling to Rhys. I love that Beckett expects real effort and honesty from Rhys and doesn’t let him hide behind his wealth. They have amazing chemistry together, and it’s rewarding to see Rhys stand up to his father and choose his own happiness with Beckett. I wish Beckett was better developed as a character. We learn a little about his family dynamic, but it feels like an afterthought. Overall, it was a really satisfying read.
February 8, 2022
Outstanding read! Rhys is rich and drowning. He wants to be in Myers Bluff, wants to be close to his brother but his father is demanding that he come home. Beckett is poor but doesn’t believe that money makes you happy. He is the total opposite of Rhys. Rhys learns that he cannot buy Beckett anything he wants. Beckett challenges him in so many ways. Their connection was fire, their chemistry off the charts, hot and steamy! I loved how the author wove all the characters, Remington and Sebastian and Callahan and Jace throughout the story. Loved, loved, loved, Rhys and Beckett so much!! Rhys was such a complex character, so prickly! My only wish was to read something more happening to Marcus St George! That man was a piece of crap! Overall, this was a really phenomenal story, really well written, highly recommend. I’m voluntarily reviewing from an advanced copy that I received. My reviews are solely based on my thoughts and opinions.
February 9, 2022
I have been itching for Rhys’s book ever since he was introduced in A Real Good Lie - I love a good redemption story and this was fantastic. We all saw how Rhys could be manipulative, hurtful, seemingly uncaring but I knew there had to be more to him and boy was there. I can’t remember the last time I teared up so early in a book. So get the tissues ready folks - Rhys’s journey to accepting he is worth more than his money is pretty heavy. This isn’t all angsty though and we have Beckett to thank for that. He brings a lot of lightheartedness to Rhys’s life and by not being concerned with money or status, he shows Rhys that he can be loved with no strings attached. We also see Rhys atone for the way he acted in the previous books - there’s no glossing over the fact he was pretty cruel and needed to apologize for his actions. And when he does, the outcome is realistic. With confronting his past and now with Beckett as his future, he could finally be the real Rhys.
February 23, 2022
A story with a lot of emotion, heat and romance.
Rhys has spent his entire life under his father’s control. As much as he hates all he’s done and sacrificed to be the perfect heir, he grows more resentful and lonely by the day. During an unfortunately bad brunch with his brother, he meets Beckett. Beckett is his waiter and Rhys is instantly attracted. Beckett isn’t at all like Rhys, he walks to his waiter job because he can’t afford gas, lives in a tiny apartment and lives off vegetables and ramen. It’s not the life he wants, but he’s surviving. Rhys and Beckett have to learn how to make their differences work, and find ways to meet each other halfway. Rhys also has to decide what he wants in life: his family legacy or the wonderful man who doesn’t want his money, as he can’t have both. It was lovely to see Rhys learning how to soften and find his way, and I loved how Beckett didn’t let him get away with anything! A beautiful balance of love and respect.
Rhys has spent his entire life under his father’s control. As much as he hates all he’s done and sacrificed to be the perfect heir, he grows more resentful and lonely by the day. During an unfortunately bad brunch with his brother, he meets Beckett. Beckett is his waiter and Rhys is instantly attracted. Beckett isn’t at all like Rhys, he walks to his waiter job because he can’t afford gas, lives in a tiny apartment and lives off vegetables and ramen. It’s not the life he wants, but he’s surviving. Rhys and Beckett have to learn how to make their differences work, and find ways to meet each other halfway. Rhys also has to decide what he wants in life: his family legacy or the wonderful man who doesn’t want his money, as he can’t have both. It was lovely to see Rhys learning how to soften and find his way, and I loved how Beckett didn’t let him get away with anything! A beautiful balance of love and respect.
March 4, 2022
A look behind the curtain. Rhys was not a likeable charater in the previous two stories. As a reader it was hard to embrace his 'human' side. However, everyone needs to grow up sometime. Beckett, is a self assurred independent man. He is in dire straights financially and drowning. Rhys, carries a heavy load of baggage behind him. It helps learning his motivation and his regrets. He built a lot of bridges over his life. He is basically living a "This is your Life" moment and not liking what he is learning with a clear head. Beckett and Rhys were opposite in nature and circumstances. They were what each needed at that time in their lives. Will they each bend to accomodate new circumstances? Can they open their hearts and minds? Will Rhys be able to repair his relationships? Excellent process of inventorying their lives. In this story, Rhys is very likeable. Very nice story. Well done! I received an ARC and am voluntarily leaving a review.
March 3, 2022
Wanting to be closer to his brother and try to make amends, Rhys finds himself on a new path.
Away from his manipulative father, Rhys meets Beckett whose beliefs are totally different from his own.
With a fiery chemistry between them, they begin to explore what can be even though they come from different walks of life.
This being the third book in the series, it’s definitely best read in order, to enjoy the redemption of Rhys as we get to see the real Rhys come through this story as he grows as a characters throughout the plot.
Beckett was someone who grounded him and not easily impressed with wealth thus enabling their relationship to flourish and grow in its own unique way as they overcame obstacles to achieve their happiness.
I liked seeing the past characters woven into this story as well. Definitely a recommended read.
Away from his manipulative father, Rhys meets Beckett whose beliefs are totally different from his own.
With a fiery chemistry between them, they begin to explore what can be even though they come from different walks of life.
This being the third book in the series, it’s definitely best read in order, to enjoy the redemption of Rhys as we get to see the real Rhys come through this story as he grows as a characters throughout the plot.
Beckett was someone who grounded him and not easily impressed with wealth thus enabling their relationship to flourish and grow in its own unique way as they overcame obstacles to achieve their happiness.
I liked seeing the past characters woven into this story as well. Definitely a recommended read.
March 4, 2022
Such a lovely read. An entertaining, sweet tale of love. Deserving of a lot more stars than i can give it. A classic tale of class distinction. A story of the power that the wealthy can yield to get what they want. The power to bend people to their will. Very wealthy Rhys has grown tired of the pressures of living a wealthy life. He desires to get away from it all. He meets Beckett who is from the opposite end of the money spectrum. There is an instant attraction between the two men. Rhys wants to possess Beckett. He wants to wine and dine Beckett. Buy him gifts. What Rhys discovers is that Beckett can't be bought with money. Rhys has to come up different ways if he wants to romance Beckett. Can the two get over their issues and become more? The book is full of surprises and secrets. I highly recommend.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 73 reviews