And onto the next one, as I’m continuing my review of HORROR LIBRARY anthologies! Really loving these anthologies, and I’m a big fan of anthos in general, but especially indie horror. Stories in these books take chances. Some fail, some succeed, but it’s exciting to read new ideas and voices. Publisher Dark Moon Books has taken over the HORROR LIBRARY series and re-released the older volumes that were put together by former publishers and editors (Cutting Block Books and Cavender). All of these were original stories of their time, written exclusively for this book. I received an ARC of the new re-released 2021 edition from Dark Moon Books.
Quick star rating on each story included in Volume #4 (29 total), just as my personal preference:
"Into the After" by Kurt Dinan = 5 stars. Setup felt slow, but man, that turned around! This story was stark, and had a punch. Resonant. Honest. Great beginning to the anthology!
"Ash Wednesday" by Lorne Dixon = 5 stars. Incredible setup: Even violent serial killers in prison must be rescued by emergency services during a massive inferno, but that’s just the start…
"Ghosts Under Glass" by Tracie Mcbride = 3-1/2 stars. Part of me just didn’t like this story, but it was a good idea. The characters didn’t win me over, but the ending was great.
"The Dreamcatcher" by Nate Kenyon = 3 stars. Another one that was fine, just not my cup of tea.
"Jammers" by Bentley Little = 5 stars. Absolutely a winner. Great idea from a horror master, what “really” causes traffic jams every day on the freeways.
"Sporting the Waters of the Bermuda Triangle" by Greggard Penance = 2 stories. Nice idea, but kind of “off”. Weird, and not in a good way.
"To Judge the Quick" by Hank Schwaeble = 5 stars. Excellent Western short story. Racial strife, and injustice, and a certain curse brought by a strange woman…
"Driving Deep Into the Night" by Harrison Howe = 5 stars. I didn’t think I was going to like this one at first, but it really got under my skin. Dark, very dark.
"In the Red" by Charles Colyott = 4-1/2 stars. Another one I didn’t think I was going to like at first, but it won me over by the end.
"Skin" by Kim Despins = 2 stars. Hated this… triggering and uncomfortable, for rape and incest. It’s a noteworthy subject the author wrote on, but just cringeworthy.
"Drain Bamage" by Jeff Strand = 4 stars. Love this author, but the story was just okay. It was funny, as is all of Jeff Strand’s work.
"Guardians" by Tom Brennan = 5 stars. A stand-out story. Modern military meets a valley of succubi witches. Horrifying and outstanding, both.
"God’s Work" by Matthew Lee Bain = 2-1/2 stars. The writing was fine, but admittedly, I just didn’t get it.
"Sleepless Eyes" by Tim Waggoner = 2-1/2 stars. Gross, but that was the point of the story. A lot of setup for a punchline. But a good punchline, to be fair.
"Flicker" by Lee Thomas = 5 stories. This story ended up on a surprisingly positive note, after I feared it was leading down a path of rape and torture… that was the guise though, all along, to a deeper level.
"The Fishing of Dahlia" by Ennis Drake = 2 stars. Kind of long-winded. Good character study, but just abruptly ended after 95% build-up.
"What Was Once Man" by Michele Lee = 2 stars. I don’t know that I entirely understood this one… it seemed meaningful. Rebel Without a Cause-type of character relationships, but trapped in a basement… was there an apocalypse outside?
"Mourning With the Bones of the Dead" by Gerard Houarner = Another one, just not my cup of tea. Muddled story, dull, maybe I misunderstood it?
"Final Draft" by Mark W. Worthen = 5 stars. A lot went on in this story, lovely, rich writing covering a lifetime, and a wartime guardian angel.
"I Am Vision, I Am Death" by Erik Williams = 5 stars. Very haunting Christopher Nolan- “noir” vibe. Good all around.
"Santa Maria" by Jeff Cercone = 5 stars. A lot happened in this story, and it’s “playful” while also very, very dark and traumatic. The ending’s “Epilogue” is fantastic.
"The Healing Hands of Reverend Wainwright" by Geoffrey L. Mudge = 5 stars. Great writing, great story. Horror, just horror of multiple ways. Murder, monsters, and martyred children.
"Continuity" by Lorne Dixon = 4 stars. Author has TWO stories in this book! This one “less” good than the first, but definitely strong on its own merits. Haunting.
"Testaville, Ohio" by M. Alan Ford = 5 stars. This could be made into a movie. Terrifying, and an analogy to many social ills. Great arc, heartwarming ending (in the ways of horror stories).
"Stone" by Catherine Macleod = 3 stars. Okay story. Felt kind of flat and forced, and didn’t go anywhere. But good writing.
"Campbell’s Pond" by Brian Knight = 5 stars. Sort of a zombie story, more of a troubled kid story, who vaguely has “less bad” things happen to him than the alternative. Personally, I related.
"All Dead" by JG Faherty = 4 stars. I didn’t get where this story was going until the ending’s twist. OMG, truly horrifying, traumatic, a lot else.
"Exegesis of the Insecta Apocrypha" by Colleen Anderson = 2 stars. Cool concept, but the execution was dry. Just didn’t gel on this story.
It’s hard to say, which volume is the best in the series so far, but from volumes 1- 4, this one #4, and the previous, Vol. #3 are tied as my favorites. Great ideas and great writing all around!