Inori’s first big competition is upon her, pitting her against her former friend, the prickly Mittens. Tsukasa, meanwhile, is still feeling his way around coaching, but he’ll soon learn the most important lesson of all - don’t meet your heroes.
Medalist, Vol.2 has all the joy and thrill of the first volume, which is a big compliment since the first volume was pretty much perfect. Your competitive underdog with a chance, the coach trying to figure himself out, even some solid life lessons for the family. While there may be nothing new here, it’s told so well that it doesn’t matter.
Inori’s sister isn’t dead, she’s just been in Canada (no jokes, thank you), so her return/appearance was a nice reveal that we won’t be heading down the ‘dead sister’s dreams’ pathway with the story. Given the amount of doting she does, it is a little surprising we didn’t hear more about her in the first volume, honestly.
Instead we get a lot of focus on how her sister’s skating career fuelled Inori’s desire to try the sport and subsequent love for it. She’s one of the easiest characters to root for ever, a plucky underdog who is just giving her all to this one thing.
This first competition is a belter - it has pretty much everything you could want from a story like this and I love how they set up just enough to bring some uncertainty into Inori’s placing. Inori’s program is about as nail-biter as they could make it and wonderful to see all lovingly drawn.
Mittens gets some twists to her tale (tail?) as she recognizes when she’s being awful but can’t take it back. Her backwards-gazing focus on what she can’t do transfers to her program and illustrates a core difference between her and Inori, reflected in the match’s outcome. Bit obvious, but nicely done.
Hikaru feels like she will be the main rival for our young heroine, though they get along well and Inori really likes Hikaru (and vice-versa). The main difference between them is Hikaru’s dour trainers, one of whom happens to be the legend that Tsukasa used to look up to.
I mean, we’re clearly going for the heart versus calculated coaching methods and that’s totally fine with me. Tsukasa is the kind of coach Inori needs and their chemistry together is great - they both make one another better.
Toss in some fun new characters, great skating, coaching lessons, and an actual apology from Mom when she realizes how much she’s been crapping on Inori’s dreams for the past always (Inori standing up for her right to fail is one of the best moments in the book)? That’s a great volume of manga.
5 stars. If you take out every single thing I don’t like about figure skating, there’d be nothing left to this book. Since I am five-starring the second book in a row of this feel-good sports story, please recognize how incredibly good it is. This is a definitive sports manga in the making.