I'd rate this a 2 or 2.5 at most, ie OK, sometimes a bit better than ok. I got this on a whim and it was recommended as humour, The sad thing is I didn't really laugh once. It is lighthearted rather than funny, and not uplifting as it's about rocky relationships. I can say I'm not usually a reader of the romance genre so I might not quite get some of it. It's quite dialogue heavy and while some people mightn't like that, I didn't mind. I think the author considers that her strength.
OK, the main character is Poppy. Other important characters are best friend Lola, ex-hubby Josh, groom Will, bride Ottilie.
For me, Lola is the stand-out best character. She's no nonsense. Poppy was a darned annoying character and maybe part of the reason the story grates is because we have to see things through such a pathetic creature's eyes. Yes, I know she's going through such a tough time, but it's how someone deals with difficulty that makes you feel for them and Poppy was hopeless. Her saving grace is that she's meant to be a good photographer.
She turns up to a wedding as a photographer and it seemed like she was hardly doing any photography. She was chatting to people mostly and they had to remind her to photograph stuff. For the awesome almost-top-photographer-before-she-married, this seemed to be a huge bungle. I wanted to see Poppy had photography as part of her soul. I kept thinking, I would photograph stuff better than her. A true photographer would itch to take photos of everything, would see everything as a photo. She didn't. She didn't convince me.
The way she handled her relationship with Josh the idiot was annoying. Yes, she made an error, I can understand that. Who hasn't made errors? But her inability to set things right and take action, and her continuous excuses for herself and going on about how things are difficult for herself just made her painful. I won't go into details but she was someone you just wanted to give a giant kick up the butt. She was always moaning about how things were bad but not willing to seek change.
Will was ok but not that interesting to me; Ottilie a slightly more interesting creation but not that sympathetic.
I didn't feel much of the romance flowering between Poppy and Will, more of the feeling that this is so wrong. It was a car crash waiting to happen rather than an inevitable, unstoppable love.
The problem also was expecting humour. I'm not sure if there is a word for it, but I felt I was watching people being funny (sort of) rather than the atmosphere actually being humorous. Does that make sense? There's a lot of dialogue and from some of it, I can imagine that if you were right there and listening to it, and in the right mood, some of the things people said and did would get a chuckle but it didn't translate to outright humour on the page.Just like if you wrote down all the things that your friends say and laugh their guts out at a get together, it would just bemuse people, because your friends can say "Riiiiiight!" and it's hilarious as what goes with it is ambience, in-jokes, knowledge of relationships, mood, tone, circumstances around you, etc. But that doesn't quite work in a book.
Similarly, some books can be absolutely hilarious making pointed observations, comments, or descriptions in relation to war, death, taxes, imprisonment, illness and so on. Things that are dry and horrible and generally not considered funny but they make them funny.
Well, I thought I was reading something where it probably might have been funnier if I'd been there but just wasn't on page. Especially when people were simply trading sarcasm. There were some lines like:
"It can be a fully immersive experience for you like seeing Avatar for the first time in 3D, but with a higher chance of someone kicking you in the dick."
I felt this didn't sound like a natural way for the character to speak, it sounded more like the author trying too hard to insert a comic line and it didn't work that well for me as it felt forced. I guess I'm just not on the same page as the author in terms of humour.
The flicking back and forth in timeline wasn't really helpful in terms of story cohesion but it didn't bother me too much.
The premise isn't bad and Lola was the saving grace of the book.