This book could have been SO much better, but it did a disservice to Lizzie McDuffie. In this book, her character was two dimensional - flat and not fully developed. How many times did the author have to write that a particular topic weighed on her mind but yet, there were guests to attend to (more guests than were on the list!). So that was that - the weighty topics that the Negro community (using the terms of the day written in the book) were dealing with were left undeveloped and, instead, we were reading about housekeeping (again and again). The author wrote that she chose to insert the topic of lynching - an important civil rights issue of that time - even though there was no record of Lizzie having these conversations with FDR. But instead of using that opportunity to help the reader understand more about the politics surrounding lynching, such as delving into the arguments in Congress, the actual bills that might have been proposed, the other people fighting for or against an anti-lynching law, she left the topic with several dead-end conversations with FDR telling her "now's not the right time because I need the Southern Democrat vote". While I'm guessing that is true, the author could have dealt with this topic with better research and writing, helping us to understand the real history at this time. Instead, multiple times Lizzie contemplated the issue (lots of her thinking about this topic), deciding to talk to FDR, having the conversation, getting rebuffed and then resolving that she wouldn't give up. A little way further in the book, the same scene would repeat itself. Again. And again.
Lizzie's thinking on a variety of topics repeated itself over and over. For example, she read letters from people asking for help and her thoughts were always the same. "I must do something, but how will I do it with so many demands at the White House? Nevertheless, I WILL find a way." While this is admirable and shows her grit and determination, when the same words are used over and over to describe the same thing, it gets to be tedious reading. Lizzie campaigned for FDR, yet all we really know was that she was nervous but determined. Then she felt good about what she did. The author repeated Lizzie's actions, resolve and satisfaction with every 4-year presidential campaign. I believe with deeper research; the author could have helped us learn far more about these campaign events than Lizzie's feelings.
I cannot recommend this book, which is sad because I think Lizzie was likely a remarkable woman in a pivotal time in our history and much could be learned about her time serving the Roosevelt's.