*ARC copy for exchange of an honest review*
This review was due in January, but I felt so bad for not being able to finish Cloaked Shadows that I kept postponing writing this review; in hopes that I'd still fall in love with Melissa's work. Melissa is such a kind soul, so warm and welcoming, and I absolutely adored the time we all spent group reviewing Cloaked Shadows on Facebook. She is an absolute sweetheart and I wish her all the best with this series, future works, and her personal life!
Anyway, this isn't about Melissa as a person but Cloaked Shadows and because this is an honest and personal review, it might not resonate with everybody. That's fine. Please do not take offense.
In the beginning, I have to clarify that I did not manage to finish this book. I started it in December, made it to page 104 this morning, and finally gave up. It is not that Ikena's story is boring, no. I loved the way Ikena cares for her family, her relationship with her siblings in particular. To avoid spoilers, I will not go into detail but the mystery surrounding her and her journey was very intriguing as well! However, for me, it did not make up for:
- regular grammatical mistakes
- lack of basic logic (e.g. you don't turn buff by exercising for one week)
- too long sentences that could easily be turned into two/three separate sentences
1. Grammatical errors could (and should) easily be fixed by having different people proofread a novel before publishing it. I'm not a native English speaker but if I noticed them, Natives probably would too. It is an unnecessary annoyance that can throw a reader off rather quickly. With a plot this good, it is very devastating to see how bad grammar can affect a reading experience.
2. If you have read Cloaked Shadows, you know that it's a fantasy novel. Therefore, logic in the sense of "but magic doesn't exist" is not what I'm referring to. What I mean with 'basic logic' is that of course you're going to smell bad if you train, sleep, and live in the same clothes for two weeks straight. So why is the character so surprised by it? They complain about being woken up early every morning, but all of a sudden they turn into early risers without any explanation. They exercise for a week and suddenly they are buff. Even in fantasy novels, you need some sort of basic logic that explains miracles and magic.
3. Long sentences are a nuisance that is easy to fix. Instead of using a comma, make a full stop and start a new sentence. That way, it is easier for the reader to follow along. It does not improve one's writing style if the sentences extend over three lines; rather, it only harms by possibly annoying the reader.
Again, this is only my personal opinion. It breaks my heart to be leaving this review when so many others love and adore Cloaked Shadows. It is Melissa's first novel, so obviously there is still room to improve, especially since she is so young. I'm honestly looking forward to her future works and anything else she might have up her sleeve!
Melissa, if you're reading this, please know that this is not intended as a personal attack. I've debated for months whether I should even post a review if most of my feedback is so.... negative. But, since you sent me your precious baby (yes, this is how I usually refer to books) as an ARC, I wanted to be completely honest.
please don't hate me