This true story all starts with a cookout. Danny Day’s buddy said that he was having a little get-together for pro-gun Christians, and that sounded right up Dan’s alley. However, when he got there, he was introduced to men who were pro-gun but definitely not pro-gun-safety, and who were “Trump Christians”, not “Jesus Christians”.
While Dan is with this group of men, talk starts to turn towards people of the Muslim faith, specifically a large Somali population in Garden City, Kansas. It is not loving talk. The Pulse nightclub shooting in Orlando had just happened, and the anti-Islamic rhetoric is in full swing. (I don’t think they cared about the gay community, they just cared that a Muslim was the shooter.)
As Dan sits through this cookout-turned-white-supremacy-meeting, he starts to realize that these people are serious about their hatred, and very serious about causing harm to the town’s Muslim population. Long story short, he becomes an informant for the FBI, and begins recording his conversations with these men.
I don’t think most people know that many small Midwestern towns have relatively large refugee populations. Garden City was once a predominantly white town, but the low cost of living and availability of jobs at meatpacking plants brought refugees and immigrants from all over. By the time Trump is starting his run for president, the town’s people of color are now the majority.
Most people are fine with this, but there is this group who have a major problem with the Somali population, and Muslims in general. They see themselves as Crusaders, on a mission for Jesus. They hype each other up, harass people of color in town, stalk the store where people shop for African merchandise and even talk freely about the desire to kill Muslim children.
For almost a year, Dan attended meetings, joined militia groups and gathered all the information he could. As long as he pretended to have the same fervent hate as everyone else, and he didn’t entrap anyone, he was golden - these are his friends. Well, they WERE his friends, until he got a good look at their hearts.
Once Trump came on the political scene, it really put this group into action … they wanted to do something big. Something to inspire others across the country. Something Trump would approve of. These men revered men like Alex Jones. They wanted a religious war, and they were going to start with bombing the two mosques and if possible, any apartment buildings in town that rent to Somalis.
They were waiting until Trump was elected so they wouldn’t hurt his chances, but they spent their time gathering munitions and learning about explosives. Soon, another FBI informant named “Brian” is brought in as the Muslim-hating explosives expert willing to trade explosives for meth. Along with Dan, they gather enough evidence to thwart this plot. They were successful, as you know if you remember this happening, and they saved hundreds of lives with their bravery and integrity.
This book goes through that first informal cookout, then through all the meetings and things that were said in them. It goes through the FBI’s entire investigation, and everything that leads up to the arrests. Then it goes through their trials and how each member of the group ended up (one was also found with child porn - the cherry on top of the pile of shit.)
It’s horrifyingly fascinating to read actual things these men talk about. I think they really did believe that they were making their country better and making God proud. You see these types at Trump rallies, you see them in YouTube videos taken by people of color being harassed, and all you can see in their eyes is anger. HATE. Rage. This book even talks about the insurrection on January 6; these were just three men taken down. How many more are there? (Turns out the “Q-Anon Shaman” wasn’t the first to blame his actions on Trump’s speeches - these guys tried that too. And also failed.)
This book is great. There is no commentary outside of the author’s opening note. These are all the actual recordings, texts, etc., that were gathered by Dan and used as evidence in court. There are also pictures of all involved, along with pictures of important locations and events.
My only complaint is that it’s very long (kind of like my review? 😬) … I don’t mind a long book, but this was wordy and some things could have been left out without changing the impact of the story. I’m giving this 4.5 stars, rounded down for that and a bit of dryness, but make no mistake - I highly recommend this true crime story as a frank and up-close look at racism in America.
(Thank you to Mariner Books, Dick Lehr and NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for my review.)