What do you think?
Rate this book
Echoes of War #1-3
Echoes of War: Books 1-3
Almost 1,500 pages of Military Science Fiction action! Corporal David Cohen thought he’d left war behind. He was wrong. The Terran Coalition faces repeated and brutal attacks from the repressive League of Sol. To defend his home planet, David trades his dream of becoming a rabbi for a battlefront in the far reaches of space. When particle beams fly, his courage under fire brings quick promotion. But in the lulls between battles when he must confront his soul, David finds a different the ghosts of those killed under his command. Yet in war, it’s kill or be killed—and the enemy shows no mercy. David must square the tenets of his faith against his responsibility to crew and country. If he fails in his command, billions face enslavement by a ruthless regime. Now it’s an all-out fight for the galaxy’s freedom. Because a man’s greatest foe lies within. If you love Babylon 5, Safehold , and Destroyermen , you must read “Echoes of War,” a military sci-fi series that will take you to the heart of duty, sacrifice, and the unseen scars of those who serve. Includes the first 3 novels in the Echoes of War
Five star reviews for Fight the Good Fight, book 1 in the
"David Weber, meet your competition ."
" Best space war book I have ever read . Action blended with religions and philosophies kept me reading well into the night.”
"This book reminds me of some of the best of the 50s military science fiction . Good characters, good story, makes me feel like I am there." “Great book strap in you are going for a ride .” “Well written, well plotted and populated with characters that jump off the page. Deserves to become a classic of the genre .”
Five star reviews for Fight the Good Fight, book 1 in the
"David Weber, meet your competition ."
" Best space war book I have ever read . Action blended with religions and philosophies kept me reading well into the night.”
"This book reminds me of some of the best of the 50s military science fiction . Good characters, good story, makes me feel like I am there." “Great book strap in you are going for a ride .” “Well written, well plotted and populated with characters that jump off the page. Deserves to become a classic of the genre .”
1224 pages, Kindle Edition
Published July 14, 2020
569 people are currently reading
134 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 51 reviews
July 22, 2020
I do not need religious indoctrination
This is a well written and well-defined scif I story. About at the 32% point of the box set, religious discussions take over the story line. While the dissertations are non sectarien , it is such a distraction than it became unenjoyable.
Sorry David, until get out from the pulpit, I will NOT follow your writtings.
This is a well written and well-defined scif I story. About at the 32% point of the box set, religious discussions take over the story line. While the dissertations are non sectarien , it is such a distraction than it became unenjoyable.
Sorry David, until get out from the pulpit, I will NOT follow your writtings.
July 14, 2020
To my eyes, Daniel Gibbs was the best new space opera writer to hit the ebook market in 2019. He may be a new author, but it does not show in his writing. His characters are profoundly human - compassionate, strong, decisive but struggling with matters of faith, ethics, realpolitick and PTSD. His created universe is broad, multilayered and consistent. The situations and dilemmas that his characters deal with ring true to readers of military fiction (science fiction, thrillers, mysteries…) or 20th century history (like the history of World War II). The personal elements are true to the newest research and bibliographies of recent vets. I pick up his books and I fall right into the story, resurfacing when the book ends. Fans of David Weber, Jerry Pournelle, Glynn Stewart and John Ringo need to take note (as do these authors since the new competition is Fierce)!
August 22, 2020
great read
5 stars because it was well written and over 1000 pages. I recommend this book to anyone who enjoys Military Sci-Fi or just plain Sci-Fi the Author did a great job with making the story as realistic as possible without getting bogged down with unnecessary details. Most of the story takes place in outer space which is a huge Plus.
5 stars because it was well written and over 1000 pages. I recommend this book to anyone who enjoys Military Sci-Fi or just plain Sci-Fi the Author did a great job with making the story as realistic as possible without getting bogged down with unnecessary details. Most of the story takes place in outer space which is a huge Plus.
August 12, 2020
A Different Outlook
There is nothing different about humans, even with alien help, fighting other humans. What's different here is a totally different style of writing. I'm buying book four right now. This book showcases the reason people buy books.
There is nothing different about humans, even with alien help, fighting other humans. What's different here is a totally different style of writing. I'm buying book four right now. This book showcases the reason people buy books.
August 13, 2020
Good read
I enjoyed this read. The interfacing of religions without being preachy. Interesting ways of seeing the interactions from the different characters.
I enjoyed this read. The interfacing of religions without being preachy. Interesting ways of seeing the interactions from the different characters.
April 9, 2021
A book and series with more proselytizing than action.
This book had more praying and proselytizing than action. If you’re interested in Judaism read this book and Siri‘s. If you want more action and sci-fi look elsewhere. Yes you learned more about Judaism than the science-fiction elements that a science-fiction story is supposed to tell you. The author should’ve mentioned this in his synopsis of the book. I read the entire first three books of the series to give it a chance. But I cannot recommend it if you really want a book full of science-fiction aliens an action this isn’t it.
This book had more praying and proselytizing than action. If you’re interested in Judaism read this book and Siri‘s. If you want more action and sci-fi look elsewhere. Yes you learned more about Judaism than the science-fiction elements that a science-fiction story is supposed to tell you. The author should’ve mentioned this in his synopsis of the book. I read the entire first three books of the series to give it a chance. But I cannot recommend it if you really want a book full of science-fiction aliens an action this isn’t it.
November 14, 2022
Fight the Good Fight (Echoes of War Book 1), My first read/listen from author Daniel Gibbs. An outstanding, enjoyable read hands down the best science fiction book I've read this year! I was given an Audible copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review." The gifting of this book did not affect my opinion of it. The book was well-written & flowed smoothly & quickly. I look forward to reading more from this author. I'm trying to acquire Stand Firm (Echoes of War #0), but it seems to be out of print, so I'll have to settle for reading Strong and Courageous (Echoes of War Book 2). I especially enjoyed the narrative talents of Jeffrey Kafer. (RIP Marley January 20, 2014 - July 24, 2018).
Strong and Courageous (Echoes of War Book 2). My second read/listen from author Daniel Gibbs. An outstanding, enjoyable read, hands down the best science fiction book I've read this year! I was given an Audible copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review." The gifting of this book did not affect my opinion of it. The book was well-written & flowed smoothly & quickly. I look forward to reading more from this author. I've acquired Stand Firm (Echoes of War #0) and need to fit it into the reading order. Meanwhile, I'll have to settle for reading So Fight I (Echoes of War Book 3). I especially enjoyed the narrative talents of Jeffrey Kafer. (RIP Marley January 20, 2014 - July 24, 2018).
So Fight I (Echoes of War Book 3). My third read/listen from author Daniel Gibbs. An outstanding, enjoyable read, hands down the best science fiction book I've read this year! I was given an Audible copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review." The gifting of this book did not affect my opinion of it. The book was well-written & flowed smoothly & quickly. I look forward to reading more from this author. I've acquired Stand Firm (Echoes of War #0) and need to fit it into the reading order. I especially enjoyed the narrative talents of Jeffrey Kafer. (RIP Marley January 20, 2014 - July 24, 2018).
I grew up reading C.S. Forester’s Hornblower books. As a young adult I was captivated by Alexander Kent’s Bolitho books, never getting enough of them. This series will stand the same test of time those books did, and I look forward to more books in this series as well as others from this author.
Strong and Courageous (Echoes of War Book 2). My second read/listen from author Daniel Gibbs. An outstanding, enjoyable read, hands down the best science fiction book I've read this year! I was given an Audible copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review." The gifting of this book did not affect my opinion of it. The book was well-written & flowed smoothly & quickly. I look forward to reading more from this author. I've acquired Stand Firm (Echoes of War #0) and need to fit it into the reading order. Meanwhile, I'll have to settle for reading So Fight I (Echoes of War Book 3). I especially enjoyed the narrative talents of Jeffrey Kafer. (RIP Marley January 20, 2014 - July 24, 2018).
So Fight I (Echoes of War Book 3). My third read/listen from author Daniel Gibbs. An outstanding, enjoyable read, hands down the best science fiction book I've read this year! I was given an Audible copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review." The gifting of this book did not affect my opinion of it. The book was well-written & flowed smoothly & quickly. I look forward to reading more from this author. I've acquired Stand Firm (Echoes of War #0) and need to fit it into the reading order. I especially enjoyed the narrative talents of Jeffrey Kafer. (RIP Marley January 20, 2014 - July 24, 2018).
I grew up reading C.S. Forester’s Hornblower books. As a young adult I was captivated by Alexander Kent’s Bolitho books, never getting enough of them. This series will stand the same test of time those books did, and I look forward to more books in this series as well as others from this author.
July 11, 2024
I had to bail on this one.
The first book in the series was moderately good and I had hopes that the author would improve max the series went on. I had to abandon hope when I was unable to finish Strong and Courageous.
I was mostly ok with Lions, Tigers and Flying Nuns, Oh my!” But I finally couldn’t take the pompousness of the characters who would put a resistance leader in the same jail as the Nazi-like bad guys who had been running concentration and death camps and charge him with the same crimes.
I could no longer find any connection to the characters and while I suspect that I share many political views with the author, who oddly even paraphrases Ayn Rand at one point in the book, I became tired of the arrogant Pollyanna ideal that almost everything can be solved with minimal violence. Even worse, the author seems to pick and choose who is allowed to make tough calls and who isn’t.
The first book was an interesting, if imperfect, experiment. With the second book it is clear that the experiment has gone awry.
While I found book one to have potential, I cannot recommend this series now.
The first book in the series was moderately good and I had hopes that the author would improve max the series went on. I had to abandon hope when I was unable to finish Strong and Courageous.
I was mostly ok with Lions, Tigers and Flying Nuns, Oh my!” But I finally couldn’t take the pompousness of the characters who would put a resistance leader in the same jail as the Nazi-like bad guys who had been running concentration and death camps and charge him with the same crimes.
I could no longer find any connection to the characters and while I suspect that I share many political views with the author, who oddly even paraphrases Ayn Rand at one point in the book, I became tired of the arrogant Pollyanna ideal that almost everything can be solved with minimal violence. Even worse, the author seems to pick and choose who is allowed to make tough calls and who isn’t.
The first book was an interesting, if imperfect, experiment. With the second book it is clear that the experiment has gone awry.
While I found book one to have potential, I cannot recommend this series now.
October 20, 2020
The story here is a good one, and the plot and the hey characters work very well.
My main issue is the (to me) really excessive religious content, the religious detail feels far more than is needed for the story. It's slightly frustrating too that the only non religious character in the Terran Coalition is presented as such an asshat of a character / personality. It's very clichéd to suggest that those who do not believe in God are either shitty in character or in moral attitude. Whereas those who believe are, whilst conflicted, generally good guys. Likewise, the definition of the League as communists and atheists, and that being the driver to their evil behaviour, feels incredibly lazy. These tropes are annoying at best, verging on offensive.
My main issue is the (to me) really excessive religious content, the religious detail feels far more than is needed for the story. It's slightly frustrating too that the only non religious character in the Terran Coalition is presented as such an asshat of a character / personality. It's very clichéd to suggest that those who do not believe in God are either shitty in character or in moral attitude. Whereas those who believe are, whilst conflicted, generally good guys. Likewise, the definition of the League as communists and atheists, and that being the driver to their evil behaviour, feels incredibly lazy. These tropes are annoying at best, verging on offensive.
July 20, 2021
The book is good; however it focused on religion a lot. I enjoyed the part where the story was on, also liked the description of customs different religions, however I felt offended as the bad guys were the non-religious ones, and the good guys are all who have faith in any religion; and this was described over pages-and-pages how bad are the bad guys as they do not believe anything, how bad things they do, partially due to the lack of believing in god. Summary: book is good, but be aware; 30-40% is about religion, highly criticize all who do not religious.
July 21, 2021
Fantasy entertaining listening
Due to eye issues and damage Alexa reads to me, I find it like 👍watching 👀a movie.
Three very will written military space adventure Sci-Fi thriller novels far in the future. The characters are interesting and will developed in the space war. The story line is fast moving, violent, complicated, with each novel standing alone and leading to the next novel. I would recommend this series to readers of space adventure thrillers. Enjoy the adventure of reading 2021
Due to eye issues and damage Alexa reads to me, I find it like 👍watching 👀a movie.
Three very will written military space adventure Sci-Fi thriller novels far in the future. The characters are interesting and will developed in the space war. The story line is fast moving, violent, complicated, with each novel standing alone and leading to the next novel. I would recommend this series to readers of space adventure thrillers. Enjoy the adventure of reading 2021
May 3, 2023
Deeply Interesting
This is a book that is more than just a great sci-fi adventure story. As an orthodox Jew myself it is so interesting to read another person’s take on the philosophical aspects of Judaism and war along with insights on other religions on the sanctity of life and interpersonal relations during armed conflict. I would absolutely recommend this series to anybody who appreciates a good story who would like to understand more about how a religious person relates to their creator.
This is a book that is more than just a great sci-fi adventure story. As an orthodox Jew myself it is so interesting to read another person’s take on the philosophical aspects of Judaism and war along with insights on other religions on the sanctity of life and interpersonal relations during armed conflict. I would absolutely recommend this series to anybody who appreciates a good story who would like to understand more about how a religious person relates to their creator.
November 6, 2020
Review of said books
When I first started reading the above series, I thought I had gotten a hold of the wrong story. In th?e first few pages was all this talk about religion, not too sci-fi, but that what's just the beginning, I read on and all was better. The characters are interesting and the plot keeps pulling on to read more. I think most Sci-fi ers will enjoy reading the series.
When I first started reading the above series, I thought I had gotten a hold of the wrong story. In th?e first few pages was all this talk about religion, not too sci-fi, but that what's just the beginning, I read on and all was better. The characters are interesting and the plot keeps pulling on to read more. I think most Sci-fi ers will enjoy reading the series.
March 15, 2021
Great read, bit preachy.
Picked this book, trilogy actually, liking the premise after reading a blurb about it somewhere. the writing is tight, the authors vocabulary extensive, and his military knowledge seems fairly extensive. There is a good deal of religion running throughout the narrative and in some places it gets a little bit preachy, it is, howeve, integral to the story. All in all, a good read.
Picked this book, trilogy actually, liking the premise after reading a blurb about it somewhere. the writing is tight, the authors vocabulary extensive, and his military knowledge seems fairly extensive. There is a good deal of religion running throughout the narrative and in some places it gets a little bit preachy, it is, howeve, integral to the story. All in all, a good read.
January 23, 2023
I thought about 5 star, but the books, although carrying the story really , world and charaters believable, it did spend an awful lot of time on religous discussions. These tended to distract from my reading of the story. Sorry Daniel, I dropped a star because of the, to me, over religous emphasis. I understand what you are doing, but it spoilt the flow of the overall story.
Having said all that, If you see these books, either on offer of full price, go for it. I really did enjoy the series.
Having said all that, If you see these books, either on offer of full price, go for it. I really did enjoy the series.
October 28, 2020
Great space war story
This was a very different war story. The protagonists all have a deep faith in God although they do question their situation. It did present a good picture of what people of faith go through, especially soldiers. The story is compelling and the action scenes are good. All in all, a great set of books.
This was a very different war story. The protagonists all have a deep faith in God although they do question their situation. It did present a good picture of what people of faith go through, especially soldiers. The story is compelling and the action scenes are good. All in all, a great set of books.
November 27, 2020
Great story, interesting mix of religious information
A well written suspenseful group of stories that adds insights from various religious prayers and thoughts to give the reader added depth into these religions. This adds to the thoughts and war fighting of the varied protagonists.
A well written suspenseful group of stories that adds insights from various religious prayers and thoughts to give the reader added depth into these religions. This adds to the thoughts and war fighting of the varied protagonists.
February 23, 2021
These books are very well written, the characters are mostly relatable, and the action sections are suspenseful. I would give it 5 stars but I found the religious conversations borderline preachy. However I give the author props for addressing issues of faith and religion without being overly biased. Starting book 3 and surprised to learn there 7 or 8 in total? Wow. Kudos!
February 27, 2021
Of you are an atheist.....
Decent story, but it feels like as an atheist I am being attacked constantly for my views. This book almost feels like an indoctrination. The good guys are believers and the bad guys aren't; even the one atheist on the religious side is portrayed as an asshole. Not for me sorry.
Decent story, but it feels like as an atheist I am being attacked constantly for my views. This book almost feels like an indoctrination. The good guys are believers and the bad guys aren't; even the one atheist on the religious side is portrayed as an asshole. Not for me sorry.
August 10, 2021
Very well done
The ship handling and combat operations remind me of older sci-fi, short on technical details so the action can move forward rapidly. There is both character development and falls from Grace. The long-term plot is well thought out so far, and I look forward to the next book. Over, very well done and highly recommended.
The ship handling and combat operations remind me of older sci-fi, short on technical details so the action can move forward rapidly. There is both character development and falls from Grace. The long-term plot is well thought out so far, and I look forward to the next book. Over, very well done and highly recommended.
January 8, 2024
Good military SciFi
I've read the series up to this point and, though I like the characters and premise, some of it borders on ridiculous.
There have been many great series where the author didn't take the Captain off the bridge and (voluntarily) put him into a live fire situation.
Finding the mettle of oneself means doing that which is right rather than that which is easy.
I've read the series up to this point and, though I like the characters and premise, some of it borders on ridiculous.
There have been many great series where the author didn't take the Captain off the bridge and (voluntarily) put him into a live fire situation.
Finding the mettle of oneself means doing that which is right rather than that which is easy.
April 1, 2024
I read the 7 books of this series. Good science fiction, mostly along the military sense, with almost all of it in outer space. Unfortunately, there is so much religion that it takes away from both the enjoyment and plot. I had to jump over 20 pages at a time to get back to the main story. However, even with these concerns, I still enjoyed the book.
October 22, 2020
Good story
I enjoyed the story, however the constant praying and God talk was a bit much. While I understand the author was trying to use it as a main plot line, it came to the point that I was skimming a heck of a lot.
I enjoyed the story, however the constant praying and God talk was a bit much. While I understand the author was trying to use it as a main plot line, it came to the point that I was skimming a heck of a lot.
November 19, 2020
Great action book for people of faith
Plenty of action with many surprises. I usually finish a single book in about a month with everything i have going. I finished all three books in less then a month.
Plenty of action with many surprises. I usually finish a single book in about a month with everything i have going. I finished all three books in less then a month.
November 26, 2020
Religion and War
An excellent look into the thoughts of many religious and non religious individuals during the time of battle. I have not read sci fi with religious overtones that were written as well as this series has been.
An excellent look into the thoughts of many religious and non religious individuals during the time of battle. I have not read sci fi with religious overtones that were written as well as this series has been.
December 24, 2020
Creative, interesting, a real adventure. Complete with good character development and futuristic high tech.
I loved the way it is so moral. It challenges us to win "the war within".
It's violent without being blood thirsty. Quite the reverse!
Jewish? Christian? Muslim? Worth reading this.
I loved the way it is so moral. It challenges us to win "the war within".
It's violent without being blood thirsty. Quite the reverse!
Jewish? Christian? Muslim? Worth reading this.
December 28, 2020
No shortage of action
Once you get started, these books are hard to put down. There is a fair bit of moralizing, which are not my favorite parts but the action makes up the bulk of the books. One note, I wish I got a nickel for every use of the word "smirk"
Once you get started, these books are hard to put down. There is a fair bit of moralizing, which are not my favorite parts but the action makes up the bulk of the books. One note, I wish I got a nickel for every use of the word "smirk"
February 14, 2021
Great series
This series keeps you interested and sucks you in. Its not repetitive and keeps throwing curve balls. When you think something is going to happen, the plot moves another direction. I thoroughly enjoyed it.
This series keeps you interested and sucks you in. Its not repetitive and keeps throwing curve balls. When you think something is going to happen, the plot moves another direction. I thoroughly enjoyed it.
February 28, 2021
A very good read
This is the first science fiction which used all the religions, non believers and atheists as a major part of an integrated story. Very different and very interesting, something our world could learn from, harmony is possible!
This is the first science fiction which used all the religions, non believers and atheists as a major part of an integrated story. Very different and very interesting, something our world could learn from, harmony is possible!
May 9, 2021
I appreciated the religious aspect or this story, not preachy or in your face, but food for thought.
This writer is, (Daniel Gibbs) has great potential in writing/story telling.
Keep up the good work!
This writer is, (Daniel Gibbs) has great potential in writing/story telling.
Keep up the good work!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 51 reviews