What do you think?
Rate this book
The Maidels of Morning Star #2
First Light in Morning Star
Hiding a secret that could cause her to be shunned, Lydianne Christner, new to Morning Star, spurns the advances of handsome Bishop Jeremiah Shetler until she, forced to tell him the truth, learns that love and forgiveness go hand-in-hand.
368 pages, Mass Market Paperback
Published December 29, 2020
About the author
Charlotte Hubbard
43 books1,341 followersDrawing upon her experiences in Jamesport, the largest Old Order Amish community west of the Mississippi, longtime Missourian Charlotte Hubbard (a.k.a. Naomi King) writes of simpler times and a faith-based lifestyle in her new Seasons of the Heart series. Like her heroine, Miriam Lantz, Charlotte considers it her personal mission to feed people—to share hearth and home. Faith and family, farming and food preservation are hallmarks of her lifestyle, and the foundation of her earlier Angels of Mercy series. She’s a deacon, a dedicated church musician and choir member, and when she’s not writing, she loves to try new recipes, crochet, and sew. Charlotte now lives in Minnesota with her husband and their border collie.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 64 reviews
February 1, 2026
This is an Amish Fiction, and this is the second book in the Maidels of Morning Star series. I have not read the first book in this series before picking up this book. This is not like the normal Amish Fiction book. The main character (Lydianne) has some secrets in her past that she is having trouble living with because of her secrets she has decided she will never get married. When she moves to Morning Star she becomes the teacher and two man starts to fight for her hand in married. She does not know how to tell them she cannot married anyone because of her past. I love the characters and the twists and turns in this book. I love the take on Amish Fiction that this book takes. I do feel some parts of this book the pacing is off in the book because some parts of this book moves so slow. I received an ARC of this book. This review is my own honest opinion about the book like all my reviews are.
January 4, 2021
This is a story that has stayed with me since finishing it as the characters and storyline are so special. Lydianne Christner moved to Morning Star for a personal reason that she cannot share with anyone. She has established herself and become part of a group of other maidels who enjoy each other's company. They have even started a business, a marketplace, where members of the Amish community can sell their wares and raises money for different things like a new schoolhouse. She knows that she will never be able to marry and have her family and is settled on that. Now she becomes the new teacher at the schoolhouse and she has a reason for wanting to become the teacher even though she has a good job with a furniture maker at the marketplace.
Bishop Jeremiah, a young man who lost his wife and has no children, is attracted to Lydianne. But she rejected him without giving him a reason. Another member of the church, Glenn also has his eyes on Lydianne. He recently lost his wife and it is too soon to be looking for a replacement. When Jeremiah makes an observation that makes him understand what is going on in Lydianne's life, he is struck with a decision. This is a story of compassion, forgiveness, faith, new beginnings, humor, and love. I really enjoyed this sweet story. Most Amish books that I have read have had older and more stern bishops and this one is a refreshing twist on a church leader.
I received a complimentary ARC from Kensington Books through NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions stated are mine only.
Bishop Jeremiah, a young man who lost his wife and has no children, is attracted to Lydianne. But she rejected him without giving him a reason. Another member of the church, Glenn also has his eyes on Lydianne. He recently lost his wife and it is too soon to be looking for a replacement. When Jeremiah makes an observation that makes him understand what is going on in Lydianne's life, he is struck with a decision. This is a story of compassion, forgiveness, faith, new beginnings, humor, and love. I really enjoyed this sweet story. Most Amish books that I have read have had older and more stern bishops and this one is a refreshing twist on a church leader.
I received a complimentary ARC from Kensington Books through NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions stated are mine only.
December 7, 2020
This is the second book in the series. I did enjoy the book. But It took a few chapters before i got into the book. The book for me was about trust, dark secret and forgiveness. A sweet read. Thank you to netgalley for letting me read This e arc in exchange for an honest opinion
January 9, 2021
I was so happy to go back to Morning Star. This is the second book in the Morning Star series.
It was just as good as the first book Morning Star.
Hubbard does not write your typical some ole Amish fiction. It is fresh and different from the rest of the Amish fiction books.
This was such a good read and well don't we all have secrets. Being a teacher has to be very hard and trying at times.
I gave this book 4 stars and I recommend it. It can be read as a stand alone but book one was just as good.
The Mary Reader received this book from the publisher for review. A favorable review was not required and all views expressed are our own.
It was just as good as the first book Morning Star.
Hubbard does not write your typical some ole Amish fiction. It is fresh and different from the rest of the Amish fiction books.
This was such a good read and well don't we all have secrets. Being a teacher has to be very hard and trying at times.
I gave this book 4 stars and I recommend it. It can be read as a stand alone but book one was just as good.
The Mary Reader received this book from the publisher for review. A favorable review was not required and all views expressed are our own.
November 21, 2020
Sweet Amish Romance
I won this book on Goodreads. So glad I did. I adore Amish fiction. This story was a little b different then the average Amish Romance making it interesting as well as sweet. Now I need to read book 1 and look for book 3, a Christmas story in this series.
I won this book on Goodreads. So glad I did. I adore Amish fiction. This story was a little b different then the average Amish Romance making it interesting as well as sweet. Now I need to read book 1 and look for book 3, a Christmas story in this series.
December 3, 2021
This is the first Charlotte Hubbard book I've read, and it's engaging , has a lot of details, and the characters are cheerful,
supportive of one another, and industrious. I like how well the maidels get along with each other. The cover is
an eye-catcher, pleasing colors and it has good back copy.
The story has several big events that keep you wanting to come back to read more! I won't go into those, and spoil it for other readers,
but each story is built well and leads smoothly into the next circumstance. It keeps you curious about it, that's for sure.
Some things that were in the book bothered me, because for a Christian book, the terms were not biblically sound. One instance
involved a teacher telling her students that she wanted them to sit on a magic carpet. Magic, in God's word, is an abomination. Magic carpets involve
levitation, which is occult. Magic carpets were also described in detail in the Egyptian and the Tibetan Book of the Dead and in Hindu religion. All those religions
are anti-Christian. I'm sure God doesn't want the mention or promotion of anything magic in any part of the body of Christ.
The book talks about people having positive or negative energy. These terms are from religions of the east which
oppose God, Jesus, and the Bible. Terms such as positive and negative energy are supernatural in nature and connected with an occultic worldview.
God says he abhors wicked practices, and New Age mysticism is a
wicked practice. [19] Now the works of the flesh are manifest, which are these; Adultery, fornication, uncleanness, lasciviousness,
[20] Idolatry, witchcraft, hatred, variance, emulations, wrath, strife, seditions, heresies,
[21] Envyings, murders, drunkenness, revellings, and such like: of the which I tell you before, as I have also told you in time past,
that they which do such things shall not inherit the kingdom of God.
Another part of the book that stood out as very non-biblical, was when the Amish young women talked in subtly disparaging terms
about submitting wholly to the authority of the husband. The bible is clear about men being the leaders of the family, and clear about the wife being
obedient to the directions of her husband, as long as it is not against the bible. Ephesians 5: [22] Wives, submit yourselves unto your own husbands, as unto the Lord.
[23] For the husband is the head of the wife, even as Christ is the head of the church: and he is the saviour of the body.
[24] Therefore as the church is subject unto Christ, so let the wives be to their own husbands in every thing.
[25] Husbands, love your wives, even as Christ also loved the church, and gave himself for it;
[26] That he might sanctify and cleanse it with the washing of water by the word,
[27] That he might present it to himself a glorious church, not having spot, or wrinkle, or any such thing; but that it should be holy and without blemish.
[28] So ought men to love their wives as their own bodies. He that loveth his wife loveth himself.
I'm hoping, I really am, that this review will encourage Charlotte Hubbard to fashion her future books to be fully honoring to Jesus, her Saviour, and
to be more in agreement with God's Holy Word, the Bible. Mrs. Hubbard has a lot of God-given talent, she can write expertly, and can tell good stories that show
real struggles, and real solutions. It is my sincere intention that this review will elevate her desire to serve Jesus Christ, and Him alone, with the talents He gave her.
I plan to see what she decides to write in future books. Mrs. Hubbard has a lot of talent, and she can glorify God with those talents to the edification of others. Galatians 5:13;
Galatians 1:6-9
King James VersionGalatians 6 : I marvel that ye are so soon removed from him that called you into the grace of Christ unto another gospel:
7 Which is not another; but there be some that trouble you, and would pervert the gospel of Christ.
8 But though we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you, let him be accursed.
9 As we said before, so say I now again, if any man preach any other gospel unto you than that ye have received, let him be accursed.
supportive of one another, and industrious. I like how well the maidels get along with each other. The cover is
an eye-catcher, pleasing colors and it has good back copy.
The story has several big events that keep you wanting to come back to read more! I won't go into those, and spoil it for other readers,
but each story is built well and leads smoothly into the next circumstance. It keeps you curious about it, that's for sure.
Some things that were in the book bothered me, because for a Christian book, the terms were not biblically sound. One instance
involved a teacher telling her students that she wanted them to sit on a magic carpet. Magic, in God's word, is an abomination. Magic carpets involve
levitation, which is occult. Magic carpets were also described in detail in the Egyptian and the Tibetan Book of the Dead and in Hindu religion. All those religions
are anti-Christian. I'm sure God doesn't want the mention or promotion of anything magic in any part of the body of Christ.
The book talks about people having positive or negative energy. These terms are from religions of the east which
oppose God, Jesus, and the Bible. Terms such as positive and negative energy are supernatural in nature and connected with an occultic worldview.
God says he abhors wicked practices, and New Age mysticism is a
wicked practice. [19] Now the works of the flesh are manifest, which are these; Adultery, fornication, uncleanness, lasciviousness,
[20] Idolatry, witchcraft, hatred, variance, emulations, wrath, strife, seditions, heresies,
[21] Envyings, murders, drunkenness, revellings, and such like: of the which I tell you before, as I have also told you in time past,
that they which do such things shall not inherit the kingdom of God.
Another part of the book that stood out as very non-biblical, was when the Amish young women talked in subtly disparaging terms
about submitting wholly to the authority of the husband. The bible is clear about men being the leaders of the family, and clear about the wife being
obedient to the directions of her husband, as long as it is not against the bible. Ephesians 5: [22] Wives, submit yourselves unto your own husbands, as unto the Lord.
[23] For the husband is the head of the wife, even as Christ is the head of the church: and he is the saviour of the body.
[24] Therefore as the church is subject unto Christ, so let the wives be to their own husbands in every thing.
[25] Husbands, love your wives, even as Christ also loved the church, and gave himself for it;
[26] That he might sanctify and cleanse it with the washing of water by the word,
[27] That he might present it to himself a glorious church, not having spot, or wrinkle, or any such thing; but that it should be holy and without blemish.
[28] So ought men to love their wives as their own bodies. He that loveth his wife loveth himself.
I'm hoping, I really am, that this review will encourage Charlotte Hubbard to fashion her future books to be fully honoring to Jesus, her Saviour, and
to be more in agreement with God's Holy Word, the Bible. Mrs. Hubbard has a lot of God-given talent, she can write expertly, and can tell good stories that show
real struggles, and real solutions. It is my sincere intention that this review will elevate her desire to serve Jesus Christ, and Him alone, with the talents He gave her.
I plan to see what she decides to write in future books. Mrs. Hubbard has a lot of talent, and she can glorify God with those talents to the edification of others. Galatians 5:13;
Galatians 1:6-9
King James VersionGalatians 6 : I marvel that ye are so soon removed from him that called you into the grace of Christ unto another gospel:
7 Which is not another; but there be some that trouble you, and would pervert the gospel of Christ.
8 But though we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you, let him be accursed.
9 As we said before, so say I now again, if any man preach any other gospel unto you than that ye have received, let him be accursed.
September 9, 2020
When a reader wants to take a break from some serious reading, this would be a perfect book to pick up. Unfortunately for me, it was rather smarmy and overly sweet.
Lydianne has a secret that brought her to Morning Star. She has applied to be the teacher of the school in an effort to be close to a little girl that is one of the scholars. She has decided that because of her secret that she will never marry. BUT, there are two men who would love to marry her. One is the bishop and the other is a widower with two young boys. Her choice to never marry stands in the way, but when the secret is revealed, she has even more decisions to make besides marrying or not.
Charlotte Hubbard usually writes good Amish Fiction, but this one misses the mark. Three Stars.
Zebra Publishing and NetGalley.com provided the copy I read for this review. All opinions expressed are my own.
Lydianne has a secret that brought her to Morning Star. She has applied to be the teacher of the school in an effort to be close to a little girl that is one of the scholars. She has decided that because of her secret that she will never marry. BUT, there are two men who would love to marry her. One is the bishop and the other is a widower with two young boys. Her choice to never marry stands in the way, but when the secret is revealed, she has even more decisions to make besides marrying or not.
Charlotte Hubbard usually writes good Amish Fiction, but this one misses the mark. Three Stars.
Zebra Publishing and NetGalley.com provided the copy I read for this review. All opinions expressed are my own.
January 22, 2022
First Light in Morning Star is the second book in the Maidels of Morning Star series. I read the first and third, so needed to read Lydianne Christner's story before the next in the series comes out. Lydianne is one of the five maidels that founded the Morningstar Marketplace. Each of them brings a gift to the running of the Market. She had been working at Flaud’s Furniture, but left there to become the teacher at the community’s new school. Lydianne has a secret in her past and she is worried that her life in Morningstar will be over if anyone finds out, so when Bishop Jeremiah Shetler asks about her past, she panics and tries to avoid him as much as possible. He begins to have feelings for Lydianne, but she refuses to allow him to court her. When a crisis hits, Lydianne is forced to share her secret with Jeremiah and now they have big decisions to make.
I really liked Lydianne and felt bad for her. The secret she is keeping is not a major issue in an Englischers life, but it could become a serious issue for an Amish woman, especially one teaching young children. Jeremiah is a wonderful character. A Bishop who follows the rules, but one who also has compassion and doesn't want to hurt anyone, especially innocent ones. There is a bit of a love triangle in the sense that two men are interested in Lydianne, but she does not reciprocate and has not intention to marry. This is a well paced story that gave another aspect of Amish life. I loved the ending and was happy for Lydianne. An easy to read, enjoyable Amish Romance. I can't wait for the next story in this series.
I really liked Lydianne and felt bad for her. The secret she is keeping is not a major issue in an Englischers life, but it could become a serious issue for an Amish woman, especially one teaching young children. Jeremiah is a wonderful character. A Bishop who follows the rules, but one who also has compassion and doesn't want to hurt anyone, especially innocent ones. There is a bit of a love triangle in the sense that two men are interested in Lydianne, but she does not reciprocate and has not intention to marry. This is a well paced story that gave another aspect of Amish life. I loved the ending and was happy for Lydianne. An easy to read, enjoyable Amish Romance. I can't wait for the next story in this series.
February 24, 2022
I have enjoyed reading of these special single women of Morning Star. A series of women that have gone against the grain of Amish Women but have kept their faith in the Lord strong. Lydianne is the center of this series and she is putting her long held secret that holds her heart into motion. She is applying for the teaching job for the Morning Star community. She is meeting with the board and the Bishop Jeremiah. She put forth a good first step and will be teaching the 8 children of Morning Star. One specific child holds a special place in her heart. She cannot reveal the secret in fear of the severe consequences but she knows that God had made a way for her to be there. She also knows that she must remain single because of this secret but two men have set their heart on Lydianne for different reasons.
Bishop Jeremiah and Glenn Detweiler who recently lost his wife. His eyes are set on Lydianne for all the wrong reasons. However, his advances are very contrasted to the feelings of Bishop Jeremiah. It does become a cat and mouse for Lydianne and the men who are pursuing her but it all changes when the Bishop "sees" Lydianne's secret and lovingly confronts her with redemption! Totally loved this budding romance.
A special thank you to Kensington Books and Netgalley for the ARC and the opportunity to post an honest review.
Bishop Jeremiah and Glenn Detweiler who recently lost his wife. His eyes are set on Lydianne for all the wrong reasons. However, his advances are very contrasted to the feelings of Bishop Jeremiah. It does become a cat and mouse for Lydianne and the men who are pursuing her but it all changes when the Bishop "sees" Lydianne's secret and lovingly confronts her with redemption! Totally loved this budding romance.
A special thank you to Kensington Books and Netgalley for the ARC and the opportunity to post an honest review.
October 19, 2020
First Light in the Morning Star by Charlotte Hubbard.
I must seriously comment on the book cover. This is just too beautiful. I couldn’t resist the book and I am so glad I got a copy from the publisher through NetGalley.
Lydianne has a wish. To be a school teacher at the school even though she has no experience in teaching. She carried a secret in her heart that influenced her desire to be the school teacher in that Amish community.
I really felt comfortable with the plot and the suspense. You need to be patient while reading this book.
Bishop Jeremiah is a good character. You can even relate with him so well.
To eat baked chicken and potatoes at an Amish gathering is so appetizing. I love how large and sumptuous they make their meals no matter the number of people eating it.
I really learnt a lot through this book. It is so good when love and forgiveness goes hand in hand.
I am rating this book 5 stars. I received a complimentary copy of this book from Kensington Books through NetGalley.
I must seriously comment on the book cover. This is just too beautiful. I couldn’t resist the book and I am so glad I got a copy from the publisher through NetGalley.
Lydianne has a wish. To be a school teacher at the school even though she has no experience in teaching. She carried a secret in her heart that influenced her desire to be the school teacher in that Amish community.
I really felt comfortable with the plot and the suspense. You need to be patient while reading this book.
Bishop Jeremiah is a good character. You can even relate with him so well.
To eat baked chicken and potatoes at an Amish gathering is so appetizing. I love how large and sumptuous they make their meals no matter the number of people eating it.
I really learnt a lot through this book. It is so good when love and forgiveness goes hand in hand.
I am rating this book 5 stars. I received a complimentary copy of this book from Kensington Books through NetGalley.
October 31, 2020
I loved being back in Morning Star and being reunited with characters that I've come to care about and learn more about what is going on in their lives and the lives of their friends.
This is primarily, Lydianne's story, and her desires and self punishment. It is also about two men who are very interested in getting her attention. One is a widower with two very young children, and your heart will break for him as we look into his circumstances. Then there is the Bishop who is also a widower and would like to move on with his life.
Come and see how the Market Place and new school is doing, and how the people are working to make it all a success.
I am now waiting for the next installment in this series, I love a deeper look into these new friends and what is going on with them.
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Kensington, and was not required to give a positive review.
This is primarily, Lydianne's story, and her desires and self punishment. It is also about two men who are very interested in getting her attention. One is a widower with two very young children, and your heart will break for him as we look into his circumstances. Then there is the Bishop who is also a widower and would like to move on with his life.
Come and see how the Market Place and new school is doing, and how the people are working to make it all a success.
I am now waiting for the next installment in this series, I love a deeper look into these new friends and what is going on with them.
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Kensington, and was not required to give a positive review.
February 14, 2021
Huge Fan of Morning Star. Charlotte Hubbard has a skill that being the characters and places to life. This story is the story of Lydianne and Jeremiah. There journey to find love is not smooth but truly worth the ride! I love the way Charlotte Hubbard created a place you wish to visit and characters you make friends with.
December 16, 2020
This book is part of the Amish series, Maidels of Morning Star. This book is number two in the series but can be read as a stand alone. Lydianne moved to Morning Star with a secret and motive. She is involved with the Amish Marketplace but applies for the teacher’s job. Jeremiah is the Bishop for Morning Star. He would like to start a relationship with Lydianne. She at first pushes him away because of her secret. The story starts out slow but eventually picks up. I can't wait to read the next one in the series. Thank you to NetGalley and Kensington-Zebra Books. This is my own opinion.
December 16, 2020
This book is part of the Amish series, Maidels of Morning Star. This book is number two in the series but can be read as a stand alone. Lydianne moved to Morning Star with a secret and motive. She is involved with the Amish Marketplace but applies for the teacher’s job. Jeremiah is the Bishop for Morning Star. He would like to start a relationship with Lydianne. She at first pushes him away because of her secret. The story starts out slow but eventually picks up. I can't wait to read the next one in the series. Thank you to Goodreads and Kensington-Zebra Books. I won this book in a giveaway. This is my own opinion.
February 3, 2021
I thoroughly enjoyed and appreciated this Amish novel! It is the first book I have read by this author and I am very impressed! It is a faith-filled novel that emphasizes grace and forgiveness. The characters are fresh and delightful, especially Bishop Shetler, Lydianne, and the other young women who began the Morning Star Marketplace. Second in the series, it can be read as a standalone.
Lydianne has worked for the furniture factory owned by Martin Flaud most of the time she lived in Morning Star. The opportunity has risen for her to interview for the position of schoolteacher in the new Amish school building, which she is very excited about. She has lived in Morning Star for a few years, but nobody knows much about her past. She is happy to be offered the position and has time to prepare for the fall term. If her Saturday duties at the Marketplace interfere with the position, she will turn over the bookkeeping and other tasks to the other young women.
Lydianne has a secret from her Old Order Amish district, one that nobody can find out. She would be shunned if her past was revealed. She will not date anyone, and does not believe she should marry.
Lydianne is an excellent teacher to her eight scholars, and after listening outside to some of the lessons, Bishop Jeremiah Shetler is impressed. He has been widowed for several years, and his mother is determined to get him remarried. Lydianne is the first woman he has considered asking out since his wife died of an aneurism, and he invited her to the upcoming family reunion. She panicked, turned him down, and requested that he not ask her to explain or invite her again.
Glenn, the youngest board member who lost his wife during the summer, has a seven-year-old son in school. Billy Jay adores his new teacher even as he misses his mother. Glenn wants his life to get back to normal and thinks his son’s teacher would be just the person to wed. When he tries to get her attention and is turned down, he is less than happy and thinks it is because of Jeremiah.
As often happens with secrets, Lydianne’s is discovered during a crisis, leaving her only three options. It was not bad enough that Jeremiah guessed the secret, but a student, then other church members, hear the speculation. She will either lose her teaching job and be shunned, leave town and find where she can support herself again, or marry Jeremiah, in which case she would still have to give up teaching.
I love this novel! Lydianne, a young woman it is easy to have empathy for, is a thoughtful, loving young woman of faith whose life had not gone the way she planned. With God’s help, she started over again. She could have revealed her secret several years ago, but believed she had a good reason to not do so. The characters in this novel are well defined through conversations and actions, and I like Lydianne and appreciate her secret. I like Jeremiah, also, even though at times I think his ego may have gotten ahead of him. How he handles her revealed secret, his feelings for Lydianne, despite her secret and as he stays true to his faith, speaks volumes of him. I highly recommend this to those who appreciate well-written Amish fiction with good friends, faith, and romance.
From a thankful heart: I received a copy of this from a Goodreads First contest, and this is my honest review.
Lydianne has worked for the furniture factory owned by Martin Flaud most of the time she lived in Morning Star. The opportunity has risen for her to interview for the position of schoolteacher in the new Amish school building, which she is very excited about. She has lived in Morning Star for a few years, but nobody knows much about her past. She is happy to be offered the position and has time to prepare for the fall term. If her Saturday duties at the Marketplace interfere with the position, she will turn over the bookkeeping and other tasks to the other young women.
Lydianne has a secret from her Old Order Amish district, one that nobody can find out. She would be shunned if her past was revealed. She will not date anyone, and does not believe she should marry.
Lydianne is an excellent teacher to her eight scholars, and after listening outside to some of the lessons, Bishop Jeremiah Shetler is impressed. He has been widowed for several years, and his mother is determined to get him remarried. Lydianne is the first woman he has considered asking out since his wife died of an aneurism, and he invited her to the upcoming family reunion. She panicked, turned him down, and requested that he not ask her to explain or invite her again.
Glenn, the youngest board member who lost his wife during the summer, has a seven-year-old son in school. Billy Jay adores his new teacher even as he misses his mother. Glenn wants his life to get back to normal and thinks his son’s teacher would be just the person to wed. When he tries to get her attention and is turned down, he is less than happy and thinks it is because of Jeremiah.
As often happens with secrets, Lydianne’s is discovered during a crisis, leaving her only three options. It was not bad enough that Jeremiah guessed the secret, but a student, then other church members, hear the speculation. She will either lose her teaching job and be shunned, leave town and find where she can support herself again, or marry Jeremiah, in which case she would still have to give up teaching.
I love this novel! Lydianne, a young woman it is easy to have empathy for, is a thoughtful, loving young woman of faith whose life had not gone the way she planned. With God’s help, she started over again. She could have revealed her secret several years ago, but believed she had a good reason to not do so. The characters in this novel are well defined through conversations and actions, and I like Lydianne and appreciate her secret. I like Jeremiah, also, even though at times I think his ego may have gotten ahead of him. How he handles her revealed secret, his feelings for Lydianne, despite her secret and as he stays true to his faith, speaks volumes of him. I highly recommend this to those who appreciate well-written Amish fiction with good friends, faith, and romance.
From a thankful heart: I received a copy of this from a Goodreads First contest, and this is my honest review.
November 4, 2020
First Light In Morning Star is a well written inspiring story by Charlotte Hubbard. This story takes the reader back to Morningstar Marketplace and the lives of five enterprising young Amish women. This story centers around Lydianne Christner and a very heartbreaking secret she has carried for years. I enjoyed getting to know Lydianne's story and felt her pain at every turn. The characters are well developed and very likeable. There are so many surprising twist to this story that I found it hard to put it down.
Lydianne has been selected to become the new teacher in Morningstar but she is reluctant to accept the position because of her past and the secret she carries. If her secret is revealed it could cost her the job, her reputation, and standing within the Amish church community. As Lydianne prepares for the upcoming school year she finds herself caught between two admirers but she has decided to never marry. As the plot to this story plays out it is surprising how the author has handled revealing Lydianne's secret. With Lydianne being surrounded by such loving, caring friends she realizes things may not be as bleak as she thought. This story brought tears to my eyes in several areas and made me realize just how important friendships can be. This story is filled with love, loss, heartbreak, and faith. Forgiveness is definitely a big element throughout this story.
I was given the opportunity to read and review this story thru an advanced copy of this book from the author. Although I received an advanced copy I was not approached to post a favorable response just an honest one. I have rated this story with five stars for meeting my expectations of a wonderful story that I can highly recommend to others. I am anxious to read the next book in this series to continue stories involving the other characters.
Congratulations to Charlotte Hubbard on writing another inspiring story for her readers enjoyment.
Lydianne has been selected to become the new teacher in Morningstar but she is reluctant to accept the position because of her past and the secret she carries. If her secret is revealed it could cost her the job, her reputation, and standing within the Amish church community. As Lydianne prepares for the upcoming school year she finds herself caught between two admirers but she has decided to never marry. As the plot to this story plays out it is surprising how the author has handled revealing Lydianne's secret. With Lydianne being surrounded by such loving, caring friends she realizes things may not be as bleak as she thought. This story brought tears to my eyes in several areas and made me realize just how important friendships can be. This story is filled with love, loss, heartbreak, and faith. Forgiveness is definitely a big element throughout this story.
I was given the opportunity to read and review this story thru an advanced copy of this book from the author. Although I received an advanced copy I was not approached to post a favorable response just an honest one. I have rated this story with five stars for meeting my expectations of a wonderful story that I can highly recommend to others. I am anxious to read the next book in this series to continue stories involving the other characters.
Congratulations to Charlotte Hubbard on writing another inspiring story for her readers enjoyment.
November 5, 2020
Here's a a favorite quote from this book that I've felt matched the story to a T! and I just had to share this right away because it's so true even in our lives.
This comes from Maratha Maude to Lydianne; "Every one of us has a secret or two we've tucked into our hearts, because some things really are best kept between us and our Lord." " Bless you for all the work you've done with our scholars. "
I love this because I'm sure being a teacher is hard work. It can't be easy and pleasant at times.
I'm so glad that at least someone is willing to recognize that and appreciate it.
I've really really enjoyed this story! Hubbard has a unique way of writing that puts us into the hearts and minds of her characters.
Another saying that I really hadn't thought about being put this way is; when something wonderfully satisfying locks into place, as though our hearts were a jigsaw puzzle we finally find the missing pieces we've been searching for.
Folks I agree completely. Hubbard couldn't have put it in a better way.
I love her books so much that I eagerly await each one. She can't write fast enough for me. Her books are just so wonderful gut!
I finished this one in a few hours. Five stars for such a wonderful gut book! The writing was awesome and I enjoyed the bit of mystery that was added in nicely.
The characters were well rounded out and the story didn't feel rushed at all.
I especially liked in how Hubbard portrayed Bishop Jeremiah. After all, preachers/Bishops have feelings too!
I felt like they were all of my friends so therefore I didn't want to say goodbye. I don't like it when a great story ends! More please?!
My thanks to Netgalley for a wonderful gut book. I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions are my own.
This comes from Maratha Maude to Lydianne; "Every one of us has a secret or two we've tucked into our hearts, because some things really are best kept between us and our Lord." " Bless you for all the work you've done with our scholars. "
I love this because I'm sure being a teacher is hard work. It can't be easy and pleasant at times.
I'm so glad that at least someone is willing to recognize that and appreciate it.
I've really really enjoyed this story! Hubbard has a unique way of writing that puts us into the hearts and minds of her characters.
Another saying that I really hadn't thought about being put this way is; when something wonderfully satisfying locks into place, as though our hearts were a jigsaw puzzle we finally find the missing pieces we've been searching for.
Folks I agree completely. Hubbard couldn't have put it in a better way.
I love her books so much that I eagerly await each one. She can't write fast enough for me. Her books are just so wonderful gut!
I finished this one in a few hours. Five stars for such a wonderful gut book! The writing was awesome and I enjoyed the bit of mystery that was added in nicely.
The characters were well rounded out and the story didn't feel rushed at all.
I especially liked in how Hubbard portrayed Bishop Jeremiah. After all, preachers/Bishops have feelings too!
I felt like they were all of my friends so therefore I didn't want to say goodbye. I don't like it when a great story ends! More please?!
My thanks to Netgalley for a wonderful gut book. I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions are my own.
November 16, 2020
It took reading several chapters for me to get interested in this story and start connecting with the characters; but as the story progressed and the pace picked up, I was drawn in by the surprises in the plot as Lydianne’s secret unfolded. I enjoyed the scenes in Lydianne’s classroom, the revealing of her secret, the development of her relationship with Jeremiah, and Jeremiah’s dilemma; but the parts about the other maidels I found rather tedious and random. On a positive note, I appreciated the strong faith element showing how God works in people’s lives and the themes of hope, new beginnings, forgiveness, and acceptance. Also, Lydianne and Jeremiah were well-developed, endearing characters. All in all this book was just OK for me.
I received a copy of this book in e-book form from the publisher via netgalley but am under no obligation to write a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
I received a copy of this book in e-book form from the publisher via netgalley but am under no obligation to write a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
February 10, 2021
First Light in Morning Star by Charlotte Hubbard is the 2nd novel in The Maidels of Morning Star series. While it can be read as a standalone, I recommend reading Morning Star first (sets the stage for the whole series). I like Lydianne Christner as well as the other characters in this series. Lydianne is woman with a secret. She is afraid of what will happen if her past is exposed. I liked that this book is not a traditional romance. There are twists to surprise a reader. The story does start out a little slow, but the pacing increases as the book progresses. There is also repetition of information that did not enjoy (I got it the first time). I like that we get to catch up with some of the characters from the author’s Simple Gifts series and Seasons of the Heart series. We get to see Bishop Jeremiah Shetler as a man with feelings and desires of his own instead of just as the leader of the community. It is nice how the Faith elements of second chances, forgiveness, hope, and acceptance are woven into the story. God has a plan for each of us and we must have faith in Him. First Light in Morning Star is a sweet story with a lovely ending. I am eager for the story of Jeremiah’s nephew, Pete. I think it is time for him to settle down. First Light in Morning Star is a heartfelt Amish tale that features developed characters with real life problems.
December 13, 2020
This is the second book of the series "The Maidels of Morning Star". It is about Lydianne who has a past that troubles her as she tries to keep the secret of things that could cause her serious problems in her new community of Morning Star where she finds a job as the teacher in their Amish school.
As two men in the community start to vie for her hand, she feels that she can not marry due to the things in her past that trouble her and the consequences she expects it would cause to not only herself but others.
I really enjoyed this book and even the cover is absolutely beautiful. I liked the characters in the story and even Glenn! I recommend this book to readers who love Amish fiction! Great book and I can't wait to see what happens next in Morning Star!
I received a complimentary copy from the author. All thoughts are my own.
As two men in the community start to vie for her hand, she feels that she can not marry due to the things in her past that trouble her and the consequences she expects it would cause to not only herself but others.
I really enjoyed this book and even the cover is absolutely beautiful. I liked the characters in the story and even Glenn! I recommend this book to readers who love Amish fiction! Great book and I can't wait to see what happens next in Morning Star!
I received a complimentary copy from the author. All thoughts are my own.
March 29, 2021
Because of her past, Lydianne believes she can never marry. She has a secret she cannot reveal. But two men are interested in courting this young school teacher. She knows that if she confesses her sin, she will be shunned, and perhaps even asked to leave the community. When the bishop, one of her would-be suitors, guesses her secret, Lydianne, and the bishop, are forced to make some decisions. It’s a well written tale, peopled with interesting and likable characters. One minor storyline is left unfinished; perhaps it will addressed in a future book.
February 3, 2021
Charlotte Hubbard writes her characters in a way that they really come to life. I absolutely loved Lydianne and Jeremiah. Both characters have suffered loss in their pasts.
January 6, 2021
First Light in Morning Star by Charlotte Hubbard is a touching story of love and forgiveness.
The school board members are surprised when maidel Lydianne Christner applies for the teaching job at the new Morning Star school, but she seems sincere and no one else has even applied. Thrilled at the chance to teach, Lydianne knows the new life she has created can all come crashing down if anyone discovers her secret.
Bishop Jeremiah, a widower, admires how Lydianne manages her classroom and students. He is also curious about her past and the burdens she seems to carry with her. When his attempt to court her is rebuffed, he feels lonelier than ever.
An unexpected crisis finds Lydianne confessing to him, leaving Jeremiah with a choice that will require all his faith and understanding.
You know how much I love Hubbard's books, but this one has to be one of her finest. I love everything about it from beginning to end. I enjoyed this story so much that I stayed up late into the night reading regardless of the fact that I had an early morning meeting. I felt tired all day, but it was well worth the exhaustion.
The secret that brought Lydianne to Morning Star now presents some of the biggest challenges she has faced. By applying for the job as the new teacher, everyone at the school board is suddenly interested in her past and why she has applied despite having no previous teaching experience.
Then there is Bishop Jeremiah Shetler, who has been content living with his mother since the passing of his first wife. Though she has nudged him to find love again, he didn't feel much reason to and busied himself with looking after the spiritual needs of the residents of Morning Star. His sudden romantic feelings toward Lydianne perplex him, but when she rebuffs him he is determined to figure out what burdens her.
This second book in Hubbard's The Maidels of Morning Star series is even better than the first. Filling each page is the author's trademark compassion and grace as she weaves stories about residents of her imaginary communities and how they find love. It is a rare gift to be able to touch the heart the way Hubbard does with her novels. I can't tell you how much I admire and respect her talent. I highly anticipate the third book in this series, Christmas Comes to Morning Star, due out in August.
I don't hold on to many books these days after reading them, but I have kept every one of Hubbard's books. They are special treasures I cherish and hope to read again.
If you enjoy Amish fiction, First Light in Morning Star is a must read.
The school board members are surprised when maidel Lydianne Christner applies for the teaching job at the new Morning Star school, but she seems sincere and no one else has even applied. Thrilled at the chance to teach, Lydianne knows the new life she has created can all come crashing down if anyone discovers her secret.
Bishop Jeremiah, a widower, admires how Lydianne manages her classroom and students. He is also curious about her past and the burdens she seems to carry with her. When his attempt to court her is rebuffed, he feels lonelier than ever.
An unexpected crisis finds Lydianne confessing to him, leaving Jeremiah with a choice that will require all his faith and understanding.
You know how much I love Hubbard's books, but this one has to be one of her finest. I love everything about it from beginning to end. I enjoyed this story so much that I stayed up late into the night reading regardless of the fact that I had an early morning meeting. I felt tired all day, but it was well worth the exhaustion.
The secret that brought Lydianne to Morning Star now presents some of the biggest challenges she has faced. By applying for the job as the new teacher, everyone at the school board is suddenly interested in her past and why she has applied despite having no previous teaching experience.
Then there is Bishop Jeremiah Shetler, who has been content living with his mother since the passing of his first wife. Though she has nudged him to find love again, he didn't feel much reason to and busied himself with looking after the spiritual needs of the residents of Morning Star. His sudden romantic feelings toward Lydianne perplex him, but when she rebuffs him he is determined to figure out what burdens her.
This second book in Hubbard's The Maidels of Morning Star series is even better than the first. Filling each page is the author's trademark compassion and grace as she weaves stories about residents of her imaginary communities and how they find love. It is a rare gift to be able to touch the heart the way Hubbard does with her novels. I can't tell you how much I admire and respect her talent. I highly anticipate the third book in this series, Christmas Comes to Morning Star, due out in August.
I don't hold on to many books these days after reading them, but I have kept every one of Hubbard's books. They are special treasures I cherish and hope to read again.
If you enjoy Amish fiction, First Light in Morning Star is a must read.
September 27, 2020
First Light in Morning Star by Charlotte Hubbard is an amazing book that gives you a look into the lifestyle of Old Order Amish Life. Charlotte Hubbard draws on her experience with the largest Old Order Amish community West of the Mississippi. You can see from the writing that Charlotte Hubbard has a lot of experience with the Old Order Amish Life.
I love the use of the language used and showing of the lifestyle, the day to day tasks and just the simpler way of life without the electric and running around us Englischers are always doing.
The group of 5 Maidels have turned an old stable into when at called the Marketpace. It is a success and the Amish in the community and some who come from other communities come and sell their wares at the Marketplace.
On the same part of land a schoolhouse is built. Lydianne applies for the position of teacher, she's the only applicant and gets hired by the school board.
Lydianne came to Morning Star 6 year prior to this, she has kept her past a secret. She doesn't talk much about what happened before she came to Morning Star. She does have some secrets but doesn't share because the one might get her banned.
The Bishop of the community develops feelings for Lydianne, but Lydianne has already resigned herself to a life of being single because of her secret. The Bishop figures out the secret on his own but does forgive her. They start courting and the end of the book comes with a wonderful surprise!
This was a great book to read and I can't wait for the next one. We got a teaser for the next book and it looks amazing.
This is the 1st book I've read by Charlotte Hubbard and she quickly became one of my favorite authors. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and will definitely be reading more of Charlotte Hubbard.
Thank you to NetGalley and Kensington Publishing for the advanced copy of the book. In return I was asked to write a book with my honest opinion.
I love the use of the language used and showing of the lifestyle, the day to day tasks and just the simpler way of life without the electric and running around us Englischers are always doing.
The group of 5 Maidels have turned an old stable into when at called the Marketpace. It is a success and the Amish in the community and some who come from other communities come and sell their wares at the Marketplace.
On the same part of land a schoolhouse is built. Lydianne applies for the position of teacher, she's the only applicant and gets hired by the school board.
Lydianne came to Morning Star 6 year prior to this, she has kept her past a secret. She doesn't talk much about what happened before she came to Morning Star. She does have some secrets but doesn't share because the one might get her banned.
The Bishop of the community develops feelings for Lydianne, but Lydianne has already resigned herself to a life of being single because of her secret. The Bishop figures out the secret on his own but does forgive her. They start courting and the end of the book comes with a wonderful surprise!
This was a great book to read and I can't wait for the next one. We got a teaser for the next book and it looks amazing.
This is the 1st book I've read by Charlotte Hubbard and she quickly became one of my favorite authors. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and will definitely be reading more of Charlotte Hubbard.
Thank you to NetGalley and Kensington Publishing for the advanced copy of the book. In return I was asked to write a book with my honest opinion.
January 4, 2021
Read my review on NovelsAlive.com by clicking the link. It's also posted in full below.
https://novelsalive.com/2021/01/04/4-...
FIRST LIGHT IN MORNING STAR is the second book in the MAIDELS OF MORNING STAR series and it was a fast-paced read even at more than three hundred pages. I haven’t read the first book in the series but there was enough information provided that I felt I knew the characters and some of what had happened previously. The characters had a depth to them and I felt that I got to know them a little at a time.
This is Lydianne’s story along with her friends who were also single. There are several male characters vying for her attention but due to a secret from her past, she doesn’t think she’s worthy of ever marrying. The Bishop surprised me with his tolerance and understanding as well as his attraction to her since he is widowed and never had children. Their friendship had tongues wagging although he wanted more and Lydianne seemed surprised that he could be attracted to her. There are a lot of Amish words and beliefs throughout that added a realism to the story. There are social gatherings, both happy and sad, as well as the schoolhouse and The Marketplace that play a role. There are moments filled with worry and angst along with sadness and fear but others that were joyful and full of hope. The story had a nice flow to it but ended very abruptly although with a hint of a happily ever after. An epilogue would have given me the closure I look for. There was an excerpt from the next book in the series, CHRISTMAS COMES TO MORNING STAR. It whet my appetite for more and I look forward to reading it. The cover was nicely portrayed and was appropriate to the story.
Ms. Hubbard is a new to me author of her full-length novels. I may have read a story or two of hers previously in different anthologies.
https://novelsalive.com/2021/01/04/4-...
FIRST LIGHT IN MORNING STAR is the second book in the MAIDELS OF MORNING STAR series and it was a fast-paced read even at more than three hundred pages. I haven’t read the first book in the series but there was enough information provided that I felt I knew the characters and some of what had happened previously. The characters had a depth to them and I felt that I got to know them a little at a time.
This is Lydianne’s story along with her friends who were also single. There are several male characters vying for her attention but due to a secret from her past, she doesn’t think she’s worthy of ever marrying. The Bishop surprised me with his tolerance and understanding as well as his attraction to her since he is widowed and never had children. Their friendship had tongues wagging although he wanted more and Lydianne seemed surprised that he could be attracted to her. There are a lot of Amish words and beliefs throughout that added a realism to the story. There are social gatherings, both happy and sad, as well as the schoolhouse and The Marketplace that play a role. There are moments filled with worry and angst along with sadness and fear but others that were joyful and full of hope. The story had a nice flow to it but ended very abruptly although with a hint of a happily ever after. An epilogue would have given me the closure I look for. There was an excerpt from the next book in the series, CHRISTMAS COMES TO MORNING STAR. It whet my appetite for more and I look forward to reading it. The cover was nicely portrayed and was appropriate to the story.
Ms. Hubbard is a new to me author of her full-length novels. I may have read a story or two of hers previously in different anthologies.
December 21, 2020
First Light in Morning Star by Charlotte Hubbard is a thought-provoking Amish romance. This latest release is the second installment in The Maidels of Morning Star series, but can be read as a standalone.
Lydianne Christner has created a new life for herself and she is surrounded by supportive friends. She is a wonderful young woman but her past mistakes continue to haunt her. Knowing she will never marry, she is hoping the school board will hire for to teach the town's children. Lydianne is intelligent, caring and well-liked so she would be the perfect teacher. She also finds herself the object of Bishop Jeremiah Shetler's affections but she deeply regrets she cannot enter into a relationship with him. She is quite dismayed to learn that widower Glenn Detweiler is interested in her as well. With Lydianne's feelings for Jeremiah growing, how will he react when he discovers her secret?
Jeremiah has deeply grieved the loss of his beloved wife, Priscilla, but he is finally ready to think about remarrying. His interest in Lydianne has been steadily growing but he is intuitive enough to recognize her emotional walls. Although Jeremiah tries to keep his distance once she firmly turns him down, he continues to hope she will give him a chance. He is a wise and respected bishop who is understanding of those seeking his counsel. But what will Jeremiah recommend after learning what Lydianne has been keeping from everyone?
Lydianne and Jeremiah are wonderful people who are obedient to their faith and trust God with their problems. They genuinely care about the well-being of everyone within their community. Both Lydianne and Jeremiah's imperfections are perfectly balanced by their strengths. Lydianne cannot forgive herself for her previous transgression and she is grateful for the grace offered to her by Jeremiah and others. The aftermath of the startling revelations proves to be healing and life altering.
First Light in Morning Star is a heartfelt Amish romance with a storyline which features real life issues. The various characters are wonderfully developed and easy to like and many are dealing with realistic problems. The setting springs vibrantly to life and it is very easy to visualize the various town, businesses and homes. Charlotte Hubbard brings this marvelous romance to a endearing and uplifting conclusion. A fabulous addition to The Maidels of Morning Star series that old and new readers are sure to enjoy.
Lydianne Christner has created a new life for herself and she is surrounded by supportive friends. She is a wonderful young woman but her past mistakes continue to haunt her. Knowing she will never marry, she is hoping the school board will hire for to teach the town's children. Lydianne is intelligent, caring and well-liked so she would be the perfect teacher. She also finds herself the object of Bishop Jeremiah Shetler's affections but she deeply regrets she cannot enter into a relationship with him. She is quite dismayed to learn that widower Glenn Detweiler is interested in her as well. With Lydianne's feelings for Jeremiah growing, how will he react when he discovers her secret?
Jeremiah has deeply grieved the loss of his beloved wife, Priscilla, but he is finally ready to think about remarrying. His interest in Lydianne has been steadily growing but he is intuitive enough to recognize her emotional walls. Although Jeremiah tries to keep his distance once she firmly turns him down, he continues to hope she will give him a chance. He is a wise and respected bishop who is understanding of those seeking his counsel. But what will Jeremiah recommend after learning what Lydianne has been keeping from everyone?
Lydianne and Jeremiah are wonderful people who are obedient to their faith and trust God with their problems. They genuinely care about the well-being of everyone within their community. Both Lydianne and Jeremiah's imperfections are perfectly balanced by their strengths. Lydianne cannot forgive herself for her previous transgression and she is grateful for the grace offered to her by Jeremiah and others. The aftermath of the startling revelations proves to be healing and life altering.
First Light in Morning Star is a heartfelt Amish romance with a storyline which features real life issues. The various characters are wonderfully developed and easy to like and many are dealing with realistic problems. The setting springs vibrantly to life and it is very easy to visualize the various town, businesses and homes. Charlotte Hubbard brings this marvelous romance to a endearing and uplifting conclusion. A fabulous addition to The Maidels of Morning Star series that old and new readers are sure to enjoy.
January 13, 2021
I'm always excited to start a new series from Charlotte Hubbard, as I expect to meet a new group of characters in a new setting and then get to explore in detail the stories of some of the individuals in that group. First Light in Morning Star is an awesome second installment in her newest series and one of my favorites of her books.
The basic premise of the Morning Star series is a refreshing one. The Marketplace that was dreamed up and organized by a close group of young Amish women has brought new direction and success for them and many others in their community.
Lydianne, who is one of those maidels, has a story that is quite an intriguing one. Not surprising with this author, you will find much forgiveness and compassion, a great deal of that being what Lydianne has to show for herself. Following the developments in the story is captivating and somewhat emotional, as you just can't be sure what will come next.
Besides the major emphasis on Lydianne, there is plenty in the storyline to keep the interest level high in the other characters, with hopes of learning more about them in future stories. And as Charlotte Hubbard is known to do, she also gives her die-hard fans a chance to revisit old friends from one of her other series.
I highly recommend First Light in Morning Star to fans of great Amish fiction. Thanks to the author for providing a copy of the book. I am happy to share my own thoughts in this review.
The basic premise of the Morning Star series is a refreshing one. The Marketplace that was dreamed up and organized by a close group of young Amish women has brought new direction and success for them and many others in their community.
Lydianne, who is one of those maidels, has a story that is quite an intriguing one. Not surprising with this author, you will find much forgiveness and compassion, a great deal of that being what Lydianne has to show for herself. Following the developments in the story is captivating and somewhat emotional, as you just can't be sure what will come next.
Besides the major emphasis on Lydianne, there is plenty in the storyline to keep the interest level high in the other characters, with hopes of learning more about them in future stories. And as Charlotte Hubbard is known to do, she also gives her die-hard fans a chance to revisit old friends from one of her other series.
I highly recommend First Light in Morning Star to fans of great Amish fiction. Thanks to the author for providing a copy of the book. I am happy to share my own thoughts in this review.
January 27, 2021
I enjoyed the continuation of the story of the maidels of Morning Star. Without knowing the exact definition, but recognizing that the five young women were into their twenties or early thirties, I like the sound of maidels better than old maids. After all, they were not old. Each one seems to have her own reason for not marrying, but only God knows if such things are valid reasons: well, maybe God and Bishop Jeremiah. He seems to be a man with wisdom beyond his years. Either he was exceptionally wise, or simply had a way of convincing others that his ideas were best. Imagine how he felt when Lydianne rejected him and he got the impression she might be sweet on a younger man who was a recent widower with a loving little boy feeling the pain of losing his mother. Lydianne had a significant role in the previous book but she shines in this story as the new teacher of the new one-room school. Bishop Jeremiah called her Sunshine on several occasions. Maybe it was because of the way her blond hair shone in the sunlight, or maybe it was because of the way she conducted herself and was dearly loved by all her young students. I felt the story had just the right mix of faith, tension, romance, and just good old-fashioned Amish living.
May 23, 2025
'Where there's a woman, there's a way.' I've read this phrase in Charlotte Hubbard's novels a number of times now, and it always makes me smile. But as I finish this book, I realise that she's left out a few key words that her characters exhibit in each novel: 'Where there's a woman who trusts God, there's a way.'
This is the second novel in the series, and also the second time where a 'shun-worthy' secret has been part of the narrative. I think I like that about the author's work . . . not only does she write strong female characters, she's not afraid to tackle difficult topics with compassion and grace.
To be honest, I wasn't sure about Lydianne and Bishop Jeremiah together at first, but as their friendship solidified, I could see how she would be a blessing to him by bringing a certain lightness into his life, and he could be a safe place for her to rest, especially given her family's rejection 6 years prior.
I will say though, that Glenn's behaviour in the novel was a bit alarming, and bordering on territorial. I am choosing to chalk it up to the grief and stress he'd been feeling after the death of his wife, and hopeful that the next book will have him exhibiting kinder, gentler behaviour.
3.5 stars
This is the second novel in the series, and also the second time where a 'shun-worthy' secret has been part of the narrative. I think I like that about the author's work . . . not only does she write strong female characters, she's not afraid to tackle difficult topics with compassion and grace.
To be honest, I wasn't sure about Lydianne and Bishop Jeremiah together at first, but as their friendship solidified, I could see how she would be a blessing to him by bringing a certain lightness into his life, and he could be a safe place for her to rest, especially given her family's rejection 6 years prior.
I will say though, that Glenn's behaviour in the novel was a bit alarming, and bordering on territorial. I am choosing to chalk it up to the grief and stress he'd been feeling after the death of his wife, and hopeful that the next book will have him exhibiting kinder, gentler behaviour.
3.5 stars
September 14, 2020
This book carries on the story of the group of maidels in the first Morning Star book. The one featured this time is Lydianne Christner. She is the new teacher at the newly built schoolhouse. She used to work in the local furniture shop but recently applied for the open teaching position. Bishop Jeremiah Shetler, a widower, is taking a special interest in her. All the maidels got together and came up with the idea of turning an old barn into a marketplace. Now they all have stalls in the market as well as other local craftsman. The proceeds go to the fund their church uses to help members that have medical bills or other needs and also finance projects such as the new schoolhouse. Lydianne is also the bookkeeper for the market. This is a fun story that takes up the tale of the basically the whole village of Morning Star. I’m sure there will be more to the series. Charlotte Hubbard has a knack for making these characters real and interesting and making the reader feel part of the whole group.
I have voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from NetGalley. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
I have voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from NetGalley. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 64 reviews