The cover says it will use positive reinforcement - this is a lie. The book is entirely about using a different range of punishment tools to shove, push, force, correct, drag, coerce and bully dogs into the most basic and easy skills.
If the author can't teach a PUPPY how to SIT in an EMPTY ROOM WITH FOOD without also needing a collar, lead and manhandling. Then they should not be writing books on dog training.
In the book we have:
Anti-vaccination rants.
Raw feeding rants and chronically inability to stay in their lane and leave diet to the specialists.
Advocating to shake jars of pennies at dogs for sniffing.
15 pages of punishment tools and methods to use them, 2 pages on rewards. Those 2 pages are the most the book talks about rewards.
Dominance theory.
Fixation with electrics fences, the statistically most unreliable method of dog containment.
Although shout out for teaching me about some cruel and inhumane tools I didn't realise existed because I would be fined and banned from pets if I did that. Amazing creativity in finding new and unique ways to frighten and force dogs. Utter lack of that creativity applied to learning how to use food, toys or premack to train in happy and gentle ways.
On page 265 was the first item taught entirely with positive reinforcement and without starting/continuing/finishing/adding unnecessary punishment.
Friends and I had a huge laugh about the "teaching" sit section and how that method would absolutely teach your puppy to be hand-shy and reluctant to approach you. Quickly followed by a parody of "teaching touch" to teach your dog to approach you and not be afraid of touch. You made your own problem there with your poor training methods that rely on force. If you taught the sit with positive reinforcement your dog wouldn't be afraid of touch would it?
EVERYTHING in this book required a lead correction. EVERYTHING. Sits. Downs. Come. Leave It. This is Dog Training for Dummies and they've used the most ridiculously complicated methods of lead corrections and physical force to teach the basic skills of sit, drop, leave it, go to bed, recall. All things that are very easy to teach with rewards and much faster to get successful enthusiastic dog from. You could have a dog who understands the exercise from the very first rep with positive reinforcement but the book brags about dogs that stop moving (learned helplessness) after 5 or so corrections, like that's some kind of achievement?
Just another punishment trainer using positive reinforcement marketing to trick people into using punishment methods instead of teaching them what you want.
And no Linda, you're not "gently" controlling your dog when you are administering collar corrections with a collar set around the most sensitive part of the neck. You are rattling the brain about and jarring the neck. That's why they're not looking away from you, because they can't trust you.
I'm not including this book in my 2025 reading challenge because it is too shit to be counted.