After a short break following its first four standalone books, the Spine Shivers series returned with another four, and Do Not Watch is a definite improvement over its predecessors. Sam Valentine is a typical teen, except for his father's occupation as owner of New To You!, an antique shop that trafficks in weird and occasionally macabre collectibles. Sam is used to traveling with his father to purchase items for the shop, but he feels a chill when they pull up in their truck outside the home of Gregory Vincent, a recently deceased movie director famed for his gritty horror films. Mr. Valentine is excited about owning the director's writing desk, which Vincent's family is selling. It's an awkward item to carry out and load in the truck, but the desk is one of the biggest scores Mr. Valentine has had in the antique business. He couldn't be happier.
Before Mr. Valentine can thoroughly examine the desk, Sam glances through its drawers and finds a VHS tape. "The Gaunt Man. Only copy. Do not watch" is penned on the label. Was this an unreleased film of Vincent's? For some reason Sam doesn't want his father to see the tape, so he removes it and invites his friends, Olivia and Bashiir, to come watch it on a night when his parents aren't home. That requires a secret trip to New To You! to pick up a VCR, and on the way there Sam, Olivia, and Bashiir have the misfortune of running into Hudson Laudner, an older teen from the neighborhood who senses they're up to no good and threatens to tell Mr. Valentine if they don't include him in the fun. The four sit down at Sam's house for the premiere viewing of The Gaunt Man, which turns out to be a noirish horror flick about the infamous creepypasta monster whose mere presence causes people to fall ill and die. But Sam isn't frightened until the Gaunt Man stares out through the screen, as though looking directly at Sam, Olivia, Bashiir, and Hudson. They all feel uncomfortable, but this is just a movie that wasn't good enough to be made for real...right?
Bashiir shows up at school looking pale and sickly. He hasn't been able to sleep; the thin-faced, hollow-eyed Gaunt Man stalks him in his dreams, and Bashiir is panicked that he might never have a peaceful night again. The school nurse sends him home; Sam tries to communicate with his friend to confirm he's okay, but receives no response. When Olivia reports a similar dreamlike encounter with the Gaunt Man, and her health, too, swiftly declines, cold dread settles into Sam's stomach. The only ones left for the Gaunt Man to infect are Sam and Hudson. Sam eventually has his own surreal encounter with the Gaunt Man, and as his health fails, he clings to the last vestiges of clear thought in search of a solution. He saw a set of journals at Gregory Vincent's old house, journals bearing the same triangular symbol as the VHS tape. His parents won't believe him if he starts babbling about a cursed movie, but will Hudson drive him to Vincent's place to see if the journals describe how to stop the Gaunt Man? It's a race against insidious evil for the last two teens who viewed the forbidden film. Can Sam stymie the curse before it claims them all as victims?
The first four Spine Shivers books were below average, but Do Not Watch is genuinely creepy and the plot makes sense. No happy ending is guaranteed in this series, so we feel a real sense of doom as the Gaunt Man picks off the characters one by one. There's also a deeper theme to the story. Demons should be left alone, however thrilling it seems to mess with them; let one into your life and they're apt to dig in their claws and not let go until they destroy you. Better to flee from vice and endure mockery for it than be dragged into the abyss. Part of me wants to rate Do Not Watch two and a half stars; Neil Evans's artwork (he's credited as Nelson Evergreen in the first four Spine Shivers) is excellent as always, and the story offers suspense to the end. This is a pretty good middle-grade horror novel.