By way of introduction, I must say that Wizards of the Coast kindly sent me an advanced copy of this book in exchange for an honest review, and that I am a native Spanish speaker, reason why I ask the reader to excuse any mistakes that may be found in this review.
In a few words, I can say that the book is fun to read, and I do think that entertainment is an important part of literature. On the other hand, it is quite well written, and the depiction of different characters is brilliant: Drizzt is wonderful, as always, and so are Wulfgar, Regis, Artemis Entreri and the villains. The character of Catti-brie and some possible depictions of orcs and goblins are aspects I did not like so much, but the book is definitely one I recommend. In my opinion, Mr. Salvatore does not disappoint and the book is wonderful. In fact, some critical analyses of literature comment on the exchange of ideas that takes place when one reads a book, and some of the controversial aspects of the book did make me think about certain things, even if I disagree with some of the elements in the book, while I was enjoying the book, and I did enjoy it, a lot. I did not put the book down.
Drizzt Do'Urden is truly an iconic character, whose fame has surpassed the context of dungeons and dragons players. While some people do not like the character, I must say that I have always found him to be fascinating, and in fact he may be properly regarded as a current archetype of a heroic and tragic character, who strives to do what is right despite the adversity and even opposition from his friends -which is a theme dealt with in this book in some places and may be covered more fully in the future.
In light of what has been said, this book delivers and truly brings us a story in which the famous ethical drow does his best, even facing risks in order to help people in need even when they were former enemies, such as SPOILERS...
Artemis Entreri and Dahlia.
End of Spoilers.
The novel begins immediately after Salvatore's previous book, The Companions, and the reader will find the previous novel's characters. Unsurprisingly, I still like Regis very much, who is in my opinion a very interesting, likable and funny but not ridiculous character. Another of Drizzt's companions from the previous era, Wulfgar, returns, as was shown at the end of 'the Companions', and while I am generally not fond of barbarian characters, Salvatore depicts him in a very interesting and wiser way that makes him an interesting character. On the other hand, I must confess that a character I did not like in the preceding novel much and still don't like at all is that of Catti-Brie. While not portrayed in such an 'almighty' magical way in the novel under review (although despite her lack of physical fighting training her handling the bow somewhat good seems a bit stretched, making the criticism of characters in the novels as invincible that I have read elsewhere somewhat credible), Drizzt's wife has two negative traits: she decides to kill someone outright because of her being possessed, without trying to capture her or somehow make others pursue her and take her to a priest who could perform an exorcism, and she advocates the breach of a peace treaty and labels all orcs and globlinoids as irredeemable evil. While later on the reader will see possible justifications for self-defense because
SPOILERS:
The drow seem to be manipulating an orc nation to attack neighboring realms
END of spoilers
Catti-Brie's opinion is that even orc babies can be legitimately killed, given the opinion that their nature is utterly evil, which she claims was shown to her by Mielikki, the goddess she follows. My problem with this is how this claim is contrary to an underlying idea that made previous Drizzt books so endearing: that of how even those belonging to communities where misdeeds are encouraged or forced upon may rise above circumstances and be good or convert, which may teach young readers to overcome discrimination of, for instance, some foreigners, which in my opinion is important nowadays -and actually, always has been-, given how some countries are stigmatized and labelled as populated by wrongdoers. Tolerance is something that the book does not inspire in this case, except for the opinion of Drizzt, which the book hints may be wrong. This is something I miss.
Perhaps this has to do with the idea of whether dungeons and dragons players are justified to kill orcs and monsters, but it has the following implications: orcs and goblins are intelligent and mortal beings. According to some beliefs in Earth, certain immortal beings chose evil once and for good, and thus truly stick to their evil. We are however talking of mortal entities whose intelligence may give them free will.
Moreover, attacking the orcs out of fear of a possible future attack seems too similar to the doctrine of preemptive self-defense that the UK and US administrations espoused some years ago, which has been described as openly contrary to international law, as written by different scholars, the United Nations and even in the British Parliament recently. The idea of books as inspiring good deeds, which the great Russian author Tolstoy advocated and that Lewis followed in his Narnia novels, makes me dislike these aspects of the book -I am aware that some schools of literature disagree with this, but it is an opinion I agree with.
Moving on to great things about the book, I must say that Salvatore is an excellent writer, who engages readers and captivates them. Curiously, his depiction of the drow plots and of characters as Entreri, Dahlia or Gromph were my favorite ones, given how they did not have success guaranteed and because he weaves intrigue perfectly in his book. Actually, that side of the plot seemed more interesting than the quest of the companions of the hall, which was a straightforward rescue operation. The problem is how these companions seemed beyond the option of defeat, especially considering the reputation of drow as deadly. I was also not so fond of constant descriptions of goblins being massacred. That being said, the author does narrate a big drow victory over defeated dwarves in the north, which surprised me and others.
In sum, I would like to say that I love the heroes winning the day, and certainly the novel brings us back to previous eras of the Forgotten Realms full of adventure, and the novel excels in that. However, I miss stressing tolerance and how all races can be good, and I hope that in the next book Drizzt manages a diplomatic move that brings peace, but I find it unlikely. Moreover, risk of defeat makes victory more interesting, but I never felt the main characters were in real danger. I must say that I applaude Salvatore's writing style, and really loved most of the characters and the plot of the villains. Jarlaxle, Entreri, Drizzt, Regis and Wulfgar are engrossing and fascinating characters, and I definitely want to read the next book, but hope that Catti-Brie is proved wrong and that both she and Bruenor are shown as more humble somehow. I simply fear that young readers may be led to endorse ideas that certain nations are evil, and hope that the next book allays such fears of mine.
Altogether, the book is very well written and fun, and most characters are interesting, but some of the approaches to dilemmas presented in the book offer a picture that may be at odds with what I found interesting in previous Drizzt books. Logically, tastes may vary, but what I can say for sure is that the next book in the series will certainly be quite interesting and I definitely look forward to reading it. At least I expect Drizzt's altruism and greatness to continue. His character did not disappoint at all in this book, and I loved his depiction.