Richard Buckner has been one of my favorite musicians since I first saw him in 2000 at Davey’s Uptown Ramblers Club in Kansas City, Missouri. He was touring behind his new album, “The Hill,” in which he’d set the poems from Edgar Lee Masters’ 1915 “Spoon River Anthology” to music. (We should have known then he had grander artistic intentions.) I saw him every chance I could, which was often, as he seemed to come through Kansas City every six months or so over the next few years. The music was always strong, but it became increasingly clear that he didn’t much enjoy performing for people — or maybe just Kansas City crowds, who certainly weren’t the most reverent. In any case, he eventually turned to house shows, which, though I haven’t seen him at one, is probably the perfect setting for him and his music.
All of that to say, I’m a fan. I’m guessing that’s how most of us found our way to “Cuttings From the Tangle,” Richard Buckner’s first book of poetry — or “non-fiction clippings in prepared formations” as the book’s back cover reads or “story-like poems” as Black Sparrow Press states on their website. Call it what you want, but my first, unadorned thought when I’d finished was, “Wow, what a pile of shit.” That’s probably unfair, and it’s why I didn’t open up the review with that line without a little context. It’s also relative: one man’s shit is another’s Shinola. Buckner certainly has a way with words. These poems are evocative, the language sinewy and seductive (e.g. “the thicket between subtle / inference and stealthy intention / standing silently-being / mere stresses spit out / smooth as grits piecemeal-sporked / with a margarine nipple melting / to mask the coarse-grain bite”). But they’re also abstract and obtuse, impenetrable beneath a stream-of-consciousness, everything-and-the-kitchen-sink style that throws a lot down on the page but never gets past “feel” to meaning. In short: there’s balls but no heart. “Cuttings From the Tangle” reads like the ramblings of a misanthrope, up too late on cough syrup and Camels, pounding away at a typewriter in the window of a shabby walkup in Midtown U.S.A., bemusing, bemoaning, bewailing — but never loving — all us sinners and this thing we call life.