Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Mac Faraday Mystery #14

Came Upon a Midnight Murder

Rate this book
Appears to have had a Title change to Shadow of Murder

Unknown Binding

First published March 30, 2022

53 people are currently reading
36 people want to read

About the author

Lauren Carr

53 books401 followers
Lauren Carr is the international best-selling author of the Mac Faraday, Lovers in Crime, and Thorny Rose Mysteries—over twenty titles across three fast-paced mystery series filled with twists and turns!

Book reviewers and readers alike rave about how Lauren Carr’s seamlessly crosses genres to include mystery, suspense, romance, and humor.

Lauren is a popular speaker who has made appearances at schools, youth groups, and on author panels at conventions. She lives with her husband, and three dogs on a mountain in Harpers Ferry, WV.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
136 (62%)
4 stars
51 (23%)
3 stars
19 (8%)
2 stars
7 (3%)
1 star
6 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 28 of 28 reviews
Profile Image for Sherry Fundin.
2,311 reviews162 followers
June 1, 2022
Deputy Chief Dustin O’Meara, his daughter, father in law and four women were murdered in a home invasion and Mac Faraday is on the case. Because of that, the perp needs to be very nervous because Mac always gets his man.

“To the animal behind this, I want to say only one thing. I’m coming for you…and I will find you.”

Lots of great characters, human and animal both.

Teddy is a hero, a cockatoo with an attitude, and I love him. I love Kourtney too. This ten year old girl is such a fabulous character, older than her years. Gnarly always cracks me up with his hijinks. Erica, the Cold Case Diva, has a horse in a dog suit. How cool is that?

Mac may need some help, so the Nancy Drew Crew is on the case. They even made Kourtney a Junior member.

Lauren is so creative and adds a touch of humor to her murder, and I found myself smiling….a lot, sometimes laughing out loud. There is so much I want to share about the critters, but I must leave it up to you to find out why I love them so much.

I have been reading the Mac Faraday series for a long time now, but Shadow of Murder is not one of my favorites. I enjoyed the story, but I got bogged down with so many characters and so much info that I kept getting lost. This is an ARC, not a finished product, so changes may be made, creating a more polished version that the one I read.

So many plots, so many suspects, some murder, some laughs, some romance.

For a police procedural, Shadow of Murder was filled with action and a battle between good and evil and a wild ride at the end, making it all worth it.

I voluntarily reviewed an ARC of Shadow of Murder by Lauren Carr.

Profile Image for Lindsay.
607 reviews24 followers
June 7, 2022
Are you looking for some fun cold cases to solve? Maybe even a bit of mystery to solve with a twist. Lauren Carr's latest book "Shadow of Murder" does just that. We get a prologue full of mystery and murder. You will be wondering how a gunman kills an entire family. Is it real, or is it not. You will have to read or listen to find out for yourself.

This book had me going and wondering who would kill a whole family, including a law officer. There are a few main characters. We meet two of them right at the beginning of the story. Erica and Dusty.

I love the fact that mysteries are going on throughout the book. I enjoy that Erica and her friends seem to need to help the new local deputy chief. David gets some time with his wife and newborn. I recall David meeting a woman and a little boy I thought was introduced to him as his son?

Mac is pulled into a Chao once he returns from Europe with Archie. His son Tristain brings to life the disappearance of a missing person, a woman named Konnor Langston. Why did she disappear? It goes on from there. There are many mysteries and curses and stories of witches as the book goes on. I wonder who killed Erica's parents and why? Who taking advance of Larry? Why were Erica Hart's parents killed, and will Erica get justice for her childhood friend Konnor?

If you are looking for a good versus evil? This book has it. Once a dark shadow tries to harm Erica. Dusty seems to fall for a bird guiding him to help Erica. Will Erica and Dusty get together? There may be some romance for more than just two folks in the book. How will Dusty's father-law decide to find some love as well? There seems to be the talk of angels and demons? They're a bit supernatural in this book; that is a nice change to the story.
Profile Image for Marilyn Wilson.
Author 4 books59 followers
March 30, 2022
This newest title in the author's Mac Faraday cozy murder mystery series offers Carr's most intricate plot to date - full of twists and turns guaranteed to keep readers up until the wee hours. While still full of the humor, fun critters and touch of romance that are her trademark, the author has also woven in a dark supernatural element that whispers through to the startling ending.

In Shadow of Murder, Mac, Archie and Gnarly (what a great name for a dog) meet a brand new sleuth, "Cold Case Diva" Erica Hart. Erica, who runs a cold case podcast, has decided to move back to Deep Creek Lake after the unexpected death of her husband. She was warned pre-move to be careful as there was a dark threatening presence that could be a danger, and that proved right as she almost ended up at the bottom of the lake while driving up to the family home. I love this new character - and her love interest Dusty and her very unique pets. I hope they continue to make an appearance in future books.

What follows is a plot full of twists and turns that are like a maze where you can only see to the next corner. How Carr keeps all these threads straight and working together I don't know, but she does it beautifully. The dark, supernatural element woven into this story was a total surprise, her first novel featuring it. But don't worry, the fun and romance and full-of-personality pets still hold court.

While Shadow of Murder was a little long for me to consume in one day by reading until three in the morning, I struggled every time to put it down. I wanted to KNOW where it would all end up.
27 reviews
April 6, 2022
Another Winner and nail biter!

The detail, the characters both animal and human kept the book flowing!! I recommend this book to all mystery lovers. Now to wait impatiently for her next book!
Profile Image for Suzette Edwards.
249 reviews
April 17, 2022
Shadow of Murder

The author had me captured from the beginning to the end. The book had so many twists and turns I couldn't stop reading it. Omg it was totally amazing! I recommend this book most definitely.
11 reviews
April 15, 2022
Another excellent book by Lauren Carr!

I loved he plot line of good vs evil. As always, Gnarly has the upper paws in finding a lose thread in a stuck mystery.
6,167 reviews
May 25, 2022
Shadow of Murder is yet another fabulous read by Lauren Carr. I read and enjoyed previous books from her Mac Faraday Mystery series and was excited to have the opportunity to read the newest release and fourteenth installment from the series. I was far from being disappointed. I have to admit, I am a lover of covers and I adored the cover and was intrigued to see what it would be all about. Oh my goodness, I thought it was great. It was fun meeting up with Erica and Dusty. They made a fun and entertaining team together. Of course, I was excited to see Mac and Gnarly, too. I wanted to find out how the mystery would be solved and see who the one responsible is. You can not read a Carr novel without the twists, turns and surprises. I loved everything about it – the setting, the humor, the characters and plot. I had to keep on reading on to the end. Such a wonderful tale to read.

I would give Shadow of Murder one hundred stars if I could. I highly recommend it for readers who enjoy reading cozy mysteries. I will be looking forward to reading more books in the Mac Faraday Mysteries series. This one is one that should not be missed. I know others will not regret it.

I received a digital copy of Shadow of Murder from the publisher, but was not required to write a positive review. This review is one hundred percent my own honest opinion.
Profile Image for Meagan Myhren-Bennett.
Author 30 books162 followers
July 10, 2022
Shadow of Murder
A Mac Faraday Mystery #14
By Lauren Carr

Police Chief David O’Callaghan is out of town on paternity leave and in his absence, a murder and cold case are left to the capable hands of Mac Faraday, who is just back from a year abroad, and Deputy Police Chief Dusty O’Meara.

True crime blogger, Erica Hart has returned to Deep Creek Lake to call her old family home her current home. But nothing goes as it should, starting with a near-death accident. This allows the "Cold Case Diva" to meet Dusty, soon the two are working together to get answers as bodies start to pile up. Can they get the answers they need before the killer makes them the newest cold case in Spenser, Maryland?

Shadow of Murder has multiple layers that need to be peeled back. There are several obvious suspects but it all seems a little too obvious. Unless it isn't. And with each new twist, it will take everyone working together to get the answers they need if they want to bring a killer to justice.

Now everything isn't all serious as Triston Faraday is remodeling his newly purchased home and let's just say his hired help is of the less than stellar variety - Anything For Beer. And anyone knows if your "hired" help works for beer it might be a little on the questionable side of good. And then there is an unfortunate case of "estate borrowing" that may leave you with a flushing to your face.

Now I enjoyed this book in the audio format, which was narrated by Mike Alger. I found the narration to be well done, though I did play it back 1.4 times its normal playback speed. I listened to it at the pace I would have been reading it in print. At the default speed, this book comes in at approximately 17-1/2 hours of listening - perfect for a week of commuting, exercise, or chores.

No Mac Faraday book would be complete without Gnarly, and Spenser's canine mayor is present though in a limited capacity but enough to bring his unique charm to the book. But there is a new character who is sure to be a new favorite - Teddy who is a well-feathered individual who I'd love to have in more books.

This book has a bit of a difference from the other books in the series as there is a spiritual element throughout. Good vs Evil has taken up residence in Spenser and they have a fight for their lives on their hands in addition to their case.

I was provided a complimentary copy of this book with no expectations but that I provide my honest opinion, all thoughts expressed are my own.
Profile Image for Julie Howard.
Author 2 books31 followers
June 5, 2022
I loved this latest instalment in the Mac Faraday series. The book starts with a surprise opening and you are left wondering did I just hear that right? Then it goes back in time to explain what lead up to the event that has you so stunned. It may sound confusing but boy does it keep you hooked wondering what happened or is going to. Mac, Gnarly and the gang are all there but this book focuses more on the new Deputy Chief Dusty and an old case. I do have to say that Gnarly (Mac's loveable dog) does take a step back, he is still full of his usual mischief but a talking parrot steals the spot light and provides some of the best laughs. The book also takes on a super natural feel to it but somehow it works and is just as entertaining as previous books. The mystery is good and like the previous books it never turns out quite like you think it is going to do. I really like this author and am so glad I discovered her because it doesn't matter which series you are reading or listening to just know it is going to be good and you are going to be entertained with a good mystery and a few laughs along the way. Can't wait for the next book.
A true crime blogger Erica has decided to return to her old home town after the death of her husband with her trusted and loyal pets. Returning home isn't so easy when that was the place your parents were killed years ago and you are returning to the abandoned home and accident also nearly stops her in her tracks. At the same time a body is discovered in a filled in swimming pool and with the victim quick identified, Erica not only knows the victim but she was the one to report her missing. A connection between the two cases is established but Erica's parents death was open and shut, wasn't it? The only way to find out, is for Erica to start up the Nancy Drew gang. Can she and her old school friends solve the murder? Or will a shadowy tell stand in there way of uncovering long buried secrets.
I liked the narrator. He is entertaining and uses different ways to voice his characters.
I was given this free review copy audiobook at my request and have voluntarily left this review.
481 reviews12 followers
April 1, 2022
This on was much anticipated. I love the Mac Faraday Series and when I heard a new one was coming I couldn't wait!

As always Author Lauren Carr does not disappoint!

The combination of humor and mystery is always fun and makes for a freat page turner.

This series has alot of characters and several new characters were added.

The author provides the reader with a list of the cast.

For the fan that has read several the cast in this series and all of Carr's series become friends.

I enjoy as the townsfolk of Spencer continue to grow.

Even sub characters weave in and out if the scenes.

Having read several books in the series I am familiar with the style of writing and plot.

The shenanigans of the Mayor at times make you laugh till you cry.

That's because he is a dog. That is a kleptomanic and and military trained to find bodies and digs them up.

Much to the chagrin of his owner Mac Faraday. Gnarly said Dog/Mayor doesn't have a real sense of the appropriate time or place to deliver the found bones.

Shadow of Murder has several stories and plots that are woven together.

A Cold Case, a few murders, several suspects. But a few get knocked off leaving the reader scratching his head along with a few of the characters that just knew who the villain is.

The title also includes a little hint about the outcome.

I have lots of theories and questions wondering if Carr will surprise us with a new spin off series.

I enjoyed the characters.

And I enjoyed some of the regulars being apart of the story.

I missed a couple though. And I have my fingers crossed and hoping for a new Thorny Rose soon.

I received a complimentary copy.
Profile Image for Stormy McDonald.
Author 7 books7 followers
September 13, 2022
As a long-time fan of Mrs. Carr, I have read most, if not all, of her works. The author has a gift for characters, and I have always loved the inclusion of pets as characters in the various mysteries. Unlike other reviewers, I did not mind the supernatural elements new to this series. I rather enjoyed them. I simply wish the author hadn't lumped all non-Christian belief systems into the evil category.

Shadow of Murder was a convoluted mystery with a more branches and moving parts than past Mac Faraday mysteries. To be honest, it had five primary mysteries and added a sixth before finding the proof of the behind-the-scenes mastermind (who all the main characters suspected from the start). That's a LOT going on in 500 pages.

All that being said, Shadow of Murder was not up to the same standard as the author's previous mysteries. I did not enjoy the religious bigotry of the characters (another element new to this series) and the mislabeling of religious practices. Wicca is not the same as Satanism, and neither are the same as demon worship.

There were also an unusual number of typos, repeated words, and general editing issues. (I'm still puzzling over the use of 'imodium' in place of 'ammonium' when referring to fertilizer ingredients.) In most cases, they were minor distractions - I've seen much worse in other books - but we don't normally see these types of editing issues in Mrs. Carr's books. I understand things get missed during the editing process - no matter how many times you've read a work, it seems you always find something you missed last time through - so this won't deter me from reading the next Mac Faraday mystery.
Profile Image for Leila.
581 reviews9 followers
April 6, 2022
The suspects. The crimes. The murders. The history. The people. The paranormal. It had it all.

It was a little overwhelming with all the goings on – the different murders; the past coming back to haunt the present; the different theories; all the people – past and present; the players – a whole lot of everything going on, but dang if it didn’t all come together in a neat little package.

There was quite a bit going on Shadow of Murder – a little romance, some murders, a little paranormal activity, some evil, some light – a little bit of everything. It definitely kept me on my toes and kept me turning the page to figure out if any of the theories that the characters and myself were correct. Needless to say, I didn’t figure it out right away and was adamant that I had it down, but like usual, Lauren kept the mystery up until the end.

I have said it before and I will say it again; I love a good puzzling mystery! Shadow of Murder did not disappoint! I didn’t see any of the truth coming until it was revealed – just the way I like it!

I am a huge fan of Lauren Carr and her writing. I have read several Mac Faraday books (and others). My goal is to read all of the books, in order, one day. They are definitely in my top 3 for favorite mysteries!

And who can’t love Gnarly, as well his relationship with Mac.
Profile Image for Dawn.
1,571 reviews19 followers
June 15, 2022
I chose to read this book after receiving a free e-copy from iRead Book Tours. All opinions in this review are my own and completely unbiased.

I have read all of the Mac Faraday books by Lauren Carr. This is the fourteenth book in the series. What a great series!

So much is happening in this book with murders 20 years ago, 12 years ago, and in the present. I was shocked at the beginning, and the first couple of chapters grabbed my attention. As I read on, it was still interesting but not unputdownable like many of Lauren Carr’s books. I’ve been trying to figure out why, and I think it’s because there was less action and more discussion about what had happened.

I thought I might have figured some things out which isn’t normal when I read the Mac Faraday books. I was wrong. There are many twists along the way before they figure everything out.

There are quite a few characters which is usual. There is a list of characters at the front of the book, though, which usually helps. I had a little trouble keeping everyone straight this time for some reason. I liked Erica Hart and her pets, and I hope that she’s in future books. Her cockatoo, Teddy, is hilarious.

I definitely recommend Shadow of Murder. Like other books in this series, it has murder mysteries, intrigue, romance, humor, and even some supernatural.
Profile Image for Amy’s Booket List.
353 reviews15 followers
Read
June 10, 2022
Another charming cozy mystery by Lauren Carr. I didn’t realize until I got into the audiobook how long it has been and how much I missed her characters.

The Mac Faraday series is chock full of quirky, original, and undeniably lovable personalities, even those of a furry persuasion. Infact, as usual, Gnarly steals the show in almost every scene he’s in. Found myself listening to the book while cuddling my pup just because.

I particularly loved the multiple murder mystery plot lines. Not only was Mac solving a new murder, but a cold case as well. Then the cold case turns red hot with new information and some new characters. Erica and Dusty quickly became a favorite couple of mine.

A cold case blogger and a detective, what could be more perfect?

I have to tell you this book is a bit, the audiobook clocking in at over 17 hours. However, this story had me guessing every minute and the twists came out of seemingly mundane scenes. Sometimes funny, sometimes murderous, but always entertaining.

Conclusion
Shadow of Murder is another great cozy mystery by Lauren Carr. Sometimes funny, sometimes murderous, but always entertaining.
Profile Image for Brent Soderstrum.
1,650 reviews23 followers
December 14, 2024
This is the 14th Mac Faraday book by Lauren Carr 4.

I like Carr's mysteries, but this one, not so much. Carr takes the spiritual evil route, which I think is an easy way out for a mystery writer. Other examples are the supernatural and the mafia.

We have two new characters who move into Deep Creek Lake. Dusty O'Meara is the new Deputy Chief of Police, moving from Montana to help cover for David O'Callahan who is on paternity leave. The second new main character is Erica Hart. Erica is known as the Cold Case Diva. She is a blogger who helps solve cold cases and true crimes. She is returning to Deep Creek Lake. Her parents were murdered 20 years ago. Dusty and Erica hook up to solve murders that are taking place in Deep Creek Lake and romance evolves.

Joining the new characters are many of the old and familiar ones including Mac Faraday, his wife Archie Monday, and Gnarly, the mayor of Deep Creek Lake.

Evil spirits, angels, churches burning down, and witchcraft are all involved in a complex story with lots of characters and murders. All tied up at the very end by Carr.

Get back to reality, please.
Profile Image for Gina  Rae Mitchell.
1,357 reviews98 followers
June 22, 2022
Shadow of Murder is book fourteen of the Mac Faraday series from Lauren Carr.

This series just keeps getting better and better. Someday soon, I need to read them all in order.

I read the audiobook version of this tale and it was wonderful. The character representation and voice work of the narrator, Mike Alger fits perfectly for this story.

Lauren Carr weaves storylines together like no other author I’ve read. With a plethora of characters included in this tale, Mac and Gnarley are still my favorites. I did enjoy the newest residents of the town and the way they interacted with long-time faves.

There are many twists and turns throughout the story. I have to admit, I was a little surprised by most of them. This entry in the Mac Faraday series feels a bit darker but nevertheless, it’s still typical Lauren Carr gripping fiction.

I can’t wait to read the next in the series.

I received a digital download of the audiobook for a book blog tour. This review is my honest, unbiased opinion.
Profile Image for Jessica.
553 reviews1 follower
June 24, 2022
My newest favorite book from Ms. Lauren

I know when I read any books from Ms. Lauren that I won't be disappointed. The Shadow Of Murder is my newest favorite book of hers. It is a mind-blowing, funny, beautiful friendship and romance.

Teddy is one funny character. He is just the most adorable bird. He is one of my favorite characters.

The Shadow Of Murder has a little science fiction which makes the story more complex in a very good way. Ms. Carr's book is always hard to put down. Once you start reading, you are doomed. This story is so emotional, gut-wrenching, and unforgettable. Evil people will never win. They will always have an end. It might not be right away but it will end eventually. It has been a while since I read books from Ms. Carr, the fan in me is so excited and she never stops to amaze me. This book is one of a kind.
Profile Image for The Page Ladies Book Club.
1,807 reviews114 followers
June 7, 2022
Shadow of Murder is a classic good vs evil with twists and turns, romance, action and some good laughs! The action starts from the very beginning and doesn't end. It was nice to get back into the Mac Faraday series. The characters were fun and it was entertaining and fun to follow Erica and Dusty. They made a great team! I've read other books by Lauren Carr and I always find it easy to get lost in her books and this one was no different making this an easy read for me. The one thing that did surprise me was the supernatural element. I don't think I've ever read a book from her with it! If you like cosy mysteries with a little bit of everything you'll enjoy this one!
Profile Image for Misty.
498 reviews241 followers
June 15, 2022
Shadow of Murder (A Mac Faraday Mystery Book 14) by Lauren Carr was amazing! I can not believe that this series already has 14 books in it and that I have read them all! While it is truly hard to pick a favorite I have to say that this one is probably my favorite (so far). I liked seeing Deputy Chief Dusty O’Meara as the lead of the murder, especially since it was his first one to solve. I really liked the way he interacted with the different characters like Mac and Gnarly as well as the addition of blogger Erica Hart.

Profile Image for Jane Cairns.
99 reviews6 followers
June 2, 2022
Why did Konnor Langston suddenly disappear while helping clean out Harvey Donahue's house? Mac Faraday and Dusty O'Meara intend to find out with help from Erica Hart, the Cold Case Diva. Good characterization, especially since there is a village full of busybodies and feuding in-laws. Read Shadow of Murder to find out who killed Konnor Langston and disposed of her body in an in-ground swimming pool that was set to be filled in and covered over with soil.

I received a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
1 review
October 31, 2022
#14 a real clunker

After 13 good ones, this one was a real clunker. I’ve read the first 13 Faraday books and liked them a lot. I read, on average, 30 books per year. I really like series, such as this one. But this one was boring, repetitive and way too long. Just dragged on forever. I’m hoping if there’s a #15 it will be like the first thirteen.
Profile Image for Jenna.
413 reviews16 followers
July 27, 2022
Another interesting story of a man running away for privacy, another hiding out due to something he did, and a wanna be writer that holds a grudge against a man from something that happened almost a century ago dealing with his family.
690 reviews3 followers
November 5, 2024
Shadow of Murder audiobook

It has been awhile since I have read a Mac Faraday book and I was excited to have a new one to read. Story started off fast and kept the pace going until 3/4 of the way through the book. Then it became bizarre; I am NOT a paranormal fan. Very disappointed.
78 reviews
June 29, 2022
Curse and Portion

I am usually a Mac Faraday Mystery book lover. However I was a bit disappointed with this book. The introduction to new characters were done well being weave into the storyline. It did have action and who did it twist plots still.
Not a fan of the occult storyline.
8 reviews
February 5, 2023
Good Book

I couldn't put this one down. It was the best one yet. Can't wait for the next book. This whole series is great.
164 reviews3 followers
July 20, 2022
Usually I love The Mac Faraday series, but this one not one. This book had too many storylines and too many characters. It was difficult to follow, but was also very predictable. Gnarly wasn’t up to his usual pranks either.
2 reviews
May 23, 2023
hard to put down

If you love a mystery with twists and turns pick out a Lauren Carr book. But be warned….her books are consuming lol. Kept me up at night and reading instead of eating during lunch hour.
Displaying 1 - 28 of 28 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.