What do you think?
Rate this book
Strong Objections to the Lady
A tale of…
Intrigue & Inheritance…
Meddling & Manipulation…
Sisterhood & Self-Improvement...
When Lady Catherine de Bourgh learns of Mr. Darcy’s proposal to Elizabeth Bennet, her wrath sets in motion a series of events at Hunsford Parsonage which embroil Darcy and Elizabeth in a family fracas that grows more complicated daily.
The shades of Rosings Park are soon polluted by the shocking transformation of its new mistress and her guests, as well as secrets of the past and schemes for the future.
Appearances and alliances shift amidst the chaos wrought by a well-intentioned house party, and Darcy and Elizabeth must finally face their feelings for one another despite mounting obstacles and misunderstandings of every kind.
Intrigue & Inheritance…
Meddling & Manipulation…
Sisterhood & Self-Improvement...
When Lady Catherine de Bourgh learns of Mr. Darcy’s proposal to Elizabeth Bennet, her wrath sets in motion a series of events at Hunsford Parsonage which embroil Darcy and Elizabeth in a family fracas that grows more complicated daily.
The shades of Rosings Park are soon polluted by the shocking transformation of its new mistress and her guests, as well as secrets of the past and schemes for the future.
Appearances and alliances shift amidst the chaos wrought by a well-intentioned house party, and Darcy and Elizabeth must finally face their feelings for one another despite mounting obstacles and misunderstandings of every kind.
366 pages, Kindle Edition
First published December 21, 2019
147 people are currently reading
92 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 50 reviews
December 24, 2019
Freedom begins between the ears. ~ Edward Abbey
Anne de Bourgh has suffered under a giant thumb all her life. What would she do if the thumb suddenly disappeared?
The story begins in Kent when Lady Catherine de Bourgh overhears her nephews discussing Fitzwilliam Darcy’s proposal and the letter Darcy intends to deliver. The great lady sets out to encounter Elizabeth Bennet in Rosings’ woods and retrieve the letter. Confrontation between the women stresses the older woman’s already weakened heart and she falls to the ground. Elizabeth runs for help but rescue attempts are unsuccessful and the esteemed patroness is gone.
Colonel Fitzwilliam breaks the news to Anne, who has grieved for her father and her older sister, Isabel. Instead of grief for her mother, Anne rejoices in her freedom. A bold, spirited Anne emerges from her quiet, sickly cocoon.
Freedom means choosing your burden. ~ Hephzibah Menuhin
Determined to be her own woman, Anne learns of the financial hardships Rosings faces. She insists on being in charge of her estate. Jane and Elizabeth Bennet will reside at Rosings with Anne while her Cousins, Darcy and the Colonel, school her and Jane Bennet on the complexities of estate management.
Other family members arrive and a competition ensues for the hand of the new heiress. Eventually the house party includes five eligible gentlemen and an equal number of eligible ladies. Add in a Grandmother and an Aunt and canon pairings are upset entirely – almost.
Although Anne is the driving force in the story, Elizabeth and Jane come in for plenty of romance of their own. I especially liked the unusual ending for the Lydia/Wickham episode.
Dialogue is a strong suit for this author. I recommend the book to anyone who enjoys JAFF.
You have freedom when you’re easy in your harness. ~ Robert Frost
Anne de Bourgh has suffered under a giant thumb all her life. What would she do if the thumb suddenly disappeared?
The story begins in Kent when Lady Catherine de Bourgh overhears her nephews discussing Fitzwilliam Darcy’s proposal and the letter Darcy intends to deliver. The great lady sets out to encounter Elizabeth Bennet in Rosings’ woods and retrieve the letter. Confrontation between the women stresses the older woman’s already weakened heart and she falls to the ground. Elizabeth runs for help but rescue attempts are unsuccessful and the esteemed patroness is gone.
Colonel Fitzwilliam breaks the news to Anne, who has grieved for her father and her older sister, Isabel. Instead of grief for her mother, Anne rejoices in her freedom. A bold, spirited Anne emerges from her quiet, sickly cocoon.
Freedom means choosing your burden. ~ Hephzibah Menuhin
Determined to be her own woman, Anne learns of the financial hardships Rosings faces. She insists on being in charge of her estate. Jane and Elizabeth Bennet will reside at Rosings with Anne while her Cousins, Darcy and the Colonel, school her and Jane Bennet on the complexities of estate management.
Other family members arrive and a competition ensues for the hand of the new heiress. Eventually the house party includes five eligible gentlemen and an equal number of eligible ladies. Add in a Grandmother and an Aunt and canon pairings are upset entirely – almost.
Although Anne is the driving force in the story, Elizabeth and Jane come in for plenty of romance of their own. I especially liked the unusual ending for the Lydia/Wickham episode.
Dialogue is a strong suit for this author. I recommend the book to anyone who enjoys JAFF.
You have freedom when you’re easy in your harness. ~ Robert Frost
February 3, 2020
2.5 rounded to 3 stars
This really starts out with a bang and a lot of promise, but I feel that the plot meanders around and becomes increasingly unfocused. There are just too many different storylines without any one central plot claiming dominance. Elizabeth and Darcy, of course, are the focus of one narrative, but a whole slew of other characters vie for the reader’s attention. I honestly have no idea which "lady" the title refers to.
As the story begins, Lady Catherine gets wind of Darcy’s interest in Elizabeth, knows he wrote her a letter, and confronts her just after Darcy delivers it. The grand lady's dismissive attitude toward Elizabeth raises her hackles, and she rips it up (without having the chance to read it all) rather than give it to Darcy's meddlesome aunt. Unknown to everyone, Lady C. had already been experiencing symptoms of a weak heart, and Elizabeth's lack of proper deference sends her into a rage that proves too much for her - she has a sudden heart attack and collapses. Guilt-ridden, Elizabeth makes the promise that had been demanded as the lady's life slips away.
Interesting premise. Unfortunately, Elizabeth’s promise turns out to be an irrelevant plot point that never amounts to anything. Lady Catherine's death, however, has a major impact on the rest of the story.
Darcy and Colonel Fitzwilliams haven't left Rosings yet, and they manage the practical issues in the immediate aftermath of their aunt's sudden demise. Anne de Bough is far from devastated; in fact, she's ecstatic. She refuses to pretend to mourn when she's more in the mood for a celebration. The alteration in her behavior is a surprise to everyone except Darcy, who is aware that she's been hiding her bubbly, energetic personality and also that she and her mother have long despised each other.
Anne pursues a friendship with Elizabeth. She is already good friends with Charlotte Collins, who experiences a life-changing event of her own. The three share confidences…to a point. It doesn’t take long for Lady Susan, Countess of Matlock, to show up with Richard’s brother Percy (a cleric) with a not-too-subtle agenda to promote marriage between Anne and one of her two younger sons, now that Lady Catherine isn't around to insist that Anne marry Darcy. Jane and Mr. Bennet arrive, partly to support Elizabeth, who’s still reeling from the unsettling result of her confrontation with Lady Catherine, and also to get Jane away from Mrs. Bennet, who isn’t happy with the result of Mr. Bingley’s visit in Cheapside. Lady Susan is a snob who looks down her nose at all the Bennets, and Mr. Bennet's irreverence doesn't exactly soften her attitude.
Then Anne’s relatives on the de Bourgh side of the family turn up. Anne gets along better with her less haughty grandmother Lady Augusta, but her cousins Henry and Arthur join the competition for her hand, and she's enjoying her newfound freedom too much to be interested in marrying anyone. Eventually, Mr. Bingley and his sister Caroline also make it there, and even Georgiana finds her way to Kent and joins the overly-large group. Only Mr. Bennet leaves.
Members of the house party travel between Rosings and Humphrey Hall (a neglected empty estate Anne plans to lease). It becomes difficult to keep track of who’s in a scene, and frequently neither Lady Susan nor Lady Augusta appears to be present, so their chaperoning is ridiculously lax. Couples frequently manage to separate from the others for a tete-a-tete. At one point, Elizabeth, Jane and Colonel Fitzwilliam are staying by themselves at Humphrey Hall, with only the housekeeper, Mrs.Templeton, as a chaperone. Lady Catherine's nieces and nephews attend an assembly in Tunbridge Wells (a Meryton-type local town) and then they host a ball with all of the local society invited. All pretense of mourning is gone by the middle of the story, even though Lady Catherine has been dead for less than a month.
The behavior of all the young people here reminds me of being a teenager in high school, with the cool kids in one group with Anne as its leader and the not-so-cool-kids trying to gain entry (in order to get closer to Anne). The incompetent adults ignore notes being passed around, encourage their favorites, and disparage others. And the intrigue also feels adolescent. Lots of these shared confidences just read the way teenage girls talk with each other about boys. Friends (and sometimes enemies with a common goal) team up to either encourage or dissuade others from matching up. It got exhausting for me long before the overly melodramatic final chapters.
There are many good moments and it’s generally well-written, but the lack of focus, the characters’ immaturity, and the absence of believable Regency behavior spoil it for me. Plus, it’s a LONG book. I can't recommend it.
Content is clean.
This really starts out with a bang and a lot of promise, but I feel that the plot meanders around and becomes increasingly unfocused. There are just too many different storylines without any one central plot claiming dominance. Elizabeth and Darcy, of course, are the focus of one narrative, but a whole slew of other characters vie for the reader’s attention. I honestly have no idea which "lady" the title refers to.
As the story begins, Lady Catherine gets wind of Darcy’s interest in Elizabeth, knows he wrote her a letter, and confronts her just after Darcy delivers it. The grand lady's dismissive attitude toward Elizabeth raises her hackles, and she rips it up (without having the chance to read it all) rather than give it to Darcy's meddlesome aunt. Unknown to everyone, Lady C. had already been experiencing symptoms of a weak heart, and Elizabeth's lack of proper deference sends her into a rage that proves too much for her - she has a sudden heart attack and collapses. Guilt-ridden, Elizabeth makes the promise that had been demanded as the lady's life slips away.
Interesting premise. Unfortunately, Elizabeth’s promise turns out to be an irrelevant plot point that never amounts to anything. Lady Catherine's death, however, has a major impact on the rest of the story.
Darcy and Colonel Fitzwilliams haven't left Rosings yet, and they manage the practical issues in the immediate aftermath of their aunt's sudden demise. Anne de Bough is far from devastated; in fact, she's ecstatic. She refuses to pretend to mourn when she's more in the mood for a celebration. The alteration in her behavior is a surprise to everyone except Darcy, who is aware that she's been hiding her bubbly, energetic personality and also that she and her mother have long despised each other.
Anne pursues a friendship with Elizabeth. She is already good friends with Charlotte Collins, who experiences a life-changing event of her own. The three share confidences…to a point. It doesn’t take long for Lady Susan, Countess of Matlock, to show up with Richard’s brother Percy (a cleric) with a not-too-subtle agenda to promote marriage between Anne and one of her two younger sons, now that Lady Catherine isn't around to insist that Anne marry Darcy. Jane and Mr. Bennet arrive, partly to support Elizabeth, who’s still reeling from the unsettling result of her confrontation with Lady Catherine, and also to get Jane away from Mrs. Bennet, who isn’t happy with the result of Mr. Bingley’s visit in Cheapside. Lady Susan is a snob who looks down her nose at all the Bennets, and Mr. Bennet's irreverence doesn't exactly soften her attitude.
Then Anne’s relatives on the de Bourgh side of the family turn up. Anne gets along better with her less haughty grandmother Lady Augusta, but her cousins Henry and Arthur join the competition for her hand, and she's enjoying her newfound freedom too much to be interested in marrying anyone. Eventually, Mr. Bingley and his sister Caroline also make it there, and even Georgiana finds her way to Kent and joins the overly-large group. Only Mr. Bennet leaves.
Members of the house party travel between Rosings and Humphrey Hall (a neglected empty estate Anne plans to lease). It becomes difficult to keep track of who’s in a scene, and frequently neither Lady Susan nor Lady Augusta appears to be present, so their chaperoning is ridiculously lax. Couples frequently manage to separate from the others for a tete-a-tete. At one point, Elizabeth, Jane and Colonel Fitzwilliam are staying by themselves at Humphrey Hall, with only the housekeeper, Mrs.Templeton, as a chaperone. Lady Catherine's nieces and nephews attend an assembly in Tunbridge Wells (a Meryton-type local town) and then they host a ball with all of the local society invited. All pretense of mourning is gone by the middle of the story, even though Lady Catherine has been dead for less than a month.
The behavior of all the young people here reminds me of being a teenager in high school, with the cool kids in one group with Anne as its leader and the not-so-cool-kids trying to gain entry (in order to get closer to Anne). The incompetent adults ignore notes being passed around, encourage their favorites, and disparage others. And the intrigue also feels adolescent. Lots of these shared confidences just read the way teenage girls talk with each other about boys. Friends (and sometimes enemies with a common goal) team up to either encourage or dissuade others from matching up. It got exhausting for me long before the overly melodramatic final chapters.
There are many good moments and it’s generally well-written, but the lack of focus, the characters’ immaturity, and the absence of believable Regency behavior spoil it for me. Plus, it’s a LONG book. I can't recommend it.
Content is clean.
November 7, 2021
Highly diverting
Reviewed in Canada on December 22, 2019
This was a fun read. Lots of twists and turns as to who will end up with who. I loved Anne in this story. I would have enjoyed seeing Charlotte get her HEA too, even if just in an epilogue. There are some proofreading errors—an especially unfortunate one in Darcy’s second proposal where he says I can’t live “with” you instead of “without”. I do recommend this book.
November 6, 2021 – Audiobook
The narrator, Sarah Groarke, has a talent for the dramatic and for the most part well done. I could not like the voice presentation for Colonel Fitzwilliam, however. He spoke in a foppish, lispy manner, which to me is the antithesis of the manly Colonel. Every time he spoke I cringed a little. I would toss that voice for a future recordings. Caroline was a female version of the same.
Reviewed in Canada on December 22, 2019
This was a fun read. Lots of twists and turns as to who will end up with who. I loved Anne in this story. I would have enjoyed seeing Charlotte get her HEA too, even if just in an epilogue. There are some proofreading errors—an especially unfortunate one in Darcy’s second proposal where he says I can’t live “with” you instead of “without”. I do recommend this book.
November 6, 2021 – Audiobook
The narrator, Sarah Groarke, has a talent for the dramatic and for the most part well done. I could not like the voice presentation for Colonel Fitzwilliam, however. He spoke in a foppish, lispy manner, which to me is the antithesis of the manly Colonel. Every time he spoke I cringed a little. I would toss that voice for a future recordings. Caroline was a female version of the same.
January 15, 2020
This book is interesting and different. I cannot say that there was a lot of angst but there certainly is a lot of plotting by various cousins, a grandmother, an aunt and a few gentlemen, 2 of whom are new to JAFF.
Darcy's Hunsford proposal has occurred and he gives Elizabeth that letter. However, Lady C. chases Elizabeth down and her words are those which occur later in canon (in that pretty little wilderness area at Longbourn). Lady Catherine demands that Elizabeth promise never to accept Darcy's hand and then attempts to grab the letter from Elizabeth. Elizabeth, while not having read the entire letter, rips it apart and sneers at Lady C. that she will not promise any such thing. The lady grabs at her heart and is gone.
Subsequently, Mr. Collins while ranting and raving about what Elizabeth has done to his patroness (instead of going for a physician) also dies. Jane is now the heiress to Longbourn. Anne de Bourgh is freed from all the restrictions her mother and Mrs. Jenkinson put upon her and freed from how she had to act to please her mother. Mr. Bennet brings Jane to Kent as Mr. Bingley has shown up and Jane interprets this as him hearing she is an heiress and so now he is interested...again. They have argued. Mrs. Bennet has basically kicked Jane out due to her behavior towards Bingley.
In this story Anne has a deceased sister, Isabel, who was engaged to Darcy. Elizabeth looks somewhat like her, which prompts questions about Darcy's motives towards Elizabeth. Questions arise about that lady's final days also.
Richard's mother, the countess, shows up as she wants him to marry Anne and bring Rosings into the Fitzwlliam family's belongings. She brings with her a younger son, a parson, who begins to fill in temporarily for Mr. Collins. Also Anne's grandmother shows up with two cousins who are not shy about their intentions to also marry her. One is two faced: painting his brother as in debt, etc. while the other is rather shy.
There is a lot of courting going on and the pairings turn out different than canon. Most of the story is set in a "castle" Anne owns, Humphrey Hall. Both Anne and Jane, as new heiresses, are learning about managing estates with lessons from Darcy and advice from a new steward Anne hires. Exploring dark and unused portions of that estate turns out to be interesting. Anne forms a very tight friendship with Jane and Elizabeth and refuses to be parted from them while also manipulating the relationships she suspects are forming.
Darcy, thinking to please Elizabeth by making amends to the situation between Jane and Bingley writes the man relating that Humphrey Hall is for rent and has great potential. He does not know what occurred in London between the two. Elizabeth's reaction has him dismayed, thinking he can never please her.
Anne is a hoot in this story. At times she is thought to be ready for Bedlam; her character is that different from what others knew of before the death of her mother.
This was an interesting story. We have more than just Darcy's and Elizabeth's relationship here to read about.
Darcy's Hunsford proposal has occurred and he gives Elizabeth that letter. However, Lady C. chases Elizabeth down and her words are those which occur later in canon (in that pretty little wilderness area at Longbourn). Lady Catherine demands that Elizabeth promise never to accept Darcy's hand and then attempts to grab the letter from Elizabeth. Elizabeth, while not having read the entire letter, rips it apart and sneers at Lady C. that she will not promise any such thing. The lady grabs at her heart and is gone.
Subsequently, Mr. Collins while ranting and raving about what Elizabeth has done to his patroness (instead of going for a physician) also dies. Jane is now the heiress to Longbourn. Anne de Bourgh is freed from all the restrictions her mother and Mrs. Jenkinson put upon her and freed from how she had to act to please her mother. Mr. Bennet brings Jane to Kent as Mr. Bingley has shown up and Jane interprets this as him hearing she is an heiress and so now he is interested...again. They have argued. Mrs. Bennet has basically kicked Jane out due to her behavior towards Bingley.
In this story Anne has a deceased sister, Isabel, who was engaged to Darcy. Elizabeth looks somewhat like her, which prompts questions about Darcy's motives towards Elizabeth. Questions arise about that lady's final days also.
Richard's mother, the countess, shows up as she wants him to marry Anne and bring Rosings into the Fitzwlliam family's belongings. She brings with her a younger son, a parson, who begins to fill in temporarily for Mr. Collins. Also Anne's grandmother shows up with two cousins who are not shy about their intentions to also marry her. One is two faced: painting his brother as in debt, etc. while the other is rather shy.
There is a lot of courting going on and the pairings turn out different than canon. Most of the story is set in a "castle" Anne owns, Humphrey Hall. Both Anne and Jane, as new heiresses, are learning about managing estates with lessons from Darcy and advice from a new steward Anne hires. Exploring dark and unused portions of that estate turns out to be interesting. Anne forms a very tight friendship with Jane and Elizabeth and refuses to be parted from them while also manipulating the relationships she suspects are forming.
Darcy, thinking to please Elizabeth by making amends to the situation between Jane and Bingley writes the man relating that Humphrey Hall is for rent and has great potential. He does not know what occurred in London between the two. Elizabeth's reaction has him dismayed, thinking he can never please her.
Anne is a hoot in this story. At times she is thought to be ready for Bedlam; her character is that different from what others knew of before the death of her mother.
This was an interesting story. We have more than just Darcy's and Elizabeth's relationship here to read about.
January 25, 2020
There was a lot and I do mean a lot going on in this story. It was actually too much for me. It took me days to read and I almost wanted to stop reading it.
I did finish it and it does have some unique plot variations.
I did finish it and it does have some unique plot variations.
January 23, 2020
"Like a piano on fire." (quote from the book)
I love the workings of Ms. Bamber's mind when she writes her variations. She delves deep into the characters providing depth and reasoning for their actions. Ms. Bamber is not afraid to shake things up, but she also stirs it quite vigorously. The dialogue is always sharp and brilliant and she drops interesting tidbits that appear later in the story. The expression, 'the devil is in the details' is certainly one that applies to her novels. And I love the details and complexity in her stories.
In this variation, Lady Catherine has not only learned of Elizabeth Bennet's refusal of Mr. Darcy's proposal while she is at Rosings, but that Mr. Darcy is also giving her a letter. This, of course, is not to be borne! What happens when she confronts Elizabeth after she receives her letter is shocking. What unfolds from this is utterly fascinating. We not only have one relationship stumbling along, we have several creative developments that makes this story one of my favourites! Oh, it is just delicious in so many ways!
"There was something they were not telling her, she was certain of it - and yet, what could it matter, when she was finally set free?" (quote from the book)
For starters, Anne de Bourgh is brought to sparkling life! With so little to work with, Ms. Bamber has given us, not only a back story, but inventive reasoning! Then there is Jane Bennet, who I absolutely adored in this book! We always want Bingley to grow a spine, but Jane...well you will have to read this to find out! Of course, Elizabeth and Darcy cannot resolve things quickly and that is so well played out. Let's not forget Mr. and Mrs. Collins. What happens there was completely unexpected.
"Jane, he is a grown man, not a puppy. On second thought, perhaps not." (quote from the book)
But we also have the Colonel, Mr. Bingley, Miss Bingley, the rest of the Fiztwilliam clan and the ever elusive de Bourgh clan. Lady Sarah (Fiztwilliam) and Lady Augusta (grandmother de Bourgh) and her grandsons certainly create mischief and mayhem. I was in my element with the chaos and manipulations that these characters all created. Then there is the eavesdropping and that usually doesn't bode well for the one listening!
"To anybody else it might look like the feeble pace of a benevolent old Lady, but to Caroline it was the practiced gait of a predator stalking prey, and she watched carefully without betraying too much interest." (quote from the book)
There are delightful 'dark' touches of Northanger Abbey in this story that add such an element of the Gothic. The imagery of an old castle was vivid. And yes, being foxed and seeing ghosts certainly causes its own trouble. However, the most magical moments between certain characters was just perfect.
"Darcy frowned into his drink. Richard's argument had some merit, and he was disconcerted. "I feel as though I am on the precipice," he said, "of all hell breaking loose." (quote from the book)
I cannot praise this book enough. There is wonderful humour, witty dialogue, intrigue, manipulations, and attempts at seduction. I cannot helping saying, "Oh Sister!"
Just fabulous and one I wholeheartedly recommend!
I love the workings of Ms. Bamber's mind when she writes her variations. She delves deep into the characters providing depth and reasoning for their actions. Ms. Bamber is not afraid to shake things up, but she also stirs it quite vigorously. The dialogue is always sharp and brilliant and she drops interesting tidbits that appear later in the story. The expression, 'the devil is in the details' is certainly one that applies to her novels. And I love the details and complexity in her stories.
In this variation, Lady Catherine has not only learned of Elizabeth Bennet's refusal of Mr. Darcy's proposal while she is at Rosings, but that Mr. Darcy is also giving her a letter. This, of course, is not to be borne! What happens when she confronts Elizabeth after she receives her letter is shocking. What unfolds from this is utterly fascinating. We not only have one relationship stumbling along, we have several creative developments that makes this story one of my favourites! Oh, it is just delicious in so many ways!
"There was something they were not telling her, she was certain of it - and yet, what could it matter, when she was finally set free?" (quote from the book)
For starters, Anne de Bourgh is brought to sparkling life! With so little to work with, Ms. Bamber has given us, not only a back story, but inventive reasoning! Then there is Jane Bennet, who I absolutely adored in this book! We always want Bingley to grow a spine, but Jane...well you will have to read this to find out! Of course, Elizabeth and Darcy cannot resolve things quickly and that is so well played out. Let's not forget Mr. and Mrs. Collins. What happens there was completely unexpected.
"Jane, he is a grown man, not a puppy. On second thought, perhaps not." (quote from the book)
But we also have the Colonel, Mr. Bingley, Miss Bingley, the rest of the Fiztwilliam clan and the ever elusive de Bourgh clan. Lady Sarah (Fiztwilliam) and Lady Augusta (grandmother de Bourgh) and her grandsons certainly create mischief and mayhem. I was in my element with the chaos and manipulations that these characters all created. Then there is the eavesdropping and that usually doesn't bode well for the one listening!
"To anybody else it might look like the feeble pace of a benevolent old Lady, but to Caroline it was the practiced gait of a predator stalking prey, and she watched carefully without betraying too much interest." (quote from the book)
There are delightful 'dark' touches of Northanger Abbey in this story that add such an element of the Gothic. The imagery of an old castle was vivid. And yes, being foxed and seeing ghosts certainly causes its own trouble. However, the most magical moments between certain characters was just perfect.
"Darcy frowned into his drink. Richard's argument had some merit, and he was disconcerted. "I feel as though I am on the precipice," he said, "of all hell breaking loose." (quote from the book)
I cannot praise this book enough. There is wonderful humour, witty dialogue, intrigue, manipulations, and attempts at seduction. I cannot helping saying, "Oh Sister!"
Just fabulous and one I wholeheartedly recommend!
April 29, 2022
3.5. Meanders a bit too much for me.
February 22, 2020
This is a really long book - its explosive right from the start. Lady Catherine finds out about Darcys proposal and seeks out Elizabeth, just after Darcy has given her his letter . Lizzy rips it up to prevent Lady Catherine reading it, which doesn't go down well, and Lady Catherine dies. This event is the trigger for a whole load of ensuing chaos as Anne de Bourgh comes in to her own, free of the shackles imposed by her mother. She becomes fast friends with Lizzy - jane also arrives and they are at Rosings along with some additional Fitzwilliam family members and de Borgh's as the families make an effort to get Anne married to one of their own and get their hands on her fortune!
Its difficult to summarise the plot here as there is so much going on. This isn't really a story about Darcy and Elizabeth - other characters feature more heavily, particularly Anne and Jane. Of all the different stories running through this book, I actually didn't like Elizabeth all that much. She's pretty mean and immature, quite nasty to Darcy actually and I found myself thinking that she didnt deserve him.
I quite enjoyed this book - its something completely different.... but its long and Anne de Bourgh probably has the starring role.
Its difficult to summarise the plot here as there is so much going on. This isn't really a story about Darcy and Elizabeth - other characters feature more heavily, particularly Anne and Jane. Of all the different stories running through this book, I actually didn't like Elizabeth all that much. She's pretty mean and immature, quite nasty to Darcy actually and I found myself thinking that she didnt deserve him.
I quite enjoyed this book - its something completely different.... but its long and Anne de Bourgh probably has the starring role.
January 4, 2020
What would Anne’s life be like after her mother died?
No table of contents. If you search on 1813 you can see most of the chapters. Searching on a word doesn’t tell what chapter the found occurrences are in.
The Lizzy of this story is very much like the Lizzy in P&P. She is overly confident, quick to make judgements, naive, prejudiced young 20 year old. Consequently since she is thrown together with Darcy a lot, she doesn’t like him much.
She finally gives up her prejudices but I wish I had seen more of her in love with Darcy.
This Darcy is trying so hard to protect Anne, Rosings, his heart, it does not seem likely he loves Lizzy or can achieve having her love him.
Their path to love occurred but there seemed at the end it was almost by accident, not that it was meant to be.
The writing of the story was so good. I really like the book. Recommended.
No table of contents. If you search on 1813 you can see most of the chapters. Searching on a word doesn’t tell what chapter the found occurrences are in.
The Lizzy of this story is very much like the Lizzy in P&P. She is overly confident, quick to make judgements, naive, prejudiced young 20 year old. Consequently since she is thrown together with Darcy a lot, she doesn’t like him much.
She finally gives up her prejudices but I wish I had seen more of her in love with Darcy.
This Darcy is trying so hard to protect Anne, Rosings, his heart, it does not seem likely he loves Lizzy or can achieve having her love him.
Their path to love occurred but there seemed at the end it was almost by accident, not that it was meant to be.
The writing of the story was so good. I really like the book. Recommended.
August 24, 2020
What If Lady Catherine Learned About Mr. Darcy’s Failed Proposal?
Source: Review Copy from Author
TYPE OF NOVEL: Pride and Prejudice Variation
TIME FRAME: Begins the morning after Mr. Darcy’s Hunsford Proposal
SYNOPSIS: Lady Catherine overhears Mr. Darcy’s intentions to deliver a letter to none other than that obstinate, headstrong girl – Elizabeth Bennet. And so the great lady is determined to find this impertinent miss and have her say! But what follows is most shocking indeed. Mr. Darcy and the Colonel do not depart Rosings as planned and Anne de Bourgh’s life (and personality) take an unexpected turn! Rosings is soon beset with an abundance of new visitors – sisters, cousins, and friends and there is quite a lot of activity and excitement. And through it all, more than one suitor is attempting to claim the heart of their lady love. Will they be successful? Or do obstacles and meddlesome relations continue to impeded their purposes?
WHAT I LOVED:
- Bold and Unique: This is a highly original premise and I enjoyed the new and shocking twists Jayne Bamber introduced into her story. There are some startling character exoduses, some unknown family history, and a bunch of new original characters introduced in this tale. I thoroughly enjoyed the journey! And since the premise was so bold and unique, it often felt very unpredictable.
- Anne in the Spotlight: I quite enjoyed this recreation of Anne de Bourgh, who (SPOILER ALERT!!) does not have a “sickly constitution” or suffer from “indifferent health.” Quite the contrary – Anne is energetic, sociable, and completely fun-loving. And she is eager to make up for lost time. This Anne was so much fun to witness! She definitely shakes everything up a good deal and can be a little too rebellious or boisterous at times, but I so loved seeing her in the spotlight and observing her finding her way. (END of SPOILER)
- Dearest Friends: I must say I loved the sisterhood that developed between Anne, Elizabeth, and Jane. Their affinity and affection for each other was heartwarming to witness! I especially loved all the moments where they showed tender care or made a point to lookout for one another. True and valued friendship – what a wonderful thing!
- Matchmaking and Meddling: With friends and relations and a large group of unwed men and women residing under one roof, you can be sure there is plenty of plotting, interfering, and scheming! I loved seeing all the endeavors others made to either help or hurt a specific couples’ coming together! It was even more entertaining to witness how many people were working at cross purposes! I also want to add that I thoroughly enjoyed and appreciated all the romantic pairings of these couples and how wonderfully they all worked and made sense!
- Shakespearean Comedy: With this big and eventful house party full of drama, mix-ups, and schemes this story often felt like a Shakespearean comedy of manners. Especially with the sometimes scandalous behavior and gothic setting – Humphrey Hall is amazing and I would so want to stay there! I loved the overall satirical tone and the suspense and drama infused into this story!
WHAT I WASN’T TOO FOND OF:
- Pacing: The most eventful sections of the book are the first few chapters and the last few chapters. I did feel that the middle section was a tad slower/longer than it needed to be. I enjoyed all the eventfulness and plot twists of this story. But since there were so many characters and storylines were taking place concurrently, perhaps it would have been better to have some quicker jumps between each storyline. Maybe just a little trimming and tightening is needed.
CONCLUSION:
Strong Objections to the Lady is a delightfully diverting and dynamic Pride and Prejudice variation that features more than just Darcy and Elizabeth! I loved spending time with this endearing and entertaining group, and my only wish is that they invite me to attend their next gathering together!
Austenesque Reviews
Source: Review Copy from Author
TYPE OF NOVEL: Pride and Prejudice Variation
TIME FRAME: Begins the morning after Mr. Darcy’s Hunsford Proposal
SYNOPSIS: Lady Catherine overhears Mr. Darcy’s intentions to deliver a letter to none other than that obstinate, headstrong girl – Elizabeth Bennet. And so the great lady is determined to find this impertinent miss and have her say! But what follows is most shocking indeed. Mr. Darcy and the Colonel do not depart Rosings as planned and Anne de Bourgh’s life (and personality) take an unexpected turn! Rosings is soon beset with an abundance of new visitors – sisters, cousins, and friends and there is quite a lot of activity and excitement. And through it all, more than one suitor is attempting to claim the heart of their lady love. Will they be successful? Or do obstacles and meddlesome relations continue to impeded their purposes?
WHAT I LOVED:
- Bold and Unique: This is a highly original premise and I enjoyed the new and shocking twists Jayne Bamber introduced into her story. There are some startling character exoduses, some unknown family history, and a bunch of new original characters introduced in this tale. I thoroughly enjoyed the journey! And since the premise was so bold and unique, it often felt very unpredictable.
- Anne in the Spotlight: I quite enjoyed this recreation of Anne de Bourgh, who (SPOILER ALERT!!) does not have a “sickly constitution” or suffer from “indifferent health.” Quite the contrary – Anne is energetic, sociable, and completely fun-loving. And she is eager to make up for lost time. This Anne was so much fun to witness! She definitely shakes everything up a good deal and can be a little too rebellious or boisterous at times, but I so loved seeing her in the spotlight and observing her finding her way. (END of SPOILER)
- Dearest Friends: I must say I loved the sisterhood that developed between Anne, Elizabeth, and Jane. Their affinity and affection for each other was heartwarming to witness! I especially loved all the moments where they showed tender care or made a point to lookout for one another. True and valued friendship – what a wonderful thing!
- Matchmaking and Meddling: With friends and relations and a large group of unwed men and women residing under one roof, you can be sure there is plenty of plotting, interfering, and scheming! I loved seeing all the endeavors others made to either help or hurt a specific couples’ coming together! It was even more entertaining to witness how many people were working at cross purposes! I also want to add that I thoroughly enjoyed and appreciated all the romantic pairings of these couples and how wonderfully they all worked and made sense!
- Shakespearean Comedy: With this big and eventful house party full of drama, mix-ups, and schemes this story often felt like a Shakespearean comedy of manners. Especially with the sometimes scandalous behavior and gothic setting – Humphrey Hall is amazing and I would so want to stay there! I loved the overall satirical tone and the suspense and drama infused into this story!
WHAT I WASN’T TOO FOND OF:
- Pacing: The most eventful sections of the book are the first few chapters and the last few chapters. I did feel that the middle section was a tad slower/longer than it needed to be. I enjoyed all the eventfulness and plot twists of this story. But since there were so many characters and storylines were taking place concurrently, perhaps it would have been better to have some quicker jumps between each storyline. Maybe just a little trimming and tightening is needed.
CONCLUSION:
Strong Objections to the Lady is a delightfully diverting and dynamic Pride and Prejudice variation that features more than just Darcy and Elizabeth! I loved spending time with this endearing and entertaining group, and my only wish is that they invite me to attend their next gathering together!
Austenesque Reviews
June 11, 2021
This was a long book and there was a whole lot happening in this story. I thought it started off really well and with an original plot twist that I had not read before. There were many things that I really enjoyed and I think this author is very talented and writes beautifully, but I think in this case, there were just a few too many irons in the fire and the waters got a bit muddied. There got to be too many plots and sub plots and so many different characters with different agendas that my head started to spin.
Overall, I liked this book but didn’t love it. I find myself disappointed that I only liked it because in the beginning I felt it had the potential to be so much better and would have been had the plot been a bit simplified and focused.
Overall, I liked this book but didn’t love it. I find myself disappointed that I only liked it because in the beginning I felt it had the potential to be so much better and would have been had the plot been a bit simplified and focused.
December 27, 2019
Long, complicated, original and quite wonderful.
It took me awhile to finish, but I remained dedicated and fascinated throughout. The focus on this characterization of Anne DeBourgh was unique. We've seen evolutions of this character before but I can't recall ever liking her so much and with such genuine sympathy and surprise. Almost enough Darcy and Lizzy interaction and plot to balance a whole load of OCs and non-canon pairings. Altogether, good emotion, well written, and great fun. I particularly enjoyed Anne's tea parties - a Regency version of Cosmos with the girls.
It took me awhile to finish, but I remained dedicated and fascinated throughout. The focus on this characterization of Anne DeBourgh was unique. We've seen evolutions of this character before but I can't recall ever liking her so much and with such genuine sympathy and surprise. Almost enough Darcy and Lizzy interaction and plot to balance a whole load of OCs and non-canon pairings. Altogether, good emotion, well written, and great fun. I particularly enjoyed Anne's tea parties - a Regency version of Cosmos with the girls.
October 14, 2025
I loved it!
Warning: Meant for mature audiences. Contains scenes that would scandalize the ton. Readers of a delicate constitution are advised to keep their fans and vinaigrettes close at hand.
It was so enticing that I couldn’t put it down, this book grabbed my interest from the very first page. I couldn’t put it down, I had to know what happened next. The story is well written with a very good storyline. You will see the most beloved characters in a whole new way. This is a Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice variation. A tale of intrigue & inheritance, meddling & manipulation, and sisterhood & self-improvement. Set chiefly in Kent and spanning the short space of just a month, this stand-alone variation begins the morning after Mr. Darcy's failed proposal at Hunsford. From there, chaos quickly erupts and the lives of three strong young women tangle together in a day-by-day journey of growth, sisterhood, and ultimately romance, in the wake of tragedy.
When Lady Catherine de Bourgh learns of Mr. Darcy’s proposal to Elizabeth Bennet, her wrath sets in motion a series of events at Hunsford Parsonage which embroil Darcy and Elizabeth in a family fracas that grows more complicated daily. The shades of Rosings Park are soon polluted by the shocking transformation of its new mistress and her guests, as well as secrets of the past and schemes for the future. Appearances and alliances shift amidst the chaos wrought by a well-intentioned house party, and Darcy and Elizabeth must finally face their feelings for one another despite mounting obstacles and misunderstandings of every kind. So with all that and more this story pulls you in and holds you tight. It’s a must read. I highly recommend to everyone.
Warning: Meant for mature audiences. Contains scenes that would scandalize the ton. Readers of a delicate constitution are advised to keep their fans and vinaigrettes close at hand.
It was so enticing that I couldn’t put it down, this book grabbed my interest from the very first page. I couldn’t put it down, I had to know what happened next. The story is well written with a very good storyline. You will see the most beloved characters in a whole new way. This is a Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice variation. A tale of intrigue & inheritance, meddling & manipulation, and sisterhood & self-improvement. Set chiefly in Kent and spanning the short space of just a month, this stand-alone variation begins the morning after Mr. Darcy's failed proposal at Hunsford. From there, chaos quickly erupts and the lives of three strong young women tangle together in a day-by-day journey of growth, sisterhood, and ultimately romance, in the wake of tragedy.
When Lady Catherine de Bourgh learns of Mr. Darcy’s proposal to Elizabeth Bennet, her wrath sets in motion a series of events at Hunsford Parsonage which embroil Darcy and Elizabeth in a family fracas that grows more complicated daily. The shades of Rosings Park are soon polluted by the shocking transformation of its new mistress and her guests, as well as secrets of the past and schemes for the future. Appearances and alliances shift amidst the chaos wrought by a well-intentioned house party, and Darcy and Elizabeth must finally face their feelings for one another despite mounting obstacles and misunderstandings of every kind. So with all that and more this story pulls you in and holds you tight. It’s a must read. I highly recommend to everyone.
January 10, 2020
Enjoyable
An interesting story, but one packed with so much chaos that it's a little overwhelming. As the story summary indicates, almost the entire tale takes place near Rosings Park. The events that color everything else are the deaths of Lady Catherine (apoplexy) and Mr. Collins (a fall and hitting his head), within hours of each other, and this happens at the start of the story.
Anne DeBourgh, instead of mourning the loss of her mother, feels liberated and immediately wants to kick up her heels and make up for all the time she's been under her mother's thumb. She almost manic in her need to start living life on her own terms, and her cousins Darcy and Colonel Fitzwilliam have a difficult time trying to moderate her behavior. As someone else mentioned in their review, this story is mainly about Anne, and the development of the relationship between ODC definitely takes a back seat. However, there is a lot of romance going on, with a lot of the characters, so all is not lost.
Anne starts out as a very strange character, but thankfully she settles down somewhat eventually. She forms a close friendship with Charlotte, Elizabeth and Jane, and all of them have their own situations. There's a lot of intrigue, heartache, misunderstanding, family betrayal, and a lot of romance. Some of the situations stretch the boundaries of belief, and seem almost silly, but it's all in good fun.
The writing is well done, but there are a fair number of editing errors, enough to be noticeable. This is not great literature, but I enjoyed the story and can recommend it.
An interesting story, but one packed with so much chaos that it's a little overwhelming. As the story summary indicates, almost the entire tale takes place near Rosings Park. The events that color everything else are the deaths of Lady Catherine (apoplexy) and Mr. Collins (a fall and hitting his head), within hours of each other, and this happens at the start of the story.
Anne DeBourgh, instead of mourning the loss of her mother, feels liberated and immediately wants to kick up her heels and make up for all the time she's been under her mother's thumb. She almost manic in her need to start living life on her own terms, and her cousins Darcy and Colonel Fitzwilliam have a difficult time trying to moderate her behavior. As someone else mentioned in their review, this story is mainly about Anne, and the development of the relationship between ODC definitely takes a back seat. However, there is a lot of romance going on, with a lot of the characters, so all is not lost.
Anne starts out as a very strange character, but thankfully she settles down somewhat eventually. She forms a close friendship with Charlotte, Elizabeth and Jane, and all of them have their own situations. There's a lot of intrigue, heartache, misunderstanding, family betrayal, and a lot of romance. Some of the situations stretch the boundaries of belief, and seem almost silly, but it's all in good fun.
The writing is well done, but there are a fair number of editing errors, enough to be noticeable. This is not great literature, but I enjoyed the story and can recommend it.
January 11, 2020
Long, complicated and a little bit crazy!
Though Lizzy and Darcy do feature strongly in this very long book, Anne de Bourgh is definitely the main character. And what a character she is. Definitely not the dull, almost lifeless Anne we meet in Pride and Prejudice, but a secret dipsomaniac who is not happy unless she is pushing all the boundaries until they buckle and will not go back into place! You definitely would not want to get on the wrong side of this particular Anne de Bourgh.
We meet Anne's grandmother on the de Bourgh side as well as two male de Bourgh cousins. The Countess of Matlock also has a leading role, and Colonel Fitzwilliam's two brothers, the Viscount and Percy, who has gone into the church are present but in a much more minor way.
I won't give the story away, but be prepared for a complicated and crazy trip that starts off as entertaining but eventually goes over the edge into the ridiculous. And it all takes place in just one month. The writing is generally very good, but there are a few malapropisms and instances of words being omitted. I also began to cringe every time I read the word, 'smirk'! Everyone smirks in this story and they do it often! All the smirking instead of smiling made the story—along with some other elements—seem too modern.
I've awarded a generous 4 stars, but it is probably closer to 31/2 stars. 🌟🌟🌟🌟
Though Lizzy and Darcy do feature strongly in this very long book, Anne de Bourgh is definitely the main character. And what a character she is. Definitely not the dull, almost lifeless Anne we meet in Pride and Prejudice, but a secret dipsomaniac who is not happy unless she is pushing all the boundaries until they buckle and will not go back into place! You definitely would not want to get on the wrong side of this particular Anne de Bourgh.
We meet Anne's grandmother on the de Bourgh side as well as two male de Bourgh cousins. The Countess of Matlock also has a leading role, and Colonel Fitzwilliam's two brothers, the Viscount and Percy, who has gone into the church are present but in a much more minor way.
I won't give the story away, but be prepared for a complicated and crazy trip that starts off as entertaining but eventually goes over the edge into the ridiculous. And it all takes place in just one month. The writing is generally very good, but there are a few malapropisms and instances of words being omitted. I also began to cringe every time I read the word, 'smirk'! Everyone smirks in this story and they do it often! All the smirking instead of smiling made the story—along with some other elements—seem too modern.
I've awarded a generous 4 stars, but it is probably closer to 31/2 stars. 🌟🌟🌟🌟
January 1, 2020
Avid Reader
This author caught my attention immediately! Lady Catherine literally drops dead after an argument with Elizabeth over Darcy, and Mr. Collins died in his sleep after he faints and hits his head upon Lady Catherine 's death. Anne is no longer under her mother 's thumb after the death of her oldest sister Isabel who looked like Elizabeth. Jane refuses to marry Bingley because she thinks he proposes because she is now an heiress. Charlotte falls in love with Percy Fitzwilliam, Colonel Fitzwilliam 's youngest brother who is a parson. Anne finds herself in danger from her deBourgh grandmother and cousin Henry who plot to drug her after the plot to compromise her doesn't work. Anne and Richard are set up by his mother, the countess, although Anne lived Bingley and Richard lived Jane. Wickham runs off with Lydia but marries Alfred deBourgh. By the end, there are four happily ever afters!
This author caught my attention immediately! Lady Catherine literally drops dead after an argument with Elizabeth over Darcy, and Mr. Collins died in his sleep after he faints and hits his head upon Lady Catherine 's death. Anne is no longer under her mother 's thumb after the death of her oldest sister Isabel who looked like Elizabeth. Jane refuses to marry Bingley because she thinks he proposes because she is now an heiress. Charlotte falls in love with Percy Fitzwilliam, Colonel Fitzwilliam 's youngest brother who is a parson. Anne finds herself in danger from her deBourgh grandmother and cousin Henry who plot to drug her after the plot to compromise her doesn't work. Anne and Richard are set up by his mother, the countess, although Anne lived Bingley and Richard lived Jane. Wickham runs off with Lydia but marries Alfred deBourgh. By the end, there are four happily ever afters!
October 12, 2021
I am obsessed with P and P. I will pretty much read anything and everything in that world.
I thought this one was exceptional.
The first book I read by this author was Madness in Meryton which is P and P meets Groundhog Day- jolly amusing.
(I don't consider that a spoiler because if you read the summary or just get a few chapters into the book- you figure that out...)
Anyway, this book is essentially a "What if certain characters were dead? What would happen?" story. There are some either invented characters or lesser utilized characters (from the original novel). And there's a spooky old castle which gives me Northanger Abbey vibes (always nice)... I won't spoil what happens, but I found it interesting, amusing, and well-worth the Audible credit. I will definitely re-listen to it again.
I thought this one was exceptional.
The first book I read by this author was Madness in Meryton which is P and P meets Groundhog Day- jolly amusing.
(I don't consider that a spoiler because if you read the summary or just get a few chapters into the book- you figure that out...)
Anyway, this book is essentially a "What if certain characters were dead? What would happen?" story. There are some either invented characters or lesser utilized characters (from the original novel). And there's a spooky old castle which gives me Northanger Abbey vibes (always nice)... I won't spoil what happens, but I found it interesting, amusing, and well-worth the Audible credit. I will definitely re-listen to it again.
March 5, 2020
Loved the diversity of characters
Very interesting to see the focus on Anne. Introduction of the de Bourgh relatives was welcome and fascinating. I didn’t like the Countess as much in this version than in others although I understand why her machinations are necessary for the storyline.
Anne seemed somewhat overdone at times, even for her new freedom. Isobel was another surprise I enjoyed.
There were some editing errors that were repeated all through the book-incorrect words that were grammatical errors that changed the meaning of sentences.
Highly recommended for JAFF readers who want to know more about Anne, Jane, and Richard.
Very interesting to see the focus on Anne. Introduction of the de Bourgh relatives was welcome and fascinating. I didn’t like the Countess as much in this version than in others although I understand why her machinations are necessary for the storyline.
Anne seemed somewhat overdone at times, even for her new freedom. Isobel was another surprise I enjoyed.
There were some editing errors that were repeated all through the book-incorrect words that were grammatical errors that changed the meaning of sentences.
Highly recommended for JAFF readers who want to know more about Anne, Jane, and Richard.
March 31, 2021
This was a great story kept me interested. This is a different twist in the events after the proposal in Kent.
What happens when Elizabeth doesn't read a of Darcy's letter? What happens when Lady C. Is no longer able to be a tyrant over all.
What happens when Jane is unwelcome home?
We see a whole new version of Anne d'B, I really liked her and felt for everything she had been through only to find she has other relatives almost if not more scheming than ther mother.
There is a bit of a mix up with out pairings and I actually liked them. There is a bit of a difference in the Lydia/Wickham issue, but over all a great book.
What happens when Elizabeth doesn't read a of Darcy's letter? What happens when Lady C. Is no longer able to be a tyrant over all.
What happens when Jane is unwelcome home?
We see a whole new version of Anne d'B, I really liked her and felt for everything she had been through only to find she has other relatives almost if not more scheming than ther mother.
There is a bit of a mix up with out pairings and I actually liked them. There is a bit of a difference in the Lydia/Wickham issue, but over all a great book.
January 11, 2020
Most thorough, satisfying finish to P and P yet
No stone was left unturned, no character left unexplored. I loved that every single character was brought to some type of conclusion. Lydia's problem especially had a satisfactory conclusion.
Given the length of the book and the number of characters, the author did an excellent job of pacing...it never felt like you were at the end of the book, or should be at the end, before you actually got there. I will definitely be on the lookout for this author again.
No stone was left unturned, no character left unexplored. I loved that every single character was brought to some type of conclusion. Lydia's problem especially had a satisfactory conclusion.
Given the length of the book and the number of characters, the author did an excellent job of pacing...it never felt like you were at the end of the book, or should be at the end, before you actually got there. I will definitely be on the lookout for this author again.
Read
January 27, 2020If only there were not a glaring error in the middle
Was somewhat enjoying the story until the middle of the book where Anne's grandmother, Lady Augusta, is confused with Anne' aunt, Lady Susan! Quite ruined my rating and then made me become nitpicky about other issues in the story, in addition to the impossibly short timing and complete lack of a mourning period for anyone. Such a pity because otherwise it was rather diverting. Cannot decide if the borrowed Austen lines were well done or annoying.
Was somewhat enjoying the story until the middle of the book where Anne's grandmother, Lady Augusta, is confused with Anne' aunt, Lady Susan! Quite ruined my rating and then made me become nitpicky about other issues in the story, in addition to the impossibly short timing and complete lack of a mourning period for anyone. Such a pity because otherwise it was rather diverting. Cannot decide if the borrowed Austen lines were well done or annoying.
September 12, 2020
Wickham not rewarded
I’m a fan of JAFF where Wickham doesn’t get rewarded. I especially love any version in which Jane doesn’t marry Bingley and it’s refreshing when Anne has a voice and some depth of character. I like Bingley just not for either of the Bennet sisters. The novel was a bit longer than necessary but a decent read. Oh, I definitely appreciate Miss Bingley getting her just reward too.
I’m a fan of JAFF where Wickham doesn’t get rewarded. I especially love any version in which Jane doesn’t marry Bingley and it’s refreshing when Anne has a voice and some depth of character. I like Bingley just not for either of the Bennet sisters. The novel was a bit longer than necessary but a decent read. Oh, I definitely appreciate Miss Bingley getting her just reward too.
January 3, 2020
Join the fun!
Quite a different and delightful story. All the original characters are here, with some new ones added to add some spice. Elizabeth gets her Mr. Darcy but that comes about in a most surprising way and with everyone else tossed together to make this quite an interesting adventure.
Quite a different and delightful story. All the original characters are here, with some new ones added to add some spice. Elizabeth gets her Mr. Darcy but that comes about in a most surprising way and with everyone else tossed together to make this quite an interesting adventure.
January 17, 2020
An Enjoyable Version
I loved Jane Austin growing up. This version is a n interesting twist on the classic. She caught Elizabeth’s strengths and Janes’s sweetness. aHer dialogue between the characters was captivating and the misunderstandings between the principles were not contrived. I am looking forward to more from this author.
I loved Jane Austin growing up. This version is a n interesting twist on the classic. She caught Elizabeth’s strengths and Janes’s sweetness. aHer dialogue between the characters was captivating and the misunderstandings between the principles were not contrived. I am looking forward to more from this author.
January 17, 2020
Absolutely loved this book!
I love a good P&P vagary, and this one did not disappoint! To take the story off in a completely different direction, yet weave parts of P&P into it, I'd grand, especially when it's so masterfully done. I found myself slowing down towards the end of the book because i didn't want it to be over. A sequel would be much appreciated!
I love a good P&P vagary, and this one did not disappoint! To take the story off in a completely different direction, yet weave parts of P&P into it, I'd grand, especially when it's so masterfully done. I found myself slowing down towards the end of the book because i didn't want it to be over. A sequel would be much appreciated!
June 18, 2020
When I started this book, I was really enjoying the story, but then after a couple of the characters die, the story starts to take on more and more like a snowball rolling downhill. It just sort of kept picking up more and more tidbits and characters. The more characters picked up, the confusing the plot. It wasn't a bad book, but just had a lot going on.
April 30, 2024
Subplots Abound
This is really the story of several couples' paths to love. Lizzy and Darcy were not more dominant than the others. I wish I had known that going in. After the first few chapters of disappointment, though, I got into the many subplots and was glad I read to the end.
This is really the story of several couples' paths to love. Lizzy and Darcy were not more dominant than the others. I wish I had known that going in. After the first few chapters of disappointment, though, I got into the many subplots and was glad I read to the end.
January 3, 2020
Great read
This was a very interesting book I enjoyed reading it however there are some grammatical mistakes as well as a few times it was very hard to understand what was happening but all in all it was a very good read
This was a very interesting book I enjoyed reading it however there are some grammatical mistakes as well as a few times it was very hard to understand what was happening but all in all it was a very good read
February 2, 2020
What happened with Charlotte?
It is a good read, but I was left unfinished. I needed a little more of their happiness as married couples, and whatever happened to Mary and Kitty? The ending felt rushed and incomplete.
It is a good read, but I was left unfinished. I needed a little more of their happiness as married couples, and whatever happened to Mary and Kitty? The ending felt rushed and incomplete.
February 11, 2020
Good Variation!
This novel really turns some of the canon on its head, while remaining very true to P&P’s core. Many of the phrases are lifted from the original, but are used by different characters. It winds around a good bit, but is ultimately quite satisfying.
This novel really turns some of the canon on its head, while remaining very true to P&P’s core. Many of the phrases are lifted from the original, but are used by different characters. It winds around a good bit, but is ultimately quite satisfying.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 50 reviews