What do you think?
Rate this book
Knit & Nibble Mystery #5
A Fatal Yarn
Pamela Paterson and her Knit and Nibble club must clear the name of one of their knitters when he's accused of murdering the mayor . . .
The trees in Arborville, New Jersey, have started sporting sweaters. Part of the trend of public knitting art? Not exactly. An anonymous activist has been wrapping trunks in yarn to cover red X's that mark certain trees for removal by the town so they don't interfere with power lines. When the town's mayor—who supports cutting down the trees—is murdered, Pamela wonders if the tree hugger committed homicide to prevent arborcide. A knitter is arrested, but it's one of Knit and Nibble's own—the harmless Roland DeCamp, who was seen arguing with the mayor. Pamela is sure the police are barking up the wrong tree. With the help of her reporter friend Bettina, she branches off on her own investigation to root out the real killer . . .
Knitting tips and delicious recipe included!
The trees in Arborville, New Jersey, have started sporting sweaters. Part of the trend of public knitting art? Not exactly. An anonymous activist has been wrapping trunks in yarn to cover red X's that mark certain trees for removal by the town so they don't interfere with power lines. When the town's mayor—who supports cutting down the trees—is murdered, Pamela wonders if the tree hugger committed homicide to prevent arborcide. A knitter is arrested, but it's one of Knit and Nibble's own—the harmless Roland DeCamp, who was seen arguing with the mayor. Pamela is sure the police are barking up the wrong tree. With the help of her reporter friend Bettina, she branches off on her own investigation to root out the real killer . . .
Knitting tips and delicious recipe included!
336 pages, Kindle Edition
First published March 31, 2020
291 people are currently reading
628 people want to read
About the author
Peggy Ehrhart
27 books487 followersPeggy Ehrhart is a former English professor with a Ph.D. in Medieval Literature who now writes mysteries. Her publications include a prize-winning nonfiction book; she has also won awards for her short fiction. Her blues mystery series, featuring blues singer "Maxx" Maxwell, was inspired by her guitar-playing hobby. She currently writes the very cozy Knit & Nibble mystery series for Kensington Books, featuring amateur sleuth Pamela Paterson, founder and mainstay of the Knit and Nibble knitting club in charming Arborville, New Jersey.
Series:
* Maxx Maxwell Mysteries
* A Knit & Nibble Mysteries
Series:
* Maxx Maxwell Mysteries
* A Knit & Nibble Mysteries
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 135 reviews
May 3, 2021
A Fatal Yarn by Peggy Ehrhart is the fifth book in the cozy A Knit & Nibble Mystery series. Each book of the series contains it’s own mystery that will be solved so they can be read as a standalone or in any order one chooses. However, those that follow from the beginning will see the full character development that carries over from book to book.
The main character of the Knit & Nibble series is Pamela Paterson who is on the older side for a cozy protagonist. Pamela found herself with an empty nest when her daughter headed off to college so she joined the Knit and Nibble knitting group. The group not only spends time together crafting their favorite projects but also cooks up some yummy treats as the name suggests.
Pamela and her best friend and fellow knitter, Bettina, first became involved in what has become a habit for them in solving murders when a body was found at Pamela’s home. This time around however Pamela and Bettina find themselves investigating the murder of the mayor when the agenda he was supporting has had obvious opposition which may have resorted to murder.
I have followed the Knit & Nibble series from the beginning as this one has an endearing quality to me reminding me of my own knitting grandmother. The characters in this cozy series keep me coming back time and again as I always get a good chuckle out of their antics. However, I find myself always coming to the same conclusion of wishing the author would break away from the overly descriptive recipes and knitting and spend more time on the mystery and characters leaving my rating again at 3 1/2 stars.
I received an advance copy from the publisher via NetGalley.
For more reviews please visit https://carriesbookreviews.com/
The main character of the Knit & Nibble series is Pamela Paterson who is on the older side for a cozy protagonist. Pamela found herself with an empty nest when her daughter headed off to college so she joined the Knit and Nibble knitting group. The group not only spends time together crafting their favorite projects but also cooks up some yummy treats as the name suggests.
Pamela and her best friend and fellow knitter, Bettina, first became involved in what has become a habit for them in solving murders when a body was found at Pamela’s home. This time around however Pamela and Bettina find themselves investigating the murder of the mayor when the agenda he was supporting has had obvious opposition which may have resorted to murder.
I have followed the Knit & Nibble series from the beginning as this one has an endearing quality to me reminding me of my own knitting grandmother. The characters in this cozy series keep me coming back time and again as I always get a good chuckle out of their antics. However, I find myself always coming to the same conclusion of wishing the author would break away from the overly descriptive recipes and knitting and spend more time on the mystery and characters leaving my rating again at 3 1/2 stars.
I received an advance copy from the publisher via NetGalley.
For more reviews please visit https://carriesbookreviews.com/
April 25, 2020
A Fatal Yarn by Peggy Ehrhart has Pamela Paterson surprised to see trees sporting knitted creations in Arborville, New Jersey. It seems someone is trying to save trees that are scheduled to be cut down with the mayor’s approval. Then the mayor is found dead in his kitchen and Roland DeCamp, a Knit & Nibble member, is arrested for the crime. Pamela and Bettina team up to clear Roland and find the true killer. A Fatal Yarn is the 5th A Knit and Nibble Mystery and it can be read on its own. I like the characters in the story and the descriptions of the yarn plus their knitting projects. I did find the endless details of how they make coffee and cook or bake various items to be tiring. Every single time that Pamela made coffee, it is described in detail. Pamela’s daily routine is also written about (articles she edited, what she wore, what she ate and drank). The focus of A Fatal Yarn is on the people and their lives instead of the mystery. The mystery is straightforward with a dead guy, a few suspects, and misdirection. Identifying the killer was a snap. I wish the mystery had been as interesting as the knitted wraps around the trees. If you prefer your cozy mysteries to have more cozy than mystery, than A Fatal Yarn is right up your alley. A Fatal Yarn is a lighthearted tale with trembling trees, nifty knitted creations, copious quantities of coffee, tasty treats, and a murdered mayor.
August 22, 2020
After successfully solving several murders, the Knit & Knibble team are facing a real quandary. One of their own, Roland DeCamp has been accused of killing the mayor. Can Pamela Paterson and her team of avid knitters clear Roland's name?
Just like the other cozy mysteries I love to read, Pamela and her friends are amateur detectives. This doesn't slow them down in any way. With this being the fifth book in the series, I have gotten to know and love Pamela and her friends. To think one of them could have committed murder is all but unthinkable.
So, the task is on. Finding the real killer and keeping Roland out of jail. We do have extra players in this story - the trees that were to be cut down and have a close connection to the mayor's murder.
So, if you are loving this series as much as I am, then be sure to pick up A Fatal Yarn. You will definitely be in for a treat.
Many thanks to Kensington and to NetGalley for this ARC for review. This is my honest opinion.
Just like the other cozy mysteries I love to read, Pamela and her friends are amateur detectives. This doesn't slow them down in any way. With this being the fifth book in the series, I have gotten to know and love Pamela and her friends. To think one of them could have committed murder is all but unthinkable.
So, the task is on. Finding the real killer and keeping Roland out of jail. We do have extra players in this story - the trees that were to be cut down and have a close connection to the mayor's murder.
So, if you are loving this series as much as I am, then be sure to pick up A Fatal Yarn. You will definitely be in for a treat.
Many thanks to Kensington and to NetGalley for this ARC for review. This is my honest opinion.
December 26, 2020
This was a great cozy mystery with a plot that kept me guessing. The story focuses on a female amateur sleuth who takes part in a knitting club. I liked the main characters and their little quirks. The setting was a small town in New Jersey, and the description of it appealed to me. It seemed like a place you could relax in, even though you had to watch out for the occasional murderer. I recommend this book to any mystery lover.
April 3, 2020
Another visit to Arborville, New Jersey involves mystery, knitting, wonderful food, friendship, lovable feline & canine furbabies and murder! Pamela & Bettina have to find out who committed a murder and their knitting circle member, Roland is the prime suspect.
Reading this book/series feels like a visit with good friends. The mystery is fast-paced, well-written and the descriptions of Arborville and Pamela's work as an assistant editor for a magazine, the friendships in the knitting group and her cooking skills add to the character's depth. Of course, having two feline housemates makes the books even more cozy. Pamela doesn't take risks and I enjoy the fact that her sleuthing partner Bettina's character is written as strongly as the main character. I do wish Pamela would be a little more open to a relationship with the next door neighbor, Richard Larkin.
Impatiently waiting for the next visit!
I received an ARC from NetGalley and the opinions expressed are my own.
Reading this book/series feels like a visit with good friends. The mystery is fast-paced, well-written and the descriptions of Arborville and Pamela's work as an assistant editor for a magazine, the friendships in the knitting group and her cooking skills add to the character's depth. Of course, having two feline housemates makes the books even more cozy. Pamela doesn't take risks and I enjoy the fact that her sleuthing partner Bettina's character is written as strongly as the main character. I do wish Pamela would be a little more open to a relationship with the next door neighbor, Richard Larkin.
Impatiently waiting for the next visit!
I received an ARC from NetGalley and the opinions expressed are my own.
March 13, 2020
Too Much Fluff and Fill; Too Little Mystery
A Fatal Yarn is the fifth book in Peggy Ehrhart’s Knit & Nibble Mystery series. This is a light and entertaining read. The author’s descriptive writing flows somewhat smoothly and slowly, and the descriptions of making coffee, eating, cooking, and daily routines that are more than a little tedious. The well-developed characters are likable, and the mystery is interesting but other than in a few scenes, it plays a minor role in the book.
Pamela Paterson is a widow who lives in Arborville, New Jersey, and has one daughter, Penny, who attends college. Pamela works from home as an associate editor of a craft magazine and is the founder of the Knit and Nibble knitting club. Bettina Fraser is her neighbor, friend, fellow knitter, the chief reporter for the town’s weekly newspaper, and sleuthing partner. The town has been placing red Xs on trees that are to be cut down because they might interfere with power lines, and an anonymous activist group known as the Yarnvaders has been knitting sweaters for the trees to cover the red Xs. When Mayor Bill Diefenbach, who is in favor of the tree removal, is murdered, Detective Clayborn arrests Roland DeCamp, one of the members of the knitting group, because the two men were observed arguing in public and his car was spotted in front of the mayor’s house the evening he was murdered. Pamela and Bettina hope to learn more about the Yarnvaders and want to clear Roland’s name.
I received an Advance Reader Copy of this book from NetGalley and voluntarily reviewed it.
A Fatal Yarn is the fifth book in Peggy Ehrhart’s Knit & Nibble Mystery series. This is a light and entertaining read. The author’s descriptive writing flows somewhat smoothly and slowly, and the descriptions of making coffee, eating, cooking, and daily routines that are more than a little tedious. The well-developed characters are likable, and the mystery is interesting but other than in a few scenes, it plays a minor role in the book.
Pamela Paterson is a widow who lives in Arborville, New Jersey, and has one daughter, Penny, who attends college. Pamela works from home as an associate editor of a craft magazine and is the founder of the Knit and Nibble knitting club. Bettina Fraser is her neighbor, friend, fellow knitter, the chief reporter for the town’s weekly newspaper, and sleuthing partner. The town has been placing red Xs on trees that are to be cut down because they might interfere with power lines, and an anonymous activist group known as the Yarnvaders has been knitting sweaters for the trees to cover the red Xs. When Mayor Bill Diefenbach, who is in favor of the tree removal, is murdered, Detective Clayborn arrests Roland DeCamp, one of the members of the knitting group, because the two men were observed arguing in public and his car was spotted in front of the mayor’s house the evening he was murdered. Pamela and Bettina hope to learn more about the Yarnvaders and want to clear Roland’s name.
I received an Advance Reader Copy of this book from NetGalley and voluntarily reviewed it.
April 4, 2020
Dollycas’s Thoughts
The Knit and Nibblers are back and trying to figure out who is wrapping tree trunks in knit scarves to cover up the red x’s designated the trees to be destroyed to protect the power lines above. The town’s mayor supports the project and when he is murdered Pamela wonders if the tree hugger is responsible. But the police arrest fellow knitter Rolland DeCamp because he was witnessed arguing with the mayor. Pamela and Bettina cast on a wider net of suspects and do their best to knit together the clues to purl the right culprit behind bars.
We follow Pamela through her daily life as she works from home as an editor for “Fiber Craft Magazine,” and does a little sleuthing on the side with friend, neighbor, and yarn and nibbler Bettina. Bettina is very pushy trying to get Pamela to date another neighbor but Pamela keeps putting her off. She is just not interested. I am surprised it hasn’t caused more strain in their friendship. It seems that issue has wrapped in this installment and that makes me very happy.
I do enjoy Ms. Ehrhart’s descriptive writing style. She tells the story in a way that brings the reader right into each scene, from her home office with her working on such interesting sounding articles, to the items being knit and the food being eaten. I love the camaraderie between the characters and the way they support each other. The conversations are realistic and you can tell they truly care about each other.
The mystery is on the light side and I did figure it out early in the story but all the drama and daily life kept me entertained right up to the final word. These are characters I love visiting and am looking forward to the next book.
A Fatal Yarn is a great addition to this series. Fix yourself something to nibble on and enjoy.
The Knit and Nibblers are back and trying to figure out who is wrapping tree trunks in knit scarves to cover up the red x’s designated the trees to be destroyed to protect the power lines above. The town’s mayor supports the project and when he is murdered Pamela wonders if the tree hugger is responsible. But the police arrest fellow knitter Rolland DeCamp because he was witnessed arguing with the mayor. Pamela and Bettina cast on a wider net of suspects and do their best to knit together the clues to purl the right culprit behind bars.
We follow Pamela through her daily life as she works from home as an editor for “Fiber Craft Magazine,” and does a little sleuthing on the side with friend, neighbor, and yarn and nibbler Bettina. Bettina is very pushy trying to get Pamela to date another neighbor but Pamela keeps putting her off. She is just not interested. I am surprised it hasn’t caused more strain in their friendship. It seems that issue has wrapped in this installment and that makes me very happy.
I do enjoy Ms. Ehrhart’s descriptive writing style. She tells the story in a way that brings the reader right into each scene, from her home office with her working on such interesting sounding articles, to the items being knit and the food being eaten. I love the camaraderie between the characters and the way they support each other. The conversations are realistic and you can tell they truly care about each other.
The mystery is on the light side and I did figure it out early in the story but all the drama and daily life kept me entertained right up to the final word. These are characters I love visiting and am looking forward to the next book.
A Fatal Yarn is a great addition to this series. Fix yourself something to nibble on and enjoy.
November 11, 2021
3.5 ⭐
another great installment in this series that has quickly become a favorite. though i read this book slowly - and therefore felt a little less connected to the story than usual - it was only because of an oncoming reading slump and every time i did get around to picking this up, it was a welcome cozy bubble away from the world
another great installment in this series that has quickly become a favorite. though i read this book slowly - and therefore felt a little less connected to the story than usual - it was only because of an oncoming reading slump and every time i did get around to picking this up, it was a welcome cozy bubble away from the world
March 3, 2020
A Fatal Yarn is a great addition to this series. The knitting group has to save one of their own after the grisly murder of a local man sets the town on edge.
This is a light cozy mystery, with plenty of action to keep the reader anxiously waiting for the big reveal.
This is a light cozy mystery, with plenty of action to keep the reader anxiously waiting for the big reveal.
January 11, 2021
Pamela Paterson is a widow living in Arborville, New Jersey. She works from home for a craft magazine, and is the creator of the Knit and Nibble group, which are people who go from home to home each week with their knitting projects, and the host feeds the "nibbles." She's wondering who's putting knitted sweaters on trees, but when the mayor is suddenly murdered, the trees take a back seat to her looking into who had motive to kill him, since the person who was arrested is the knitters' own Roland DeCamp, the sole male and quietest of the group. Now Pamela and her best friend Bettina Fraser, who is a newspaper reporter, are on the trail of a killer...
This is the fifth book in the series and I have to say it's the weakest. There were things that bothered me aside from the usual, which is the incessant rattling on of what everyone is eating and wearing. Our protagonist, Pamela, doesn't fall into the "wearing" category because she never wears anything but jeans and cotton tops. How boring. So naturally, she's always mentally commenting on Bettina's scarlet hair (not found in nature) and clothing. Nothing like constantly critiquing your best friend, right?
I've pretty much had it with this series. Besides what I've mentioned above (and in other reviews on other books of this author), Pamela doesn't appear to be as smart as she's made out to be. She's been a widow for seven years, but isn't ready to date again? Does she believe her late husband wants her to be alone the rest of her life? And I don't think much of a man who will give away his pet because his new girlfriend is superstitious. What happens if the relationship doesn't work? Now his beloved pet isn't there, either. Stupid, stupid, stupid. Both of them. My own opinion, people.
I also get tired of the fact that there are no clues leading to the identity of the murderer, but Pamela puts it together like that!...and the conclusion is there. It seems that the author is more concerned with what everyone is eating, wearing, and what dishes they're using to serve on, etc., than the murder or the solving of it. (I also get tired of Nell looking down on people who eat sugar and criticizing them for it. It is none of her business what other people eat).
When my eyes stopped glazing over, I had finished the book. I've read five of these, but I can't say that I will read any more of them.
This is the fifth book in the series and I have to say it's the weakest. There were things that bothered me aside from the usual, which is the incessant rattling on of what everyone is eating and wearing. Our protagonist, Pamela, doesn't fall into the "wearing" category because she never wears anything but jeans and cotton tops. How boring. So naturally, she's always mentally commenting on Bettina's scarlet hair (not found in nature) and clothing. Nothing like constantly critiquing your best friend, right?
I've pretty much had it with this series. Besides what I've mentioned above (and in other reviews on other books of this author), Pamela doesn't appear to be as smart as she's made out to be. She's been a widow for seven years, but isn't ready to date again? Does she believe her late husband wants her to be alone the rest of her life? And I don't think much of a man who will give away his pet because his new girlfriend is superstitious. What happens if the relationship doesn't work? Now his beloved pet isn't there, either. Stupid, stupid, stupid. Both of them. My own opinion, people.
I also get tired of the fact that there are no clues leading to the identity of the murderer, but Pamela puts it together like that!...and the conclusion is there. It seems that the author is more concerned with what everyone is eating, wearing, and what dishes they're using to serve on, etc., than the murder or the solving of it. (I also get tired of Nell looking down on people who eat sugar and criticizing them for it. It is none of her business what other people eat).
When my eyes stopped glazing over, I had finished the book. I've read five of these, but I can't say that I will read any more of them.
November 23, 2020
I really enjoyed this book. This is the first book I have read from this series. The characters are fun and interesting. The setting of a small town is cozy and quaint. The mystery is full of twists and turns to keep you guessing. I will definitely read more of this series.
All thoughts and opinions are my own, and in no way have I been influenced by anyone.
All thoughts and opinions are my own, and in no way have I been influenced by anyone.
March 17, 2020
4 Stars
This is the fifth book in the Knit & Nibble mystery series by Peggy Ehrhart.
The mystery here is a little far-fetched but nothing beyond comprehension. I love crafting mysteries and this one did not disappoint. I got all the feel good friend moments and the searching for answers moments as well.
There have been a few trees in Arborville tagged for removal and there is a knitter or group of knitters out there trying to hide the marks to save the trees. However, there is one tree hugger who will turn to murder to further their nature loving cause.
Pamela is the main POV character here but she spends quite a lot of time with Bettina trying to solve the mystery of who killed Mayor Diefenbach. The Knit and Nibble knitters club featuyres prominently too. Such a fun group to watch socialize. This is one of the best aspects of the book. I love how they bond together by doing their craft. One of their fellow knitters, Roland, gets pegged as the main suspect.
At the end there is a recipe that almost felt like it was in an awkward place. The ending wasn’t as solid as I normally like. And while I was listening with the text reader, it flowed straight into the recipe. I guess I just wanted a little better “this is the end” moment. I did feel left a bit hanging once the story was over. But in a way that is good since you want to leave them wanting more, right?
If you love a good cozy mystery, definitely check this one out. You won’t be disappointed.
I received this as an ARC (Advanced Reader Copy) in return for an honest review. I thank NetGalley, the publisher and the author for allowing me to read this title.
This is the fifth book in the Knit & Nibble mystery series by Peggy Ehrhart.
The mystery here is a little far-fetched but nothing beyond comprehension. I love crafting mysteries and this one did not disappoint. I got all the feel good friend moments and the searching for answers moments as well.
There have been a few trees in Arborville tagged for removal and there is a knitter or group of knitters out there trying to hide the marks to save the trees. However, there is one tree hugger who will turn to murder to further their nature loving cause.
Pamela is the main POV character here but she spends quite a lot of time with Bettina trying to solve the mystery of who killed Mayor Diefenbach. The Knit and Nibble knitters club featuyres prominently too. Such a fun group to watch socialize. This is one of the best aspects of the book. I love how they bond together by doing their craft. One of their fellow knitters, Roland, gets pegged as the main suspect.
At the end there is a recipe that almost felt like it was in an awkward place. The ending wasn’t as solid as I normally like. And while I was listening with the text reader, it flowed straight into the recipe. I guess I just wanted a little better “this is the end” moment. I did feel left a bit hanging once the story was over. But in a way that is good since you want to leave them wanting more, right?
If you love a good cozy mystery, definitely check this one out. You won’t be disappointed.
I received this as an ARC (Advanced Reader Copy) in return for an honest review. I thank NetGalley, the publisher and the author for allowing me to read this title.
May 15, 2021
Scrumptious food and a puzzling mystery
Once again I loved the foods cooked up by Pamela and Bettina as they slowly unravel the mysteries of their little town. I love the neighborhood feel of these stories and feel like I could be joining in with this group of friends and neighbors who love their town and community events if there are different factions wanting different things. I had hoped Pamela would relax around Richard more. But maybe he just isn't the one - or at least the second one. And I almost want to take up knitting!!
Once again I loved the foods cooked up by Pamela and Bettina as they slowly unravel the mysteries of their little town. I love the neighborhood feel of these stories and feel like I could be joining in with this group of friends and neighbors who love their town and community events if there are different factions wanting different things. I had hoped Pamela would relax around Richard more. But maybe he just isn't the one - or at least the second one. And I almost want to take up knitting!!
June 22, 2022
There has been yet another murder in Arborville and a member of the Knit & Nibble has been arrested. Of course Pamela and Betina set out to uncover the facts and discover who the real killer is. As with previous books there is plenty of focus on Betina's fashion and the food. Lots of food. Honestly, who can eat as much of these two? The books provide a good light hearted and quick read, perfect for between heavier topics, and I'll continue on with the series.
May 25, 2020
I enjoyed Pamela and Bettina! I probably enjoyed Bettina a little more because she's colorful and energetic and happy and poor Pamela can come across a little morose. I enjoyed the simplicity and the family feel that this cozy gave. I also enjoyed the day to day details which made it feel more mature to me. I could do without Pamela's daughter Penny though! Nice clean story.
May 27, 2020
Pamela sees the trees around town with knitted sweaters on them, trying to get the mayor to stop the trees being cut down. The Mayor is killed and one of Pamela’s knitting group is the main suspect. Pamela knows he didn’t do it and goes in search of who did.
April 5, 2020
This one takes place around Easter in New Jersey. There isn't much romance, but there is a lot of food and coffee. There is also a lot of yarn and knitting. The mystery involves trees, yarn bombing, jam, the historical society, and a tag sale. The mystery was interesting, and the story was fun.
January 14, 2021
How the killer did the deed and why made sense, but you might as well shoot dice and pick a killer-there is no game for the reader in these books.
May 9, 2023
Another great book in the series.
June 29, 2020
I'm ambivalent about this serie.
I bought the 5 books, and pre-ordered the next but... description, description, description.
I have no problem with it in itself, but it takes way too much place. Three pages to describe a 30mn car travel ? If there was any remarkable landmark to be described, why not, but there's nothing of the sort.
And is it necessary to describe over and over the color of Bettina's plates and mugs (11 times) or the use of Pamela's wedding china (13 times) or of her sugar and milk set (5 times) and "the lace that curtained the oval window" of her front door (6 times) ?
I get it that describing a daily routine might create a cozy feeling, but it also slows the story a lot (and reading again and again the exact same words brings me close to screaming more than anything else). Maybe a bit less whole-grain bread (11 times) and a bit more feelings and dialogues would help giving rythm to the mystery, which is interesting, and a bit more depths to the characters.
And yet, I'm quite fond of Pamela's social awkwardness and of Bettina's colorful self (and maybe that's why I keep reading those books).
I bought the 5 books, and pre-ordered the next but... description, description, description.
I have no problem with it in itself, but it takes way too much place. Three pages to describe a 30mn car travel ? If there was any remarkable landmark to be described, why not, but there's nothing of the sort.
And is it necessary to describe over and over the color of Bettina's plates and mugs (11 times) or the use of Pamela's wedding china (13 times) or of her sugar and milk set (5 times) and "the lace that curtained the oval window" of her front door (6 times) ?
I get it that describing a daily routine might create a cozy feeling, but it also slows the story a lot (and reading again and again the exact same words brings me close to screaming more than anything else). Maybe a bit less whole-grain bread (11 times) and a bit more feelings and dialogues would help giving rythm to the mystery, which is interesting, and a bit more depths to the characters.
And yet, I'm quite fond of Pamela's social awkwardness and of Bettina's colorful self (and maybe that's why I keep reading those books).
September 16, 2020
A good friend sent me a screenshot of this, we both enjoy knitting and the book was on sale for $0.99. We didn't realize it was a series, nor the 5th in the series when we decided to read it together, because it's a pandemic and a knitting mystery with cats on the cover sounded exactly perfect. And you know, it was exactly perfect! And you don't need to read the first 4 books to dive in, although confession, I did download the first book because the characters are zany and fun.
The one strange thing that I kept noticing about the writing is that the author will describe a lot of routine things in very great detail without it being applicable to the plot. For example, very detailed description of the character making a piece of toast...to the point where you think toasting bread must be a key to the mystery, but no, it wasn't. And it was like that for a lot of things--going to the grocery store, making a sandwich...so that was amusing but if I read too many of these it would get old.
The one strange thing that I kept noticing about the writing is that the author will describe a lot of routine things in very great detail without it being applicable to the plot. For example, very detailed description of the character making a piece of toast...to the point where you think toasting bread must be a key to the mystery, but no, it wasn't. And it was like that for a lot of things--going to the grocery store, making a sandwich...so that was amusing but if I read too many of these it would get old.
July 9, 2023
This is the 5th book in the series, although one can read each book as a stand alone. I really wanted to like the series as I'm always looking for a new cozy mystery series and especially since the characters are a little older than the normal cozy mystery. But, after the 5th book the descriptions of cooking and eating and what each character is wearing gets a little tedious and distracts from the mystery. In fact, it seems that the description of brewing coffee takes up more space than the actual mystery. If the author would take out the cooking and clothes descriptions, I bet the book would be 30 pages shorter. At any rate, I got tired of it and couldn't finish this one. It's enough for me.
April 25, 2024
The murder happens even before the story begins in "A Fatal Yarn." The victim is the newly elected mayor who is pro-business and anti-small town vibe. Roland, our grumpy male member of the Knit and Nibble knitting group, is the only suspect.
Of course, Pamela and Bettina step in to solve the murder and to save their friend.
Guessing whodunit is fairly formulaic, at this point. The reason behind the murder came mostly out of left field at the last moment and really was fairly senseless. To be fair, though, lots of real-life crimes make little sense, either.
Pamela has a tiny development in her personal life, and it's not a good one. Bettina gets a chance to flirt with a shifty guy.
Of course, Pamela and Bettina step in to solve the murder and to save their friend.
Guessing whodunit is fairly formulaic, at this point. The reason behind the murder came mostly out of left field at the last moment and really was fairly senseless. To be fair, though, lots of real-life crimes make little sense, either.
Pamela has a tiny development in her personal life, and it's not a good one. Bettina gets a chance to flirt with a shifty guy.
August 18, 2022
I really wanted to like this better. Maybe it's a side effect of starting a series at book 5, but I just couldn't connect with the characters. I found it very distracting that the author spent as much time (if not more) describing the food the characters were eating as she did developing the mystery. While this was odd, it was irritating how frequently I had to learn how everyone took their coffee, and what specific utensils were used.
May 13, 2024
Too much toast. Too many explanations of recipes. It feels like filler - like trying to get 1000 words, so you talk about bread. I’ve never read a mystery that talks about bread and toast soooooo much. Very odd. Otherwise the mystery is good. Just let up on the toast!!
July 11, 2025
"A Fatal Yarn," the fifth book in Peggy Ehrhart's Knit & Nibble Mystery series, brings Pamela Paterson and her knitting club into a quirky local controversy that turns deadly. In Arborville, New Jersey, someone's been "yarn bombing" trees marked for removal, covering red X's with colorful, cat-faced cozies. It's a charmingly rebellious act—until the town's mayor, who's all for cutting down the trees, is murdered. Suddenly, the anonymous "tree hugger" becomes a prime suspect, and when one of Knit and Nibble's own, Roland DeCamp, is arrested, Pamela knows it's time for her to start unraveling clues.
The concept of "arborcide" prevention through yarn bombing is a unique and fun hook for a cozy mystery, and it gives the book a distinct flavor. The camaraderie of the Knit and Nibble club is, as always, a comforting presence, and their collective efforts to clear Roland's name drive the investigation. It's easy to settle back into the familiar routines and friendships of Arborville, and the inclusion of a reporter friend helps Pamela branch out in her sleuthing.
However, while the premise is delightful and the characters are endearing, the execution of the mystery itself felt a little thin in places. The list of suspects, while present, didn't offer as many surprising twists or compelling red herrings as I usually look for. The investigation, while driven by Pamela's determination, sometimes felt a bit straightforward, and the ultimate reveal didn't quite have the impact or complexity that would have elevated it. The "yarn" of the plot, so to speak, didn't always feel as tightly spun as I would have liked.
Overall, "A Fatal Yarn" is a pleasant and comfortable read for fans of the Knit & Nibble series and those who enjoy knitting-themed cozies. It offers the familiar charm of Pamela and her club, but the central murder plot, while engaging enough, didn't fully capture my attention with its twists and turns.
★★★☆☆
#AFatalYarn #PeggyEhrhart #KnitAndNibbleMystery #CozyMystery #BookReview #Bookstagram #KnittingMystery #YarnBombing #Arborville #AmateurSleuth #Whodunnit #SmallTownMystery #TreeHugger
The concept of "arborcide" prevention through yarn bombing is a unique and fun hook for a cozy mystery, and it gives the book a distinct flavor. The camaraderie of the Knit and Nibble club is, as always, a comforting presence, and their collective efforts to clear Roland's name drive the investigation. It's easy to settle back into the familiar routines and friendships of Arborville, and the inclusion of a reporter friend helps Pamela branch out in her sleuthing.
However, while the premise is delightful and the characters are endearing, the execution of the mystery itself felt a little thin in places. The list of suspects, while present, didn't offer as many surprising twists or compelling red herrings as I usually look for. The investigation, while driven by Pamela's determination, sometimes felt a bit straightforward, and the ultimate reveal didn't quite have the impact or complexity that would have elevated it. The "yarn" of the plot, so to speak, didn't always feel as tightly spun as I would have liked.
Overall, "A Fatal Yarn" is a pleasant and comfortable read for fans of the Knit & Nibble series and those who enjoy knitting-themed cozies. It offers the familiar charm of Pamela and her club, but the central murder plot, while engaging enough, didn't fully capture my attention with its twists and turns.
★★★☆☆
#AFatalYarn #PeggyEhrhart #KnitAndNibbleMystery #CozyMystery #BookReview #Bookstagram #KnittingMystery #YarnBombing #Arborville #AmateurSleuth #Whodunnit #SmallTownMystery #TreeHugger
September 20, 2020
I have read four out of five of the books in the Knit & Nibble Mystery Series by Peggy Ehrhart, so I obviously enjoy the series as a whole. All of the books are more calming than usual for a cozy mystery series, rather like knitting is a tranquil activity for many. In A Fatal Yarn, however, the author’s greatest asset, descriptive writing, becomes a flaw in her writing. At first I was just amazed at passage after passage detailing settings and meals. Then I realized that the food descriptions especially had become redundant. I don’t really need repeated retellings of the main character’s preparations of black coffee and multigrain toast to understand that she only has coffee and toast for breakfast every day.
The story revolves around Pamela, a widow who edits articles for a fiber craft magazine, and her friend and neighbor Bettina, a writer for the local weekly paper. In this case, they are trying to prove that Roland, a member of their knitting group, did not murder the mayor. Before they can accomplish that task, they discover that an elderly woman in town did not die of natural causes. Pamela and Bettina follow clues by trailing suspects, interviewing those with connections to the victims, and occasionally putting themselves in harm’s way. The plot was good, the characters quite likable, and the descriptions well executed. I enjoyed it because I like the series, but I would not recommend this book to introduce someone to the series. I wondered, sadly, if this talented author was trying to fill out a word count. Regardless, I still want to read the next book in the Knit & Nibble series.
I would like to extend my thanks to Netgalley and to Kensington Books for giving me the opportunity to read this book in exchange for an honest review.
The story revolves around Pamela, a widow who edits articles for a fiber craft magazine, and her friend and neighbor Bettina, a writer for the local weekly paper. In this case, they are trying to prove that Roland, a member of their knitting group, did not murder the mayor. Before they can accomplish that task, they discover that an elderly woman in town did not die of natural causes. Pamela and Bettina follow clues by trailing suspects, interviewing those with connections to the victims, and occasionally putting themselves in harm’s way. The plot was good, the characters quite likable, and the descriptions well executed. I enjoyed it because I like the series, but I would not recommend this book to introduce someone to the series. I wondered, sadly, if this talented author was trying to fill out a word count. Regardless, I still want to read the next book in the Knit & Nibble series.
I would like to extend my thanks to Netgalley and to Kensington Books for giving me the opportunity to read this book in exchange for an honest review.
March 5, 2020
This is a fun story with a good plot. Bettina is hostess for the Knit and Nibble Knitting club. During their discussion, Roland thought Diefenbach, the current Mayor of Arborville, had excelllent ideas, whereas Nell said he was distressing becauce he wants to replace the Community Gardens with a high rise. Bettina's husband, Wilford, comes in to suggest it's time for tea and goodies. Pamela announces there is a hand knit sweater on her tree. The Yarnvaders are a secret group trying to save the trees which the the town wants to cut down by covering the red X with a sweater!
After snacks, the police arrive and arrest Roland, one of the knitters. Bettina and Pamela have more coffee after everyone leaves and decide they need to help save Roland. The next day they find that Roland is the prime suspect for the murder of Mayor Diefenbach, who has been murdered in his own kitchen by being hit in the head by something very heavy. Bettina and Pamela figure out several possible culprits, and visit several people who might not like the Mayor. They sometimes get in trouble while questioning, and near the end one of them decides who the murderer is, and puts herself into a very dangerous position.
My major complaint about the book is that there seem to be too many coffee breaks with long descriptions of the dishes and making the coffee as well as cooking procedures. There is a recipe at the end of the book of Lemon Yogurt Easter Cake with Cream Cheese Icing. In the story part there are three pages telling how Pamela made the cake. However, I want to make it clear that I liked the story and the characters.
After snacks, the police arrive and arrest Roland, one of the knitters. Bettina and Pamela have more coffee after everyone leaves and decide they need to help save Roland. The next day they find that Roland is the prime suspect for the murder of Mayor Diefenbach, who has been murdered in his own kitchen by being hit in the head by something very heavy. Bettina and Pamela figure out several possible culprits, and visit several people who might not like the Mayor. They sometimes get in trouble while questioning, and near the end one of them decides who the murderer is, and puts herself into a very dangerous position.
My major complaint about the book is that there seem to be too many coffee breaks with long descriptions of the dishes and making the coffee as well as cooking procedures. There is a recipe at the end of the book of Lemon Yogurt Easter Cake with Cream Cheese Icing. In the story part there are three pages telling how Pamela made the cake. However, I want to make it clear that I liked the story and the characters.
April 9, 2020
This is the fifth installment in the cozy series "Knit & Nibble" by cozy author Peggy Ehrhart. I always enjoy returning to this delightful series. This can be read as a stand alone however I recommend the entire series and each reader will enjoy reading this series from the beginning. Thank you to the publisher and to Net Galley for the opportunity. My review opinions are my own.
Our protagonist Pamela and her "Knit & Nibble" group are trying to figure out who is putting knitted sweaters on the trees in town . The anonymous person has been covering the trees that are marked for removal by the city of Arborville New Jersey. Each tree covered had a red X on it to be marked for removal. Many are unhappy about the tree removal and the knitting activist covering every tree marked is unknown to Pamela and her group of friends all of whom are in her knitting group. When the mayor is murdered it leaves the town reeling and wondering if he was killed because he supported taking down the trees. Pamela and her savvy group of knitters are soon to investigate when one of their own friends is prime suspect number one led to the police by knitting needles and clues. Soon red herrings and suspects abound as their investigation takes a unexpected turn.
I loved this next in series. Each book is fun and has knitting tips knitters will love. The author even includes receipes in every book. The knitters are a fun group of close friends who always support one another. The charcters all add to the story and the sleuth was surprising to me to conclusion. I look forward to the next in series.
Our protagonist Pamela and her "Knit & Nibble" group are trying to figure out who is putting knitted sweaters on the trees in town . The anonymous person has been covering the trees that are marked for removal by the city of Arborville New Jersey. Each tree covered had a red X on it to be marked for removal. Many are unhappy about the tree removal and the knitting activist covering every tree marked is unknown to Pamela and her group of friends all of whom are in her knitting group. When the mayor is murdered it leaves the town reeling and wondering if he was killed because he supported taking down the trees. Pamela and her savvy group of knitters are soon to investigate when one of their own friends is prime suspect number one led to the police by knitting needles and clues. Soon red herrings and suspects abound as their investigation takes a unexpected turn.
I loved this next in series. Each book is fun and has knitting tips knitters will love. The author even includes receipes in every book. The knitters are a fun group of close friends who always support one another. The charcters all add to the story and the sleuth was surprising to me to conclusion. I look forward to the next in series.
March 28, 2020
A Fatal Yarn has some good misdirection that makes for a mystery to keep readers guessing, and it continues to do something that I really appreciate. So many niche cozy mystery series have a "hook"-- be it knitting, cooking, glassblowing, or any other hobby-- but often those hooks are superficial. Once used to draw readers in, they have little to do with the actual story. Not with Peggy Ehrhart's Knit & Nibble series. Knitting continues to be at the heart of the stories, and I really liked the version of yarnbombing that was used in connection to the tree sweaters.
Pamela Paterson is the heart and soul of the Knit & Nibble mysteries. She's an editor for "Fiber Craft Magazine," and I have the sneaking suspicion that I'm not the only reader who wishes the magazine was real. Many of the articles mentioned sound fascinating. The only thing I don't care for is Pamela's best friend Bettina constantly trying to be a matchmaker between Pamela and Pamela's next-door neighbor. Not every single woman wants or needs a man to be happy, and that matchmaking schtick gets old.
Not only A Fatal Yarn but all the books in this series are perfect comfort reads for trying times. Ehrhart has a writing style that is lush, filled with a dazzling color palette and mouthwatering tastes and aromas. She wants readers to be fully immersed in her world, and she creates a wonderful feeling of community by including all the sorts of little rituals that bind us together. Just one tiny word of warning. If repetition bothers you, don't read these books one right after the other. If you do, you might want to scream after awhile when Bettina dons her pumpkin-colored coat for the umpteenth time or puts her sage green plates on the table yet again. If you aren't bothered by repetition, then dive right in. Peggy Ehrhart's Knit & Nibble mysteries are a feast for the eyes, the taste buds, and the heart. It's a series that I truly enjoy.
Pamela Paterson is the heart and soul of the Knit & Nibble mysteries. She's an editor for "Fiber Craft Magazine," and I have the sneaking suspicion that I'm not the only reader who wishes the magazine was real. Many of the articles mentioned sound fascinating. The only thing I don't care for is Pamela's best friend Bettina constantly trying to be a matchmaker between Pamela and Pamela's next-door neighbor. Not every single woman wants or needs a man to be happy, and that matchmaking schtick gets old.
Not only A Fatal Yarn but all the books in this series are perfect comfort reads for trying times. Ehrhart has a writing style that is lush, filled with a dazzling color palette and mouthwatering tastes and aromas. She wants readers to be fully immersed in her world, and she creates a wonderful feeling of community by including all the sorts of little rituals that bind us together. Just one tiny word of warning. If repetition bothers you, don't read these books one right after the other. If you do, you might want to scream after awhile when Bettina dons her pumpkin-colored coat for the umpteenth time or puts her sage green plates on the table yet again. If you aren't bothered by repetition, then dive right in. Peggy Ehrhart's Knit & Nibble mysteries are a feast for the eyes, the taste buds, and the heart. It's a series that I truly enjoy.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 135 reviews