Book # 2 in the best selling Helmsman saga! Ursis nodded soberly out the Hyperscreens toward the merchant ships, then turned to Brim. "Out there, Wilf Ansor," he brooded, "are real heroes of war. To fight from behind disruptors of warship is something anyone can do. One can always count on lucky shooting to save him from disaster—or heavy armor plate at least. But to face enemy with only black void and thin sheet of hullmetal separating you from disruptors—and then stay in formation—that is kind of bravery we Sodeskayans record in Great Books."
Of course, I also like greasy tortilla chips piled high with melted cheese and bits of sliced olives and stuff. Not as a steady diet, but now and then. You have been warned.
This is the first book in "The Helmsman" series by Bill Baldwin. I have had this book in my to read pile for a while now and decided to read it because I am a fan of Space Opera/Military Science Fiction. I was a little disappointed in it however. The story line was pretty standard stuff. A poor boy named Wilf Brim from a backwards planet makes it into the space academy where he is looked down upon by the higher class students. Upon graduation he is assigned to a starship where he decides to prove himself to everyone and he does! Along the way he falls in love with a pretty Lieutenant who turns out to be a princess. She is betrothed to a prince, but against all, odds she loves Wilf back. One thing I didn't like about this book was that at every meeting between the Princess and Wilf they would spout obscure poetry at each other. I have the next book in this series in my to read pile but I don't know if I will ever get around to reading it.
This was surprisingly better than I remember it being, having read it years ago. I was amused to discover that the recent Imperials book by M. Snodgrass borrowed many of the exact same plot elements (over-achieving lower caste military hero meets imperial princess & begins hopeless relationship, for instance). However, the picaresque tale told here has more space navy substance and less political/psychological maneuvering. This is a straightforward military coming-of-age book, a genre I enjoy as a guilty pleasure. This book hits all the right notes, and I enjoyed reading it again.
While the science and the practical qualities of this book are dated, the adventure is fun. The characters are interesting if a little off the shelf. This is a very fun series of books and a good one for the younger readers transitioning from the young adults books to full fledged novels. I read it for the first time when I was in high school and have read it again twice. It still holds that youthful charm for a crusty old man in his forties.
This is my third time reading this series, but will be a first in two ways - my first time reading all eight books in succession, and my first time reading them all in electronic format.
In my late teens I discovered the Helmsman space opera series and enjoyed them. The Helmsman series, at the time, was the first space opera that I read with somewhat graphic sex (pretty mild by comparison today) and written by a history buff.
As someone interested in both World Wars and familiar with several of the naval battles used as templates for the conflicts in these books, I have enjoyed them every time I read them.
I have always thought that Wilf Brim and the Carescrian people were based on the Irish with some Welsh mixed in. The way that the author describes treatment of the Carescrian people in the mines, is similar to how the Irish and Welsh were treated in the coal mines.
As someone from a marginalized, disenfranchised segment of society to rise so quickly has always made me think "bullshit." For someone to date a royal and known to spend time in her bed, I always had to suspend some belief that a Carescrian would rise to bed a royal princess so quickly.
Granted it says a lot about Margot's character that she is able to see past Wilf's humble origins and does not let that stop her from loving him, despite her royal obligations. Thankfully the romantic aspects are few and far enough in the background that it does not read like a space romance.
Noticed a lot of typos and errors in this version, not enough to detract from reading but enough to pull me from the action for a minute. I like the expanded version but still wish there was more about some of the minor characters such as Colonel Dark.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
This is my third voyage through Bill Baldwin's superb Helmsman series, and I am still learning more about the craft of sci-fi writing with every page. Baldwin takes you there, from the day when Sublieutenant Wilf Brim boards the IFS Truculent until he receives the Imperial Comet decoration from the hand of Prince Onrad. The action is fast, the world building magnificent and specific, the characters unforgettable.
Enjoyable sci-fi novel. It has it all, action, adventure, comradely, a very believable history, and an interesting science. It also touches on social injustice, class conflict, and even has a love affair. The battles are gripping and intense, the heroics believable and admirable. Overall a great military sci-fin novel.
Read it back in the 80s and loved it. Almost 40 years later I'm enjoying it again. As a grown man the sex scenes are kinda graphic and gross. Bill just doesn't have erotic prose. Suppose it was a must have for the young boys who read scifi then. I'm sure i thought it was great when i read ot ad a virgin.
Návrat k sérii po asi 20 rokoch. V zásade trochu prostoduchý dej, priamočiary smerom k hrdinovi. Ale prekne vykreslený svet plný konfliktov, ktoré sa neopakujú. Akurát rozmýšľam, kto bol skôr, či Wilf Brim alebo Honor Harrington. Jedna * navyše za nostalgiu.
The author is very good at story telling. Actually too good. He has a tendancy to get too verbose and wastes numerous pages with inconsequential stuff. I found myself skimming multiple pages of descriptions that were no more than page fillers. His use of extraterrestrial measurements became confusing. There was no need for it and only served to blur the mental image of what was being described. English or Metric would have been easier to imagine. Haven't yet decided to tackle another plethora of cycles, and such.
It was ok. Well, except for the poetry spouting romance scenes. I could have done without those. Actually, cutting out all the romance scenes would cut the size of the book by 1/3 & boost it to 3 stars. The atmosphere of the book felt very British-ww2-navy. I think in the artwork they should make him some sort of minority. I doubt I will read anymore. It just wasn't up to series like Sten, Honor Harrington, Lost Fleet, Lt. Leary, Star Carrier, or Old Man's War.
Fun, although did not read as smoothly as it could have. The main characters are relatively well developed and the battle scenes read well, but the love/sex scenes felt awkward. This is one of those series I would continue with if my local library had them, but I don't think this will become a "keep to re-read" for me, so I doubt if I will purchase the next one.
Excellent Space Navy Science Fiction. Main character Wilf Brim very strongly written with space and land battles galore It having been a few years since I read this book I'd forgotten how terrific it is. Excellent Military Space Navy space opera. A strong almost believable romance and fantastic battle scenes. Great and happily I have 7 more books in the series to re read
Fun, workmanlike, rags to riches space opera. The main character is fun, the episodes are entertaining, some of the plot twists are enjoyably improbable, and lots of spaceships blow up. Don't ask for more, and this is just the ticket.
This book although set far in the future has the feel of a tale of a Knight in shining armour. I have heard that this series is over 10 books now thogh I have read only 6. I would easily give the ones I have read 4 stars ( the first gets 5).
I still don't know if this is a space opera or a parody of one :) Stoned space Nazis, bears on troikas, hyperscreen on bridges... But this is good and action-packed story. I quite enjoyed it.
Old school science fiction - sorta like Horatio Hornblower in space but not as well done as David Weber's Honor Harrington series. A good but not great read.