Cet ouvrage présente et commente les plus importantes œuvres d’art chinoises, dont certaines sont encore inédites en Occident. Se voulant le reflet des manières spécifiques dont Chinois et Occidentaux écrivent sur l’art et en construisent l’histoire, il nous donne une vision d’ensemble d’une tradition picturale pluri-millénaire.
A large formatted, very heavy book with astonishingly beautiful prints -- accompanied by academic essays by various specialists. I rarely find the 'academic' essays in these art books to be of much interest -- I'm not sure why -- either because I'm too impatient or because they are often dull --. At any rate, a lovely survey of a vast sweep of Chinese painting.
this was really good i thought it was super in depth. unfortunately it was too long and i was not able to finish it before i had to return it to the library lol
I was surprised at how uninteresting this book could be, at times, at how plodding the narrative was. The artwork was great, but I felt like the discussions of the artwork was often not insightful or illuminating.
Not as good as I had expected. Except for the chapter on Qing paintings, I found the other chapters to be not pleasantly written, quite difficult to follow. Sometimes paintings were described that were not even depicted in the book. I find myself not anymore knowledgeable on Chinese painting, unfortunately.
2 stars for the nice paintings and for the Qing chapter.
Second half of the essays is extremely messy and could have used more judicious editing; first half, esp. essays by Wu Hung, Barnhart, and Cahill excellent.