This is a book I’ve heard many praise. Furthermore, as one preparing for pastoral ministry, and as one living within a culture growing in perversion and sexual temptations, I was eager to read this book, and I approached such with the expectation of finding this book to be a 5 star review. Sadly, Street provides a less than helpful resource for battling sexual sin.
First, the positives of the book. Street’s desire to genuinely help those struggling with sexual sin is abundantly clear in his writing. It’s obvious that was what he wanted to accomplish in writing this book.
Secondly, Street provides helpful chapters on seeing sexual sin as ultimately a heart issue, and ultimately a sin issue. Street does a good job showing how sexual lusts and temptations (as all other lusts and temptations) have their genesis within our hearts. Furthermore, the deceitful nature of our heart is therefore evidence that we must look outside of ourselves for any hope. Likewise, Street speaks of the severity we must deal with our sin and temptation. He also shows how motivations and idolatry of the heart are to be dealt with regarding sin.
Within these two areas, Street succeeds. However, despite the above positives, there are significant negatives that of the most unhelpful kind.
For starters, it’s hard to tell the intended audience of this book. At times it seems to be written for those struggling with sexual sin (which is the primary audience this reader gathered from reading). However, there are many times where the book seems to be written for those counseling others in and through sexual sin. Perhaps, the book was intended as some form of hybrid. The issue with this lack of clarity is that, for this reader, it made the overall argument and flow clunky and unnecessarily repetitive without building on the argumentation in area of repeat.
The second issue is in relation to the intention and intended audience. For a book that is seeking to aid those who are entrapped in serious and deep sexual sin, the book uses language that is, to be quite blunt and honest, overly graphic and encouraging to the imagination. Street’s apparent lack of consideration here would not be helpful for the imagination for one seriously struggling with, and wanting to kill, sexual sin. If anything, it is a book that is written with such graphic language at times, I would fear it may cause someone to fall into the very sin this book is seeking to rescue them from. Overall, the language chosen in this book is not edifying. This also leads me to think perhaps this book was written for the counselor, not the counselee. And even so, the language is unhelpful at times.
More sensitivity, discernment, and consideration for this perhaps would have saved this book from such a devastating flaw.
Discussing this issue with others that read it, they likewise found the same issue to be a burden while reading.
Despite the above negatives, there is still one that is more problematic for this reader. Simply, Street does not actually provide any hope for those entrapped with this category of sin. There is very little hope offered in the gospel, in Christ, and through sanctification found in this book. Street ends with an apparent attempt at such hope, but it’s really just a quick list of things with little to no explanation. If a reader is struggling with sexual sin, I have very little confidence they would walk away with any sense of hope and encouragement in Christ through the gospel. If anything, they would most likely walk away defeated, if a Christian, doubting their salvation, and faced with the question if there is any hope of escape from such serious sin.
Street simply spends virtually 95% of the book showing how to identify sexual sin and the seriousness of sexual sin, but never actually giving hope of conquering sexual sin through sanctification.
In sum, this would be a book I would reference on my bookshelf for counseling someone entangled with sin, but is not a book I would ever place in the hands of one enslaved to sexual sin wanting to kill it.