What do you think?
Rate this book
We Could Be Heroes
Shiloh meets Raymie Nightingale in this funny and heartwarming debut novel about a ten-year-old that finds himself in a whole mess of trouble when his new friend Maisie recruits him to save the dog next door.
Hank Hudson is in a bit of trouble. After an incident involving the boy’s bathroom and a terribly sad book his teacher is forcing them to read, Hank is left with a week’s suspension and a slightly charred hardcover—and, it turns out, the attention of new girl Maisie Huang.
Maisie has been on the lookout for a kid with the meatballs to help her with a very important mission: Saving her neighbor’s dog, Booler. Booler has seizures, and his owner, Mr. Jorgensen, keeps him tied to a tree all day and night because of them. It’s enough to make Hank even sadder than that book does—he has autism, and he knows what it’s like to be treated poorly because of something that makes you different.
But different is not less. And Hank is willing to get into even more trouble to prove it. Soon he and Maisie are lying, brown-nosing, baking, and cow milking all in the name of saving Booler—but not everything is as it seems. Booler might not be the only one who needs saving. And being a hero can look a lot like being a friend.
Hank Hudson is in a bit of trouble. After an incident involving the boy’s bathroom and a terribly sad book his teacher is forcing them to read, Hank is left with a week’s suspension and a slightly charred hardcover—and, it turns out, the attention of new girl Maisie Huang.
Maisie has been on the lookout for a kid with the meatballs to help her with a very important mission: Saving her neighbor’s dog, Booler. Booler has seizures, and his owner, Mr. Jorgensen, keeps him tied to a tree all day and night because of them. It’s enough to make Hank even sadder than that book does—he has autism, and he knows what it’s like to be treated poorly because of something that makes you different.
But different is not less. And Hank is willing to get into even more trouble to prove it. Soon he and Maisie are lying, brown-nosing, baking, and cow milking all in the name of saving Booler—but not everything is as it seems. Booler might not be the only one who needs saving. And being a hero can look a lot like being a friend.
Hardcover
First published January 1, 2020
20 people are currently reading
538 people want to read
About the author
Margaret Finnegan
11 books28 followersMargaret Finnegan's work has appeared in Salon, LA Times, FamilyFun and other publications. She is the author of the middle-grade novel, WE COULD BE HEROES (Atheneum Books for Young Readers)--NOW A JUNIOR LIBRARY GUILD SELECTION!
She lives in Southern California with her husband, two children, and her dog, Walt. She loves baking, soft-serve ice cream, and walking her dog.
She lives in Southern California with her husband, two children, and her dog, Walt. She loves baking, soft-serve ice cream, and walking her dog.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 82 reviews
February 24, 2020
It isn't easy to set a book on fire, but if you are the owner of a piece of camping equipment called a Survival 4000 Fire Striker with Compass and Whistle, you just might be able to accomplish your mission. At least, that's what Hank Hudson, a sensitive fourth grader, thought when he tried to burn the 495 page book about the Nazis hunting down a young boy that his teacher was reading to the class, a book that he found particularly sad and upsetting.
Hank, who is autistic, generally likes spending his time alone, thinking about and collecting rocks for his vast collection, from which he selects three each day to keep in his pocket and help him through the day. Returning to school after a three day suspension for trying to burn the book, Hank is approached by Maisie Huang, a girl in his class who was totally impressed by Hank's act of rebelliousness. Maisie has decided that he has 'the meatballs' to help her accomplish her own bold-as-brass mission. And she has just the thing needed to get Hank interested - both her parents are geologists and there are lots of rocks at her house.
Maisie's mission is simple - after freeing her neighbor's pit bill Booler, Hank will take him and give him a good home. Booler has epilepsy and his owner, Mr. Jorgensen, keeps him outside and tied to a tree while his two other dogs have free run of the house and yard. Maisie thinks this is cruel and, since Mr. Jorgensen won't let her have the dog, she's devised a plan to free Booler, so he can be Hank's dog, instead.
Little by little, Hank and Maisie become friends, much to the delight of Hank's parents. Maisie is, after all, his first friend and they spend lots of time together acting out The Jungle Book, Hank's favorite movie, while hanging around with Booler in his yard, and sometimes looking for rocks together in the schoolyard. But Maisie can be a strong, determined, even manipulative personality, who is relentless in her need to save Booler. Hank, on the other hand, is quiet and generally content with his rocks. But he does feel Maisie's manipulation and after their first attempt at saving Booler fails, along with Hank's first attempt at lying, he has a complete meltdown and is asked to consider whether she is really a good friend. Yes, Hank decides, she is. But that doesn't mean the two friends have given up on Booler, not by any stretch of the imagination.
We Could Be Heroes is told in the third person from Hank's point of view, which is an interesting perspective. Interesting because the story isn't about autism so much as it is about how Hank sees, experiences, and navigates the world as a person on the spectrum. I came away with a better understanding of autism, and particularly, autistic meltdowns and I think Finnegan made it very accessible for young readers to understand, as well. For example, Finnegan gave Hank the perfect geological description for the way his meltdowns might feel like to him: A'a is a Hawaiian word that describes the way the surface and bottom layers of lava cool at different rates after a volcanic eruption. With a meltdown, Hank experiences his body as out of sync. On the surface, he feels punctured and bruised by the way sounds, textures, colors, smells poke at him, while inside, he feels dense, heavy and immovable. Later, she describes how Hank's mother helps him regain a sense of evenness after a meltdown.
I have to admit I really didn't like Maisie at first for the same reason Hank is somewhat leery of her. But as Hank and Maisie's friendship begins to really solidify, I began to see her differently, so that by the time Maisie's truth finally comes out, I felt real empathy for her.
One thing I really liked in this book is that Hank's family is intact, that his parents marriage didn't end because of his autism, and that both parents are involved, understanding and, most importantly, patient.
We Could Be Heroes is at times very serious story, that deals with themes like autism, epilepsy, bullying, empathy, and friendships (both age appropriate and intergenerational), but it not one without humor and some very delicious sounding cookies. This is Margaret Finnegan's debut middle grade novel and it is a well-crafted open and honest look at what it means to be different without being less and living one's authentic truth. And definitely not to be missed.
Meet the Author:
Margaret Finnegan's work has appeared in FamilyFun, the Los Angeles Times, Salon, and other publications. She lives in South Pasadena, California, where she enjoys spending time with her family, walking her dog, and baking really good chocolate cakes. You can connect with her at MargaretFinnegan.com and
on Twitter @FinneganBegin and
Instagram @finneganbegin
This book is recommended for readers age 8+
This book was gratefully received from Barb at Blue Slip Media
Hank, who is autistic, generally likes spending his time alone, thinking about and collecting rocks for his vast collection, from which he selects three each day to keep in his pocket and help him through the day. Returning to school after a three day suspension for trying to burn the book, Hank is approached by Maisie Huang, a girl in his class who was totally impressed by Hank's act of rebelliousness. Maisie has decided that he has 'the meatballs' to help her accomplish her own bold-as-brass mission. And she has just the thing needed to get Hank interested - both her parents are geologists and there are lots of rocks at her house.
Maisie's mission is simple - after freeing her neighbor's pit bill Booler, Hank will take him and give him a good home. Booler has epilepsy and his owner, Mr. Jorgensen, keeps him outside and tied to a tree while his two other dogs have free run of the house and yard. Maisie thinks this is cruel and, since Mr. Jorgensen won't let her have the dog, she's devised a plan to free Booler, so he can be Hank's dog, instead.
Little by little, Hank and Maisie become friends, much to the delight of Hank's parents. Maisie is, after all, his first friend and they spend lots of time together acting out The Jungle Book, Hank's favorite movie, while hanging around with Booler in his yard, and sometimes looking for rocks together in the schoolyard. But Maisie can be a strong, determined, even manipulative personality, who is relentless in her need to save Booler. Hank, on the other hand, is quiet and generally content with his rocks. But he does feel Maisie's manipulation and after their first attempt at saving Booler fails, along with Hank's first attempt at lying, he has a complete meltdown and is asked to consider whether she is really a good friend. Yes, Hank decides, she is. But that doesn't mean the two friends have given up on Booler, not by any stretch of the imagination.
We Could Be Heroes is told in the third person from Hank's point of view, which is an interesting perspective. Interesting because the story isn't about autism so much as it is about how Hank sees, experiences, and navigates the world as a person on the spectrum. I came away with a better understanding of autism, and particularly, autistic meltdowns and I think Finnegan made it very accessible for young readers to understand, as well. For example, Finnegan gave Hank the perfect geological description for the way his meltdowns might feel like to him: A'a is a Hawaiian word that describes the way the surface and bottom layers of lava cool at different rates after a volcanic eruption. With a meltdown, Hank experiences his body as out of sync. On the surface, he feels punctured and bruised by the way sounds, textures, colors, smells poke at him, while inside, he feels dense, heavy and immovable. Later, she describes how Hank's mother helps him regain a sense of evenness after a meltdown.
I have to admit I really didn't like Maisie at first for the same reason Hank is somewhat leery of her. But as Hank and Maisie's friendship begins to really solidify, I began to see her differently, so that by the time Maisie's truth finally comes out, I felt real empathy for her.
One thing I really liked in this book is that Hank's family is intact, that his parents marriage didn't end because of his autism, and that both parents are involved, understanding and, most importantly, patient.
We Could Be Heroes is at times very serious story, that deals with themes like autism, epilepsy, bullying, empathy, and friendships (both age appropriate and intergenerational), but it not one without humor and some very delicious sounding cookies. This is Margaret Finnegan's debut middle grade novel and it is a well-crafted open and honest look at what it means to be different without being less and living one's authentic truth. And definitely not to be missed.
Meet the Author:
Margaret Finnegan's work has appeared in FamilyFun, the Los Angeles Times, Salon, and other publications. She lives in South Pasadena, California, where she enjoys spending time with her family, walking her dog, and baking really good chocolate cakes. You can connect with her at MargaretFinnegan.com and
on Twitter @FinneganBegin and
Instagram @finneganbegin
This book is recommended for readers age 8+
This book was gratefully received from Barb at Blue Slip Media
February 5, 2023
A story about good intentions that go awry. Hank and Maisie are determined to save Booler, a dog who is tied up all the time. Sometimes what we perceive as 'doing the right thing' makes things worse instead of better.
Not only is this a story about the mistakes we make as we try to do our best, it is also a friendship story and a story for those who love dogs. This would make a great classroom read aloud (IMO).
Not only is this a story about the mistakes we make as we try to do our best, it is also a friendship story and a story for those who love dogs. This would make a great classroom read aloud (IMO).
February 13, 2020
This is a darling story of two kids who want nothing more than to save the dog next door. Hank is an endearing main character. He is sensitive, kind and empathetic. When he's overwhelmed, due to his autism, he takes out the rocks he carries in his pocket and distracts himself by listing off cool facts about each rock. He is clever and sweet. Hank has strong feelings and up til now, he's been able to use his strategies at school fairly well. When he meets Maisie, Hank is very excited about her showing an interest in being friends with him. Most of his childhood friends moved along to form new friendships and Maisie is the first person he's had anything in common with for a long time. She's special because not only does she like acting out the Jungle Book, her parents are even geologists and Hank loves collecting rocks. I really love the way that Hank is portrayed in the story, it's not a story about him being autistic or being bullied, it's an uplifting story with kids who are easy to relate to.
Hank and Maisie's friendship is also wonderfully depicted. They do have their share of difficult moments and tests to their friendship but eventually resolve their differences. Maisie is such a force, strong-willed and determined. She strikes me as inquisitive and tenacious, when there is something that she really wants, she usually gets it. What she really wanted was to save Booler from being tied to a tree all day. She wasn't going to give up, even when Hank starts to think that some of the things she's asking him to do might be wrong, even after they both get into trouble. The actions they took, from calling 911 to report Mr. Jorgensen for being mean to his dog to writing a letter to their parents arguing the legal reasons for keeping Booler, to eventually taking the dog and running away, all seemed like real things that children of this age group might try. Even though I sometimes was disappointed with Maisie's methods, especially when she used Hank's feelings and emotions to get him to go along with her plans, her heart always seemed to be in the right place and her actions did seem to come from a deep caring for Booler.
I also really adored Hank's parents and the lovely interactions they had with him. They were caring, kind and encouraging. There were some especially difficult conversations that they had with him about friendship. Their conversation felt real and especially thoughtful of Hank's feelings. Like when they suspected Maisie was taking advantage of Hank by playing into his empathy and sadness over Booler's situation, they explained how true friends don't make you change who you are, and friends also do things that you want to do. There were some valuable messages in here about what makes for a true friend. No one wants to feel like they're being taken advantage of and Hank gets very upset with his parents because they're putting doubt into his mind about Maisie. Again, these situations felt so real, full of the potential emotions one would have when we start questioning everything you think you know about your friend. Hanks struggles to keep his emotions in check, to use his strategies will help children gain insight or provide a realistic glimpse into the life, feelings, and emotions of a child with autism. Such a heartwarming story with characters that are easily relatable and a wonderfully positive message that as Hank would say "different isn't less. "
Hank and Maisie's friendship is also wonderfully depicted. They do have their share of difficult moments and tests to their friendship but eventually resolve their differences. Maisie is such a force, strong-willed and determined. She strikes me as inquisitive and tenacious, when there is something that she really wants, she usually gets it. What she really wanted was to save Booler from being tied to a tree all day. She wasn't going to give up, even when Hank starts to think that some of the things she's asking him to do might be wrong, even after they both get into trouble. The actions they took, from calling 911 to report Mr. Jorgensen for being mean to his dog to writing a letter to their parents arguing the legal reasons for keeping Booler, to eventually taking the dog and running away, all seemed like real things that children of this age group might try. Even though I sometimes was disappointed with Maisie's methods, especially when she used Hank's feelings and emotions to get him to go along with her plans, her heart always seemed to be in the right place and her actions did seem to come from a deep caring for Booler.
I also really adored Hank's parents and the lovely interactions they had with him. They were caring, kind and encouraging. There were some especially difficult conversations that they had with him about friendship. Their conversation felt real and especially thoughtful of Hank's feelings. Like when they suspected Maisie was taking advantage of Hank by playing into his empathy and sadness over Booler's situation, they explained how true friends don't make you change who you are, and friends also do things that you want to do. There were some valuable messages in here about what makes for a true friend. No one wants to feel like they're being taken advantage of and Hank gets very upset with his parents because they're putting doubt into his mind about Maisie. Again, these situations felt so real, full of the potential emotions one would have when we start questioning everything you think you know about your friend. Hanks struggles to keep his emotions in check, to use his strategies will help children gain insight or provide a realistic glimpse into the life, feelings, and emotions of a child with autism. Such a heartwarming story with characters that are easily relatable and a wonderfully positive message that as Hank would say "different isn't less. "
September 5, 2020
Finished this one yesterday and still thinking about Hank, Maisie, Mr. Jorgensen, and Booler. They made me laugh. Cry. Think quite a bit. They’re going to stick with me for a while. Great middle grade read with themes of friendship, trust, and decision making while providing discussion topics of autism, epilepsy, and elder care. Highly recommend!
June 21, 2020
We Could Be Heroes by Margaret Finnegan, 240 pages. Atheneum (Simon), 2020. $18
Content: G
BUYING ADVISORY: EL - OPTIONAL
AUDIENCE APPEAL: AVERAGE
Because he deals with autism, Hank, 9yo, knows that most people don’t understand him. It doesn’t help when he steals and sets on fire the novel about the Holocaust that his teacher is currently reading to his class. But Maisie, a girl in his class is suddenly interested in Hank and seems to be his friend. Maisie wants Hank’s help to care for a dog owned by her elderly neighbor – a dog Maisie believes is being abused. Hank is not so sure, but goes along with Maisie – even lying to his parents for the first time. But is Maisie really Hank’s friend. That’s an important question for Hank to decide.
I was really angry at Maisie and how much she manipulates Hank. And a bit angry at some of the parents around for insisting that the dog belonged to the neighbor and that he could do what he wants. The cahracters are very yound and I’m just not sure that students that age will be drawn to this.
Cindy, Library Teacher, MLS
https://kissthebookjr.blogspot.com/20...
Content: G
BUYING ADVISORY: EL - OPTIONAL
AUDIENCE APPEAL: AVERAGE
Because he deals with autism, Hank, 9yo, knows that most people don’t understand him. It doesn’t help when he steals and sets on fire the novel about the Holocaust that his teacher is currently reading to his class. But Maisie, a girl in his class is suddenly interested in Hank and seems to be his friend. Maisie wants Hank’s help to care for a dog owned by her elderly neighbor – a dog Maisie believes is being abused. Hank is not so sure, but goes along with Maisie – even lying to his parents for the first time. But is Maisie really Hank’s friend. That’s an important question for Hank to decide.
I was really angry at Maisie and how much she manipulates Hank. And a bit angry at some of the parents around for insisting that the dog belonged to the neighbor and that he could do what he wants. The cahracters are very yound and I’m just not sure that students that age will be drawn to this.
Cindy, Library Teacher, MLS
https://kissthebookjr.blogspot.com/20...
October 16, 2020
I adored this warm, funny novel about two friends' campaign to save a very special dog. Hank's thoughts, feelings, and actions feel very authentic for a child with autism—in fact, this is one of the best depictions of an autistic character I've ever read (probably because the author has an autistic daughter). Maisie is simply hilarious, full of spunk and charisma. Their exploits feel true to their ages. Aside from the fact that WE COULD BE HEROES is a thoroughly engaging and enjoyable read, it also teaches some valuable lessons about what true friendship looks like, not making assumptions, owning up to and learning from one's mistakes, and accepting each other in spite of the things that make each of us different. I highly recommend reading this touching, uplifting novel. It's a gem (as Hank would say)!
March 26, 2020
I’ve never reviewed a children’s book before, so I googled the traits that good ones have. Margaret Finnegan’s “We Could Be Heroes” has all of them, in spades. First, the book is an exciting, but also compassionate, story of two children who set out to rescue a dog tied to a neighbor’s tree. I kept cheering for them, through all their struggles, failures and at last, their coming to an understanding with the world and the world’s coming to an understanding with them. Second, Finnegan channels the way the children feel and speak, swooping the reader into their heads. And third, because all the characters – including the dog - have disabilities, readers can experience what the world is like from a different point of view than their own. Two thumbs up.
did-not-finish
June 23, 2021DNF a few pages into Chapter 3. I typically give books around 50 pages before giving up, but Maisie's manipulative BS about the dog paired with her yelling at Hank for not being normal almost did me in. I'm sure 4th graders aren't known for their maturity, but no ma'am.
October 8, 2020
I can’t pass up a good book about dogs and friendships and family!
August 22, 2023
The love and determination of two people and a dog was explained well. The description of Autistic feelings was well written.
Read
November 6, 2021A sweet with a duo of unlikely heroes. This book pairs nicely with Out of my Mind. Recommended for readers 9-12.
May 17, 2020
We Could Be Heroes
by Margaret Finnegan
Simon and Schuster Children's Publishing
Atheneum Books for Young Readers
Children's Fiction
Pub Date 25 Feb 2020
I am reviewing a copy of We Could Be Heroes through Simon and Schuster Children’s Publishing/Atheneum Books for Young Readers:
Hank finds himself in trouble after an incident that involved the boys bathroom and a horribly sad book his teacher is having his class read. Hank finds himself with a week’s suspension, a hardcover that is slightly charred as well as the attention of the new girl Maisie Huang, attention he certainly did not expect.
Maisie has been looking for a kid who is brave enough to help her with her mission. She is determined to save her neighbors dog, Booler, Booler has seizures and his owner Mr Jorgensen keeps him tied to a tree, because of the seizures. Knowing what is happening to Booler makes him even sadder than the book did, he has Autism and knows what it is like to be treated badly because of it.
Hank is determined to show everyone different is not less even if it means he has to get in more trouble in order to prove it. It isn’t long before both Hank and Maisie are baking, brown nosing, and milking coed in order to save Booler. But is Booler the one who needs saving?
I give We Could Be Heroes five out of five stars!
Happy Reading!
by Margaret Finnegan
Simon and Schuster Children's Publishing
Atheneum Books for Young Readers
Children's Fiction
Pub Date 25 Feb 2020
I am reviewing a copy of We Could Be Heroes through Simon and Schuster Children’s Publishing/Atheneum Books for Young Readers:
Hank finds himself in trouble after an incident that involved the boys bathroom and a horribly sad book his teacher is having his class read. Hank finds himself with a week’s suspension, a hardcover that is slightly charred as well as the attention of the new girl Maisie Huang, attention he certainly did not expect.
Maisie has been looking for a kid who is brave enough to help her with her mission. She is determined to save her neighbors dog, Booler, Booler has seizures and his owner Mr Jorgensen keeps him tied to a tree, because of the seizures. Knowing what is happening to Booler makes him even sadder than the book did, he has Autism and knows what it is like to be treated badly because of it.
Hank is determined to show everyone different is not less even if it means he has to get in more trouble in order to prove it. It isn’t long before both Hank and Maisie are baking, brown nosing, and milking coed in order to save Booler. But is Booler the one who needs saving?
I give We Could Be Heroes five out of five stars!
Happy Reading!
April 20, 2020
April is Autism Awareness month so this was a perfect time to read this book. The rock-loving main character (Hank) is autistic and the book starts out with him having a bad day. And it goes downhill from there. Hank is kind, opinionated, passionate and very self-aware. He feels things strongly and takes a firm stance on things he believes in. Whether it be a book he dislikes, a girl who befriends him, a dog in peril, or an elderly man who may or may not have things under control, Hank is there, loyal to his friend and promoter of what is right. I teach children with autism and found this book to be a very sensitive portrayal of an autistic child. It was about more than autism though. This was a book about acceptance, accepting people and animals for who and what they are (beyond autism and epilepsy, age and whatever else may be different), investigating (when it could be a life or death situation), compassion (for animals, friends, and adults) and courage (to step out of one's comfort zone and make it right). This book also embraced joy. The joy of being a child and the games, songs, friendships, and wonder of childhood danced throughout this entire book. There were tense moments but there were also moments to cherish, and there was laughter. You'll find yourself laughing at funny nuggets woven throughout this book, cheering for Hank, Maisie, and Booler as they navigate the adventure of their lives, and the reoccurring theme "We Could Be Heroes". Well....ARE they heros? You'll have to read this book to find out!
December 1, 2019
Hank is a sensitive fourth grader with autism. He’d much rather spend his time alone organizing his extensive rock collection, but he’s caught the attention of spirited Maisie after a curious incident at school when the fire department had to be called. WE COULD BE HEROES by Margaret Finnegan (releasing 2/25/20), is an endearing story of friendship, strong feelings, and understanding that just warmed my heart. Maisie’s sure she has the best of intentions as she devises a plan to rescue her neighbors dog, Booler, who suffers from seizures, from a life chained to a tree. Hank is empathetic to Booler’s situation and goes along (with some reservation) with persistent Maisie and the adventure begins, but of course it’s not without consequence. I just adored Hank and Maisie’s growth as individuals and together as friends—it felt real with plenty of “ups and downs.” There were challenges, debates, mistakes, and lots of lessons learned. The author writes authentically as she was inspired by her daughter’s diagnoses and experiences thereby providing a window for readers in gaining awareness of the emotional toll someone with autism might be dealing with. WE COULD BE HEROES will satisfy not only dog lovers, but readers who enjoy an emotional coming-of-age story with relatable, memorable characters that tug at your heartstrings.
March 16, 2020
Ten year old Hank hates the book his teacher is reading aloud to the class so much that he sets it on fire in the boys’ bathroom. He has autism, and the sad feelings he gets when he hears the story, of a boy trying to hide from Nazis during World War II, are overwhelming. Luckily, he has his rock collection and a loving family to steady him. When a new kid named Maisie befriends Hank, his family is thrilled. But does Maisie only want him as a friend to help steal the neighbor’s dog? Hank learns about the ways friends help each other, and he also learns about dogs. Maisie has strong feelings herself, as she worries about the dog, Booler, who is left tied up in the neighbor’s yard. Booler has epilepsy, and the kids conspire to give him what they think is a better life. Lots of great themes here: friendship, understanding people with autism, getting to know an elderly neighbor, and caring for a dog. Hank is never portrayed with anything but respect, and I think readers will really enjoy getting to know him and how he thinks. Maisie is a dynamite character, and her struggles with epilepsy will also shine a light on invisible disabilities. The book’s title is the name of a song that the two kids sing together, and it’s like their theme song. A lovely, funny book that celebrates two atypical kids and their heart-felt adventures.
April 4, 2020
We are on lockdown in NYC now, and my son and I basically read We Could Be Heroes in two long sittings. Over and over again, he demanded that I "keep reading." Although my son is not autistic, he is differently wired, and we have not been having an easy time homeschooling. (Like the main character, Hank, he needs a lot of routine and struggles with transitions.) When we finished the book, he said, "I have a lot of the same feelings that Hank has." We were able to talk about Hank and what he calls his a'a feeling. For possibly the first time, I got what my son's meltdowns feel like to him. And he had the important experience of being understood.
Obviously this is a great book for neurodiverse kids, but any child will relate to the story. As a grown-up reader, I appreciated the fact that the book works through real problems that all children face--things like, what makes a good friend? Is it ever right to lie or steal? Plot lines that seem simple initially turn out to be impossibly complicated. So much of life is like that but not so much of children's fiction. And Finnegan manages to deliver a satisfying ending while dealing with these issues in a realistic, serious way.
October 12, 2020
Contains insensitive references to Nazis killing Jewish children. "You know that boy is going to die...they always do." Perhaps the author meant it to sound otherwise, but I don't think it did.
September 3, 2022
I appreciate that this book has some great moral lessons about friendship, jumping to conclusions, and taking a stand. As honorable as that is, it doesn't mean it's great reading material. I know my students, and I know this isn't a winner. Take the first paragraph. It should be an attention grabber. It isn't. In fact, I had to reread it, so I understood exactly what was going on.
The book opens with Hank (age unknown) setting a Holocaust book on fire in the school bathroom. He doesn't like the book because it makes him sad. That should be a humdinger of an opener, but it's not. The thing with Hank is that he's autistic. You'd think that after a stunt like that the teacher would switch to a different book or at least wouldn't make him sit through it. Not so. And that is where I cry foul. No school in America would make a kid continue to listen to a book after he starts a fire over it.
While he's in the fire evacuation line outside he meets Maisie, and for the first time in awhile he has a new friend. He goes to Maisie's house a lot, and they always end up jumping the fence into old Mr. Jorgensen's backyard. Three dogs live there, but one is always tied up to a tree and sometimes he has seizures. Maisie is convinced the dog is being neglected, so she elicits Hank's help to rehome him, call 911 about him, and even runaway with him. Quite a lot of adventure for kids with disabilities.
It's a pretty slow-moving book. It's not one that you can't wait to get back to. And once it's discovered that Mr. Jorgensen is actually a nice guy and has a reason for keeping the dog tied up, the rest of the story feels pointless. And I must mention all the playacting these two kids do. I had to speed read through those, especially the ones based on their favorite movie, The Jungle Book. The Jungle Book? Have kids today seen that one?
There are better dog books. Better books about autism. For starters, try Rain Reign.
The book opens with Hank (age unknown) setting a Holocaust book on fire in the school bathroom. He doesn't like the book because it makes him sad. That should be a humdinger of an opener, but it's not. The thing with Hank is that he's autistic. You'd think that after a stunt like that the teacher would switch to a different book or at least wouldn't make him sit through it. Not so. And that is where I cry foul. No school in America would make a kid continue to listen to a book after he starts a fire over it.
While he's in the fire evacuation line outside he meets Maisie, and for the first time in awhile he has a new friend. He goes to Maisie's house a lot, and they always end up jumping the fence into old Mr. Jorgensen's backyard. Three dogs live there, but one is always tied up to a tree and sometimes he has seizures. Maisie is convinced the dog is being neglected, so she elicits Hank's help to rehome him, call 911 about him, and even runaway with him. Quite a lot of adventure for kids with disabilities.
It's a pretty slow-moving book. It's not one that you can't wait to get back to. And once it's discovered that Mr. Jorgensen is actually a nice guy and has a reason for keeping the dog tied up, the rest of the story feels pointless. And I must mention all the playacting these two kids do. I had to speed read through those, especially the ones based on their favorite movie, The Jungle Book. The Jungle Book? Have kids today seen that one?
There are better dog books. Better books about autism. For starters, try Rain Reign.
April 16, 2025
I’m so disappointed because I really wanted to like this book, especially since it’s a freshly new bought one which I rarely do. As an autistic person myself, though, I appreciate how the author tried to expand upon what the traditional narrative of an autistic person can go through and be, including the characters expanded emotional empathy defying stereotypes, but I just wasn’t a fan of the story, which is the biggest sin a book can have when it comes to engagement.
At first I thought the bond the boy and girl had was cute in the beginning and even though they could’ve been friends, I thought the growth in characters and caring for each other would lead to something bigger or cuter even though it’s middle grade, I’ll probably be an outlier in that area, but that wouldn’t been nice to see. I wish we got to focus on their friendship more because unfortunately, this is just another misunderstood child befriends poor animal trope story. Think reign rain or the curious incident of the dog in the nighttime but slightly more modern and updated when it comes to neurodivergent depictions. In terms of that it would get a B or A- but given we spend most of this time worrying about a dog, the rank is much lower. If it were a more sympathetic or understanding reason to private them, it would’ve been more driving, but given the explanations they got for leaving the dog alone, it just becomes annoying and repetitive, especially when they talk about it when they’re not even near it, like at school; like what else is this friendship made of?!
I also wasn’t a big fan of the way it was written. I felt like I had to read every paragraph twice in order to understand what they were thinking and doing which shows how much kids would comprehend it if they read it. If it went through another round of editing, peer review, or proofreading, it could’ve much a little better and maybe it would’ve gotten an extra star or half, but since it didn’t, it won’t earn anything more than what I already have it credit for.
At first I thought the bond the boy and girl had was cute in the beginning and even though they could’ve been friends, I thought the growth in characters and caring for each other would lead to something bigger or cuter even though it’s middle grade, I’ll probably be an outlier in that area, but that wouldn’t been nice to see. I wish we got to focus on their friendship more because unfortunately, this is just another misunderstood child befriends poor animal trope story. Think reign rain or the curious incident of the dog in the nighttime but slightly more modern and updated when it comes to neurodivergent depictions. In terms of that it would get a B or A- but given we spend most of this time worrying about a dog, the rank is much lower. If it were a more sympathetic or understanding reason to private them, it would’ve been more driving, but given the explanations they got for leaving the dog alone, it just becomes annoying and repetitive, especially when they talk about it when they’re not even near it, like at school; like what else is this friendship made of?!
I also wasn’t a big fan of the way it was written. I felt like I had to read every paragraph twice in order to understand what they were thinking and doing which shows how much kids would comprehend it if they read it. If it went through another round of editing, peer review, or proofreading, it could’ve much a little better and maybe it would’ve gotten an extra star or half, but since it didn’t, it won’t earn anything more than what I already have it credit for.
March 5, 2020
The beginning of We Could Be Heroes pulled me into the book right away. Hank's efforts to burn the book his teacher is reading to his class gets him into a lot of trouble. But it also allows the author to introduce Hank and his autistic struggles. It also brings Hank a friend, or so it seems. Maisie is a girl on a mission and thinks Hank would make a great sidekick. Maisie wants to rescue her neighbor's dog, Booler. Booler spends all his time tied to a tree because he has seizures and might get hurt otherwise. But Maisie refuses to accept this and recruits Hank to help her "save" the dog and be heroes.
But the two kids, despite meaning well, make some poor decisions that get them in trouble. And their final effort may be more dangerous than heroic. I'll admit I had a hard time with some of the decisions the kids made. Their motives were good, but they didn't listen to their parents or Mr. Jorgensen, the dog's owner. And because they acted at the last based on rumors instead of talking to Mr. Jorgensen, they put themselves into a dangerous situation. This part of the book really bothered me. However, the resolution mitigated those feelings as Maisie and Hank face the consequences of their actions and start making better choices.
Young readers will be able to appreciate Hank and Maisie's efforts to be heroic while, hopefully, also gaining some empathy for their differences. Hank and Maisie both have experienced poor treatment because they are different than their peers, and it leads them to sympathize especially strongly with Booler's predicament. But as with many people, their good motives doesn't result in wise actions, not at first anyway.
I did appreciate the fact that Hank tells the story, showing the reader his perspective and struggles with communication and his coping strategies. A good book for helping young readers develop empathy for those who are different.
But the two kids, despite meaning well, make some poor decisions that get them in trouble. And their final effort may be more dangerous than heroic. I'll admit I had a hard time with some of the decisions the kids made. Their motives were good, but they didn't listen to their parents or Mr. Jorgensen, the dog's owner. And because they acted at the last based on rumors instead of talking to Mr. Jorgensen, they put themselves into a dangerous situation. This part of the book really bothered me. However, the resolution mitigated those feelings as Maisie and Hank face the consequences of their actions and start making better choices.
Young readers will be able to appreciate Hank and Maisie's efforts to be heroic while, hopefully, also gaining some empathy for their differences. Hank and Maisie both have experienced poor treatment because they are different than their peers, and it leads them to sympathize especially strongly with Booler's predicament. But as with many people, their good motives doesn't result in wise actions, not at first anyway.
I did appreciate the fact that Hank tells the story, showing the reader his perspective and struggles with communication and his coping strategies. A good book for helping young readers develop empathy for those who are different.
February 16, 2020
Thank you to @kidlitexchange and the publisher for sharing a review copy of this MG book. All opinions are my own. It’s available 2.25.20.
Oh, WE COULD BE HEROES is one of those stories you’ll be thinking about for a very long time. This memorable tale, about two delightful neurodivergent children who find friendship for the first time, will grab your heart. It allows us to view the world through their eyes and to experience their feelings as they struggle to understand it.
It also allows us to meet their parents who are supportive, loving and firm. Your heart a bit when you witness the surprise and joy they all feel when Hank and Maisie become friends. And you’ll admire them as they gently guide their children to understand how to be a good friend. Most of all you’ll love the way they teach their children “different is not less”.
Then there is the story of how the kids work together to save Booler, a neighbor dog with seizures who is tied to a tree 24 hours a day “for his own protection”. Hank, who has autism, and can tell you anything you’d ever want to know about rocks, has learned to know the “a’a” feeling when he’s losing control and tries his best to use his coping strategies. Maisie, the girl who just moved to Hank’s Montana town has decided she and Hank are going to be friends and save Booler, no matter the cost. And the costs turn out to be huge!
This is a #windowsandmirrors story for all of us. It’s a great one to read aloud and will lead to lots of good discussions about some of the decisions Hank and Maisie make. You’ll also have lots of fun talking about all of the idioms Maisie uses. I was laughing out loud more than once!
WE COULD BE HEROES is for grade 3+ and needs to be on every elementary and public school order list.
Oh, WE COULD BE HEROES is one of those stories you’ll be thinking about for a very long time. This memorable tale, about two delightful neurodivergent children who find friendship for the first time, will grab your heart. It allows us to view the world through their eyes and to experience their feelings as they struggle to understand it.
It also allows us to meet their parents who are supportive, loving and firm. Your heart a bit when you witness the surprise and joy they all feel when Hank and Maisie become friends. And you’ll admire them as they gently guide their children to understand how to be a good friend. Most of all you’ll love the way they teach their children “different is not less”.
Then there is the story of how the kids work together to save Booler, a neighbor dog with seizures who is tied to a tree 24 hours a day “for his own protection”. Hank, who has autism, and can tell you anything you’d ever want to know about rocks, has learned to know the “a’a” feeling when he’s losing control and tries his best to use his coping strategies. Maisie, the girl who just moved to Hank’s Montana town has decided she and Hank are going to be friends and save Booler, no matter the cost. And the costs turn out to be huge!
This is a #windowsandmirrors story for all of us. It’s a great one to read aloud and will lead to lots of good discussions about some of the decisions Hank and Maisie make. You’ll also have lots of fun talking about all of the idioms Maisie uses. I was laughing out loud more than once!
WE COULD BE HEROES is for grade 3+ and needs to be on every elementary and public school order list.
April 24, 2023
Hank knows that different is not less. It’s one of the things his parents taught him to help him get through moments when it’s clear that he’s different than his classmates. Like when he set fire to a book because it made him sad. Or how he still likes to play games that his friends lost interest in. Or how his feelings bubble up and make him feel anxious when he doesn’t know how to handle social situations.
When his classmate Maisie wants to be his friend, at first Hank is happy. Then he feels she is just using him to save Booler, the dog next door, from being tied up all the time. After the two of them forge a true friendship, they decide on a plan that will make them heroes, just like the words in their favorite David Bowie song.
We Could Be Heroes by Margaret Finnegan is a sweet story about two kids who think of themselves as misfits, Hank because he has autism, and Maisie because of a condition that’s revealed later in the book. They are both lonely, and they want to help Booler because they perceive him to be similar to them in many ways. Through their time spent together, they learn a lot about themselves and each other, and they grow in the way they see the world around them.
We Could Be Heroes is a great story for anyone who has ever felt misunderstood or at a loss to understand the right thing to do in confusing situations, which is most of us. I highly recommend it for mother-daughter book clubs and readers aged 9 to 13.
When his classmate Maisie wants to be his friend, at first Hank is happy. Then he feels she is just using him to save Booler, the dog next door, from being tied up all the time. After the two of them forge a true friendship, they decide on a plan that will make them heroes, just like the words in their favorite David Bowie song.
We Could Be Heroes by Margaret Finnegan is a sweet story about two kids who think of themselves as misfits, Hank because he has autism, and Maisie because of a condition that’s revealed later in the book. They are both lonely, and they want to help Booler because they perceive him to be similar to them in many ways. Through their time spent together, they learn a lot about themselves and each other, and they grow in the way they see the world around them.
We Could Be Heroes is a great story for anyone who has ever felt misunderstood or at a loss to understand the right thing to do in confusing situations, which is most of us. I highly recommend it for mother-daughter book clubs and readers aged 9 to 13.
June 3, 2023
A heartwarming story of friendship, right vs wrong, and becoming a hero.
Characters: Maisie lives next door to Mr. Jorgeson with his 3 dogs Cowboy, Honey and Booler. Booler is a pitbull who has epilepsy (just like Maisie) and is tied to a tree to protect him from hurting himself. Rock collecting Hank Hudson lives with his his parents and baby brother Sam. He goes to school in Mrs. Vera's class with Maisie. Hank has autism and has so much empathy that he feels everything deeply. He gets what he describes as an "a a" feeling when things get too intense. When he lights the class book on fire because it is too sad and he wants his teacher to stop reading it, Maisie befriends him.
*The two friends spend time with Mr. Jorgeson's dogs and eventually plot a scheme to "be the hero in the story" by saving Booler. In their opinion Mr. Jorgeson is not fit to take care of this dog. When their plan results in Maisie having a seizure and Hank getting attacked by a bull cow, their parents realize the seriousness of the duo's dedication.
*Complete with references to The Jungle Book, lots of random rock facts and realizing what a real friend it, this book is a great example of standing up for what you believe in.
Topics: friendship, dogs, autism, epilepsy, old age, neighbors, "evil daughter"
Recommend: appropriate for any able reader- grade 3+, or read aloud for younger.
Characters: Maisie lives next door to Mr. Jorgeson with his 3 dogs Cowboy, Honey and Booler. Booler is a pitbull who has epilepsy (just like Maisie) and is tied to a tree to protect him from hurting himself. Rock collecting Hank Hudson lives with his his parents and baby brother Sam. He goes to school in Mrs. Vera's class with Maisie. Hank has autism and has so much empathy that he feels everything deeply. He gets what he describes as an "a a" feeling when things get too intense. When he lights the class book on fire because it is too sad and he wants his teacher to stop reading it, Maisie befriends him.
*The two friends spend time with Mr. Jorgeson's dogs and eventually plot a scheme to "be the hero in the story" by saving Booler. In their opinion Mr. Jorgeson is not fit to take care of this dog. When their plan results in Maisie having a seizure and Hank getting attacked by a bull cow, their parents realize the seriousness of the duo's dedication.
*Complete with references to The Jungle Book, lots of random rock facts and realizing what a real friend it, this book is a great example of standing up for what you believe in.
Topics: friendship, dogs, autism, epilepsy, old age, neighbors, "evil daughter"
Recommend: appropriate for any able reader- grade 3+, or read aloud for younger.
April 7, 2024
And that’s a wrap, 25 of 25 MCBA nominated titles! I’m feeling proud, but that’s career-related and irrelevant to the book.
I had a complicated time reading this. Hank felt like an autistic boy stereotype to me. He felt so much like one that it took me weeks to finish this middle grade novel. Hank felt so stereotypical to me that I said to a colleague, “I wonder what the author’s tie is to the autistic community?
I learned in the author’s note that she has an autistic daughter diagnosed with epilepsy. There are differences between boys’ and girls’ ASD presentation style. To me, Hank felt stereotypical. But he receives respect, thoughtfulness, and concern from Finnegan. Also, it’s like in “The Danger of a Single Story,” stereotypes are not the whole story; they are limited.
(Wow. Yeah. That’s why this one took me weeks.)
I enjoyed Maisie’s meddlesome concern for Booler, a neighbor’s dog who lives tied to a tree in a backyard. I enjoyed the dynamics between Hank and Maisie’s nascent friendship. I enjoyed the geology and Bowie references. I enjoyed the evolution of most characters’ relationships.
Dislikes: uneven pacing, biting off just a few too many subplots for the audience, empathetic but stereotypical behaviors being much of Hank’s personality.
I had a complicated time reading this. Hank felt like an autistic boy stereotype to me. He felt so much like one that it took me weeks to finish this middle grade novel. Hank felt so stereotypical to me that I said to a colleague, “I wonder what the author’s tie is to the autistic community?
I learned in the author’s note that she has an autistic daughter diagnosed with epilepsy. There are differences between boys’ and girls’ ASD presentation style. To me, Hank felt stereotypical. But he receives respect, thoughtfulness, and concern from Finnegan. Also, it’s like in “The Danger of a Single Story,” stereotypes are not the whole story; they are limited.
(Wow. Yeah. That’s why this one took me weeks.)
I enjoyed Maisie’s meddlesome concern for Booler, a neighbor’s dog who lives tied to a tree in a backyard. I enjoyed the dynamics between Hank and Maisie’s nascent friendship. I enjoyed the geology and Bowie references. I enjoyed the evolution of most characters’ relationships.
Dislikes: uneven pacing, biting off just a few too many subplots for the audience, empathetic but stereotypical behaviors being much of Hank’s personality.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
April 6, 2025
DNF at 35%.
I really wanted to enjoy this book, and at first, I did. Hank seemed to be an intriguing character, and I felt his experiences rang true to me as an autistic person. But after pausing and reading through it again, I felt like I wouldn’t be able to finish it. The story not only dragged out, but I also didn’t like how Hank’s friendship with Maisie was handled. Throughout the novel, Maisie was manipulative and only hung out with Hank because she wanted him to help her save Booler. Her behavior is rarely challenged, and she and Hank are still friends by the end of the novel (I had to skim to find that out). This is problematic because it sets an unhealthy example of what friendships should look like. It’s telling readers that it’s normal or okay to be friends with someone who takes advantage of you. Which is not a good message to send, especially since autistic people are more likely to be manipulated.
Usually, I love reading books with autistic characters. However, because of the story’s sluggish pacing and Hank still being friends with Maisie (despite her manipulation), I couldn’t finish it.
I really wanted to enjoy this book, and at first, I did. Hank seemed to be an intriguing character, and I felt his experiences rang true to me as an autistic person. But after pausing and reading through it again, I felt like I wouldn’t be able to finish it. The story not only dragged out, but I also didn’t like how Hank’s friendship with Maisie was handled. Throughout the novel, Maisie was manipulative and only hung out with Hank because she wanted him to help her save Booler. Her behavior is rarely challenged, and she and Hank are still friends by the end of the novel (I had to skim to find that out). This is problematic because it sets an unhealthy example of what friendships should look like. It’s telling readers that it’s normal or okay to be friends with someone who takes advantage of you. Which is not a good message to send, especially since autistic people are more likely to be manipulated.
Usually, I love reading books with autistic characters. However, because of the story’s sluggish pacing and Hank still being friends with Maisie (despite her manipulation), I couldn’t finish it.
May 27, 2020
Hank hates the book his teacher is reading to the class. It's really emotional and sad and Hank can't handle it. So he steals the book and sets it on fire in the boys' bathroom. He gets in trouble, of course, but also captures the attention of his classmate, Maisie. Maisie sees strength in Hank, and sees that he's willing to stand up for what he believes in. So she introduces him to Booler, the sweet pit bull next door who is always tied to a tree. Maisie wants Hank to help her free Booler, and as he gets swept up in her plan, Hank learns a lot about himself and friendship.
I love how this book addresses disabilities without shining a spotlight on them. Hank has autism and it's just matter of fact and handled very realistically.Maisie also has a somewhat rare condition that is hidden for much of the book, but is also handled in a realistic manner as it comes out. I think it's important for all kids to have books like this - so they can see themselves in fiction and so they can learn empathy.
I love how this book addresses disabilities without shining a spotlight on them. Hank has autism and it's just matter of fact and handled very realistically.Maisie also has a somewhat rare condition that is hidden for much of the book, but is also handled in a realistic manner as it comes out. I think it's important for all kids to have books like this - so they can see themselves in fiction and so they can learn empathy.
July 9, 2022
I don't have a ton of notes for this book because I read it on my kindle and I'm too tired to take notes on my phone right before I fall asleep.
I do know that I REALLY enjoyed this book. The characters are just lovely. The writing is superb.
The publishing market is slowing starting to open up the market more for books with neurodiverse protagonists. This is one of the gems that is out there and I'm so excited about it.
You get to see the world through Hank's (who has autism) eyes. It's both entertaining and informative and wonderful for neurotypical kids to hear and understand.
Love this line: "A few bad moments don't make a bad day."
The parents in this book are great! Patient and understanding. The mom reminds Hank to use his strategies.
The overwhelming message of the depth of his empathy is striking.
All the characters have huge hearts and you can learn so much about life from them. A great story to help students learn about empathy.
I do know that I REALLY enjoyed this book. The characters are just lovely. The writing is superb.
The publishing market is slowing starting to open up the market more for books with neurodiverse protagonists. This is one of the gems that is out there and I'm so excited about it.
You get to see the world through Hank's (who has autism) eyes. It's both entertaining and informative and wonderful for neurotypical kids to hear and understand.
Love this line: "A few bad moments don't make a bad day."
The parents in this book are great! Patient and understanding. The mom reminds Hank to use his strategies.
The overwhelming message of the depth of his empathy is striking.
All the characters have huge hearts and you can learn so much about life from them. A great story to help students learn about empathy.
March 30, 2020
We Could Be Heroes is a heartfelt story on friendship and compassion. But it's also a story about finding yourself and finding your way when you don't fit into a box the world has set in stone. What I like most about the book is how well the primary characters are crafted - while Maisie is outspoken and confident, we also see vulnerability in her, and while Hank seems confused and timid at times, we see resilience in him - and eventually we fall in love with both! Another aspect I appreciate is how the characters are funny and flourishing even as they're challenged in certain ways. While this shouldn't have to be highlighted, I'm glad this book is normalizing it. We Could Be Heroes is an important and enjoyable read for its themes as well as its characters.
April 3, 2020
Just finished this wonderful book--devoured it in one sitting. Margaret Finnegan writes with such a fine combination of humor and sensitivity, perfect for her subject here--two kids with special challenges, and a dog who has them too. Finnegan's insight into what it feels like to have autism, together with her use of pitch--and age--perfect metaphor, make this book both a fascinating read and a heart-opener for young and older readers alike. Finnegan's sense of humor shines throughout, and because of that, the book never verges on the edge of the sappy or sentimental, as some treating this subject matter might. It's a gem, polished and sparkling. And don't miss the acknowledgments at the end.
May 16, 2021
This surprised me a lot! It was smart, funny, adventurous, made me cry a little and overall really good.
As a teen (who normally enjoys more 'serious' books) I didn't think a MG book would be for me but this was perfect! I could relate to both mc and the plot keep me really invested. And the life lessons this book are for everyone.
I also really liked how the author wrote the mc and their families. lt felt very real and something a kid that age would do (including little me).
The author also did a good job 'representing' the autism on Hank, which made really happy. And also how Maise related to Booler and seeing her train of thought, no words for how that made me feel.
Overall a great book!! It was amazing to read it!
As a teen (who normally enjoys more 'serious' books) I didn't think a MG book would be for me but this was perfect! I could relate to both mc and the plot keep me really invested. And the life lessons this book are for everyone.
I also really liked how the author wrote the mc and their families. lt felt very real and something a kid that age would do (including little me).
The author also did a good job 'representing' the autism on Hank, which made really happy. And also how Maise related to Booler and seeing her train of thought, no words for how that made me feel.
Overall a great book!! It was amazing to read it!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 82 reviews