Because this book is about ideas, it is hard for me to use simple terms of "I like it" or "I did not like it." If everything in this book is true then this should not be happening, which is why it is hard to use a 5-star scale in terms of likeability. In this case, 3-stars means neutral and not that I like it. With that said, I am going to dive into this review.
The Premise
This book's premise is that conservatives are under attack on college campuses, but as long as conservatives keep having a presence and keep facing those who impose them then Conservatives can have a presence in colleges.
The Argument
14 chapters was establishing the evidence and what the political left is doing. For me, my biggest criticism about this book is there are no footnotes or a bibliography. There are websites mentioned and specific examples, but there was nothing about where you can directly find the information. This is the second book I have read by Charlie Kirk and the second book with no footnotes. If you are saying you want people to think and have a dialogue with you then should you not supply where your evidence comes from?
Based on paper, the argument is quite persuasive. Without verifying the evidence, this sounds like a real problem. All ideas should be heard, because sometimes not hearing an idea can cause long-term problems. This means if people are doing this then that should not happen.
Win?
Bad ideas should never win. On the other hand, I was not fan of how this sounded like a "us vs. them" thing. Nobody should bully, harass, and all of the other negative words. To open a dialogue with someone in hopes to understand and maybe change someone's bad ideas, you have to do it from a place of compassion and empathy. I felt this part was not coming off strong enough for me, especially when using the word "win." Win implies losers and winners. You could put this in terms of ideas, but when the focus seems to be more on people it is hard to not think of it as "us vs. them."
The Author
I do find Charlie Kirk's story fascinating. Putting together an organization after high school is no small task. What he has managed to do is no short of impressiveness.
Verdict: If everything in this book is true then people should make sure everyone feels their voice is being truly heard and represented.