What a noble sweetie David Horowitz wants us to think he is. Such a prudent, moderate voice without bias – a humbly patriotic agnostic just trying to give religion a fair shake. As many of his previous screeds have shown (“Big Agenda: President Trump's Plan to Save America,” “The Black Book of the American Left”), he is an alt-Right conservative devoted to demonizing the Left. That's fine; the political bookshelf certainly has room for that. But his disingenuousness – the emperor's clothing in which he wraps “Dark Agenda” – poisons this latest book, which hopes its measured tone will obscure its anti-liberal, pro-religion crusade. It doesn't.
The book's hysterical subtitle, “The War to Destroy Christian America,” is what most tidily damns Horowitz. Nowhere in the book does he credibly demonstrate this “war.” He presumes it, and presumes you'll agree without reflection and without demanding clear evidence. Examples of his fraudulent thinking:
* “[T]he left celebrates not just teaching about Islam but actively proselytizing for Islam in the public schools. Why? It’s because Christian doctrines were foundational to the American Republic, which the left despises.” No evidence or rationale provided; we are simply to accept this vilification – which is demonstrably not true. Let's just get this out of the way: The Left loves America as much as the Right; it's the approaches and philosophies that diverge, not the intentions. Is Horowitz genuinely unaware that most Democrats are Christians? Can he show a single public rally, ostensibly by his version of the Left, in which the chants were against Christian doctrines in schools and for Islamic fiat? Or, for that matter, can he point to a single public school in which Islam is actively taught and advocated? Of course he can't, but that doesn't stop him from making wild, prejudicial claims.
* “When I consider the short duration of my life, swallowed up in the eternity before and after, the space which I fill, and even can see, engulfed in the infinite immensity of spaces of which I am ignorant and which know me not, I am frightened and astonished at being here rather than there; for there is no reason why here rather than there, why now rather than then. Who has put me here? These are the questions that only a religious faith can attempt to answer. There is no science of the why of our existence, no scientific counsel or solace for our human longings, loneliness, and fear.” Nonsense. Science, through cosmology, biology, chemistry, sociology and logic, is quite able to address such “why” questions – and unlike religion, it does not rely on unsubstantiated and unprovable claims of gods. Religion's “answers” are comforting illusions, often easily exposed by a rational analysis. As for “who put [you] here,” that would be your mother and father, Mr. Horowitz. Biology 101. Further, that is one hell of an unwieldy first sentence, sir. Find an editor.
* “When Soviet Communism collapsed in 1991, progressives didn’t give up their illusions. Instead they changed the name of their utopian dream. Today they no longer call their earthly redemption 'Communism.' They call it 'social justice.'” So, in Horowitz's humble, fair view, progressives (i.e. liberals, i.e. Democrats) had a utopian dream, an earthly redemption, and it was Communism. Ah. Please share your sources, Mr. Horowitz. Exactly. He can't. But it makes for rousing, incendiary prose that is catnip to the arch-conservative mindset. Democratic presidents as well as Republican stood against the Soviet Union and Cuba and North Korea and Red China. A peek into any remedial history book will confirm this. And “social justice” is a pure evil, Mr. Horowitz? Ah.
“Dark Agenda” is littered with such poppycock. Where Horowitz errs – where fundamentalist Christians of all stripes do – is in conflating constitutional adherence with anti-Christian assaults. Schools can no longer force prayers on students? Gays, blacks, women and others who have been historically marginalized now have increasingly equitable rights? Judaism, Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism and other religions are given equal footing on the national stage? Horowitz cries foul. I say, Good. The country has become more inclusive and more prosperous by emphasizing the Constitution and limiting religious intervention in, and by, government.
These facts may be anathema to Horowitz, but they express the essential will and vision of the Founding Fathers. No one is shuttering churches, forbidding prayer or the wearing of crosses, canceling Christian TV or radio broadcasts, banning Christian books, ordering the end of tax exempt status of churches, eliminating Christmas and Easter, or banishing all mentions of God, Jesus, Christianity or the Bible from the public square (even though none of those four words appears, not once, in the Constitution). Christianity is doing just fine, thank you. If its numbers are declining, it has only itself to blame – and surely the molestation and cover-up scandals in the Catholic Church, alone, have driven many from the pews. If there's a “war to destroy Christian America,” the soldiers all wear crosses. Gott mit uns. And most of the generals are Republicans.
Extremist, fundamentalist Christianity is coming under fierce scrutiny, and that appears to be what has Horowitz palpitating. The hypocrisy of charismatics who doggedly support Donald Trump but overlook his un-Christian comments and behaviors (somehow I missed the admonition about grabbing p*ssies in Proverbs) is rightly gaining wider derision. And you can still refuse to sign marriage licenses for gays or march for Trump while waving a Nazi or Confederate flag, but you're going to face righteous public blowback for it.
In this book, Horowitz is throwing kerosene on an extinguished fire, and hoping you'll toss on the match. Don't fall for it. While he does touch on legimate issues for America and for Christians, Horowitz displays his political nakedness for all to see in “Dark Agenda.” He is, to coin a pun, at his own cross-purposes. “The War on Christianity” is indeed alive and well – in his head. Not outside it. Christians continue, in so many ways, to be pandered to, not persecuted. But now that lesbians can be shown on the Hallmark Channel as happy, regular couples, THIS is what Horowitz finds blasphemous, and this is the impetus behind his fraudulent book. To define the activation and embrace of the Constitution as a “War to Destroy Christian America” is, itself, an attack on America. This book is a wolf in sheep's clothing. Don't be fooled.