I used to uphold this book as the "Holy Grail" to overcome my gay self and counted it among my all time favorite books. I enjoy the stories in the book, like the writing style and optimistic tone "you can do anything", however, I fault this book as misleading that you can change your innate sexuality. I found it unsurprising to find out that BOTH authors (who were married at the time they co-authored this book) have since divorced and have embraced their sexual identity of loving persons of their same gender. I do not fault the authors as I took their same approach as advocated by our Mormon church that with God's love and Christ's redeeming power you can over come the burden of same-gender attraction. I cannot speak for everyone, but I can share my experience: the moment I stopped trying to change my innate self, and embraced my homosexual self at age 44, I felt like "my eyes were truly opened". I felt renewed, alive and truly happy for the first time in many years. I no longer keep this book on my bookshelf. I do not recommend this book for those struggling with sexual identity. It may prove useful with someone with a drug addiction or anorexia but I think there are better books for those debilitating issues
As a person who has been the victim of compulsive behaviors, I was trapped by them. I would stop one behavior only to have two or three replace the one I had overcome! I was truly caught in a cycle of bad habits. The authors use case histories to show how their gospel-centered approach can work, whereas conventional approaches fail. I can attest to this myself, as I have tried various approaches. This book is one that can truly be relied to break that downward cycle.
A very insightful read. Changed my way of thinking about guilt (seeing it as actually a destructive force instead of constructive), and increased my understanding of why people spiral out of control. It is pretty amazing that the co-authors (Martha Beck and her then-husband) could then ignore everything they knew and spiral out of control themselves, but this book is still great.