As always, I write this without having read any other reviews. My thoughts are subject to change as I gather other opinions later, but for now, this take is entirely my own.
You can see from the titles exactly what this is. It's a fantasy buddy adventure where they tee up the big bad, and then kill it in the end. Move on to the next book in the franchise. There's no real stakes as the title protagonists, the indomitable dwarf Gotrek Gurnisson and his hapless human sidekick Felix Jaeger, have plot armor until the final entry in the saga. They are doomed to succeed, inevitably. We know the end before we read the first line, like a romance novel but for strategic tabletop gamers. But it's not about the end, right? We don't listen to a concerto just to hear the final chord and we don't read a book for the final page; it's about the personalities as they go through the steps, it's about watching this improbable duo's bromance bloom into something hilarious and heartwarming and worth rooting for. So I bought the omnibus.
I wasn't wrong on the broad strokes, and author William King quickly gets readers up to speed on the nuances. Since Gotrek and Felix are literally (literarily? Is that not a word?) invincible, tension is introduced in the form of secondary characters who absolutely do get killed. I 100% support killing characters, it's one of my favorite things. I also appreciate how each of the three entries have a distinct feel to them. Inspired by Tolkien or Bram Stoker, William King does a competent job of plotting through and adding that Games Workshop overlay to the aesthetic. Finally, the climaxes are rock solid, and as a subtle note, King is particularly good at point of view. Novels spring from a single person's mind, and most authors have trouble disguising that fact. Allies and antagonists all seem to stay on the same page, where King has some deft work in exposing different character's knowledge of the plot and their motivations. I want to be clear on how much I appreciate these elements, because it's going to seem like I hated every minute of these three novels and I didn't.
The complaints I have are mostly in characterization. The blossoming bromance I described looking forward to? There isn't one. I wanted an odd couple dynamic, and as I read I easily found what I wanted it to be; Gotrek is neigh invincible on the battlefield but an astonishingly standoffish boor, a barbarian archetype, where the cowardly Felix relies on his silver tongue to charm his way into or out of near any situation he likes. Due to plot reasons readily supplied, the pairs' lots are thrown together, to mutual chagrin; Gotrek must put up with Felix's squeaking and whining if he wants his doom to be properly recorded, while Felix is reluctantly dragged into one deadly predicament after another, just so he can witness the doom and get this mad adventure over with. Hilarity ensues, as over their journeys their respect for one another and their talents grow, their characters arc, and we genuinely don't want to see Gotrek die in the final entry though we know it's inevitable. I want to read that story. I almost want to write that story, because I can see in my minds eye exactly how I would do it. Instead, Gotrek barely engages and Felix is content to leave well enough alone. I'm not mad, I'm disappointed.
Most of my complaints stem from Felix's passivity. Far from being a charismatic yet craven ne'er do well, and despite occasionally telling us how reluctant he is to fight, Felix is quite brave and always holds his own in the fray. In fact, about half the time his heroic feats outshine Gotrek's. Felix also enjoys an intensely sexual relationship with an incredibly attractive warrior princess, despite both characters explicitly acknowledging he has NO ATTRACTIVE QUALITIES. He's Bella from "Twilight," he's the worst sort of GaryStu; a bland reader self-insert who happens to experience amazing events without trying or suffering or earning it in any plausible way. Which really sucks, because his is the perspective we're in more than anyone else. Frankly, the entire series is misnamed. If there was truth in titles it wouldn't be "Gotrek and Felix." It wouldn't even be "Felix and Gotrek." It would be "Felix and Friends," of whom Gotrek would rank maybe fifth in this trilogy, after Ulrika Magdova, Maximilian Schreiber, Snorri Nosebiter, and even Grey Seer Thanquol. I think Malakai Makaisson has more dialogue in the trilogy, and he's not even in "Vampireslayer." Gotrek hardly speaks, hardly impacts the plot, all he does is kind of hang out and drink until it's time to fight, at which time he bloodies his thumb with the edge of his "frightful axe," and promptly chops dozens of bad guys to bits. At least Snorri is sort of amusing while he does the same. We're not given reason to care about either Gotrek or Felix, besides the fact that they are the title characters.
I was hoping, when I purchased this tome, that I would love it so much I'd want to read the first omnibus, and then seek out the... let me count... seveneightnine... eleven other entries in the series to bring it to a nice total of seventeen books... but I'm not going to. Unless I hear that it drastically improves, I'm not down to watch Felix Jaeger bumble his way under skirts and into glory. I have other books to read. And yet, I'm not sad I read these and I'm not sad they exist. The rest of the series isn't for me, and I'm okay with that.