Louis Bromfield, the Pulitzer Prize-winning writer, established one of the most significant homesteads in Ohio on his Malabar Farm. Today it receives thousands of visitors a year from all over the world; once the site of the wedding of Humphrey Bogart and Lauren Bacall, it was a successful prototype of experimental and conservation farming.
This lively, outspoken, and affectionate memoir preserves all things Louis Bromfield fought for or against in a life marked by surging vitality and gusto. He came from an Ohio family whose roots were in the land before the land was lost. He had his father's love of the land, and from his willful mother a hunger to know the world. From the New York City of theaters, concerts, parties, and novels, and a life in France that his success allowed, he finally returned to Ohio and established a new order for his family and friends, and for his followers, a new orbit into which they were drawn.
Ellen Bromfield Geld wrote a memoir of the man who was Louis Bromfield, father and friend, tyrant and “Boss,” alive always to whatever was worth responding to in people and in places, yet complex and lonely as a writer must essentially be to work at his craft. Now revived in paperback thirty-five years after its first publication, The Heritage remains a moving tribute and the recreation of a remarkable human being.
I always loved working on my uncle’s dairy farm during the summers. As a teen, I discovered the Louis Bromfield “Malabar Farm” series of books. I fell in love with his theories of agriculture and organic farming. I devoured all the books when I was in college; they presented such an idyllic view of life on the farm. They were a major force in my decision to go into dairy farming after college. That phase lasted about five years.
Bromfield bought the farm that he named “Malabar” (after the Malabar Coast)with earnings from the books he had written about India (The Rains Came which was made into a movie that won some Academy Awards, The Rains of Ranchipur.) To give you a flavor of his books one need only read this short paragraph about the ending of the movie: Lady Edwina tries to explain to the Maharani that her love for Safti has become true, so much so that she will make the sacrifice of leaving him for his own good. She drives away from Ranchipur with her husband. You get the idea. His books were extremely popular and even earned him a Pulitzer.
The farm was run down with pastures being taken over by thistles and other “noxious” weeds (I suppose one might argue that was nature reclaiming what it had lost.) Gullies were causing erosion and the buildings were in a state of disrepair.
Bromfield had studied agriculture at Cornell for several years before transferring to Columbia to study journalism. His agricultural ideas, considered fresh and innovative in the forties and fifties had their roots in what he had learned in school. (Fresh with naivete, when I was working on my uncle’s dairy farm in Wisconsin, I described many of Bromfield’s ideas to my uncle, who, in his inimitably kind manner, replied, “well, I guess he studied at the same places we did.”)
Using his considerable fortune, Bromfield implemented conservation techniques and experimented with “new” practices such as roto-tilling instead of moldboard plowing (a practice still used some places but not as much any more because of its high energy requirements,) chisel plowing (very common now) and multiflora rose plantings to replace fences as they attracted large numbers of birds and other wildlife while keeping cattle safely penned in a field. Multiflora rose is now considered an invasive (it is native to Korea and Japan) noxious species as it spreads wildly, taking over everything. It’s certainly quite pretty and good fodder for goats, but very discouraged presently.
The plan for the farm was roughly that of a cooperative with the member families earning a salary with rent-free housing and food from the farm. It was to be a general farm mixing dairy with beef, hogs, chickens a variety of fruits and a common vegetable garden Bromfield was to cover all the expenses until the farm made a profit and then would draw 5% of any net, the rest to be divided among the families. The farm manager Max, a very competent sort, remained skeptical, arguing the cost of machinery was more than the farm would be able to bear and noting presciently that much of the food could be purchased cheaper than it could be raised.
Ellen published these memoirs first in 1962, just a few years after her father’s death and then they were republished some thirty-five years later. The writing is often quite lyrical:
We came to Malabar Farm in early spring, which is an important condition in the fixing a farm in the heart. We saw the winter whiteness that covered the hills and burdened the limbs of trees dissolve under the cold misery of March rains, into thick sucking mud, which dragged off our boots a hundred times between the house and the barn. The mud and rain, chill and sorry, converged upon Switzer’s Creek, swelling it to the proportions of a roaring river. It lapped at the groaning iron frame of the bridge, grating its underside with bits of driftwood and trunks of fallen trees which, once the rains had ceased, would lodge to form deep pools where trout streaked temptingly silver in the summer twilight.
After Bromfield published Pleasant Valley, the first of the Malabar books, the others being Malabar Farm and Out of the Earth, he became something of a cult figure and the farm was beset by hoards of visitors, Bromfield holding court in a rather heroic manner.
He was seldom accurate in his descriptions. If anything he was expansive and grossly optimistic and I think any good farmer with sharp ears and a practical eye could have tripped him up on a hundred disparities. But, somehow, his audience didn't seem to care about these enthusiastic exaggerations. What seemed to be important was the picture they evoked, the whole vast scene of farm life which suddenly became complete, important and, using one of his favorite expressions, "limitless in possibilities" 'the common everyday practice that most of those people carried out became suddenly alive and meaningful as he described them in a way that every farmer understood but could never quite describe to himself.
Ellen continued her father’s dream recreating Malabar in Brazil where they foster sustainable agriculture. Malabar Farm itself could never sustain itself after Bromfield’s death. The children had no ability to keep it going so it was sold to a trust which eventually donated it to become a state park in Ohio (which I MUST visit one of these years.)
The book is hagiographic, but so what? Bromfield was her father. In the end, I realize now that Malabar Farm was a rich man’s plaything, but in a good way. Some of his ideas were worth adopting and the fact that people like Humphrey Bogart could marry Lauren Bacall there helped to publicize his thinking. It never would have succeeded without his considerable income from writing, however. Bromfield had the best of all worlds: the farm, a great place to hang out and play with, and a vibrant intellectual community. His wife, Mary, wasn’t quite so fortunate. Bromfield “rescued” her from a Massachusett’s Brahmin environment, and she did fine as they traveled around Europe and the world, but the farm made her very lonely.
I still retain very fond memories of lying around my dorm room transported to the idyllic lands of Malabar Farm.
I visited Malabar Farm with a friend a couple of years ago and we purchased books in the gift shop which we have shared. I read this collection of essays--skimming some and reading others entire. Having been enchanted by the farm, my reading of these memories of Louis Bromfield's daughter brought back all the visuals of the tour that day and the smell and feel of the house itself. If you are thinking of reading these essays, please visit Malabar first. The read will then be a wonderful stroll down memory lane.
When we visited Malabar Farm here in Ohio, I bought this book out of curiosity: How would his daughter remember Louis Bromfield? Turns out, she's a very good writer, and the book was fascinating and enjoyable. Maybe a little bit repetitive, but even so, the combination of charm and frankness makes that a very minor quibble. Interesting to read the description of the terrible emotional chaos of an alcoholic home, while the author is assuring you it was all okay because the alcoholic could be so much fun. She doesn't use the A-word, but she does make the connection between alcohol consumption and behavior, so she might as well have. Even so, she does manage to make me like her father, most of the time, no matter how crazy he may have been to live with. Still, I know that funny stories often conceal experiences that were not funny to live through (even if we laughed at the time). Much of the story is heartbreaking, especially toward the end, but that's not surprising, is it?
The part that I find most intriguing is the live-in male companion, supposedly his manager (also a beloved-yet-crazy alcoholic, judging by the stories): The daughter suggests that he was the only person who could talk back to her father, and that his critical view made her father's writing better. Part of her evidence is that the writing after the companion died is not as good. She doesn't add the other possible explanation: After his partner in crime died, life went flat for her father and his writing did, too. Naturally, I could be reading too much into it, but I don't think so.
Recommended for those who enjoy lives of the rich and famous (but essentially decent, in this case).
This book was much more readable, engaging, and interesting than I expected. Having been to Malabar Farm a few times enhanced my enjoyment. I definitely recommend this book to anyone who appreciates Malabar Farm.
Highly recommended for all Louis Bromfield fans, and those who love the Malabar Farm he created. Bromfield-Geld is a marvelous writer who adds context and color to the many stories her father shared in Pleasant Valley, Malabar Farm, From My Experience, and other works.
Great book even if you never visited Malabar. A wonderfully written, very descriptive book about her memories of her father, Louis Bromfield. It was written in 1962 not long after his untimely death. Her portrait of the man, his love of the land and the Ohio countryside, as well as his creative talent as a writer, story teller and all around enthusiastic man is well worth reading even if you're not into sustainable ag. Loved it.