This was another re-read for me. I first read this book in high school. Reading this again as an adult, a lot of things hit me differently and I was able to pick up on some of the more questionable things that were happening. This was a way more emotional book for me this time around.
If Mr. Severson was really worried about being fired for dating one of his students, he had a funny way of showing it. At least one of his fellow teachers at the high school knew he had feels for Bernice, and it kind of sounded like the principal may have been on to it as well. Not to mention picking her up on his bike and giving her rides (they could hear people talking about them as they went past). And having sex in his classroom during prom . . . Not the smartest decisions.
I think it was pretty stupid of Severson to sneak into the school after he was diagnosed to 'say goodbye' to his students. Rather he was contagious or not, he shouldn’t have pushed his luck with spreading the disease throughout the school. Although, at that point, if he was going to spread it to any of his students it could have been to late by then.
I’m confused. First Doc said that leprosy runs in families, and later he said that it was rare for a child born from leper parents to have the disease. Also, from what I read as I continued, there doesn’t seem to be much of a connection with families. There is no mention of anyone on the island being related (besides for Michael and his military veteran father). Was Doc simply mistaken about his ‘family tie’ theory or did the author simply decide not to explore this idea much.
After receiving the letter that his mother had died, Severson escapes from the camp and starts to head back home. It makes me slightly concerned about how he doesn’t seem to be worried and even cares if he will effect anybody else with leprosy. I mean, he just walks down the road in New Orleans, stopping at street vendors and at a cafe (not to mention the club where he got beat up). Doc told Severson once that most of the people at the leper camp didn’t know how they caught the disease. THIS IS HOW THEY CAUGHT IT. From some idiot sitting a couple tables away from them in a restaurant or passing someone that has it on the street, and yet Severson doesn't seem to care in the slightest if anyone else around him gets sick.
I had forgotten that Severson had raped Sheri. I understand he was angry over everything that he has been through (diagnosed positive for leprosy, treated like a prisoner in the camp, getting beat up after attempting to escape, and then getting attacked by Sheri with a knife), but hurting Sheri in THIS way was not going to help his situation. Although he did technically rape Bernice too (by modern day standards anyways). He did have sex with a minor. Was this considered rape back in the early 1900s?
I don’t know if Sheri was in denial or what, but she did not act like someone who was raped by Severson. Going back to visit with him after just a couple weeks? Having 'real' sex with him? Shouldn’t she be avoiding him or at the very least not wanting him to touch her? Just because she is a whore doesn’t mean she doesn’t have the right to say ‘no’ and she did. “She slapped him as hard as she could. ‘You’ll have to kill me first,’ she yelled in defiance. ‘You’ll be fuckin’ my dead body’” (189). They seemed to have started dating after this as well.
It was annoying how clueless Severson could be about some stuff. For example, when Doc admitted to him that he wasn’t attracted to women, Severson (shocked) questioned him about his age, apparently assuming that the reason Doc wasn’t attracted to women was because he was to young. Doc is old enough to have graduated from university. It has nothing to do with age . . . Also, when Sheri started randomly asking him questions about kids being born from leper parents and how that would effect them, did he really think that she was just curious. He didn’t even think to ask her why she wanted to know? He could have done something more to help her if he had known that she was pregnant, and may have been able to protect her from the hospital staff too. There were several points in this book where I wanted to shake some common sense into this man.
Severson really does have a thing for younger woman, huh? Not only did he date (and was engaged to) Bernice, but then 22 years after dropping off the little girl with golden hair with the nuns, she shows up at the Molokai leper settlement and THEY hook up.
This quote shocked me: “Alcoholism plagued the village, and Severson could do little to curb it. What he did curb, and some said with an unholy vengeance, was assault and battery. Property damage. Theft. And most importantly, rape” (289). This coming from the man that had sex and was engaged to a minor and raped a whore, but God forbid if anybody else rapes someone . . .
Pee Wee (aka Peter Waimea) was Severson’s deputy and a good friend of his. The guy had one of the worse cases of leprosy and was suffering. Why would Severson refuse to help Pee Wee end his life when he was suffering like this and barely breathing anyways?? Severson wouldn’t help him, so Pee Wee apparently found someone else to drag him out of the hospital and he died being eating alive by pigs. This was a terrible way to go, but he had asked Severson for help first. Instead of being furious for the way Pee Wee died, he should have found a more humane way to but the poor guy out of his misery. No one deserves to spend their last days in this kind of pain.
Did Peter Waimea not tell his doctors/nurses that he wanted to be put out of his misery?? I mean, they allowed Severson to continue with his treatments that they warned him several times could be killing him and he says, "Dead or alive, I’m through with leprosy” (320). If Severson has the right to tell the doctors to continue with a treatment that they advice him to stop because it is hurting him, Pee Wee should have had the right to ask them to end his suffering when he was in that amount of pain.
I loved the ending of this book. It reminded me of the end of the movie, Titanic, when after Rose passed away, she returned to the ship where everyone that had died that night were their to welcome her (including Jack). The only difference was that instead of just passing by his fellow lepers that he lived with in the camps, he was visited by everyone he had known in his live and was important to him in someway. The last scene, with Severson seeing the light and his 'wife', Bernice, told him that it was time to go . . . It was a nice way to end his lives journey.