I liked many things about this book. The descriptions of pregnancy and labor, while a bit textbook-ish, were detailed and precise and not alarmist. I liked the diagrams and pictures, and having everything clearly laid out. I also think the sections on natural ways to control pain and discomfort during pregnancy and labor will be helpful later, and I'm going to make my husband read the sections on massage and relaxing touch.
However, this was definitely not an unbiased book. I felt that although the book presented various options for labor and delivery, there was a strong bias toward "natural," non-hospital births, or at least hospital births with as little intervention as possible. Now, in theory that sounds great. I'd love to labor without medication for as long as I can handle it and have a vaginal birth, and I think the advice about not letting yourself be intimidated by your doctor into making a decision you are not comfortable with is very sound. However, I also feel that no matter how much research and practice I do and how prepared I am, I may not ultimately have complete say in my own labor. I think it's just irrational to believe that I can have complete control over the experience. What if there is a medical emergency and I have to have a fast c-section? Or what if there is a blizzard and I can't get to the hospital and have an unplanned home birth? It just seems like making a birth plan, as this book advocates, will only set me up for disappointment and feelings of guilt when the birthday doesn't match my ideal.
I like to plan and I appreciate the resources this book gives me, but I didn't find this book as "complete" as I would have liked since I felt that it was really advocating one ideal form of childbirth but describing other less-than-ideal options just in case. And I suppose a c-section IS a less-than-ideal option, but there has to be a way to describe it and other medical interventions in a way that don't make them sound like something dreadful to be avoided at all costs. In the end, what I care about is getting the baby out of my body safely, however that happens. I'll keep reading and doing research so that I can hopefully make good choices when it matters (and when I am given choices), but I know that is all I can do.
Finally, I'll concede that it's possible that my own personal views (and my own pregnancy hormones) are coloring my review of this book a bit much and I read judgment into it where no judgment was intended. And overall it was the best pregnancy book I've come across so far, hence the 4 stars.