Wir hätten gewarnt sein können: Donald Trumps Sicht auf die Welt

by Brendan Simms, Charlie Laderman

Wie unberechenbar ist Donald Trump wirklich? Was wir von dem US-Präsidenten zu erwarten haben


Donald Trump erscheint vielen als Politiker, der das Handwerk nicht beherrscht und dessen politische Äußerungen impulsiv und widersprüchlich sind. Doch damit unterliegen wir einem Trugschluss. In einer scharfsinnigen Analyse zeigen die Historiker Brendan Simms und Charlie Laderman, dass Donald Trump seit seinen ersten öffentlichen Äußerungen in den Achtzigerjahren beharrlich eine Linie verfolgt: Amerika, das von aller Welt ausgenutzt wird, wieder den nötigen Respekt zu verschaffen und zu alter Größe zu führen. Und dafür braucht es, nach den vorhergehenden Versagern im Amt, einen starken Präsidenten: Donald Trump. Ein erhellender Einblick in Trumps weltpolitische Vorstellungen.

Genres: Politics, Nonfiction, American, Biography

157 pages, Hardcover

First published January 24, 2017

About the author

Brendan Peter Simms is Professor of the History of International Relations in the Department of Politics and International Studies at the University of Cambridge. Simms studied at Trinity College Dublin, where he was elected a scholar in history in 1986, before completing his doctoral dissertation, Anglo-Prussian relations, 1804-1806: The Napoleonic Threat, at Cambridge under the supervision of Professor Tim Blanning in 1993. A Fellow of Peterhouse, he lectures and leads seminars on international history since 1945

Reviews

[Ami · Rating 4 out of 5]

The key takeaways from this book:

- Trump has always had a very narrow and superficial understanding of world politics. Said understanding was very little affected by what was going on in the 'bigger picture' he claimed to see: he had the same complaints and the same fears both when America was supposedly 'losing' the Cold War, and when the country was the uncontested power in the world system; what he says now about China he was saying about Japan in the 80s etc. On the plus side, he is definitely consistent
- Despite the above, Trump is good at spotting 'storm clouds': he predicted the fall of the USSR a year before it happened, and was warning in 2000, a year before 9/11, that Osama bin Laden was a serious threat
- He routinely overestimates his abilities: the president who refused to receive daily security briefings because he is "like, smart", was claiming in 1984 that he could learn all about nuclear missiles in "an hour-and-a-half" and negotiate on the topic with the Soviets
- Trump was always susceptible to the "CNN effect", hence why we should not be surprised that Fox News has such a profound effect on him
- Trump lies, even to himself. I believe his concern for America is real, I believe his bombastic patriotism is truly heartfelt, but that doesn't stop him from seeking his own self-interest. A good example is his attitude regarding Cuba: he was paying good money for advance access to the Cuban market should the embargo be lifted while claiming publicly that lifting it would be a moral degradation for the United States
- Despite wanting to "make America great again", Trump is turning the USA from the power into a power by destroying the complex and fragile web of alliances successive administrations built

[Chad · Rating 4 out of 5]

Must-read for all who want to know who Trump really is. The authors trace Trump's publicly expressed opinions from 1980 to 2014, stopping there because any comments Trump made from then on were potentially tainted by the necessities of political campaigning, pandering, etc. A consistent theme of Trump's public commentary up to his candidacy is the complaint that America was not receiving the "respect" it deserved from the rest of the world, and how this signified the folly and stupidity of American political leaders. But the section of the book from 2015 to the present contains interesting and thoughtful speculative analysis of what Trump's foreign policy positions mean for the world. Pity the book was evidently rushed to print, as there are a tad too many typos for my liking. But still great!

[Miltiadis Michalopoulos · Rating 4 out of 5]

Although it looks outdated nowadays, since it was written in 2017, this book is still very important in understanding Trump's policy and ideology. It looks more important today than 8 years before, since now Trump is most determined to impose his tax-tarif and anti- immigration policy. The book explains that this policy is not opportunistic and Trump is not a mere populist leader. On the contrary, his views were already formed during the eighties and were also declared in many interviews and also in his book which was published few years before his first election. I will finish this short review with a few excepts from the book:
Donald Trump was a child of the 1950’s and, just as his domestic agenda is a nod to that era’s vision of the American Dream, his worldview reflects the mentality that Brogan identified. For Trump, almost every international problem that besets the United States is explained by the idiocy of its leaders...
In his 1987 open letter to the American people, when Trump bullishly inserted himself into national politics for the first time, Trump declared that “the world is laughing at America’s politicians.” The same day that letter appeared, he told Larry King in a CNN interview that other countries “laugh at us behind our backs, they laugh at us because of our stupidity and [that of our] leaders.”He has been repeating that refrain ever since.
...what is clear is that when Donald Trump entered the White House, he did so with a worldview that has been constantly advanced and relatively consistently articulated in countless statements over the past three decades. Don’t say he didn’t warn you.

[Benjamin Stahl · Rating 3 out of 5]

All things considered, a mixed bag. While I greatly appreciated and commend the generally non-biased, non-deranged, non-"Trump is the next Hitler!" approach this book took, it's still hard to come away from the book feeling like Trump was really that clever or smart a guy. He sounds more like a broken record, railing off his favourite catchphrases and anecdotes to whoever will listen in a way that kind of reminded me of my father-in-law (no disrespect to the latter, of course; my wife's father is a great man). This is not really the book's fault, but Trump's own. And it must be said that since the deeply disappointing (and, I still think, kind of dubious) election of Joe Biden last year, my already measured liking for Trump has diminished to more of a realistic, reluctant admission that he wasn't as great as I thought he was on his best days. I just liked him because he sent the lefties, who I was tired of seeing get their way, into hysterics and embarrassing conspiracy theories for four years.

Anyway, the book is good for its lack of an anti-Trump agenda. However, it does not make for a wholly satisfying read, as much of the ground it covers is very repetitive, shallow and kind of dumb - even if you don't entirely disagree with all Trump's impassioned rants.

[Lea · Rating 4 out of 5]

Sehr neutrale und unparteiische schreibweise, wodurch man sich eine eigene meinung bilden kann. Allerdings fand ich, dass seine sozialen Ansichten viel zu wenig bis gar nicht beleuchtet wurden.

[syranez · Rating 3 out of 5]

Das Buch ist verständlich geschrieben und liest sich sehr angenehm und flott. Es zeigt mit mehreren Zitaten durch Jahrzehnte hindurch Trumps Anschauungen auf und ergründet die möglichen Auslöser für diese. Aus diesen Zitaten zieht das Buch Rückschlüsse und wagt Ausblicke in mögliche Zukünfte. Hervorragen ist die, wie man es von wissenschaftlichen Büchern kennt, ausführliche Literaturangabe.

Ich hatte es in in drei Tagen durchgelesen und Mir sind nun einige Ansichten Trumps klarer, hinsichtlich der Herkunft (Goldene Fünfziger, 80iger), der Gründe (Bad Deal) und der Beliebigkeit des Gegners beziehungsweise der Auswechselbarkeit. Das Buch ist günstig, lehrreich und schnell gelesen. 3 von 5 Sternen.

Aus dem Buch nehme Ich hauptsächlich mit, dass einmal gemachte Erfahrungen Überzeugungen generieren, die schwer wieder abgelegt werden können. Je früher man die Erfahrungen macht und damit je länger man sie mit sich trägt umso mehr werden sie zu unveränderlichen Axiomen. Der Blick wird eingeschränkt und man hält sich im Recht. Ganz deutlich wird das daran, dass Trump den militärischen Schutz seiner Verbündeter und der Welt rein finanziell betrachtet ohne die weniger messbaren Ergebnisse zu berücksichtigen.

[Neil · Rating 3 out of 5]

I received a free copy via Netgalley in exchange for a honest review.

Although I found this interesting it was also very repetitive.
Hence only 3 stars.

[Klaus Prömpers]

Great insight how Trump developed his "world view" and branded himself during the years 1989-2011