US Uber Alles
Refused To Finish. Rating: minus 5
I think that the one star reviews might be useful. A Goodreads tech (rogue, of course)😊 blocked my seeing other reviews more than a year ago and masked the commenter ID's on my pages. 🤔
I had to close my pages to comments and remove all my lurkers, except one. Goodreads will not allow me to remove Dr Susan Hamilton (a Maths professor at University of Tennessee ?). 🤔 She posted nothing over two years after her friend request and has not responded to four requests that she unfriend me. 🤔 She may be fascinated but I am just not that interesting, really.🤗
It seems that if you write one brutally negative review of a "sorry salute to the January 6, 2021 hero", a Goodreads tech (rogue, of course) can suddenly decide that a member being a communist is a bad thing. Who knew.🤗
For fun, see my review of "Dark Horse", a nice first contact story by M Diener or Powers of the Earth (a sorry salute to the January 6, 2021 hero) and the comments by a Claes Rees, Jr/cgr710 (a Self-identified NeoNazi and US patriot).
To Claes Rees, Jr/cgr710
Don't be a numpty. Be a smarty. Come and join the Communist Party. 🤗
I think that large gold transfers explain why US patriots (Tucker Carlson, Claes Rees Jr and US Republican Party, for example) support Putin's Russia even after his threatening to launch nuclear weapons against their own country. It might also be "Come for the gold, stay for the fascism" syndrome. In any case.
Today Kherson! Tomorrow Crimea! GLORY TO UKRAINE !!! and GLORY TO THE HEROES !!!
There is effectively no world building to speak of. There is no character with as much depth as an anime main character. There is no basic structure available for a story that might be believable or interesting. The developing theme is openly expressed.
US is very, very important and is the biggest, toughest country on the planet.
Europeans by existing, are a serious threat to the US position.
What about statement one?
Britain is the only good European country.
Britain is not really a European country?
Is the above a contradiction or is the writer's ignorance on display?
A president of the US being a woman is unfortunate but that is more or less acceptable.😀
Unfortunately she is cordial to foreign leaders, which makes her weak (?).
Does the writer remember that the US under Franklin D Roosevelt unashamedly conducted actual diplomacy? I doubt that he has heard of even Bretton Woods. I wonder whether the writer has read anything or seen a lecture or two that discusses geopolitics, political history or any history.
Does he or his audience think that the misogyny on which he bases his book's plot (?), is disguised by one sentence? Does a patronizing allowance that a woman, despite being a woman might be competent not register on the writer or audience as obvious, ridiculous and offensive? Unfortunately the answer is yes. Before challenging my answer, please look at the number of five star ratings. 🙂
The fawning Prime Minister of Britain is the good European leader. The Conservative Party leader is beset and besieged by forces preventing his destruction of the NHS. That is his one and only benevolent priority? That was and is an american precondition for a trade bill which is a little published fact.
Did it not occur that this portrayal might offend a British audience regardless of their party preferences?
The writer reduces the special Anglo-US relationship to this subordinate's groveling for approval. It has been more or less accurate for many decades, going back as far as the Suez campaign at least. It is still offensive. I was going to ask if the writer had seen even "Love Actually" and realized that he has never heard of the film.
All the above is found in the first 11% of the book and little more. I could not read futher.
I would love to see the writer try to write the scene of a Ukrainian soldier sitting in the ruins of a building in recently liberated Kherson, a light halo outlining his helmet with an AK on his lap. He puts a flute to his lips and begins to play a hopeful and haunting tune with his back to the incoming late morning sun shining through the broken wall. That is a real online video that is both sad and beautifully optimistic. 🙂
The writer can not because he would not recognize the value of a scene which conveys real emotion or attempts to convey the ephemeral life affirming joy that can be found in the midst of deadly combat. These US patriots do not realize that characters are representatives of real people, who have usually mixed emotional reactions to the events, in which the writer has placed them. 😎
It is not surprising to see such blind spots in the mind of an Ayn Rand addict or sad victim of "Objectivist" thought (?) overdose. These are often side effects of the dread disease "Ultranationalist Brain Freeze", also referred to as "White Nationalist and Fascist Magical Thinking". It is an indictment of society that there is little help available to these unfortunates. We should care, if only that this disease may very well be an epidemic in the making. 🤔
The characters barely register as people. One of the three news networks in the book is a major character and it is a thinly veiled Fox News. No surprise there. It was the strongest character In the book by that point and I would have dropped it then but I wondered where this was going. As if I did not know. Sometimes a train wreck is mesmerizing.
The Fox lookalike channel was given the title of "most watched" network in the US by the writer, which is the standard portrayal given by all similar US science fiction writers (and they are many).
US Goodreads members are supposed to keep politics out of their reviews according to some others 🤔 but their writers' politics can border on direct propaganda with no blowback. What a strange Russia like society, the US members seem to inhabit. Britain is racing to the bottom and may yet reach it first but America is still number one at the moment. 😀
The main (?) character is the oddest person. He believes that the government is hiding facts about an alien presence on earth and sets out to expose it, barely expecting consequences. Had he ever watched an episode of the twenty year old show "X-Files" or almost any film since about the US government from the last several decades, he could have written a better story.
Had he watched or read any news story about the years long saga of the US government's persecution of Julian Assange, he would have written a better story.
If the writer had seen any French or British films' portrayal of their governments' reaction to a citizen's attempt to expose their illegal or unethical actions, would his character be concerned about a rude reporter? Has he not read a British spy novel? Has he not at least, read reviews of "La Femme Nikita".
What a fantastical america, the writer imagines.
These first 11% of story obviously can only lead to contrived dangers, a comedy of errors and confirmed stock stereotypes for the character cast. This book may be somewhat enjoyable for a certain type of american reader or as a comedy/adventure about americans for other audiences. Otherwise there is no entertainment to be found in these pages.
The above is representative of the bulk of low end US science fiction. Poor prose, poor plotting, no real attempt at world building, no character work and a naked political stance as basis for the book are the standard. The underlying message is that the USA is the best and only altruistic country in the world. Yay!! 😂
Because the bulk of current low end US science fiction is so awful, I have begun to watch rather than read science fiction. All the streaming services seem to offer some science fiction stories, almost all of which are better written and all of which are more entertaining than the low end print. Netflix also includes a solid multinational selection for a treat.
I began searching YouTube for science fiction news and commentary over two years ago and found a large number of channels. As I browsed the other interest areas, I stumbled upon the book channels and it was look at first video. 😍😍😍
These are a varied group with different foci across the across the many elements of the world of books. The reader communities which they host are thoughtful, have varied tastes and interests but are enamored of all things bookish. They are the exact opposite to what constitutes the Goodreads experience. I recommend a visit to several book channels for any reader and have listed some below.
I discovered the educational video sites through advertisements on YouTube channels. I began with Curiosity Stream/Nebula at a cost of about $15 USD for a yearly subscription. I was very satisfied and think that they are all worth a look.
As for Goodreads, please treat Goodreads as a potentially hostile site, just to be safe.😐
Some suggestions: Minimize information on your profile, beware of messages (exchange emails) and remove all lurkers (they can be vindictive and some staff are willing to get involved). End ominous music.🙂 Seriously, please protect yourself. 😊
My YouTube picks of the moment.
Honest Ads, Mrs Betty Bowers, Snappy Dragon, Then & Now, Democracy at Work, Owen Jones, Some More News, Tulia, Kings and Generals, Sarah Z, Military History Visualized, A Cup of Nicole, The Narrowboat Pirate.
Some of my favorite channels are.
Tara Mooknee, Karolina Zebrowska, Some More News, Owen Jones, Novara Media, Munecat, Cover in French, The Armchair Historian, Sarah Z, Tulia, The Narrowboat Pirate, Physics Girl, Between the Wars, The Irish Reader, Lady knight the Brave, Books and Lala, Abbie Emmons, Emmie, Tom Nicholas, Philosophy Tube, Jadyn Rylee, Alize, Adult Wednesday Addams, Alice Cappelle, Jessica Gagnon, France 24, Randy Rainbow, Double Down News, DW News, Chloe Stafler, Between the Lines, Austin McConnell, Noah Samsen, Swell Entertainment, Enby Reads, Linguoer Mechanic, Thirdworld Booknerd, Noelle Gallagher, The Great War, Kings and Generals, Sabine Hossenfelder, Patrick is a Navajo, Three Arrows, Second Thought, Half as Interesting, Linguoer Mechanic, With Olivia, The Shades of Orange, The Snake Charmer, The Narrowboat Chef, Bookslike Whoa, History Hit, Tibees, A Life of Lit, A Clockwork Reader, Emmie, The Juice Media, The Mindful Narrowboat, Odyssey, Storyworldling, Bookleo, Petrik Leo, Christy Anne Jones, Mythic Concepts, Pentatonix, Told in Stone, Ancient Americas, Elena Taber, Neringa Rekaslute, Melodie Rose, Lilly's expat life, Lindsey Stirling, Hailey in Bookland, Mrs Betty Bower, Railroad Street, What Vivi did next, Zoe Baker, Northern Narrowboaters, Camper Vibe, Practical Engineering, Sara'H, Sir Christopher Clark, SandRhoman History, 2 Steps from Hell, Books with Brittany, GK Reads, Richard Wolff, Prime of Midlife, Maximillien Robespierre, Daniel Rubin, Mala Armia Janosika, Celtica, Jill Bearup, Then and Now, Alt Shift X, Autumn's Boutique, Atun Shei, MWG Studios, BrandonF, Everyday Astronaut, Beautifully Bookish Bethany, Art by Annamarie, Northern Narrowboaters, UA Courage, Kathy's Flog in France, Overly Sarcastic Productions, Between the Wars, Real Royalty (really, Patrick!), Eleanor Morton, Epimetheus, Crecganford, Ryan Chapman, The Plano Guys.
I wish you a sunny morning, a gorgeous afternoon, a pleasant evening, a wonderful night and may we all keep learning.
Hope and Courage together are the twin pillars of all strength.
Operations, Sisters of the Light