The reason for the 1-star rating is the timing. It sucks. Had I read this prior to Dan Brown's The Da Vinci Code or Angels and Demons this could have earned another star. Had I read this right after reading a book on Harry Potter or Percy Jackson, there could have been another star. Had I read this when I was in my teens or 20's, there could have been another one.
The mention of Knights of Templar, ancestral rites done in midnight with those chantings, search for a sword, etc. just did not hit the right chords in me. I had enough of them while being fascinated with the Dan Brown books a few years ago. Just yesterday I was crying about how deeply touched I was reading the last chapters of Nikos Kazantzakis' The Last Temptation of Christ. Then right after, I spent almost full 24 hours (getting my usual 6-hour sleep of course), trying to finish this book chosen by my Filipino group read for March 2010. This novel, Paulo Coelho's first widely published one, at times feels like a travelogue, sometimes a how-to-do-it-by-yourself book on relaxation and at times like a fantasy novel: what with Paolo being able to talk to his "messenger" (guardian angel), fought with a dog by biting and behaving like a dog, climbing a waterfall naked and with his search for his sword (like Excalibur, my goodness).
Paolo Coelho (born in 1947) dreamed of becoming a writer even at a very early age. His parents did not want him to so he took up Law. Still he persisted despite getting hooked on drugs during the hippie 60's. In 1982 he published his first work, Hell Archives that did not make any impact. In 1986, he published his second book, The Practical Manual for Vampirism that he himself took off the shelves as he realized that it was of "bad quality."
In 1986, when he was 39 years old, he went to a pilgrimage to Santiago de Compostela. This pilgrimage became the basis of this book. I am not sure if those supernatural experiences were just added to appeal to a fantasy, sci-fi young readers. There might be truth on the historical aspect of the pilgrimage like it was the route Ulysses, Don Quixote, Dante, Orpheus, Columbus, etc. once took but I am not sure about the others. Of course, I don't think I will ever have the chance to go there and verify as I would rather go to Nazareth, Jerusalem or any other more popular pilgrimage destinations.
This 1986 novel paved way for The Alchemist that was cited by Guinness World of Records as the most translated (67 languages) novel by a living author. Had Coelho not gotten the attention of readers by his supernatural-laden pilgrimage to Compostela, there could not have been The Alchemist which is also one of the best-selling books in history.
I read The Alchemist a few years ago and I rated it with 3 stars. Then early this month, I read his 1001 Must Read Books Before You Die novels: Veronika Decides to Die and The Devil and Miss Prym. After reading The Alchemist, I thought that Coelho is a serious no-nonsense writer. In Veronika, I got turned off by the masturbation scene but I took it lightly as it was relevant to the story. In The Devil, it was like a fable and intended for kids. Here in The Pilgrimage, coming before The Alchemist, he first tried the formula that worked well in afterwards: preach to the reader like a saint, put in some magic-fantasy, describe an exotic faraway place and presto: a bestseller.
There is no nothing wrong with that. Coelho hit a jackpot and laughed all the way to the bank (and with his other books, he will have an easy and financially secured retirement years). Yes, as he keeps on mentioning in his novels, let's all continue to dream as we will all die when we stop doing so.