What do you think?
Rate this book
花と忍び [Hana to Shinobi] #4
A Springtime with Ninjas, Vol. 4
Tamaki’s been cursed to die within a month. Benio can’t stand to just sit and watch, and she’s not afraid to put her life on the line to save the ninja she loves. But Tamaki tells her something she never thought she would hear him say: He wants to break up… Benio just can’t get a break! See her and Tamaki’s forbidden love put to the test in this final volume. Plus, get a peek at what happens after the story is over in the bonus comic.
162 pages, Kindle Edition
First published February 13, 2017
42 people are currently reading
36 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 17 of 17 reviews
February 20, 2023
Nooooo, I’m so sad it’s over!! 😭😭😭😭
What a fun series!!
I started this on a whim since I was so sick and it really perked up my days when reading! Benio was definitely a damsel in distress and cried more often then not, but she was also deeply passionate and caring. I deeply enjoyed seeing the desire she had for change between masters and ninjas come full circle in this final volume. (I will even say in more ways then one, though I won’t say more due to spoilers!)
I also deeply enjoyed how the ninjas were prevalent all the way to the end! Some of it definitely didn’t feel realistic and/or way over the top, but it was so fun to read, especially when Tamaki was involved! He always surprised me (and Benio too LOL!) and was always looking forward to what he would do next. (Not going to lie though. I got teary-eyed in one spot reading with him!)
And the ending! It was everything I hoped it would be. 🥰🥰🥰
Overall, this was a great series! I would definitely recommend it if you’re looking for a story with ninjas, a stubborn and passionate hero, and a really fun (but sometimes worrisome because #danger) romance!
What a fun series!!
I started this on a whim since I was so sick and it really perked up my days when reading! Benio was definitely a damsel in distress and cried more often then not, but she was also deeply passionate and caring. I deeply enjoyed seeing the desire she had for change between masters and ninjas come full circle in this final volume. (I will even say in more ways then one, though I won’t say more due to spoilers!)
I also deeply enjoyed how the ninjas were prevalent all the way to the end! Some of it definitely didn’t feel realistic and/or way over the top, but it was so fun to read, especially when Tamaki was involved! He always surprised me (and Benio too LOL!) and was always looking forward to what he would do next. (Not going to lie though. I got teary-eyed in one spot reading with him!)
And the ending! It was everything I hoped it would be. 🥰🥰🥰
Overall, this was a great series! I would definitely recommend it if you’re looking for a story with ninjas, a stubborn and passionate hero, and a really fun (but sometimes worrisome because #danger) romance!
February 2, 2023
Selesai!
Alurnya agak berantakan ya, kayak buru-buru gitu, perasaan di halaman sekian lagi di sini, eh pas buka halaman selanjutnya malah udah di situ, yah, coba baca sendiri deh biar paham.
Sebel juga karena Benio dikit-dikit mewek, aku paling kesel kalo ada heroine begitu. Tapi untung bisa baca sampai selesai, nanggung soalnya, penasaran endingnya. 😂
Cukup menghibur sih buatku, art-nya juga bagus, cuma emang ceritanya yang agak lompat-lompat alurnya, well, not bad lah ya buat karya seri pertama. Semoga ke depannya Narumi Hasegaki-sensei bisa bikin cerita yang lebih bagus lagi, soalnya art-nya udah cakep banget.
Alurnya agak berantakan ya, kayak buru-buru gitu, perasaan di halaman sekian lagi di sini, eh pas buka halaman selanjutnya malah udah di situ, yah, coba baca sendiri deh biar paham.
Sebel juga karena Benio dikit-dikit mewek, aku paling kesel kalo ada heroine begitu. Tapi untung bisa baca sampai selesai, nanggung soalnya, penasaran endingnya. 😂
Cukup menghibur sih buatku, art-nya juga bagus, cuma emang ceritanya yang agak lompat-lompat alurnya, well, not bad lah ya buat karya seri pertama. Semoga ke depannya Narumi Hasegaki-sensei bisa bikin cerita yang lebih bagus lagi, soalnya art-nya udah cakep banget.
May 12, 2021
Adorable. Adorable. Adorable. My heart has busted the fattest uwu! This is definitely the definition of "shojo manga" It was sweet and simple. This series is good for a short read. There weren't many memorable characters. This would probably be a bigger hit with the younger audience. Lmao, I might be too old. Oh no! There is never really a specific age to enjoy manga right????
August 1, 2019
I really need the half star option... 3.5
September 7, 2022
🌼 Benio seorang majikan yang menjalin cinta terlarang dengan Ninja yang melayaninya yakni Tamaki. Sekuat apapun mereka mencoba menghalalkan hubungan mereka, tetap terjadi penolakan dari berbagai pihak. Bukan hanya penolakan tapi nyawa Tamaki juga terancam, dan Benio pun harus menghadapi konspirasi yang ingin menyeret nyawanya.
🌼 Akhirnya satu serial shoujo yang ku ikuti ini tamat, meskipun bukan judul best seller tapi manga pendek ini berhasil tamat sampai selesai di Indonesia juga patut disyukuri.
🌼 Menurutku ceritanya diselesaikan dengan baik walau ya aku berharapnya sampai ke jenjang pernikahan karena melihat covernya. Hanya saja banyak bagian yang terkesan terburu-buru diselesaikan, seperti pengadilan ninja dan meyakinkan pihak antagonis.
🌼 Oke jujur aja ya volume terakhir ini pergerakan panelnya terasa acak dan terkesan tiba-tiba berubah. Butuh waktu bagiku untuk menelaah dan mengikuti alurnya yang bergerak pesat, paling tidak aku mengulang membaca sampai tiga kali baru memahami perpindahan panelnya.
🌼 A Springtime With Ninjas merupakan debut yang oke untuk Narumi Hasegawa, gambar karakternya manis dan imut, temanya cukup unik tapi alurnya di buku terakhir ini lumayan membuatku mengernyitkan dahi, ada plot twist yang bisa ku tebak sejak awal, tapi volume terakhir ini tidak terasa hambar untukku.
🌼 Ikut bahagia Benio dan Tamaki bisa punya akhir yang mereka inginkan.
🌼 Akhirnya satu serial shoujo yang ku ikuti ini tamat, meskipun bukan judul best seller tapi manga pendek ini berhasil tamat sampai selesai di Indonesia juga patut disyukuri.
🌼 Menurutku ceritanya diselesaikan dengan baik walau ya aku berharapnya sampai ke jenjang pernikahan karena melihat covernya. Hanya saja banyak bagian yang terkesan terburu-buru diselesaikan, seperti pengadilan ninja dan meyakinkan pihak antagonis.
🌼 Oke jujur aja ya volume terakhir ini pergerakan panelnya terasa acak dan terkesan tiba-tiba berubah. Butuh waktu bagiku untuk menelaah dan mengikuti alurnya yang bergerak pesat, paling tidak aku mengulang membaca sampai tiga kali baru memahami perpindahan panelnya.
🌼 A Springtime With Ninjas merupakan debut yang oke untuk Narumi Hasegawa, gambar karakternya manis dan imut, temanya cukup unik tapi alurnya di buku terakhir ini lumayan membuatku mengernyitkan dahi, ada plot twist yang bisa ku tebak sejak awal, tapi volume terakhir ini tidak terasa hambar untukku.
🌼 Ikut bahagia Benio dan Tamaki bisa punya akhir yang mereka inginkan.
February 18, 2020
2020 Read #198
I finished this series because I had all the digital volumes, and...wow, it was blasé. I wish it had been better. I didn’t care for the characters or the plot. I’d say Matsuri Hino’s two-volume Shuriken and Pleats is even better as a ninja shojo romance than this series is. Disappointing.
I finished this series because I had all the digital volumes, and...wow, it was blasé. I wish it had been better. I didn’t care for the characters or the plot. I’d say Matsuri Hino’s two-volume Shuriken and Pleats is even better as a ninja shojo romance than this series is. Disappointing.
January 15, 2021
Ini Nakayoshi banget sih. Baik dari gaya gambar, karakteristik tokoh cewek dan cowoknya, sampai ke plot.
Ending-nya bikin terheran-heran. Semua masalah selesai, bahkan niat bunuh-membunuh antara ayah dan putra kandung, hanya karena sang ayah "sekonyong-konyong" teringat ucapan tokoh utama cewek pas masih kecil??? Oh, no, please.
Beruntung, tokoh cowoknya lumayan likeable.
Ending-nya bikin terheran-heran. Semua masalah selesai, bahkan niat bunuh-membunuh antara ayah dan putra kandung, hanya karena sang ayah "sekonyong-konyong" teringat ucapan tokoh utama cewek pas masih kecil??? Oh, no, please.
Beruntung, tokoh cowoknya lumayan likeable.
July 3, 2021
Cute n adventurous
I enjoyed the story and how I ended, it was definitely differnt than what I've read before. The story has it's own creative work. Would 100% recommend if u like romance with a crazy twist
I enjoyed the story and how I ended, it was definitely differnt than what I've read before. The story has it's own creative work. Would 100% recommend if u like romance with a crazy twist
April 13, 2025
Gosh this was just so super cute. Adorable to the end. Nothing life changing but really sweet no toxic bs and just adorable little couple working together to fight the structure that is trying to keep them apart.
March 14, 2021
This series was just super cute and fun. Love the mix of ninja action with the romance. Yeah it was predictable but it's such a quick fun read you don't even care.
June 29, 2021
Enjoyed reading this manga, it's the average shojo manga.
The ending was a little off for me, but still, I had fun reading it.
The ending was a little off for me, but still, I had fun reading it.
November 4, 2021
I really feel that the series kind of got away from the author. It feels different.
February 2, 2023
Wow…. That was conveniently easy to accomplish at the end. Seriously, she has the worst-best luck!
May 12, 2021
Average shojo with a fun ninja twist.
July 11, 2019
Ok, we see somewhat a lot of action in this volume and lots of love.
The ending was predictable :((( but I had so much fun that I gave it a 5 anyways. Really Adorable.
The ending was predictable :((( but I had so much fun that I gave it a 5 anyways. Really Adorable.
Displaying 1 - 17 of 17 reviews