Okay, here is the deal. I like these books. A lot. But this one has a few negatives that almost made me give it less than 3 stars. Which I do not think that I have ever done with these [I don't remember because I have serious old lady brain]. I have even grown to like the narrator [who I DID NOT like in the beginning of me listening to these].
So here are my dislikes of this book:
1. I do not need to have a list of every single drink that Charlie has during the day. I get that people drink liquids all day long, I am one of them. But I do not text my friend and tell them that I am having a glass of water, tea, coffee [well, sometimes I do with the coffee only because I want them to drink a cup with me virtually, but I digress...] etc etc like what happens in this book. And I don't need to be reminded every time Charlie [poorly] chooses to have a diet soda that it is because his waistline is getting thicker. Every. Single. Time.
2. I do not need to know EVERY. SINGLE. TIME. Diesel [that is the cat] has to go into the utility room to use his box or eat. EVERY. SINGLE. TIME. Most people are aware that cats [animals in general I think] go potty and we don't need a running commentary about it. In this one, we even get to find out that Charlie seeks out a patch of grass for Diesel to do his business in when they had been in the car for awhile. This has been an issue in previous books but was really excessive in this one. . I might have almost sprained my eyes on that one.
3. Charlie is truly more possessive and caring of his cat than he is of his grandson. Don't get me wrong, I believe that he is totally in love with being a grandfather and loves little Charlie to pieces, but I think he loves his cat more. Probably even more than his children. This is made evident fully in this book with both Charlie's belief that he can take Diesel everywhere [except the hospital and every single time he has to go there without the cat, he laments it], including restaurants where he thinks people will make concessions to him having Diesel with him always. Which brings me to part B of this: Charlie takes Diesel E V E R Y W H E R E and is reticent to leave him alone. For even an hour. In previous installments of this series, Diesel being alone was never, ever an issue. Sure Diesel would be upset when Charlie came home and would chirp and squawk at Charlie, but Charlie had never hesitated to leave him at home when he needed to go somewhere where the cat was not allowed to be. THIS all changed in this book. Charlie was almost paranoid about having to leave the cat and even went as far as to get his daughter and son-in-law to "babysit" Diesel when he had to make a trip to the hospital [where we are then treated to Charlie pouting about how he had to leave Diesel etc]. I had a real issue with this - I don't believe in leaving animals for long periods of time alone and never, ever in cars when it is hot!!, but an hour or two at home alone is not a big deal and it was detracting from the story to have this happen now.
4. I do not, at any point, ever need to know about a MC's [in a cozy] personal life in such detail as was in this one. I like Charlie and Helen Louise together and I like that they have found each other at this time in their lives. It is lovely and I am happy for them. What I DO NOT NEED is the details of their evening phone calls and I most certainly DO NOT want or NEED details of their afternoon tete e tetes. E V E R.
What I DID like about this story [and what kept it from being a 2-star read]:
1. The actual story. I loved that it was a cold case and that Charlie didn't have to find a dead body. That was truly refreshing. And even though I had a running film in my brain while reading this [and while discussing this review with my Mom, I realized that the running film was an episode of CSI that was VERY similar to this story and it was why I went with the "why" I did, even though I didn't realize it at the time] and having the killer right, I had the why ALL WRONG. And that alone is worth 2 extra stars because when you read as many mysteries as I do in a year [over 100 this year alone], plus you watch mystery-based TV, you become honed to the who's and the why's quicker than the average person. So when I cannot get a part of it or all of it, I truly jump up and down.
2. Baby Charlie. Even though he isn't in this very much, he is a lovely addition to the story-line and I love how everyone interacts with this precious baby.
3. More of Stewart and Haskell. They work so well together and they always have good interaction with Charlie and actually bring out the good parts of Charlie when they do interact. I hope that they continue to be in the future stories as much as they were in this one.
4. Charlie and Helen Louise. Even though I said some harsh things above about them, they are truly lovely together [just NOT the extra romancey parts]. The idea of finding love again in the later years of your life is never a bad thing [and something those of us who have loved and lost still dream about at times] and I love that the author was brave enough to both explore and then pursue this. Just leave all the "extracurricular activities" out of it please. ;-)
What I liked about this book just outweighs what I didn't like about it and I loved the story arc of it enough to give it the 4 stars. AND, I will read the next book. But I do hope that the negatives I mentioned in this review do not become a trend. I'd hate to have to give up another series [ala Hannah Swensen] because the author chose to go down a road that is a 360 from all the previous reads.