dense, loquacious, pragmatic
The Good:
contains some real gems; socially relevant theme
The Bad
: dense philosophical writing;
Pieper's book, Leisure:The Basis of Culture is about work and play, labor and leisure, the ultimate point/counter-point of our lives. The initial attraction of the book is based on the assumption that the concept of leisure can be discussed lucidly and without the erudite language that typically accompanies philosophical writings. This is a misconception, as the work could be classified into all the other dense, erudite writings of philosophy.
It's a philosophical work that is especially relevant for our day and age where a society divorced from God has enslaved us to insidious notions such as work for work's sake. This is because our current society views us as mere commodities, valued exclusively through what we can put out in our work. But a Christian society views a person's value as so much more than that. Pieper garrulously touches on all of these things in his elaboration on how society should view work, leisure, and celebrations in order to coincide with a theistic perspective.
One of the most important concepts touched upon in the book is the act of philosophizing itself. Pieper states:
"Whereas my thesis... is that the essence of 'philosophizing' is that it transcends the world of work. It is a thesis which comprehends the assertion of the theoretical character of philosophy and its freedom; it does not, of course, in any way deny or ignore the world of work, but it does affirm that a real philosophy is grounded in belief, that man's real wealth consists, not in satisfying his needs, not in becoming 'the master and owner of nature', but in seeing what is and the whole of what is, in seeing things not as useful or useless, serviceable or not, but simply as being. The basis of this conception of philosophy is the conviction that the greatness of man consists in his being capax universi."
Pieper has identified a critical deficiency in our society, which is a lack of philosophizing. Philosophy pierces through the dreary existence totally dominated by work in that it tells us that there is more to life than work; that there are actually truths in the world, and a God. It helps us break free of our purely proletariat purpose and lifestyle where our total value, meaning, and existence are based on labor, or as Pieper calls it "the workaday world."
To wrap-up the book, Pieper spends the last section talking about the relationship between philosophy and theology. Here, it takes him 20 pages to say what St. Augustine concisely said in six words: philosophy is the handmaiden of religion.
The book is a treasure hunt, where most of the time you’re reading, waiting for Pieper's argument to culminate in a robust moment of clarity. Fortunately, you do eventually reach these moments, making Leisure:The Basis of Culture a rewarding experience.