My family reads all the Goodreads-award-nominated picture books every year. This is book #13 (of more than 20) of 2019, and statistically this looks like one of there two best of the year for my family. It's a fairly predictable (and marketable) topic for a book to be purchased by elementary school teachers, parents and librarians about reading, but it features colorful collage art we (collectively) at least found unique and interesting
Lyra (12) 4.5. If I ever wrote a book [go, Lyra, the budding artist!] this would be one my choices for art style and fonts, all over the place. I love the collages. So many patterns, colors and pictures. It's so fun to look at. Every page looks like it is from a different book I have never read. Oh, a couple pages
Hank (13): 4. For a book about learning how to read, it is pretty hard to read. Okay, but it's kinda fun to read, really.
Harry (14): 4.5. Fun art, but it is confusing at the start and at different places.
Tara: 4. Loved the art. And I thought the poem would be hokey but it turned out really nice.
Dave: 3.5. As an adult I though the collage approach was interesting and colorful but I agree with Hank, for sa book about how to read the art makes it almost impossible for little kids too read. The flat and largely unoriginal poem is about the joys of reading, ideal for librarians but not for kids.