What do you think?
Rate this book


264 pages, Paperback
First published October 11, 2016
Secret Heart is a light, sweet, f/f high school contemporary. Avery is an out-and-proud lesbian in an all-girl lesbian band called Detonate the Gazelle. She's always had a bit of a crush on classmate Madison, even though she knows it's a bad idea to pine after straight girls. When Madison goes to the GSA that Avery got roped into hosting with her best friend Scott, the two get to know eachother a bit better, and sparks begin to fly (like the Taylor Swift song that Avery probably secretly loves!) Meanwhile, Avery is also trying to decide what she wants to do after high school; move with her band to Austin, or stay in town so she can still be with her mom and Scott?
Avery is a memorable character, I loved her humor and snark. She felt like a person I would like to know. I could really feel her frustration with her between Madison's hesitance about them and their relationship, and her anxiety about deciding whether or not moving with her band mates after high school was the right way to go. Scott was also a great character, and the two of them were a fun, hilarious duo! I chuckled out loud at least a few times at their banter and sass.
Madison was a bit harder to decipher as a character. We learn she's a very kind and thoughtful person, always looking out for other people's best interests, that she plays soccer, and wants to continue the family legacy of winning Prom Queen. She was nice, but didn't seem quite as fleshed out as Avery and Scott. I would have liked to get to know her more and understand who she was, more about her family, her past relationships, her thoughts and feelings. She never really explained what it was about Avery that drew her to her the way Avery could describe all of Madison's qualities that she adored. I would like to see more of what's on her mind.
The pacing of this book is very fast. The book seems to span between December and June of Avery's senior year, but I can't really be sure where it begins and ends. This was a bit confusing at times, with maybe two or three chapters in a row happening at one point in time, then leaping to a week or two, maybe a month later. I would've liked to see more of Avery and Madison's relationship between the two of them; they were certainly cute and sweet, but I was left wondering what it really was that drew them together and made them like eachother, or what they did together alone. We read that they share some steamy makeout sessions (and props for including a f/f handjob scene, as girl/woman sexual needs is still something that YA is learning to be open about) but what else? What did they talk and joke about, or do before and after those things? I would've liked to see more of their secret relationship.
Overall, Secret Heart is a cute, light, story that I would recommend if you like contemporaries about any of the following topics: LGBT, rocker girls, high school drama, proms! I can promise you will love Avery and her attitude.