I enjoyed reading The Pecan Man and The Truth About Grace. I have been looking for another author with the writing pizazz of Bille Letts. So, I really wanted to love this book. I really, really tried – and failed. It was not terrible. It is a nice story, pleasantly written with the potential to be a great story but the clichéd characters and typified social injustices were just too much – it was like a over-personified Lifetime movie of a small psychologically damaged haven in the South.
The characters are likable and somewhat developed, but not in a way you can identify with them. Selleck even takes the time to provide a chapter for each main character who directly “talks” to the reader, further expounding on his/her issues and feelings within the confines of the story. Somehow all that did not make me more attached to the characters. Please note, it is not due to a lack of experience or understanding of the South - I have spent most of my childhood summers in New Orleans and spent my college years in Atlanta in the 70s.
I think Selleck tried to put too many social issues into a book about a little town, so, as I said, it became overwrought with clichés. There is Suvi, the super-sized NBA hero cut down in his prime with a knee injury, owner of the only barbeque in town who runs his life by his perceptions of prejudice among the locals. Will, the displaced ‘foreigner” from Minnesota, owner of the local B & B, who lost his wife to cancer after buying this place on a whim, who is determined to see his wife’s dream through. Then there is Sweet, the matriarch of a local poor family with “Bubba”, her husband, and their 5 children who live in a double wide trailer, can hardly make ends meet, but owns the local dress ship. Of course there is the crowd at the local ‘Café’ who are the gossip mongers and clearly have black/white issues. All these people not be outdone by Beanie, the town odd-ball who loves to dress in her version ‘Dale Evans’ attire every day down to the cowboy boots, crinolines, and matching cowboy hats and ride a bicycle in town (but had no discernible job other than Avon to pay for the material to make these intricate outfits) but perhaps the most sane person in the bunch.
If that were not enough, there are lottery winnings, jealousies, abortion issues, religion, bullying, learning disabilities, strange love interests, and a slew of other oddities that make this story fairly unbelievable. Listed under satire and humor – this is the one thing I found lacking, I did not laugh once.
I feel terrible about this review and will never write a review of less than 3 stars. I research my books before I read them, so I am never really disappointed. So, I was very surprised after finishing this read. My reason for the 3 stars and hence this review is that the writing and the concept of this story have great potential. If you want a fast read that is entertaining with a bunch of odd characters who may grow on you over time, this book is for you. But for me, after The Pecan Man, What Matters in Mayhew is lackluster at best.