All the plays are considered individually elsewhere, so a summary of my ratings must do (though it needs modifying, on balance), plus a brief account of the two long poems and the sonnets:
Hamlet [1600-1601] 10.17
Tempest [1611], The 9.27
King Lear [1605-1606] 9.2
Romeo and Juliet [1595-1596] 9.03
Winter's Tale [1611], The 9.02
Richard II [1595-1596] 8.4
Macbeth [1605-1606] 7.83
Coriolanus [1608] 7.7
Richard III [1592-1594] 7.7
Twelfth Night [1601] 7.7
Merchant Of Venice [1596-1597], The 7.68
Antony and Cleopatra [1606-1607] 7.6
Henry VI Part III [1591] 7.58
Julius Caesar [1599-1600] 7.57
Othello [1604] 7.57
Measure for Measure [1604] 7.5
Much Ado About Nothing [1598] 7.48
Pericles [1608] 7.45
Cymbeline [1610] 7.43
Taming Of The Shrew [1589-1592], The 7.43
Henry V [1599] 7.35
Midsummer Night's Dream [1595-1596], A 7.17
Titus Andronicus [1591-1592] 7.13
As You Like It [1599] 6.9
Troilus and Cressida [1601-1602] 6.9
Henry VI Part II [1591] 6.88
Henry IV Part I [1596-1597] 6.78
Henry VIII [1613] 6.77
Two Noble Kinsmen [1613], The 6.32
Henry VI Part I [1592] 6.58
Henry IV Part II [1597-1598] 6.53
All's Well That Ends Well [1605] 6.37
Love's Labour's Lost [1595] 6.27
Timon Of Athens [1605] 6.17
Two Gentlemen Of Verona [1591-1592], The 6.13
Comedy Of Errors [1594], The 5.8
King John [1595-1597] 5.8
Merry Wives Of Windsor [1600-1601], The 4.97.
Venus And Adonis [1593] 5.6
The Rape Of Lucrece [1594] 7.7.
Sonnets [1592-1603, pub. 1609] 7.19.
Venus and Adonis (1593), written in a six-line stanza rhyming ababaa, I didn't like at all, and felt it to be an over-elaborate and elongated plaint in love, written in an ardour of youth, and so the style smacked. The Rape Of Lucrece (1594), was, even though only a year later, far more mature and expressive. A seven-line stanza in ababbcc, in iambic pentameter, flowed even better when using monologue, a considerable amount of its content. Here, I felt a sympathy with Lucrece, who, much like Philomel, who is raped and then abused (see Lavinia in Titus Andronicus [1591-2]), is similarly raped, but has still her lamenting tongue (else, the poem would be shorter and less plaintive), yet decides she cannot bear the shame, and opts for suicide. Shakespeare therefore draws on Ovid's tale, but sends it in a different direction, compounding her sorrow. This, I appreciated much more.
The sonnets have traditionally been classified into two nominal categories, the first 126 (of 154) addressing a younger man, sonnets 127-154 to the 'Dark Lady', the last pair indicating the sexual disease consequent on the sexual voracity earlier connoted. They imply a personal if not just a poetic dramatisation of spiritual love for the former and sexual desire for and consummation with the latter, speaking largely with a strong personal voice implying or directly stating the poet's, with sonnets 135 & 6 punning on his own name. Frequently the sonnets discuss a theme or use a motif in pairs, a second (and sometimes a third and fourth, and more, as the first four to eleven do) developing the former theme in different permutations. Some of the sonnets are almost impenetrable (sonnets 35, 94 & 5 and 108 particularly), while there are tonal shifts implicit in others (69 seems to shift from adoration to criticism, but is paired off back to theme in its successor).
But there is also a stylistic difference evident. The 'young man' series becomes metaphysically mature, showing early impersonal abstraction (33-4, the sun imagery), later discussing Time and immortality, but only a few do not directly address its subject, becoming fully abstract, such as the famous 116 ('Let me not to the marriage of true minds') to Love, and 123 ('No, Time, thou shalt not boast that I do change'), to Time; and end in 126 with the 'silent' (empty) couplet, indicating that Time's claims (death) may be delayed, but cannot be defeated. While the adoration of the 'Dark Lady' escalates to a beseeching imploration (143, 145), a sickening through love (146) turning through hate (147) to a self-disgust (147) and contention (149) where recriminations abound (151-2), they end not with a metaphysical maturity but in the base physical: syphilis (153-4). But these last (28) sonnets, which become progressively more unpleasant to experience, because of their sickening content, also alienate by containing some very structurally clunky offerings (128 & 9), yet even while they physically repel, they eventually demonstrate a maturity of construction (147-52), their best leaving admiration for both beauty (130, 'My mistress' eyes are nothing like the sun') and superb cleverness (138, 'When my love swears that she is made of truth').