Helpless is bold and daring, and walks the fine line between what is acceptable and what is not. The heroes are larger than life, and more than a little...bent. Damaged, but not broken. They're not hindered by the law or held to any code other than their own sense of right and wrong, which has been shaped by their histories and is also a little bent.
Caden started off on shaky ground for me. He is hard, uncompromising, and obviously tortured by something(s) in his past. He does some things usually considered unforgivable. (You'll get no spoilers out of me.) He doesn't listen! But the depth of his character is revealed in a satisfying way, and as the story progressed I actually grew to like him quite well. He is strong, and loyal, and once you get him on your side, he won't shake free.
But Fracas.... You're asked to feel sympathy for, and root for, a woman who has had the shit end of the stick since puberty. She's crass, vulgar, and goddamned if she doesn't have a fighting spirit that society would sing praises of--if she were a man. So why not? Fracas is indomitable, outspoken, blunt and honest. Even when she's having her ass handed to her--and she knows that it's time to shut up--as a reader I really wanted her to win.
On the flip side, she is so flippant about her history--especially in the beginning, during the backstory rundown--that I wondered if she was even human. She almost lost me, there. How could anyone endure the crapfest that was her life and be so matter-of-fact about it? If I were having a conversation with Fracas and she told me all of that in one sitting, as it is presented in the opening chapter, I would either be looking for an exit or Googling a good therapist.
The author has a delicate line to walk. If the backstory isn't told, the reader may not be sympathetic with Fracas. But if it is told without kid gloves, it almost becomes too much to take in. There's got to be a happy medium, of revealing information in just the right increments to deliver the character's full depth without the reader despising her for what she is, or going a little numb because we learned too much too fast.
The plot has plenty of twists, and funny moments as well as horrifying ones. I very much enjoyed reading it. I can't think of anything to say that couldn't be considered a spoiler, so I'll just reiterate, it is a story worth reading. Crazy, up and down, wild ride. I did grow to care quite a lot about the characters and their battle to prevail...(no spoilers!) I wanted Caden and Fracas and the Disciples to WIN! There were a couple scenes that even had my eyes leaking on Fracas' account--the kind of tears I get from someone's core belief about themselves getting blown to pieces, when that's a good thing.
Now, as far as that missing star...
Because it is in first person, I had a rough time with some of it. As anyone who follows my reviews knows, I'm not a huge fan of first person. I don't see the appeal, and find when it isn't flawless it feels to me like I'm overhearing Chatty Kathy in the diner, telling her best friend about what happened last night. Helpless isn't flawless, but a lot of it is pretty well done. AJ has done better in other stories, though.
I found it hard to connect with Fracas--possibly as much if not more due to the issue I discuss above. Most especially, Fracas' little asides--commentary as though she's telling the story from some future date. Most of these I just found odd enough to pop me out of the bubble, but at least one was overtly revealing. Caden does at least one of those, too. As a reader, they make me go "A-ha! Something is coming!" but as a writer, I find it...well, a cheap trick. Foreshadowing with a sledgehammer.
The other quality of note is the amount of slang in this book. Britishisms galore, and many of them just plain derogatory terms. I could follow along through most of them, because they're used pretty well in context, but at times it was a bit overwhelming to follow. It gives the story a very salty feel, and I enjoyed a lot of it, but sometimes the sheer quantity was enough to pop me out of the bubble while I tried to figure out what on earth they were talking about.
This was a solid 4 star read for me. I would recommend it to anyone who has enjoyed other AJ Adams books, and also to anyone who enjoys a read about the darker side of life--people who are not held up as shining examples of humanity, but who really, at their core, highlight some of humanity's finest attributes.