Well, it's official, Ian Douglas' Star Carrier series has jumped the shark.
Much like his Warstrider series, the Star Carrier series should have ended before this book. Warstrider was an excellent trilogy, and the fourth book was a disappointment.
Star Carrier has managed to stay on track a little longer, only starting to go off the rails in the sixth book, and completing the train wreck in this the seventh installment.
I love the universe that Douglas has created, the technology is fascinating and the characters are engaging. "Sandy" Gray is easily one of my favorite protagonists in all the military fiction I have read. Or he was, until this book where he has begun a slide into paranoia and bigotry. The paranoia I can forgive, because the AIs really are running the show and leaving humans out of the loop, but the bigotry has come to the fore and it's an ugly thing.
I was so excited when I read about the White Covenant in the first book of the Star Carrier series. The idea that religious wars did so much damage to the world that society finally woke up and banned proselytizing and public displays of religion was extremely exciting. However, it has become clear over the course of seven books that Douglas thinks that the White Covenant is a stupid idea, or at least Gray does.
At one point in this book, Gray mentally rails against the celebration of the Winter Solstice. Why would he object to people celebrating the return of the light and the beginning of the journey out of winter? Because it’s not Christmas you see. Gray is from a segment of society that practices monogamy, and are apparently Christians, since they celebrate Christmas. Grey objects to people not being able to publicly celebrate a religious holiday (he also makes the point that “Holiday” is derived from “Holy Day”), without ever thinking to ask the celebrants if they want to celebrate anything other than Winter Solstice. The base assumption here is that everyone in the United States of North America is Christian and being repressed. Gray has been in military service for many years and should have a concept of diversity in his subordinates, but clearly he missed the boat.
It’s clear in this book that what Douglas alluded to in book five is going to come to pass, the White Covenant is going to be repealed and religious expression and proselytizing will again be legal. This is disappointing, but perhaps not surprising.
Gray’s paranoia and bigotry towards machine intelligences also makes a prominent appearance in this book, being highlighted in his conversation with a tech who has so many implants that Gray questions her humanity, with the implication that someone who follows a different path can be deemed non-human. The brief time we have with the tech as the narrator gives us the clear impression that she has been seduced by technology and is unable to consider that AIs may be a danger to humans. A disappointingly shallow characterization, and completely unneeded to move the story forward, just a little jab at people who take a path that Douglas does not approve of.
After that particular disappointing segment, the book goes completely off the rails and introduces us to sentient bacteria that have been controlling a bunch of alien species because they don’t want to lose their organic hosts to a technological singularity, like what happened way back in the past. So the secret of why a coalition of aliens from ~850 million years in the past is trying to force humanity to give up certain types of technology is because of a sentient bacteria that can’t figure out how to build their own bodies. On top of that, the bacteria waited all this time (200 years, give or take) to try and cross the species barrier and infect humanity. It’s almost like they didn’t exist before this book…
Of course the book wouldn’t be complete without humanity triumphing against a species so technologically superior that they appear as gods to the ants of humanity. To set the scene, there is a ship the size of a small planet with weaponry so advanced that it can wipe out a human fleet with no more effort than a human swatting a mosquito. The plucky human fleet consisting of star carriers from nations all over Earth (and some other ships, but nothing really matters except the star carriers) is being slaughtered.
While this is happening, Gray is off on a mission given to him by the super AI Konstantin to go look at a system that supposedly has a super secret super advanced super helpful (maybe) alien race that can help humanity against the Rosette aliens. Why this system hasn’t been investigated in the past when it’s relatively nearby and has anomalies that have been observed since way back in the 21st century is never explained, but it’s critical that Gray disobey orders from his human superiors and go to this system.
So at this point I’m really curious where this is going, since there are so many possibilities. As events progress at Tabby’s Star we find out that Douglas has gone full Independence Day. That’s right, the valiant crew of the star carrier America is going to hack the Gibson. Wait… Wrong storyline. They’re going to use an alien computer virus to take out the Rosette aliens. Yes, seriously. On top of this (and yes, I realize I’ve gotten the timeline a little out of order) we’re supposed to believe that somehow the Konstantin clone on the America is capable of containing and copying this super virus made by a technologically superior species.
As usual, the humans triumph, the main characters live to fight another day, and we are left with yet another cliffhanger. I’m not excited about the future of this series.