In 1980, writer and former magazine editor Willie Morris returned to his native Mississippi after a long sojourn in the North and abroad. Casting about for a story into which he could inject his thoughts on the South and the changes it had undergone since his youth, Morris settled on the unlikely subject of high school superstar football player Marcus Dupree.
In 1981, Marcus Dupree was widely regarded as the best-ever high school football player in the State of Mississippi and one of the best, if not the best, from any state. He had it all: 6-3, 230 pounds, the God-given ability to run 40 yards in under 4.3 seconds, and, most importantly, the fluidity needed to avoid tacklers and "run to daylight." Every major football-playing college in the country wanted him for its team.
To Morris, the happenstance of Dupree's birth was even more compelling. Dupree had been born in Philadelphia, Mississippi in 1964, the year three civil rights workers were murdered there in one of the most highly publicized events of the 1960s. (This crime later became the basis for the Willem Dafoe film Mississippi Burning.) Although Dupree obviously had no recollection of these events, he attended school with the children of the townspeople from that time, and, in an ironic turn of history, one of his friends on the football team was the son of a sheriff's deputy who had been convicted of complicity in the killings.
Disappointingly, but perhaps not surprisingly, the book is more about Willie Morris than Marcus Dupree. As Morris drives around the state attending Dupree's games, he ruminates about his obsessions: race, the Old (i.e. Jim Crow) South, the civil rights era, and the changes it wrought. What emerges is a picture of a dinosaur: a 1960s liberal-leftist who retained his affection for his home state but was obsessed with the subject of race, and perhaps a little too ready to attribute racist motives to those around him.
By the early 1980s, Morris, who died in 1999, was a dinosaur. The society he had grown up in was gone, segregation was history, and the political concerns which had been so important to him were largely irrelevant to what actually was going on around him. It would be interesting to know whether Morris realized how archaic he had become, but no such revelation is included in this book.
The injustice of the book's title. of course, lies in the relatively minor position to which it relegates Dupree and his exploits. Dupree's story is the subject of legend and filled with pathos. Unlike many high school stars, Dupree's schoolboy exploits were only the opening act of what made him a permanent sporting legend. After graduating from Philadelphia High School, Dupree matriculated at the University of Oklahoma as a highly touted running back. Legendary coach Barry Switzer junked his equally-legendary wishbone offense midway through the season so he could feature Dupree as an I-formation tailback, and Dupree ended the season by rushing for 249 yards against Arizona State, which had the nation's top-ranked run defense, in the Fiesta Bowl even though he only played half the game. The following season, Dupree left Oklahoma, where he apparently was not happy, and signed a multi-million dollar contract with the upstart United States Football League at age 19. Less than one full season later, Dupree suffered a serious knee injury which robbed him of his scintillating ability. In 1990, after sitting out for several years, Dupree managed to make a brief comeback with the NFL's Los Angeles Rams, but by that time he was just a plowhorse running back who couldn't break away from anyone, much less the entire opposing defense as he regularly had done before his injury. When ESPN produced a documentary on Dupree around 2015, it chose the highly evocative and apt title The Best There Never Was.
Near the beginning of Morris' book, he quotes a townsman saying that if Dupree suffered a serious injury, he would be just another colored kid in a small Mississippi town. It was a rhetorical comment; neither Morris nor the speaker anticipated it would apply to Dupree's life. How Dupree dealt with that unfortunate fate probably would make a much more interesting story than the one Morris told, but it is not the story of this book.