One word best describes Yorien’s Hand, I think: EPIC. You want two words? Try “staggeringly epic.”
A whole bunch of your favorite characters from books 1 and 2 come back to play, and they’ve got the whole world to do it in. We’re geared up early for an epic showdown with the Bad Guy, and wowza does Jenelle Schmidt deliver! It’s too easy to say this is the biggest baddest dude and monstrous army ever assembled; it’s another thing entirely to pull it off so that it’s not over in a couple pages. Instead, just the final battle itself takes up almost a fifth of the book—with plenty of preliminary attacks to soften our heroes and try to make them fail. It is truly awesome when a book lives up to its potential in this way.
My gripes were two, and entirely personal: first, because I had read King’s Warrior a little bit longer ago, and since Second Son is a prequel, when Yorien’s Hand picked up where King’s Warrior left off, I knew I should know some (maybe all?) of the characters, but I wasn’t sure—couldn’t quite remember who was who. It seemed odd, to me, to do Book-Prequel-Sequel, but as I look back I can see why Schmidt chose this path and it has a lot of benefits. So, to compensate for my first issue, I would recommend either having a better memory than me, or reading them all in a row. So I’m not taking a star off for that. Second gripe was that the writing still lets me go, sometimes, when the author takes a more languorous route to the point than I feel is truly necessary. Now, she is consistent—after King’s Warrior, this particular aspect just seems to be her writing style. So, while it doesn’t fit me, it may fit you.
Since I reserve five-star ratings for books that completely knock my socks off, I’m giving this one a four just because a little tighter writing style suits me better. Beyond that, I see nothing really detracting from this excellent installment in The Minstrel’s Song series, and I’m definitely looking forward to finishing it off soon!