When I first picked up the Rebecca Schwartz Mysteries box set, I was expecting a pleasant cozy mystery staring a feminist Jewish Lawyer. I was expecting to read about the foibles of a single Jewish princess who struggled to juggle her life, her career, and her overbearing mother. While there was some of that layered into the stories, most of the narrative centered around an abusive boyfriend. Seriously?
I was so hoping to read a story about a lawyer, but instead found a diatribe of should she or shouldn't she stay with an insensitive, career-obsessed, thoughtless boyfriend. The narrative didn't so much focus on the relationship as on his antics. I thought this was supposed to be the "Rebecca Schwartz Mysteries" not the Rebecca Schwartz's boyfriend's capers. In that respect, the books were rather disappointing.
Aside from the fact that Rebecca didn't figure prominently in her own stories and the rather cliched portrayal of the relationship between Rebecca and her family/sister's boyfriend, the writing is actually quite good. When the narrative focuses on Rebecca and her trying to save a client, the author is witty, creative, and intelligent. Unfortunately, there aren't enough of those great moments in the books for me to recommend them at the highest level.
I do recommend them though. The books are a fun read and an excellent way to spend a winter afternoon.