Allie and Mal discover yet another dead body-the body of a young woman presumably fell off a yacht,, drowned and washed up near the marina. Unfortunately for Allie's track record, the police say the young woman was hit on the head and then thrown in the water. Even more unfortunate, the main suspect is Paige Trent! Sure Carin and Paige hated each other in high school but is that enough hatred for a murder 10 years later? Allie refuses to believe it but Trent keeps shutting her out. What is she to do but launch an investigation of her own? Meanwhile, with Yacht Race Week in full swing, Mackinac Island is busier than ever and that means more chocolate and more fudge. Closer to home in the McMurphy, Mr. Devaney is ready to ask Frances to marry him and wants Allie and Jenn to plan a magical proposal. When Allie's loved ones are threatened, she's scared but not scared enough to stop her investigation. Can she catch the killer before one of her beloved pets - or worse- her friends- is hurt?
The plot of this mystery is OK. I thought I had figured out who did it, changed my mind and then realized my initial guess was correct. The story wasn't super engaging. I really can't stand mean girls and high school drama. No one deserves to be murdered though. The story spent way too much time on minute details like what everyone was wearing and how much the men resembled GQ models. Allie doesn't have any interest in fashion but she seems well acquainted with fashion magazines. There was also way too much mean girl drama -he said, she said, *itch, *itch, *itch. SO over that! The mystery got bogged down with all those details. I also question why Allie supposedly lives at the McMurphy 24/7 and has next to no relationship with the locals has time to go off on an investigation every afternoon? She risks her life one too many times for my comfort in this story. The reason for murder wasn't satisfactory and the red herring plot would have been better if it wasn't a red herring. I just loved the sweet secondary romance.
Allie's personality in this book is closer to the way she was in the first book. She shows that she barely notices or cares to talk to anyone other than Jenn. It's Jenn who forges connections with the locals and brings in business. It's Sandy who makes half the fudge and chocolate. Allie is the only "Fudgie" in the hotel and though she claims she's trying, she doesn't make much effort to fit in. Trent is a jerk for most of the book and if I were Allie, I'd run far away from those old much rich people who close ranks. Mal is super adorable as always.
There are a bunch of new characters in this book. Caramella (Mella), is Allie's new adopted cat. She lives mostly in Allie's apartment or on the fire escape and knows how to con Allie into giving her more kitty treats. Most of the humans are unlikable. There's Eleanor, the victim's "best friend"/minion, who is still a mean girl trying to social climb. Then there's Carin herself. The more revealed about her, the more I disliked her. The men they associate with are no prizes either, except maybe Reggie, Paige's fiance, but I don't know if I trust him. Gail from the coffee shop is first on the scene and disappears from the story before Allie can get to know her. Janet Biggs is an older lady with a cute dog who befriends Allie. She seems nice but I don't know if she's trustworthy. The old ladies at the senior center are a hoot. I enjoyed them. Mrs. Jones, an elderly, wheelchair bound woman, sounds like she could be a good friend but I have a feeling she won't appear again. Another important character is Maggs, Florence's best friend, whom Allie is just getting to know. She could fill the void Grammy Alice left in Allie's life.
This book contains some yummy fudge recipes. I only saw one that I would try and one I would like to try but never have those ingredients on hand.